CIT v. Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders

349 ITR 336High Court2012#47 most cited

What is CIT v. Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders authority for?

Appellate authorities can entertain fresh claims or revised computations of income made by an assessee, even if these were not submitted through a revised return of income.

956

judgments rely on this decision, according to BharatTax’s citation analysis of 384,370 Indian tax judgments — from 2014 to 2026.

Also referred to as

Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders · 349 ITR 336 · Bombay High Court · appellate authority power · entertain fresh claim · additional ground of appeal · revised computation of income · absence of revised return · section 139 · Goetz India Ltd. · Tribunal power

Issues it is cited on

Judgments citing CIT v. Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders

Suman Agarwal, Mumbai vs. ITO-26(3)(3), Mumbai

ITA 4240/MUM/2019[2013-14]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai16 Jan 2020AY 2013-14

Bench: Shri Shamim Yahya, Hon’Ble & Shri Pawan Singh, Hon’Ble] I.T.A. No. 4240/Mum/2019 Assessment Year: 2013-14 Suman Agarwal……...........…...…………..….................................................................................Appellant 103, Agarwal Ashram, M.N. Patankar Marg, Kurla (W), Mumbai – 400 070. [Pan: Akapa 0022 A] Vs. Ito – 26(3)(3), Mumbai……………….......…..…………………....…..........................................Respondent Mumbai. Appearances By: Shri Mandar Vaidya, Ar Appeared On Behalf Of The Assessee. Shri Akhtar H Ansari, Dr Appeared On Behalf Of The Revenue. Date Of Concluding The Hearing : November 19, 2019 Date Of Pronouncing The Order : January 16, 2020 Order

Section 2(14)Section 54Section 54FSection 68

…tains to A.Y. 2013-14. 2. The grounds of appeal read as under: “i. The Ld. CIT(A) erred in not considering the appellant’s claim for exemption u/s 54F which runs contrary to the ratio laid down by the Hon'ble Jurisdictional High Court in Pruthvi Stock Brokers 349 ITR 336 (Bom). ii. The Ld. CIT(A) fell in error of law in holding that gold jewellery was not a ‘capital asset’ u/s 2(14) of the Act, resulting into the appellant being ineligible for exemption u/s 54F. iii. The Ld. CIT(A) was not justified in ignoring the CBDT Instruction No. 1916 [F. No. 286/63/93-IT (INV. II)] dtd. 11th May, 94, regarding the quantity…

The DCIT Cir 3(1), Mumbai vs. M/S. Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd, Mumbai

Appeal stand partly allowed to the extent indicated in the order

ITA 7486/MUM/2007[2004-2005]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai06 Jan 2020AY 2004-2005

Bench: Hon’Ble Shri Mahavir Singh, Jm & Hon’Ble Shri Manoj Kumar Aggarwal, Am आयकरअपील सं./ I.T.A. No.7486/Mum/2007 (िनधा"रण वष" / Assessment Year:2004-05) Acit-(Ltu)-1 Ambuja Cements Limited बनाम/ World Trade Centre [Earlier Known As Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd.] Elegant Business Park Centre-1, 29Th Floor, Vs. Midc Cross Road “B”, Off Andheri-Kurla Road Cuffe Parade, Mumbai-05. Andheri (E), Mumbai-400 059. "थायीलेखासं./जीआइआरसं./Pan/Gir No. Aaacg-0569-P (अपीलाथ"/Appellant) (""थ" / Respondent) : & आयकरअपील सं./ I.T.A. No.7494/Mum/2007 (िनधा"रण वष" / Assessment Year:2004-05) Ambuja Cements Limited Dcit–Range-3(1) [Earlier Known As Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd] बनाम/ Aaykar Bhavan, M.K. Road Elegant Business Park Mumbai-400 020. Vs. Midc Cross Road “B”, Off Andheri-Kurla Road Andheri (E), Mumbai-400 059. "थायीलेखासं./जीआइआरसं./Pan/Gir No. Aaacg 0569 P (अपीलाथ"/Appellant) (""थ" / Respondent) : & C.O. No.222/Mum/2017 [Arising Out Of Ita No. 7494/Mum/2007] (िनधा"रण वष" / Assessment Year:2004-05) Acit-(Ltu)-1 Ambuja Cements Limited बनाम/ [Earlier Known As Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd.] World Trade Centre Elegant Business Park Centre-1, 29Th Floor, Vs. Midc Cross Road “B”, Off Andheri-Kurla Road Cuffe Parade, Mumbai-05. Andheri (E), Mumbai-400 059. "थायीलेखासं./जीआइआरसं./Pan/Gir No. Aaacg-0569-P (अपीलाथ"/Appellant) (""थ" / Respondent) :

For Appellant: S/Shri Yogesh Thar, Hardik Nirmal &For Respondent: Shri Anadi Varma-Ld.CIT-DR & Shri
Section 115JSection 143(3)

…le warrant issue expenses since the said claim was omitted to be lodged in the return of income. However, Ld. CIT(A) declined to admit the same. Drawing analogy from the decision of Hon’ble Bombay High Court in CIT V/s Pruthvi Shares & Stockbrokers Pvt. Ltd. (349 ITR 336), we direct Ld. AO to admit this claim and adjudicate the same after providing due opportunity of hearing to the assessee. This ground stand allowed for statistical purposes. 4.8 Gr. No.8: Premium on Leased land for Rs.30.73 Lacs The assessee claimed deduction of premium on leasehold land. The assessee submitted that it obtained various lands on…

Addl CIT 1(3), Mumbai vs. Tata Communications Ltd ( Formerly Videsh Sanchar Nigam Ltd), Mumbai

In the result, the appeal of the assessee in ITA No

ITA 4452/MUM/2011[2005-06]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai24 Dec 2019AY 2005-06

Bench: Shri Mahavir Singh, Jm & Shri M.Balaganesh, Am Additional Commissioner Vs. M/S. Tata Communications Of Income Tax, Range – Limited (Formerly Known As 1(3) Videsh Sanchar Nigam Limited) Mumbai Videsh Sanchar Bhavan Room No.540/564, 5 Th M.G.Road, Fort Floor, Aayakar Bhavan, Mumbai – 400 001 Maharshi Karve Road, New Marine Linmes Mumbai – 400 020 Pan/Gir No.Aaacv2808C (Appellant) .. (Respondent) & M/S. Tata Communications Vs. Additional Commissioner Of Limited (Formerly Known As Income Tax, Range – 1(3) Videsh Sanchar Nigam Mumbai Limited) Room No.540, Aayakar Videsh Sanchar Bhavan Bhavan, Maharshi Karve M.G.Road, Fort Road Mumbai – 400 001 Mumbai – 400 020 Pan/Gir No.Aaacv2808C (Appellant) .. (Respondent) M/S. Tata Communications Ltd.

Section 120(4)(b)Section 127Section 143(3)Section 263

…se of Jute Corporation of India Ltd. vs. CIT reported in 187 ITR 688; Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of CIT vs. NTPC Ltd. reported in 229 ITR 383 (SC) and Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court in the case of CIT vs. Pruthvi Brokers and Shareholders reported in 349 ITR 336 (Bom), among others. 5.1. At the instance of the bench, the ld. DR filed the following written submissions clarifying the queries raised by the bench as a matter of abundant caution:- M/s. Tata Communications Ltd. M/s. Tata Communications Ltd. M/s. Tata Communications Ltd. M/s. Tata Communications Ltd. M/s. Tata Communications Ltd. M/s. Tata Com…

Caprihans India Ltd, Mumbai vs. Dccc -36, Mumbai

ITA 4252/MUM/2011[2005-06]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai23 Dec 2019AY 2005-06

Bench: Shri Pramod Kumar & Shri Ravish Soodita Nos. 4252 To 4254/Mum/2011 (Assessment Years: 2005-06 To 2007-08) M/S Caprihans India Ltd. Dy. Cit Central Circl-36 Block-D, Shivsagar Estate, Mumbai. Vs. Dr. A.B.Road, Worli, Mumbai – 400 018 Pan – Aaacc1646F (Appellant) (Respondent) The Asstt. Commissioner Of Income-Tax, M/S Caprihans India Ltd. Central Circle-36, Room No.11, Block-D, Shivsagar Estate Vs. Aayakar Bhavan, M.K. Marg, Dr. Annie Besant Road,Worli, Mumbai – 400 020 Mumbai- 400 018 Pan – Aaacc1646F (Appellant) (Respondent) Appellant By: Shri R. Murlidhar, A.R Respondent By: Shri Awungshi Gimson, D.R Date Of Hearing: 01.10.2019 Date Of Pronouncement: 23.12.2019 O R D E R Per Ravish Sood, Jm The Assessee & The Revenue Being Aggrieved With The Order Passed By The Cit(A)- 41, Mumbai, Dated 31.12.2009 For A.Y. 2005-06 Have Preferred Cross-Appeals Before Us. Also, The Assessee Is In Appeal Against The Respective Orders Of The Cit(A)-41 For A.Y. 2006-07 & A.Y. 2007-08, Both Dated 31.12.2009. As Certain Common Issues Are Involved In The Captioned

For Appellant: Shri R. Murlidhar, A.RFor Respondent: Shri Awungshi Gimson, D.R
Section 115JSection 132Section 143(1)Section 153C

…IT(A) was in error in declining to entertain the said claim of the assessee. In support of his aforesaid contention the ld. A.R relied on the judgment of the Hon‟ble High Court of Bombay in the case of CIT Vs. Pruthvi Brokers and Shareholders Pvt. ltd. (2012) 349 ITR 336 (Bom). It was submitted by the ld. A.R that in the aforesaid order the Hon‟ble High Court of Bombay had observed that an assessee can raise a claim before an appellate authority, despite the fact that the same was not made in its return of income. It was also submitted by the ld. A.R that the Hon‟ble High Court while concluding as hereinabove had…

Imperial Consultants & Securities Ltd. (Formerly Known As Omperial Consultants & Securities Pvt. Ltd.), Mumbai vs. DCIT -6 (3)(1), Mumbai

In the result, appeal of the Revenue is dismissed

ITA 3529/MUM/2018[2012-13]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai17 Dec 2019AY 2012-13

Bench: Shri A.D. Jain & Shri Rajesh Kumarm/S. Imperial Consultants & Dcit, Circle - 6(3)(1) Securities Ltd. Room No. 506, 5Th Floor (Formerly Imperial Consultants & Aayakar Bhavan, M.K. Road Securities P. Ltd) Vs. Mumbai 400020 Manickam Complex, Gr. Floor 1/3, General Paters Roadchennai 600002 Pan – Aaacg4413G Appellant Respondent Dcit, Circle - 6(3)(1) M/S. Imperial Consultants & Room No. 506, 5Th Floor Securities Ltd. Vs. Aayakar Bhavan, M.K. Road Essar House, 11, Kk Marg Mumbai 400020 Mahalaxmi, Mumbai 400034 Pan – Aaacg4413G Appellant Respondent

For Appellant: Shri Vijay MehtaFor Respondent: Shri Awungshi Gimson
Section 143(3)Section 144Section 36(1)(iii)Section 56Section 57

…IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL "C" Bench, Mumbai Before Shri A.D. Jain, Vice President and Shri Rajesh Kumar, Accountant Member M/s. Imperial Consultants & DCIT, Circle - 6(3)(1) Securities Ltd. Room No. 506, 5th Floor (formerly Imperial Consultants & Aayakar Bhavan, M.K. Road Securities P. Ltd) Vs. Mumbai 400020 Manickam Complex, Gr. Floor 1/3, General Paters RoadChennai 600002 PAN – AAACG4413G Appellant Respondent DCIT, Circle - 6(3)(1) M/s. Imperial Consultants & Room No. 506, 5th Floor Securities Ltd. Vs. Aayakar Bhavan, M.K. Road Essar House, 11, KK Marg Mumbai 400020 Mahalaxmi, Mumbai 400034 PAN – AA…