4 orders · Page 1 of 1
The Tribunal held that the appeal stands dismissed in view of CBDT Circular No. 3/2018. The circular mandates that appeals shall not be filed before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal where the tax effect does not exceed Rs. 20,00,000. Since the tax effect in the present appeal was stated to be less than Rs. 50 lac, and the limit for ITAT is Rs. 20,00,000, the appeal was not maintainable under the revised guidelines. The court further clarified that the appellant (Revenue) is at liberty to revive this appeal if it is not coming within the ambit of the above Circular, implying that if the tax effect was indeed below the Rs. 20,00,000 threshold, the dismissal is final, but if there was any ambiguity or if the appeal fell under an exception, it could be re-examined. The ratio decidendi is that departmental appeals must adhere to the monetary limits prescribed by the CBDT for efficient litigation management.
The Tribunal held that the reliance by the respondents on sale deeds to disentitle the appellants from the value of the 17.03.1986 exemplar sale was unsustainable. The Court found no justification for not applying the value of this exemplar sale. Regarding the potentiality of the land, the Tribunal noted that the proximity to developed/posh colonies was admitted by the respondents. The potentiality must be assessed not just by actual use but by what use the land can be put to in the foreseeable future. The Tribunal also observed that the land was clearly being used for agricultural purposes. Furthermore, the Tribunal noted that a similar reference/assessment was done in cases of other villages. The Tribunal found that the LAC's categorization of land in contiguous villages (Kilokari, Khizrabad, Nangli Razapur, and Garhi Mendu) as 'Sailabi', 'Khadar', and 'Flooded land' respectively, while awarding the same amount per Bigha, indicated that the LAC assessed the potentiality and proximity to developed colonies similarly. The Tribunal cited the Supreme Court's decision in Union of India v. Bal Ram and Anr. (2010) 5 SC 747, which held that there is no justification to make a distinction between lands lying in different villages if the purpose of acquisition is the same and the lands are identical and similar. The Tribunal concluded that failing to award similar compensation in similar areas would lead to discrimination between landowners. The emphasis laid by the respondents on the land being flooded or in 'Forward Bunds' was also not supported by evidence. The Tribunal found the approach of the LAC in awarding similar compensation for 'Khadar' land and 'Flooded land' showed the government viewed the lands for potential development on an equal scale, making the vast difference between the award of Behlolpur Khadar and the other villages unwarranted. The Tribunal also noted that the Supreme Court in New Okhla Industrial Development Authority v. Harnand Singh (Deceased) thr. LRs & Ors. held that where there is no direct evidence of relevant sale exemplars, it is reasonable to make an adjustment.
The High Court held that revision petitions filed under Section 25 of the Wealth Tax Act, 1957, against an intimation issued under Section 16(1) of the Act are maintainable. The Court found that the Commissioner had not examined the matter on merits and that the analogy drawn from the Income Tax Act, specifically the Bombay High Court's decision in Commissioner of Income Tax vs. Anderson Marine & Sons Pvt. Ltd., was persuasive. The reasoning was that the process of taking a decision, including sending an intimation, constitutes a decision in itself and is in the nature of an order passed by the concerned authority. This provides sufficient ambit within the law to invoke the jurisdiction of revision under Section 25 of the Wealth Tax Act, 1957. The Court noted that the intimation under Section 143(1) of the Income Tax Act, as interpreted by the Bombay High Court, partakes of the colour of an order passed under the Act, and this interpretation was upheld by the Supreme Court. Therefore, the special appeals were dismissed.