CIT v. Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders

349 ITR 336High Court2012#47 most cited

What is CIT v. Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders authority for?

Appellate authorities can entertain fresh claims or revised computations of income made by an assessee, even if these were not submitted through a revised return of income.

956

judgments rely on this decision, according to BharatTax’s citation analysis of 384,370 Indian tax judgments — from 2014 to 2026.

Also referred to as

Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders · 349 ITR 336 · Bombay High Court · appellate authority power · entertain fresh claim · additional ground of appeal · revised computation of income · absence of revised return · section 139 · Goetz India Ltd. · Tribunal power

Issues it is cited on

Judgments citing CIT v. Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders

DCIT 1(3)(2), Mumbai vs. Tata Communication Limited, Mumbai

In the result, this appeal by the assessee is allowed

ITA 1561/MUM/2015[2010-11]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai23 Feb 2022AY 2010-11

Bench: Shri Vikas Awasthy & Shri M. Balaganeshआअसं. 7514 /मुं/2011 ("न. व. 2007-08 ) आअसं. 6781/मुं/2012 ("न.व. 2008-09) आअसं. 572/मुं/2014 ("न.व. 2009-10) आअसं. 1106/मुं/2015 ("न.व. 2010-11) Tata Communications Ltd. (Formerly Videsh Sanchar Nigam Ltd.) Videsh Sanchar Nigam Bhavan, M.G Road, Fort, Mumbai 400 001 ...... अपीलाथ" /Appellant Pan: Aaccv-2808-C बनाम Vs. Additional Commissioner Of Income Tax, Range 1(3), Room No.540, Aaykar Bhavan, M.K.Road, Mumbai 400 020 ..... ""तवाद"/Respondent आअसं. 1657/मुं/2014 ("न.व. 2009-10) आअसं. 1561/मुं/2015 ("न.व. 2010-11) The Dcit -1(3) Room No.564,Aaykar Bhavan, M.K.Road, ...... अपीलाथ" /Appellant Mumbai 400 020 बनाम Vs.

For Appellant: Shri J.D. Mistry, Sr. Advocate with S/Shri Harsh M. Kapadia and K.DamaniaFor Respondent: Shri. Vatsalya Saxena& Shri B.K.Bagchi
Section 120(4)(b)Section 143(3)

…of additional legal ground, the ld.Counsel placed reliance on various decisions including: (i) Jute Corporation of India Ltd. vs. CIT, 187 ITR 688 (ii)Ahmedabad Electricity Company Ltd. vs.ACIT, 199 ITR 351(Bom) (iii)CIT vs. Pruthvi Brokers and Shareholders, 349 ITR 336(Bom) The ld.Counsel for the assessee pointed that similar legal ground was raised in assessee’s appeal for Assessment Year 2002-03 in ITA No.7071/Mum/2005 the Tribunal vide order dated 30/06/2017 admitted the additional grounds and decided the legal ground in favour of the assessee. 3. The additional grounds of appeal raised by assessee vide app…

Tata Communications Ltd, Mumbai vs. DCIT 1(3)(2), Mumbai

In the result, this appeal by the assessee is allowed

ITA 1106/MUM/2015[2010-11]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai23 Feb 2022AY 2010-11

Bench: Shri Vikas Awasthy & Shri M. Balaganeshआअसं. 7514 /मुं/2011 ("न. व. 2007-08 ) आअसं. 6781/मुं/2012 ("न.व. 2008-09) आअसं. 572/मुं/2014 ("न.व. 2009-10) आअसं. 1106/मुं/2015 ("न.व. 2010-11) Tata Communications Ltd. (Formerly Videsh Sanchar Nigam Ltd.) Videsh Sanchar Nigam Bhavan, M.G Road, Fort, Mumbai 400 001 ...... अपीलाथ" /Appellant Pan: Aaccv-2808-C बनाम Vs. Additional Commissioner Of Income Tax, Range 1(3), Room No.540, Aaykar Bhavan, M.K.Road, Mumbai 400 020 ..... ""तवाद"/Respondent आअसं. 1657/मुं/2014 ("न.व. 2009-10) आअसं. 1561/मुं/2015 ("न.व. 2010-11) The Dcit -1(3) Room No.564,Aaykar Bhavan, M.K.Road, ...... अपीलाथ" /Appellant Mumbai 400 020 बनाम Vs.

For Appellant: Shri J.D. Mistry, Sr. Advocate with S/Shri Harsh M. Kapadia and K.DamaniaFor Respondent: Shri. Vatsalya Saxena& Shri B.K.Bagchi
Section 120(4)(b)Section 143(3)

…of additional legal ground, the ld.Counsel placed reliance on various decisions including: (i) Jute Corporation of India Ltd. vs. CIT, 187 ITR 688 (ii)Ahmedabad Electricity Company Ltd. vs.ACIT, 199 ITR 351(Bom) (iii)CIT vs. Pruthvi Brokers and Shareholders, 349 ITR 336(Bom) The ld.Counsel for the assessee pointed that similar legal ground was raised in assessee’s appeal for Assessment Year 2002-03 in ITA No.7071/Mum/2005 the Tribunal vide order dated 30/06/2017 admitted the additional grounds and decided the legal ground in favour of the assessee. 3. The additional grounds of appeal raised by assessee vide app…

Tata Communications Limited(Formerly Videsh Sanchar Nigam Ltd.), Mumbai vs. Addl. CIT Range - 1(3), Mumbai

In the result, this appeal by the assessee is allowed

ITA 572/MUM/2014[2009-10]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai23 Feb 2022AY 2009-10

Bench: Shri Vikas Awasthy & Shri M. Balaganeshआअसं. 7514 /मुं/2011 ("न. व. 2007-08 ) आअसं. 6781/मुं/2012 ("न.व. 2008-09) आअसं. 572/मुं/2014 ("न.व. 2009-10) आअसं. 1106/मुं/2015 ("न.व. 2010-11) Tata Communications Ltd. (Formerly Videsh Sanchar Nigam Ltd.) Videsh Sanchar Nigam Bhavan, M.G Road, Fort, Mumbai 400 001 ...... अपीलाथ" /Appellant Pan: Aaccv-2808-C बनाम Vs. Additional Commissioner Of Income Tax, Range 1(3), Room No.540, Aaykar Bhavan, M.K.Road, Mumbai 400 020 ..... ""तवाद"/Respondent आअसं. 1657/मुं/2014 ("न.व. 2009-10) आअसं. 1561/मुं/2015 ("न.व. 2010-11) The Dcit -1(3) Room No.564,Aaykar Bhavan, M.K.Road, ...... अपीलाथ" /Appellant Mumbai 400 020 बनाम Vs.

For Appellant: Shri J.D. Mistry, Sr. Advocate with S/Shri Harsh M. Kapadia and K.DamaniaFor Respondent: Shri. Vatsalya Saxena& Shri B.K.Bagchi
Section 120(4)(b)Section 143(3)

…of additional legal ground, the ld.Counsel placed reliance on various decisions including: (i) Jute Corporation of India Ltd. vs. CIT, 187 ITR 688 (ii)Ahmedabad Electricity Company Ltd. vs.ACIT, 199 ITR 351(Bom) (iii)CIT vs. Pruthvi Brokers and Shareholders, 349 ITR 336(Bom) The ld.Counsel for the assessee pointed that similar legal ground was raised in assessee’s appeal for Assessment Year 2002-03 in ITA No.7071/Mum/2005 the Tribunal vide order dated 30/06/2017 admitted the additional grounds and decided the legal ground in favour of the assessee. 3. The additional grounds of appeal raised by assessee vide app…

DCIT 1(3), Mumbai vs. Tata Communication Ltd, Mumbai

In the result, this appeal by the assessee is allowed

ITA 1657/MUM/2014[2009-10]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai23 Feb 2022AY 2009-10

Bench: Shri Vikas Awasthy & Shri M. Balaganeshआअसं. 7514 /मुं/2011 ("न. व. 2007-08 ) आअसं. 6781/मुं/2012 ("न.व. 2008-09) आअसं. 572/मुं/2014 ("न.व. 2009-10) आअसं. 1106/मुं/2015 ("न.व. 2010-11) Tata Communications Ltd. (Formerly Videsh Sanchar Nigam Ltd.) Videsh Sanchar Nigam Bhavan, M.G Road, Fort, Mumbai 400 001 ...... अपीलाथ" /Appellant Pan: Aaccv-2808-C बनाम Vs. Additional Commissioner Of Income Tax, Range 1(3), Room No.540, Aaykar Bhavan, M.K.Road, Mumbai 400 020 ..... ""तवाद"/Respondent आअसं. 1657/मुं/2014 ("न.व. 2009-10) आअसं. 1561/मुं/2015 ("न.व. 2010-11) The Dcit -1(3) Room No.564,Aaykar Bhavan, M.K.Road, ...... अपीलाथ" /Appellant Mumbai 400 020 बनाम Vs.

For Appellant: Shri J.D. Mistry, Sr. Advocate with S/Shri Harsh M. Kapadia and K.DamaniaFor Respondent: Shri. Vatsalya Saxena& Shri B.K.Bagchi
Section 120(4)(b)Section 143(3)

…of additional legal ground, the ld.Counsel placed reliance on various decisions including: (i) Jute Corporation of India Ltd. vs. CIT, 187 ITR 688 (ii)Ahmedabad Electricity Company Ltd. vs.ACIT, 199 ITR 351(Bom) (iii)CIT vs. Pruthvi Brokers and Shareholders, 349 ITR 336(Bom) The ld.Counsel for the assessee pointed that similar legal ground was raised in assessee’s appeal for Assessment Year 2002-03 in ITA No.7071/Mum/2005 the Tribunal vide order dated 30/06/2017 admitted the additional grounds and decided the legal ground in favour of the assessee. 3. The additional grounds of appeal raised by assessee vide app…

Tata Communications Ltd ( Formerly Videsh Sanchar Nigam Ltd), Mumbai vs. Addl CIT RG 1(3), Mumbai

In the result, this appeal by the assessee is allowed

ITA 6781/MUM/2012[2008-09]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai23 Feb 2022AY 2008-09

Bench: Shri Vikas Awasthy & Shri M. Balaganeshआअसं. 7514 /मुं/2011 ("न. व. 2007-08 ) आअसं. 6781/मुं/2012 ("न.व. 2008-09) आअसं. 572/मुं/2014 ("न.व. 2009-10) आअसं. 1106/मुं/2015 ("न.व. 2010-11) Tata Communications Ltd. (Formerly Videsh Sanchar Nigam Ltd.) Videsh Sanchar Nigam Bhavan, M.G Road, Fort, Mumbai 400 001 ...... अपीलाथ" /Appellant Pan: Aaccv-2808-C बनाम Vs. Additional Commissioner Of Income Tax, Range 1(3), Room No.540, Aaykar Bhavan, M.K.Road, Mumbai 400 020 ..... ""तवाद"/Respondent आअसं. 1657/मुं/2014 ("न.व. 2009-10) आअसं. 1561/मुं/2015 ("न.व. 2010-11) The Dcit -1(3) Room No.564,Aaykar Bhavan, M.K.Road, ...... अपीलाथ" /Appellant Mumbai 400 020 बनाम Vs.

For Appellant: Shri J.D. Mistry, Sr. Advocate with S/Shri Harsh M. Kapadia and K.DamaniaFor Respondent: Shri. Vatsalya Saxena& Shri B.K.Bagchi
Section 120(4)(b)Section 143(3)

…of additional legal ground, the ld.Counsel placed reliance on various decisions including: (i) Jute Corporation of India Ltd. vs. CIT, 187 ITR 688 (ii)Ahmedabad Electricity Company Ltd. vs.ACIT, 199 ITR 351(Bom) (iii)CIT vs. Pruthvi Brokers and Shareholders, 349 ITR 336(Bom) The ld.Counsel for the assessee pointed that similar legal ground was raised in assessee’s appeal for Assessment Year 2002-03 in ITA No.7071/Mum/2005 the Tribunal vide order dated 30/06/2017 admitted the additional grounds and decided the legal ground in favour of the assessee. 3. The additional grounds of appeal raised by assessee vide app…

Tata Communication Ltd. (Formerly Known As Videsh Sanchar Nigam Ltd.), Mumbai vs. Addl.C.I.T.RG.1(3), Mumbai

In the result, this appeal by the assessee is allowed

ITA 7514/MUM/2011[2007-08]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai23 Feb 2022AY 2007-08

Bench: Shri Vikas Awasthy & Shri M. Balaganeshआअसं. 7514 /मुं/2011 ("न. व. 2007-08 ) आअसं. 6781/मुं/2012 ("न.व. 2008-09) आअसं. 572/मुं/2014 ("न.व. 2009-10) आअसं. 1106/मुं/2015 ("न.व. 2010-11) Tata Communications Ltd. (Formerly Videsh Sanchar Nigam Ltd.) Videsh Sanchar Nigam Bhavan, M.G Road, Fort, Mumbai 400 001 ...... अपीलाथ" /Appellant Pan: Aaccv-2808-C बनाम Vs. Additional Commissioner Of Income Tax, Range 1(3), Room No.540, Aaykar Bhavan, M.K.Road, Mumbai 400 020 ..... ""तवाद"/Respondent आअसं. 1657/मुं/2014 ("न.व. 2009-10) आअसं. 1561/मुं/2015 ("न.व. 2010-11) The Dcit -1(3) Room No.564,Aaykar Bhavan, M.K.Road, ...... अपीलाथ" /Appellant Mumbai 400 020 बनाम Vs.

For Appellant: Shri J.D. Mistry, Sr. Advocate with S/Shri Harsh M. Kapadia and K.DamaniaFor Respondent: Shri. Vatsalya Saxena& Shri B.K.Bagchi
Section 120(4)(b)Section 143(3)

…of additional legal ground, the ld.Counsel placed reliance on various decisions including: (i) Jute Corporation of India Ltd. vs. CIT, 187 ITR 688 (ii)Ahmedabad Electricity Company Ltd. vs.ACIT, 199 ITR 351(Bom) (iii)CIT vs. Pruthvi Brokers and Shareholders, 349 ITR 336(Bom) The ld.Counsel for the assessee pointed that similar legal ground was raised in assessee’s appeal for Assessment Year 2002-03 in ITA No.7071/Mum/2005 the Tribunal vide order dated 30/06/2017 admitted the additional grounds and decided the legal ground in favour of the assessee. 3. The additional grounds of appeal raised by assessee vide app…