CIT v. Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders

349 ITR 336High Court2012#47 most cited

What is CIT v. Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders authority for?

Appellate authorities can entertain fresh claims or revised computations of income made by an assessee, even if these were not submitted through a revised return of income.

956

judgments rely on this decision, according to BharatTax’s citation analysis of 384,082 Indian tax judgments — from 2014 to 2026.

Also referred to as

Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders · 349 ITR 336 · Bombay High Court · appellate authority power · entertain fresh claim · additional ground of appeal · revised computation of income · absence of revised return · section 139 · Goetz India Ltd. · Tribunal power

Issues it is cited on

Judgments citing CIT v. Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders

Hindustan Oil Exploration Company Ltd, Mumbai vs. ITO Cir 9(2)(1), Mumbai

In the result, Revenue’s appeal is dismissed

ITA 942/MUM/2015[1996-97]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai12 Oct 2018AY 1996-97

Bench: Shri Saktijit Dey & Shri Manoj Kumar Aggarwalhindustan Oil Exploration Co. Ltd. Anand House, 13Th Road, Off Linking Rd. ……………. Appellant Khar (W), Mumbai 400 052 Pan – Aaach1407P V/S Jt. Commissioner Of Income Tax ……………. Respondent Special Range–1, Mumbai Hindustan Oil Exploration Co. Ltd. Anand House, 13Th Road, Off Linking Rd. ……………. Appellant Khar (W), Mumbai 400 052 Pan – Aaach1407P V/S Income Tax Officer ……………. Respondent Circle–9(2)(1), Mumbai Hindustan Oil Exploration Co. Ltd. Anand House, 13Th Road, Off Linking Rd. ……………. Appellant Khar (W), Mumbai 400 052 Pan – Aaach1407P V/S Dy. Commissioner Of Income Tax ……………. Respondent Range–9(2), Mumbai

For Appellant: Shri V. ChandrashekharFor Respondent: Shri Rajeev Gubgotra
Section 143(3)Section 42(1)(a)

…3 ITR 508 (Guj.); iii) CIT v/s Gold Tex Furnishing Industries, [2002] 276 ITR 164 (Del.); iv) CIT v/s P.R. Prabhakar, [2004] 276 ITR 176; v) Goetz India Ltd. v/s CIT, [2006] 284 ITR 323 (SC); and vi) CIT v/s Pruthvi Brokers And Shareholders Pvt. Ltd. [2012] 349 ITR 336 (Bom.). 22. Thus, the learned Authorised Representative submitted, the Assessing Officer may be directed to consider the revised return of income filed by the assessee and decide the claim made in the revised return of income. 23. The learned Departmental Representative, though, relied upon the observations of the Departmental Authorities, howe…

Zahir Shabbir Kachwalla, Mumbai vs. ITO 21(3)(5), Mumbai

In the result appeal of the assessee is partly allowed for statistical purposes as indicated above

ITA 1104/MUM/2017[2012-13]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai24 Sept 2018AY 2012-13

Bench: Shri C.N. Prasad & Shri Ramit Kocharआयकर अपीऱ सं./I.T.A. No.1104/Mum/2017 (नििाारण वर्ा / Assessment Year : 2012-13) बिाम/ Shri. Zahir Shabbir Ito 21(3)(5) Kachwalla, Mumbai 400051 F.No. 111, Silver Beach V. Chs, Off. V.S Marg Dadar, Mumbai 400028 स्थायी ऱेखा सं./ Pan : Amypk5755C (अपीऱाथी /Appellant) (प्रत्यथी / Respondent) .. Assessee By: Dr. K. Shivaram,Senior Advocate Revenue By : Shri. T.A Khan, Dr सुनवाई की तारीख /Date Of Hearing : 24.07.2018 घोषणा की तारीख /Date Of Pronouncement : 24.09.2018 आदेश / O R D E R Per Ramit Kochar: This Appeal, Filed By Assessee, Being Ita No. 1104/Mum/2017, Is Directed Against Appellate Order Dated 01.11.2016 Passed By Learned Commissioner Of Income Tax (Appeals)-33, Mumbai (Hereinafter Called “The Cit(A)”), For Assessment Year 2012-13, The Appellate Proceedings Had Arisen Before Learned Cit(A) From Assessment Order Dated 30.03.2015 Passed By Learned Assessing Officer (Hereinafter Called “The Ao”) U/S 143(3) Of The Income-Tax Act, 1961 (Hereinafter Called “The Act”) For Assessment Year 2012-13. I.T.A. No.1104/Mum/2017

For Appellant: Dr. K. Shivaram,Senior AdvocateFor Respondent: Shri. T.A Khan, DR
Section 10(38)Section 143(3)Section 69

…ed by way of revised return of income keeping in view decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Goetze (India) Limited(supra) . The assessee relied upon decision of Hon’ble Bombay High Court in the case of CIT v. Pruthvi Brokers and Shareholders (2012) 349 ITR 336(Bom). The Ld. DR on the other hand submitted that Ld. CIT(A) has allowed the claim of the assessee so far as shares gifted by father as well given by grandfather which were declared under VDIS scheme. It was submitted that learned CIT(A) has given direction to the AO to consider and allow the claim of the assessee for shares acquired from AY 2009…

Bhav Vardhan Trust, Mumbai vs. ITO (E) 1(1), Mumbai

In the result, the appeal filed by the assessee is partly allowed in terms of our aforesaid observations

ITA 5578/MUM/2016[2008-09]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai12 Sept 2018AY 2008-09

Bench: Shri G.S. Pannu & Shri Ravish Soodm/S. Bhav Vardhan Trust Income Tax Officer Nirmal Niketan (Exemption) 1(1) Vs. 2, Dr. Bhajekar Street Mumbai, Mumbai 400004 Pan – Aaatb3631Q Appellant Respondent Appellant By: Shri Rajesh P. Shah Respondent By: Shri Abdul Hakem M Date Of Hearing: 28.08.2018 Date Of Pronouncement: 12.09.2018 O R D E R Per Ravish Sood, Jm The Present Appeal Is Directed Against The Order Of The Cit(A)-1, Mumbai, Dated 23.06.2016, Which In Turn Arises From The Order Passed By The A.O Under Section 143(3) Of The Income Tax Act, 1961 (Hereinafter Referred To As "The Act") Dated 02.12.2010 For A.Y. 2008-09. 2. The Assessee While Assailing The Order Of The Cit(A) Has Raised Before Us The Following Grounds Of Appeal: - “1. On The Facts & Under The Circumstances Of The Case & In Law, The Learned Commissioner Of Income Tax (Appeals) Erred In Confirming The Action Of Ao Of Considering The Tax Claim Of Rs.19,87,100/- As New Claim On The Ground That There Was No Claim Made By Appellant In The Return Of Income. 2. On The Facts & Under The Circumstances Of The Case & In Law, The Learned Commissioner Of Income Tax (Appeals) Erred Confirming The Action Of Ao Of Not Considering The Tax Expenses Of Rs. 19,87,100/- Incurred On The Object Of The Trust. The Ao Ought To Have Allowed The Same As It Is Allowable As Per Law.

For Appellant: Shri Rajesh P. ShahFor Respondent: Shri Abdul Hakem M
Section 11(1)Section 143Section 143(3)

…s an adjudication of a legal issue based on the facts available on record. The learned A.R. buttressed his aforesaid contention by relying on the judgement of the Hon'ble Bombay High Court in the case of CIT vs. Pruthvi Brokers and Shareholders P. Ltd. (2012) 349 ITR 336 (Bom) and the order of the ITAT, Mumbai “C” Bench in the case of DCIT vs. CMS Securitas Ltd. (2016) 47 ITR (Trib) 378 (Mum). The learned A.R. further taking us to the merits of the issue involved in the present appeal submitted that the same was squarely covered by the order passed by the Tribunal in assessee‟s own 4 M/s. Bhav Vardhan Trust case…

DCIT 3(2)(1), Mumbai vs. Mangalore Refinery and Petrochemicals Ltd, Mumbai

In the result the appeal filed by the revenue is dismissed

ITA 7241/MUM/2014[2009-10]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai07 Sept 2018AY 2009-10

Bench: Shri Saktijit Dey () & Shri N.K. Pradhan () Assessment Year: 2009-10 Mangalore Refinery & Addl. Cit-3(2), Mumbai Petrochemicals Ltd. 15Th Vs. Floor, Maker Tower, Ewing, Cuffe Parade, Mumbai- 400005. Pan No. Aaacm5132A Respondent Appellant Assessment Year: 2009-10 Dcit-3(2) Room No. Mangalore Refinery & 674, 6Th Floor, Petrochemicals Ltd. 15Th Vs. Aayakarbhavan, M. K. Floor, Maker Tower, Ewing, Road, Mumbai-400020. Cuffe Parade, Mumbai- 400005. Pan No. Aaacm5132A Appellant Respondent Assessee By : Mr. J.D.J. Mistri, Senior Advocate & Mr. Madhur Agrawal, Advocate Revenue By : Mr.Samuel Darse, Cit(Dr) Date Of Hearing : 12/06/2018 Date Of Pronouncement: 07/09/2018

For Appellant: Mr. J.D.J. Mistri, Senior AdvocateFor Respondent: Mr.Samuel Darse, CIT(DR)
Section 143(3)Section 195Section 40Section 44B

…IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI BENCH “L” MUMBAI BEFORE SHRI SAKTIJIT DEY (JUDICIAL MEMBER) AND SHRI N.K. PRADHAN (ACCOUNTANT MEMBER) Assessment Year: 2009-10 Mangalore Refinery & Addl. CIT-3(2), Mumbai Petrochemicals Ltd. 15th Vs. Floor, Maker Tower, Ewing, Cuffe Parade, Mumbai- 400005. PAN No. AAACM5132A Respondent Appellant Assessment Year: 2009-10 DCIT-3(2) Room No. Mangalore Refinery & 674, 6th Floor, Petrochemicals Ltd. 15th Vs. AayakarBhavan, M. K. Floor, Maker Tower, Ewing, Road, Mumbai-400020. Cuffe Parade, Mumbai- 400005. PAN No. AAACM5132A Appellant Respondent Assessee by : Mr. J.D.J. Mis…

Magnalore Refinery and Petrochemicals Ltd, Mumbai vs. Addl CIT 3(2)

In the result the appeal filed by the revenue is dismissed

ITA 7133/MUM/2014[2009-10]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai07 Sept 2018AY 2009-10

Bench: Shri Saktijit Dey () & Shri N.K. Pradhan () Assessment Year: 2009-10 Mangalore Refinery & Addl. Cit-3(2), Mumbai Petrochemicals Ltd. 15Th Vs. Floor, Maker Tower, Ewing, Cuffe Parade, Mumbai- 400005. Pan No. Aaacm5132A Respondent Appellant Assessment Year: 2009-10 Dcit-3(2) Room No. Mangalore Refinery & 674, 6Th Floor, Petrochemicals Ltd. 15Th Vs. Aayakarbhavan, M. K. Floor, Maker Tower, Ewing, Road, Mumbai-400020. Cuffe Parade, Mumbai- 400005. Pan No. Aaacm5132A Appellant Respondent Assessee By : Mr. J.D.J. Mistri, Senior Advocate & Mr. Madhur Agrawal, Advocate Revenue By : Mr.Samuel Darse, Cit(Dr) Date Of Hearing : 12/06/2018 Date Of Pronouncement: 07/09/2018

For Appellant: Mr. J.D.J. Mistri, Senior AdvocateFor Respondent: Mr.Samuel Darse, CIT(DR)
Section 143(3)Section 195Section 40Section 44B

…IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI BENCH “L” MUMBAI BEFORE SHRI SAKTIJIT DEY (JUDICIAL MEMBER) AND SHRI N.K. PRADHAN (ACCOUNTANT MEMBER) Assessment Year: 2009-10 Mangalore Refinery & Addl. CIT-3(2), Mumbai Petrochemicals Ltd. 15th Vs. Floor, Maker Tower, Ewing, Cuffe Parade, Mumbai- 400005. PAN No. AAACM5132A Respondent Appellant Assessment Year: 2009-10 DCIT-3(2) Room No. Mangalore Refinery & 674, 6th Floor, Petrochemicals Ltd. 15th Vs. AayakarBhavan, M. K. Floor, Maker Tower, Ewing, Road, Mumbai-400020. Cuffe Parade, Mumbai- 400005. PAN No. AAACM5132A Appellant Respondent Assessee by : Mr. J.D.J. Mis…