ACIT v. Hotel Blue Moon

321 ITR 362Supreme Court of India2010#94 most cited

What is ACIT v. Hotel Blue Moon authority for?

The issuance of a notice under Section 143(2) within the statutory time limit is mandatory for completing an assessment under Section 143(3), and the failure to do so renders the assessment invalid. This defect is not curable under Section 292BB of the Income Tax Act, 1961.

623

judgments rely on this decision, according to BharatTax’s citation analysis of 384,082 Indian tax judgments — from 2001 to 2026.

Also referred to as

ACIT v. Hotel Blue Moon · Section 143(2) notice · mandatory compliance · assessment invalid · quashing assessment · Section 292BB · curability of defect · assessment procedure · time limit notice · Section 143(3)

Also reported as

3 SCC 259229 CTR 219188 Taxmann 13

Issues it is cited on

Judgments citing ACIT v. Hotel Blue Moon

Jagannath Sahoo, Puri vs. Income Tax Officer, Puri Ward, Puri

In the result, appeal of the assessee stands allowed

ITA 517/CTK/2024[2013-14]Status: DisposedITAT Cuttack31 Dec 2024AY 2013-14

Bench: Before Shri George Mathanmember & Manish Agarwal Manish Agarwalassessment Year : 2013-14 Jagannath Jagannath Sahoo Sahoo S/O. S/O. Vs. Income Tax Officer, Puri Income Tax Officer, Puri Sridhar Sahoo, At Sridhar Sahoo, At-Kalia Devi Ward, Puri Sahi, Sahi, Near Near Dakhina Dakhina Kali Kali Temple, Po/Ps; /Dist: Puri Temple, Po/Ps; /Dist: Puri Pan/Gir No. No.Djqps 1301 J Assessee By : Shri P.K.Mishra, Adv Assessee By : Shri P.K.Mishra, Revenue By : Shri S.C.Mohanty, Sr Dr S.C.Mohanty, Sr Dr Date Of Hearing : 31/12/20 2024 Date Of Pronouncement : 31/12/20 024 O R D E R Per Bench This Is An This Is An Appeal Filed By The Assessee Against The Order Of The Ld Appeal Filed By The Assessee Against The Order Of The Ld Cit(A), Nfac, Delhi Dated Cit(A), Nfac, Delhi Dated 3.7.2024 In Appeal No. Cit(A), Bhubaneswar A), Bhubaneswar- 2/10251/2019-20 20 For The Assessment Year 2013-14. 2. Shri P.K.Mishra, P.K.Mishra,Ld Ar Appeared For The Assessee & Shri The Assessee & Shri S.C.Mohanty, Sr. , Sr. Dr Appeared For The Revenue.

For Appellant: Shri P.K.Mishra, AdvFor Respondent: Shri S.C.Mohanty, Sr DR
Section 143(2)Section 148

…ear : 2013-14 issuance of notice u/s.143(2) of the Act. Once the notice u/s.143(2) is not validly issued, consequent proceedings cannot be held as valid. In this regard, reliance on the judgement of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Hotel Blue Moon [2010] 321 ITR 362 (SC), wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that the issue of notice u/s. 143(2) of the I.T. Act is mandatory and not procedural and if the notice is not served within the prescribed period, the assessment order is invalid. Respectfully following the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Hotel Blue Moon (supra) and looking to the…

M/S. Altrade Minerals Pvt. Limited, Rourkela vs. ACIT, Central Circle, Sambalpur

In the result, appeal of the assessee is partly allowed

ITA 65/CTK/2023[2011-12]Status: DisposedITAT Cuttack16 Dec 2024AY 2011-12

Bench: Before Shri George Mathanmember & Manish Agarwal Manish Agarwalassessment Year : 2011-12 M/S. Altrade Minerals Pvt /S. Altrade Minerals Pvt Vs. Asst. Asst. Commissioner Commissioner Of Of Ltd., C/O. Kadmawala & Co., C/O. Kadmawala & Co., Income Tax, Central Circle, Income Tax, Central Circle, C.A., C.A., Budhram Budhram Oram Oram Sambalpur Market, Market, Kachery Kachery Road, Road, Rourkela. Pan/Gir No. No.Aafca 7136 F (Appellant (Appellant) .. ( Respondent Respondent) Assessee By : Shri M.R.Sahu, Ca Revenue By : Shri S.C.Mohanty, Sr Dr : Shri S.C.Mohanty, Sr Dr Date Of Hearing : 16/12/20 2024 Date Of Pronouncement : 16/12/20 024

For Appellant: Shri M.R.Sahu, CAFor Respondent: Shri S.C.Mohanty, Sr DR
Section 120(4)(b)Section 127Section 143(2)Section 143(3)Section 14A

…stion by this court. 6. as far as Question No. (iii) is concerned , the matter is squarely covered in favour of the Assessee by several judgements of the Supreme Court and the High Court including Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax v. Hotel Blue Moon (2010) 321 ITR 362(SC) and the Delhi High Court in Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax v. Shri Jay Jay Shiv Shankar Traders Pvt.Ltd.(2016) 383 ITR (Del) 448 and the order dated 25th February 2022 of this Court in ITA No.20 of 2017 (Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, Bhubaneswar v. Orissa Mining Corporation Ltd.) 7. With the admitted position being that on facts in th…

Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle-1, Patna, Fourth Floor, J.P. Bhavan, Dakbunglow Chauraha vs. Tulshyan Metals Private Limited, Patna

The appeal is allowed and the order of the High Court is vacated

ITA 340/PAT/2024[2015-16]Status: FixedITAT Patna27 Nov 2024AY 2015-16

Bench: Shri Duvvuru Rl Reddy, Vice- & Shri Sanjay Awasthii.T.A. Nos.339&340/Pat/2024 Assessment Years: 2014-15 & 2015-16 Acit, Circle-1, Patna……..........................................................……….……Appellant Vs. Tulshyan Metals Pvt. Ltd…………………………...............……...…..…..Respondent 3D, Shakambari Complex, Sabji Bazar Chowk, Nagla Bihar-800008. [Pan: Aacct2904K] Appearances By: Shri Ashok Kumar Cit, Appeared On Behalf Of The Appellant. Shri Sandeep Goel, Ar, Appeared On Behalf Of The Respondent. Date Of Concluding The Hearing : November 18, 2024 Date Of Pronouncing The Order : November 27, 2024 Order Per Sanjay Awasthi: 1. The Captioned Appeals Have Been Preferred By The Revenue Against The Separate Orders Of Even Date 30.01.2024 Of The National Faceless Appeal Centre [Hereinafter Referred To As ‘Cit(A)’] Passed U/S 250 Of The Income Tax Act (Hereinafter Referred To As The ‘Act’) For Assessment Years 2014-15 & 2015-16. Since, The Substantive Issues Are Common In Both The Assessment Years & The Appeals Pertain To The Same Assessee, Therefore, The Two Appeals Are Being Disposed Of Through This Single Order. 2. However, In Both The Cases, The Action Of The Assessing Officer In Assuming Jurisdiction U/S 147 Of The Act Through Issuance Of Notice U/S 148 Of The Act Has Been In Dispute, Whereby, The Ld. Cit(A) Has Held That Since Notice U/S 143(2) Of The Act Was Not Issued For Both The Years, Following The Issuance Of Notice U/S 148 Of The Act, Then The Subsequent Orders Passed U/S 147 R.W.S 144, R.W.S 144B Of The Act Would Be Null & Void. However, For The Sake Of Record, The Grounds In Both The Cases Are Extracted As Under:

Section 143(2)Section 147Section 148Section 151Section 250

…impugned order dated 24.03.2022. In support of appellant's above legal ground appellant rightfully relied upon plethora of decisions of supreme court in CIT vs Laxman Dass Khandelwal (2019) 108 taxmann.com 183 (SC), ACIT vs Hotel Blue Moon reported in (2010) 321 ITR 362 (supra) and jurisdictional high court decision in case of Chand Bihari Agrawal Vs Commissioner of Income. Miscellaneous Appeal No. 239/2011 order dated 25.07.2023 and CIT-11 Vs Nagendra Prasad. Miscellaneous Appeal No. 662/2014, thus this ground of appellant deserves to be allowed and resultantly assessment order is declared to be invalid as per…

Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle-1, Patna, Fourth Floor, Loknayak Jay Prakash Bhawan, Dakbunglow Chauraha vs. Tulshyan Metals Private Limited, Patna

The appeal is allowed and the order of the High Court is vacated

ITA 339/PAT/2024[2014-15]Status: FixedITAT Patna27 Nov 2024AY 2014-15

Bench: Shri Duvvuru Rl Reddy, Vice- & Shri Sanjay Awasthii.T.A. Nos.339&340/Pat/2024 Assessment Years: 2014-15 & 2015-16 Acit, Circle-1, Patna……..........................................................……….……Appellant Vs. Tulshyan Metals Pvt. Ltd…………………………...............……...…..…..Respondent 3D, Shakambari Complex, Sabji Bazar Chowk, Nagla Bihar-800008. [Pan: Aacct2904K] Appearances By: Shri Ashok Kumar Cit, Appeared On Behalf Of The Appellant. Shri Sandeep Goel, Ar, Appeared On Behalf Of The Respondent. Date Of Concluding The Hearing : November 18, 2024 Date Of Pronouncing The Order : November 27, 2024 Order Per Sanjay Awasthi: 1. The Captioned Appeals Have Been Preferred By The Revenue Against The Separate Orders Of Even Date 30.01.2024 Of The National Faceless Appeal Centre [Hereinafter Referred To As ‘Cit(A)’] Passed U/S 250 Of The Income Tax Act (Hereinafter Referred To As The ‘Act’) For Assessment Years 2014-15 & 2015-16. Since, The Substantive Issues Are Common In Both The Assessment Years & The Appeals Pertain To The Same Assessee, Therefore, The Two Appeals Are Being Disposed Of Through This Single Order. 2. However, In Both The Cases, The Action Of The Assessing Officer In Assuming Jurisdiction U/S 147 Of The Act Through Issuance Of Notice U/S 148 Of The Act Has Been In Dispute, Whereby, The Ld. Cit(A) Has Held That Since Notice U/S 143(2) Of The Act Was Not Issued For Both The Years, Following The Issuance Of Notice U/S 148 Of The Act, Then The Subsequent Orders Passed U/S 147 R.W.S 144, R.W.S 144B Of The Act Would Be Null & Void. However, For The Sake Of Record, The Grounds In Both The Cases Are Extracted As Under:

Section 143(2)Section 147Section 148Section 151Section 250

…impugned order dated 24.03.2022. In support of appellant's above legal ground appellant rightfully relied upon plethora of decisions of supreme court in CIT vs Laxman Dass Khandelwal (2019) 108 taxmann.com 183 (SC), ACIT vs Hotel Blue Moon reported in (2010) 321 ITR 362 (supra) and jurisdictional high court decision in case of Chand Bihari Agrawal Vs Commissioner of Income. Miscellaneous Appeal No. 239/2011 order dated 25.07.2023 and CIT-11 Vs Nagendra Prasad. Miscellaneous Appeal No. 662/2014, thus this ground of appellant deserves to be allowed and resultantly assessment order is declared to be invalid as per…

Best City Realtors India Pvt. Ltd, New Delhi vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-Tax, New Delhi

In the result, the appeal filed by the assessee is partly allowed

ITA 1515/DEL/2015[2011-12]Status: DisposedITAT Delhi04 Oct 2024AY 2011-12

Bench: Shri Saktijit Dey, Hon’Ble & Shri S.Rifaur Rahmanbest City Realtors India Pvt. Ltd., Vs. Dcit, Cc – 06, Plot No.H-8, 1St Floor, New Delhi. Netaji Subhash Place, Pitampura, New Delhi. (Pan : Aaccb7687B) (Appellant) (Respondent) Assessee By : Shri Salil Kapoor, Advocate Shri Shivam Yadav, Advocate Revenue By : Ms. Nimisha Singh, Cit Dr Date Of Hearing : 24.07.2024 Date Of Order : 04.10.2024 Order Per S.Rifaur Rahman,Am: This Appeal Has Been Filed By The Assessee Against The Order Of Ld. Commissioner Of Income Tax (Appeals)-24, New Delhi [“Ld. Cit(A)”, For Short] Dated 22.12.2014 For The Assessment Year 2011-12. 2. The Grounds Of Appeal Taken By The Assessee Read As Under :- “1. That In Making Addition, The Ld/- Cit(A) Has Erred In Recording Adverse Findings Which Were Not Only Based On Misappreciation Of Evidence But Are Also Based On Non Existent Facts & Such Findings As Recorded Are Factually Incorrect To State That The Assessee Company Has Manipulated The Transactions With C. R. Sons Builders & Developers

For Appellant: Shri Salil Kapoor, AdvocateFor Respondent: Ms. Nimisha Singh, CIT DR
Section 132Section 142Section 142(1)Section 143Section 143(2)

…) was issued only on 23.10.2012 which is beyond the period of limitation specified u/s 143 (2) of the Act. Therefore, the assumption of the jurisdiction beyond 5 limitation period is liable to be quashed as held in the case of ACIT vs. Hotel Blue Moon (2010) 321 ITR 362 (SC). Hon’ble Supreme Court held as under :- “15) We may now revert back to Section 158 BC(b) which is the material provision which requires our consideration. Section 158 BC(b) provides for enquiry and assessment. The said provision reads "that the assessing officer shall proceed to determine the undisclosed income of the Block period in the man…

Rohit Baid, Kolkata vs. ITO, Ward-36(1), Kolkata

In the result, the appeal of the assessee stands allowed

ITA 15/KOL/2024[2015-16]Status: DisposedITAT Kolkata12 Sept 2024AY 2015-16

Bench: Shri Sanjay Garg & Rajesh Kumari.T.A No.15/Kol/2024 Assessment Year: 2015-16 Rohit Baid………………………..…………………… ........................……Appellant Nokha House, 190B, S P Mukherjee Road, Kalighat, Kolkata – 700026. [Pan: Adppb7719R] Vs. Ito, Ward-36(1), Kolkata…...................…................…........……...…..…..Respondent Appearances By: Shri Bikash Surana, Ar, Appeared On Behalf Of The Appellant. Shri P. P. Barman, Addl. Cit- Sr. Dr, Appeared On Behalf Of The Respondent. Date Of Concluding The Hearing : June 13, 2024 Date Of Pronouncing The Order : September 12, 2024 आदेश / Order संजय गग", "या"यक सद"य "वारा / Per Sanjay Garg: The Present Appeal Has Been Preferred By The Assessee Against The Order Dated 07.11.2023 Of The National Faceless Appeal Centre [Hereinafter Referred To As ‘Cit(A)’] Passed U/S 250 Of The Income Tax Act (Hereinafter Referred To As The ‘Act’). 2. The Assessee In This Appeal Has Taken The Following Grounds Of Appeal: “1. For That The Ito Ward 36(1) Kolkata Was Not Vested With The Pecuniary Jurisdiction Over The Case Of The Assessee For The Year Under Consideration, Therefore, The Notice U/S 148 Dated 3 1.03.2021 Issued By Non-Jurisdictional Ao Does Not Have Legal Sanctity & Thus Subsequent Proceedings & Assessment Dated 07.11.2023 Cannot Be Sustained & Is Liable For Being Struck Down, Thus Bad In Law & Void.

Section 120Section 147Section 148Section 151Section 250Section 292B

…be upheld.” 6. We note that the issue is squarely covered by various decisions of the Jurisdictional Calcutta High Court and we are bound to follow the same. Moreover, as held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of ‘ACIT vs. Hotel Blue Moon’ reported in 321 ITR 362 (SC) that the issue of notice u/s 143(2) is sine qua non to assume jurisdiction to proceed with the assessment in a case. Similarly, in our view, in the case of the reopening of the assessment u/s 147 of the Act, the issue of notice u/s 148 of the Act by the Assessing Officer having jurisdiction is also sine qua non. If the said notices had been…

Harbans Singh Bagga, Kolkata vs. DCIT, Cir-11(1), Kolkata.

In the result, appeal of the assessee is allowed

ITA 1231/KOL/2023[2014-15]Status: DisposedITAT Kolkata11 Sept 2024AY 2014-15

Bench: Shri Sanjay Garg & Rajesh Kumari.T.A No.1231/Kol/2023 Assessment Year: 2014-15 Harbans Singh Bagga.…....………………………… ........................……Appellant A-7 Rajasthali, No-3 Jamadar Khan Lane Near Copper House, Kolkata – 700019. [Pan: Afbpb0526J] Vs. Dcit, Circle-11(1), Kolkata................…................…........……...…..…..Respondent Appearances By: Shri Sunil Surana, Ar, Appeared On Behalf Of The Appellant. Shri P. P. Barman, Addl. Cit-Sr. Dr, Appeared On Behalf Of The Respondent. Date Of Concluding The Hearing : June 13, 2024 Date Of Pronouncing The Order : September 11, 2024 आदेश / Order संजय गग", "या"यक सद"य "वारा / Per Sanjay Garg: The Present Appeal Has Been Preferred By The Assessee Against The Order Dated 22.09.2023 Of The National Faceless Appeal Centre [Hereinafter Referred To As ‘Cit(A)’] Passed U/S 250 Of The Income Tax Act (Hereinafter Referred To As The ‘Act’). 2. The Assessee In This Appeal Has Contested The Addition Made By The Assessing Officer Of Rs.1,14,41,888/- Treating The Long-Term Capital Gains Claimed By The Assessee As Bogus. The Assessee Has Contested The Validity Of The Aforesaid Additions Not Only On Merits But Also On The Ground That The Concerned Assessing Officer Did Not Have The Pecuniary Jurisdiction To Pass The Assessment Order In Question By Way Of Additional Legal Ground. Since The Additional Legal Ground Taken By The

Section 120Section 143(2)Section 143(3)Section 250

…ature and are, therefore, not adjudicated upon. Accordingly, the appeal of the assessee is allowed. 10. In the result, appeal of the assessee is allowed.” 5. Moreover, as held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of ‘ACIT vs. Hotel Blue Moon’ reported in 321 ITR 362 (SC) that the issue of notice u/s 143(2) is sine qua non to assume jurisdiction to proceed with the assessment in a case. If the said notice had been issued by the Assessing Officer who did not have the jurisdiction over the assessee, then such notice is to be treated as non-est. The assessment carried out in such cases will be bad in law. Relian…