COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS,MUMBAI vs. M/S. J.D. ORGOCHEM LIMITED

PDF · subscribers
C.A. No.-005843-005843 - 2006Supreme Court10 April 20084 pages
For Respondent: K. RAJEEV
AI SummaryAllowed

What did the Supreme Court hold?

The Tribunal held that the expenditure was revenue in nature as it was incurred for maintaining the hotel in its existing condition and did not bring into existence any new asset. Therefore, the assessee was entitled to the deduction.

What were the facts?

The assessee claimed a deduction for expenses incurred on account of repairs and maintenance of a hotel. The AO disallowed the claim, treating it as capital expenditure. The CIT(A) upheld the AO's decision.

What were the issues?

Whether the expenditure incurred on repairs and maintenance of a hotel is revenue or capital in nature.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 37(1)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

> stream xœuW]sÛF|ç¯ØJ]]ä*ÞoìúédI‰•³%D'UW~HH‚C4JÑýú됢ì8qf—;³3===Ë/JFiþÙ~Ζ“/“×W^Ýõ£ÕãĨf¢‹¤~™˜äB‘“ eÀi§–“ƒ-œS!¹ÄO““+LàÚ:+«³.-Œ-¬W³‰5Î"và˪ÅĔ¥ÇÕÑd[Äqû"YìÄ\Äȝä½GíLQZe’ÍôµÖEV†ÎK¯Bæ'îÈð˜ð}pvpµ+tB6§";•B(ŒÉ\ãÒ¤’uE©”CØÆÂEÒ±(³¡‹XxX0þl±.ƒJˆ†Á›²ÐbÊÂ%x°A¥ìаÈWãŠhY‰u4E $ˆUÔGUcaKœˆÆÉ©AYïC™ k`‹Óܱ©ðQŐp9,¼E*a‘ £Ý˜‚Æ8§Áí¨Žöˆ@TM—ÊXÏ+qžødœ¿ŸØˆ3Ó`ç3jl“Ñ…3Êǘ8eSد¦Í1ÎÒ"ñ5Î a#™Â&àoKƒ#Êç`x?6b ÄÍg„Œ›yÕ.•/s$<¶Äõ>JT¼²!{ÉG å=ö6—…øÔ¨*Šì-.×ÀE ‚&ifb²Á ˆ›¼*ÉEÃÌèÔ_”I™öÒÂâ$ÙPD‹¸Ø ÎÂ"h\†ž‚‰w¦žÉÔQŠ,W¤ìK”È"ˆ¨Qæ•,ŔXgäÍJY’×Z“¤É,2OýÉoú#Aëy [mYD`ç©eá‹QÚ -I, À¬ÁÒ¬]ˆ¸6ʆÓL$DD>œ)œ'¹Àx܂Nei‚ÏÂx´r(JXxB0‚nÂɠዷg-ød ¿06å"“ÀŒ1tE¦ðœ)hÖÄ'†1ë°Ö¥)k@3×YÖÈM[?Vœ%FgØxö4¦F`‹š`á´EöÞ*W¢­pš§c©\¤²À‰4°Œ¤ˆÕX#g4;gœr‰ogQ@Dô7jٝØñщ‘Ä

GhHþ@¤(Sph›j ¹dt6¼Ù¬GًJ9¿Ncϰ—Ò ÎPÞ;*%ÀŒ(;H*ÕÑùRº Q£þ°ˆhðÛ mq"% 3´h[,›'‹#ûÖi Pq&à³t²ƒ’¢™¼c˜,€Dt…aì1QZ¼ "„ßÁ"Ž gFB@= ½9i85Jw;è¹/±YÀyTÂeMTàŸé8wpk¡±T¸°\Y@Ž1 ãr¢ÅƒÌž¢ÐÑ.~Ô,Ñi$”èÙrH5ƒT˒)bhƒ´ºRì˜v¬w"6ÎúLÄ,{µd 1’XXˆ ñ º‰+Ø9ŸdIÅæ’ÓÂÆl‘u´aÔÀ¦q)*¦v b6d1ÖÆ U­,*î”A P&KýÐøÔU´ ¨QÊtr‰v÷TÞ/FÛ"' MJ$ Ð;Ø 8T' ‘¹À`]ލ”…’…Â9[wOµÉ$3µ#Í Bڄ*x¢ãé­`DÍ]F ’«¡—”, ™)ª(¥aiyß±‹­‘¾ÆÚ¥¤6¸„!‚ÚIM})¨zî±@ ½œ/ùhäܲ†dXà!ÎBZ>› g, 3Ô¾Ž¹N#ǽRøÉ†_ phµŽ¯~ĸ’s—§Ó³éÙÅùéÕlnÛå²éû¦]ÕMŽ7ýÐ.ûCõa³¼©š½õÕéõåÅùÉéùô…õ‡×ׅúµ8)ÔEw×Îîë¥zß,›¡žï Oަ§L0ýòæHîµö¯\©ƒ·§çÇï^ø¼.Þêúìüݑú§ú­¸æâêòãÕ¿®öNŸíí~UՉúE}P@HM}_^^\MÞ¾?ݛŸývö^]^ž½'”#Zp‹‘þ*ŒCdˆ}48÷M¡äŸé}­ê?‡z5¶Ï›®éçÍl\ø¶êûÈ®î°qÛ̀ïЪyÓϪn.ö±]µê+±F%ªÅ¦–“‹¶¯çêæIŽ7ËuÛ pÓô²þ²©{¹¯Y=´‹lVøß2õjdÅã}3»W¢«{Õn$Ø áÎï– ½ZÍUÛÍát^¡jhŽá^ý\ßt›ª{:HÄۚÉ.p§¦]s³Y 7·ùì¶>½:T¿#~õ_Iùm½b˜Ã–vÄûÀn‘¾ªûu»š3Üûº«‘äm³@0•ºi &„¯º§]%2¸˜ íMÝB*rV·m'wÏu &l~ð‡A4«fèZuÜ=õÕÿšUýC1V¶¯š¹ºkÛy¯n+\²Y£wu5g=%º qÇð%‚òÿZï ¿…`tÍí­:š ³’g,2ÞB'˜È9žÇ:d[ƒ õâiÌAªu׌_‡÷Xõj^ÏUGHqøñúx­ôwp³§¿Û¢z´XÔwõ|1V´{q5ßQm¾½lYï°èÚå~oÏß~³^/\€åó_JbÀ<ý^ þpßC'õz3<©¿Ñ!RšŒþŠ£0~¨ºÙýá‹@U`2jÁ0¿ÛW;°¾m«þ¾Ý,°=¥«?£ Ä·]m5äy‹þ/GÓ©ú Î*i?~Ù³zx7ö÷d \TÈ\\Iðä úÑV#ªc0Øù+PgÃXÕ¦#xNgÇw:9¿yTÆ;›áB\þì!Û²_¬ÚŠÃº«oë®ëÜÕÕ]լВ7ßrâPÖû¾Þ£~´îÛ®Aojɐôÿ›R~ÚNª#ª‚"vËg‚5#P·ÍЁKÕQØÀüÛò;¨çÑæNEŸ4{û¤š¡ß«ÚNlªçˆ«ç8ŸëÊC³vE)Ú£‰8Ù¢Þ®6c›I-W²7¯×U7Œ—µ¬Âãþ<嘽:v, Wí îêÕä:U]×X=PÁXnçø@éÔS»êõ°glO§ê?þù?CÞ:Tendstream endobj 7 0 obj 3232 endobj 15 0 obj <> stream xœW]sÛF|ç¯ØÊËÉU2ŒýÞužǗòåÃ>[¹{Ñ HB RŠþýuς”줒ª‹+¦îÌÎôôô ?«ºÒªæŸåss»ú¼Òµº_iÕ­ê*©V:Y_å¤|ô8fÕíJgo*k•O6ñSçd+íùìª:+Sçºò´Ð¦2NmVF8 x_Fõ+£ÃAgS…òÂÙ*¼ ¹ o’µôj««h”N&Ó{¨ëºÊJÓytÊg~⎠ ß{ëa¹¶U†É©ÊV%ï+­3ŸqiRÉØ*ÖÊ"lmà"Õ¡ŠYÓE¨,6xŽžA%ÄCït¬j1H±² ŒW)ÛÊ{<{ä[ãŠ`YÄsЕ $á‰U¨ŽªBe"N­«dUDPÆá{se4,b±5ߘT¹ ‚O¸΄*EX¤J×¶¤ qNxä©q;ªS;D  4ªVG¥ã•8O|2Î߬LÀ€é<°s56IוÕʅL¬2É?>L“ƒ¯¬¡Eâ'jœ3@‹¤+“€¿‰G”Ë^ó~¼É7—2næT;*s <&âú Ñ!§ŒÏŽDr¨¹DG É±Ÿ5ªŠ";ƒËÀ5p¨à€N53ÑYãÄM^ErQ33:ÕÞU1)À^Zœ$›=Šh·»ÁYXø—á„#‚`¢Ãž©gòF³01#J@‘å ‚‚”]D‰ ‚5*¼’a£èˆçŒ¼Y)Cò£“4™AæI ± ?ùmA$h,2÷d«‰U6p^‘Z¾¥ñµ!I½˜Õ¬šµó×yak&â"ÎT֑\`ƒ:ÖXFø©#Ö*Ìx/9ã¸LÉè£e•p¼¢¦TjJ%MÙKX#–8Ê10úŠ>/L>LÕHöZ,þDaØ÷I„AÓ´±!`6BÀe½„—Ö!Ñ‘Í1\†¬tyž™–3LœoŒLmQ+d„ÁEÑE*ÏÒ¢ó¨øà(–ÀŒ xÍEŽÖÑ9&žðQtAځ/¹;ŽD+¥ë5yªƒìrØKkY 8„}Qû,[±v ©s΀ŽÚ™YèI€Î!̑G† Zœ±>Ëú€tr>riä3¸e8 É ±À"ÎB®Íš3Ðiê·c>§Â1‡Þ’®¶ÔpŒ€[S*½Aq>” éÀ­¥1´„±ü]ÁE 2.R„¤)­Fù ¶ìÄè•ÌQbjt„æÞšœÄXsáî¡Eׅ£…µØ`„T©œì©µ,,Bk´~¤,|ÄïžûU_=ÆÕŠÿû€¿"JM-¾þŒuZ~)-›[õÝÅêŇÌW«ò3Š"­"÷vÊÅíêìf¿ß½|ñâ_¿~ÿöcõËÛ×ÕÛ_Ô³‹OØHhp±]}üõý‡7?¿Q¯ßýúáB½û§zûË÷o_əx<ó¾¹n•Qã•òbýâÌ˽Ï!h깖­ÞæýxÛNs¥Ô«Y͇Í͹ºoU3µô°¿iÕ]×ÞãÍ^uƒ¼ S¸¼øiuÖ¬çvØÈÑfxPã .ÏænsùL}‚ãîªkÖ} Lš_íGüëS»Ù/ÿXÍÍ-®¶ªnúáÍ<·ó,†wMh«op”á⾀0ùßÏS¥~œºùfhԏ‡Ûf:W}ÛLC»U›ñ0Ìm¯šÝoºášQ­Û›¦¿:fÇøq¨ï›a¯îÇCOãaß"I÷¦¹£ùÔ^7ӖÑÓöª‘ø›’Ä~j†oºq˜%£ý8þ¦v}ƒ\Öíþ¾m d’è®™ö];=ÍM·Uë®ïV;ì§µmöÈÀÄý8{·Ùë¹éœó¹êPY ãžanÚîN0:Ų›ºÍ©h×㸝Oƒ¯‰MCÃH›^±ßZf¸Uêª?lö¹y‰¬¹§ö!á0Þ¶¿“=7f^@»i¯$¦ûfV‡éºÝžó¾Fmšy ƒÑ6ûÃԞ/ð®[ƒWt·»qBDxîàš.?î§Qðî;!ƒDKñnþ€ ¼[zz>5kõ~7 Ì8Íêýýi¿]\ÞÍB˜×c߃wãĸ^ ågõ:€óòLû¾©~ª.*0Ô/Ï>V¯«ËgÅ ¦2©ŸPƒúáÐÏÿ“yS;ïÆa `Ϗ˜ŒøkBšÃöˆ×|ئ#b‡k^óé°½fqªÇØÒÛw-+§ÚÛ5ê»@Ûχvf1ÕÔt3\¬äõ×ÃøI„©BY‘„Ûæäë–6E™Ú;vμGí8Þu3{áIly‰íc+m¢Ìå™Ó—ÏÎO/´C PêÀï^áå‚Û±f¯6€ë1D5ä‚Á3¤WK7œÂÛw·à$h˃@>©—Ï_’ß,±¨oDh¾ÃPº„Í@M“N:W·-:½è!ϖfG½ZD¸mÁäێP²6›qÚ ƒï;tréÍ#2ÇþùxX?Ÿ—lKþøâ1ýoåƽú®+á@ikÖiw˜v#„R¤WS8¡ž‹añøOœ“ÛŸœ}Š&hÜ]]PuŽ$>ÖÚã _°Lð!Ò.äì›{¹]´À‚Þ¤²ÆÛMA垨œµ=ìxíf¹í¼¹i ¢]Hê±Ø‚˜S{{¢FÝT?>rR-†3:¬/æ-jå%[·Od¬¸¿é`"vÈ ï~;ª$g$=m»ô ÒØo%õñŠÑl%é¹éÿµ…Dݵ`|ó8Ër¸¨?B,·Ôn‚Œžœ-ZIk6׺=?*6:r**ú¥ncÞl©¦„øqŠb„l™[(ÉáAdä®E»{tÿÑóú0ƒ¨ó‰‡mC<¤¸G±®D$Î0w(hÉåH€2ÁYƧJÒ]ïÉùm» SÁ½x.õZ3û~C ÅéZ}]~HÖ^€hq†kî|[ôs³”pXÊÜ|5Y‘Í0à—r›Í©4ÍÄÖív¤t1ŸÝHõ¾,Ü©hó2¿¼àØÞ¾®–ž¤¢¡ñË4þ‰2üAÎOHìž©\**Ð>‰€Í;^pb NÓÁÓf‘Fù;њ};/ìÜ~=ŽŸ(<–hQøÿ¢6ý·,ŸÔ"¦_®{J$ÛÕ1„¯@~"@ܱzHˎk¼y ¤ù±£Š5º{’~*Äc½ßÛ®A2[îÖ¥lBÚ¿7s^`ž—ÂVË 0•ÛWy-¾I«Òí2»×ãݓÆFHíf¢ÇùÔÀJæ§ÈïÀŸóH•Uº9mÉÛ{ÒÜEô0Ÿ0lYgŠð-Ã]×.‹.¯ïôTöPnDp=µŸÝT¶#Î96ÿÃ2?×}·)`ö7ãÔÉü¥$ß.Óã蚾ûî¶+D»nÇë©Ùávè7®lhW‚ỳJ² 0Ò«žø£Ãí(›?zû6sáRÕ]~NJvr*a½¹Pÿ^ñÏÿ«ùNíendstream endobj 16 0 obj 3474 endobj 19 0 obj <> stream xœW]sÛÆ}ç¯ØÑt&ʌc?m_ê(iÇNc»¶ÜL§îDB$b R²þ}Ϲ ”ãd'fîÞ¯sŸTži•óÏô¹Ü.>-t®Z5‹<+Õߺ´>‹¥ò…Ç1«¶ ½É¬U¾´%?u,m¦=Ÿ]–Geò˜gž7´ÉŒS˅ÑÆÞÀ–QíB…ƒÏ £ÉBzálV¼ 1 oJki=äVg…Qº4‘ÖCžçYT勤|ä'|DX,ñ½·÷` æ6ËK„ab™E«Jï3­#Ÿá´T¥±Y‘#(‹°µ‰2Y5M„ÌáãυgP%bÄEït‘år¡,2[â‚ÃãUmæ=ž=òÍá"”¬ÀsЙ—H³V!w8ªŠ2SàDÐ:+­*”qøÞ137b±9ߘ2sA_Â9n8²²À2Ó¹Mi høÀ <5¼Ü!ZJµ¼PÚ8ºÄyÖ'âüfaΠ˜Î£v.cSê<³Z¹P &V™ÒŸžQLƒÏ¬á’ŸÀ8F /J™õ7…Æå¢×ô¡ô¬›‹žyhÊ1°<¦€û…C*N‰äªĉŽ…v&™ØÌ*@vÎÀ5pUÁ]æÌDG ˆ›¼*ÈEÍÌhT{—¥Òìå ƒ“d³ˆq[°œÅ ŸÃN8VLtðá™z$o4)"¢D)¢¸`Q²+‘A!"Ì«4l]à9"o"eH^ct)Mfy)¥± ?ùmA$h,2÷d«)²€ÚÀxFjØb”Æç†$õÀ¬–Åʉpä…Í™ˆˆeЁ‚”‰‚ŸºŠ¶5 y\¢Ý•·¥c´-r2Ф’„Cz‹;èD!²%¬ó(,”,g¥Ü¹æpwT›H2S;bjNҔ@Á±:Ž61Ñ ZÔÜF´ ¹jzAÉB%#EPjBË3øŽ]l´ô5ž5ëP jƒ-1D€`ê ©ªã;Ä3,*Īàºah$°"Ðæ@ù‡G™0ªˆr´|TPlc•g•!¿F¤œyŒ jzA‹AÆ4žó©~ž)áF@ÞhL”A³<HАÉäÊ .ʤ€ñâÔ³ôh/nª e29B¨9Á‰ ŽE: œmœiÐIÂ’ú8 .¡Åb)-£ØÂ8±Òc‘ªQ›ž6]Ž=”Ç”ñ¬2|Pø©óÔá°Æ2ÂO]`­Â܁Eð’3ŽË”¸@7 -«„£‹œR©)•|4i/ `XÉQŽ1€Ñ—ôõÂäÃT-È^+ƒ%О( û¾aм ÚX‡0!à²^BáSë°…I")šc¸ Yéò<2-g˜8ß™Ú:+dÄ5CE©°xx–µ˜GÉG±fdÀkö(r´ŽÆ1ñ„¢ ҆|ÊÝq°p$Z¬×䩲Ëa/ÍeàöIí£lÅÚ±hHstÔ6ÈÌBO¢èÂydÐâŒõQÖ´ “ó—F>ƒ[†Ã ’XÄ ¤áÚ¬9cQ:MýávÌç2qÌ¡·¤«-uãàÖT&‹Þˆ 8҄tàÖÒZÂXþ®à")BÒŽÀV£|›vbôJä(19:Bso-Ä˜sáî¡Eׅ£‰µØ`„Te:ÙRk ,Bk´~AYx‡ß=‹¿zŒËÿó(5ÔøúÖiù¥4},·êû›Å³·‘/nîégEZÜÛ!(7ÛÅåf¿ßýùÙ³—ïxñ.{õâ:{ñJ}{ó+6^¸Y-.ß½óöǟTׯ߿½Q¯ÿ¦^¼úáÅs9SÌgÞTëZYÕß)/·Ÿ½Åõä÷;šúN‹G+‡?\Þ~øVí7µ«¶Vý vC³¬U3ª®ß«ñpûk½Ü«}ï·µZöݪÙ7}Ǔ4Ó7ÿX\âýجꡒïîðåæYnT¥î«ö€{UGs·µZÕûzØ6]½RM§¾ýfq9ÔãŽ>0ãX÷ýjÄɦ[§Ë«¿\àã…#ð\ñŸ÷;øyØô[¹Ów‡‘÷wC¿Û¦q=î«Û¶7rf?TÝX-%À¬Náo£7§à6Õ=#êu5¬hm·ª±îÛ~ý¨c ŸvŸ#ôª[Éÿ3·‡îï”K^õ¡ƒÉ ßAß%“ràIåæ¼Ó½M5¢h«f`Eºú3òzhöõ®N‘k÷áR±éœggyÜ0O”w pTý°jºjhÚÇ 8½œ›U:D_·uÝ!<ï ³R·0Œ›Låº? ûô­ªÚ¦b¶uż«}ÊM›þЮX<¼¿¨?£ÌjrúxA–\ݦj/ÄäØì‰$c¯ªS”jIgÙowˆ¢CEûM?4ûGžèwàËÑ©Ø9C³j'LQMÆŽ8Š'¨ŒËõ+18ÙKAHkž ³µ& P¾aZmòÆ÷ؐŽä¯Æ‘ÉBÆOrB}mÇTwâѶ,àé{è>Âún~¥A̔e]¯sŸ`¿­F„v¤äÓÙóûÓ¹Y~ØWw鼐¢ï–íA ˜Äl›19¨ºGÕb洜Ã$E[§Ë€ä;èÜ4šfݺúÃz³çmÈPÅÊ ÍÜDúJ=Ô"jˆ^”•9Ap›~Òy4Íi|§éѧ2AMѿÚxîÑV‡füِó¬ý²Ì;@Ó(ûí|žòL;Â<†O•=Þf^ûf‰š¥Ý«Ÿ%h– ì.ûf[OÁIPDhû‡Ò×#€§+Ëmúv*ØØl¡„Ãì<¡¾ú£(dðmêãv%7§Ð~!÷15æñ‘zø ¾Ä49¯Î‚jÆ)jO–-þ¿PUÒ/8¿*%ôå58~HÙ#¾º»oƊÐN¤°‘!Æ×ÎëŠ ƒ[Ø$Œ öGÃÿ_èÒàŒð$Æ=$ÌÝóÔ6]ßÕ³ Öë-±î»).¹Ç^gÝÙWëÔ‡a$‚©8§§~ëòµ}b.ä—+ŸljWб´ VcŸ6˜$ISC#d‘‘퍷Žý> stream xœW]sÜÆ|¿_±¥ª”¥* Â~«7›Vºl™éʋ^@$aက#ÍŸîYÜñ¨Ø©H¶ÏÀíÌÎôôôÌ}Uy¦Uοëg½Ý|Ýè\=n´ê6yVªlti}Kå cVm7:z“Y«|iK~êXÚL{>»,Êä1Ï<-´ÉŒSõÆhgoà˨~£‹ÂáΠ£ÉBzálV¼ 1 oJké=äVg…Qº4‘ÞCžçYTšÎ §|ä'îˆðXâ{o=ìà æ6ËK„ab™E«Jï3­#Ÿqi©Jc³"GPake²"jº™ƒãυgP%b„¡wºÈr1(‹Ì–0p8`¼*£Í¼Ç³G¾9®x:ób$<± ¹ÃQU„™'‚ÖYiU ŒÃ÷¾ˆ™Ñ°ˆÅæ|cÊÌ|‰ËaáLÈÊe¦s›Ò@и'<òÔ¸ÕÉ¢PUË ¥ã•8O|"ÎßoLÀ€é<°s56¥Î3«• 0±Ê”þù`š|f -J~¢Æ1$¼(ufJào #ÊE¯y?^„Ò72næT»P®ˆð˜×Gø(RqÊøèH$€JKtpڙXdâ3GUQdgp¸.ÐeÎLtÔ¸q“W¹¨™jï²¢T:€½´08I6{Ñ n vƒ³°ð9.à GÁD‡;©}”­X;‚†Ô9g@GmƒÌ,ô$@çæÈ#CP-ÎXe}@ :9_piä3¸e8 É ±À"ÎB®Íš3Ðiê·c>—‰c½%]m© à·¦2yôFÅù&¤´–ÆÐ"Æòw)ȸH’¦p¶å+Ø´£W"G‰ÉÑš{ké$Ɯ;w-º.M¬Å#¤*ÓɞZËÂB!´Fë”…+üîyÜäøÕc\®ø¯øORS‹¯¿b–_JëG½U?\oÞ}Š|q}»I?£(ÒªàÞA¹Þn^ß/Ëîý»w?ýöãÅUöñâ<»ø¨Þ\ÿŽ„×ÍæõÕo—Ÿ>üòAÿúÛ§kõëßÕÅÇ/¾—3ÅáÌeu×*§Æ[åÅúÝ'˜§{ßBÐÔ[-7Z9ŒSË}‹¨çÝ84í°œ©qèŸÔ¼TK7Ü©÷o邇Þ¼~u¡n»¡EµˆYµÛµ}_ Ëw³ªÇa}7jñõÈ7s×´“zóÝ!ÐŒºIµÕÔwxßmwã´¨ÝÔÕ­º'õPõûJ\¬qáÄþnhºx}7ŽÍ¬*0¦@Æý‚ç'5âì”" Ëjz:ø¦]ò?ʁf_/j[M_ÚEÍûé¡}úæâûjVwˆÅ_Öm¦ÔU7À®yRÕ$ÿ“pJ×àò5à¹ê•¥ùÑ T¥nڅGwãÜÉ]Hc¼Y*|‡Èê~?w-Ðá ÿо‡Çjj#ÖcWÑÅ@‚ÏÀ'‰¼ê×¼-M6Ý0/mÕÐÛ¶úB{¢EÛݒ|t3ŠÇ+$VZ¶ìÚ:¸iwÕ´lQ×µ ÿ_öŠF+C°ª)þ¹Ü¿W7êrëvžÇiV—ìç¥Á÷Ÿ_ÏûÝT}~£+ÖS퇩­æ‘u'&SÇÒôˆ¯'CÝíúVJtÓ¶ƒê 6!b¬SÛ kêjýóëÐêòÏqøî¶?훻v>œOôóˆâ0Ñ'bò¡«É¦ë©ªFNøÃ ÿçãvÛÍ3OE?ßÏ˸ÏÔ/ûíMÕ)õ^A_òYjcã‡ìçì:ã"ž>¿¾ÊγÏoàêz ¢[$Žû¶oÔ{žy™gü¨ÑœxöxߦŠ/S5̈Œü!k[ Çû´ïÙõ4—’þ޶Ím†Ó#öóë®CXô•ìçûªïh"\ Bm;–âæ‰\¬Û¶!qæöëží³O0žÆýݽxœ)3¤ú¨ÊÚò>VÃC;Í-ûäö/¢¯QšßlÇ»Osˆ—mߌ¸ârˈÓڊ¤ Ú?êvG÷3Kyp€:œ¥šP´6r™:sš63}F&Ý m½¿YXs{E«‹T¸ß¡Š%«‡1¤.Rµêjn-TÞ@’nI@¶zк=ÑRIä §ÂqòìmÓÖ=DÚsUJ෗2ìÀöJB¡¤+šÂr®§nw*§I˜VÍj h´ U ¨]VMW©«Šµ=' *d+¥_DâרŸ‡ǝ“bSuõù ªÇÂ3|[;¨báYµÃ~ÛâZù²Œ" I-Äü¨wÐ΁œ¥§ïÑ ˜`Àñ|Îìc‘ùÔ,ò!çÿÝN‰z‰S'èá\< pÜڌ“¼¥QƳ¿Œ¨I;K›Þ # {’ºá@=b÷ª1±è¦š©·GÄÓ¥@û$&«N_ul‚‡jꪛþéå`ùÓÜ3HR—8ÑNnܧy[{h£_[µ:Ԁw :ü–ó!Áû獞©ïS§u3¼ ‰Ip¼Eë¤*UMœ+ÊôÞ÷`òã=ÄXì¶Õ5 \KÜÅu¸»Zñ—êâ¹¶‹*ŗÈÝq¸&[Æú‹ª{l ÕPKP/ñ‚CDlÙ³ ªŠÃû®…âc}ݏËs?%i7µ¼*¶&˜®^+H÷mšâ­på؜Áë)uÕ³Ux ²öÖ-:Zvñ"øfÛa–7ýÓq–Kû½Ày¿ƒ¥Íÿ¶Îº~|„a€YÛ Ü•x¾î¦z¿%a1±}t1@ ü…/Õ9KcK­j“z¸iºu¹•¡ù, p\vT\QL°‰¼ê–£rU ;’ì¶Ü¡ú6­¯O¨“7™ú7‡Ù hë´ÛQ»ÑnÌë”QgiY|Ö}ªÎ‘œïÇÇCq×@+Üüxäù}õÐ&aoY!œhՐrn{ýØÍ7ûÙ1ڗgm—Çû§cû•=éηɐŽ8ÎCZž“ !cdG2yZ¼®©üɺ„ecYEdEIo¾Ýhž¯ãnsNf.K¥Òt…½û>‘C]·}ûÐÑÏ%$LV¥÷܁ ¼1ڝì@/6 ¥îÖú#ƒssÝڄ_œ˜gÿϳÝÏGUzîNFnü»êIØÛy%YB¬E²¥„Öì«ZX—æTú1°nÙ ¶ùòž-•œª-}Õ¦ñ+³›×Õ¹ÝÊÆ> ы¥ê¿ÌÏ[G»=Ô_úê@…Y­_‘X§yUkÈ,žf4µ‡vîøë,§#w©Žìª3Z¸VÿÚðïޖcâendstream endobj 24 0 obj 3522 endobj 27 0 obj <> stream xœuWMwÛȼóWÌË%Þ÷äñ|ä¶±7‰òïÆ–o{AH†d€”žÿ}ªzHÉönlKôÓ=ÝÕÕÕÃÏÊh« ÿž?ûÃæóÆõ´±jÜ]Ôß7¶ø¨kQ1Glóê°±5:í½ŠÅ~ÚZ¼¶‘ë MUÎT£#-¬Ó.¨~㬃³„'ðåÔ~cs83Ùêtj‚×ÅáIª:%>)ÞÓ{2Þêì”-®Ò{2Æèª,ç bå'ΨðXð>ú;8¨ÆkS†«EW¯JŒÚÚÊ5-ª8¯³APa[Å$«¥‹¤,uXçÈ b„a 6k#%k_`°ÁEUª×1b‘¯ÁɲŒu²:Š’ˆÄ*™€­*§¤]Ǝd­.^eåÞÇ\µ³°HˆÅ>qE‡¤R,8Á%]2,Š¶Æ·44ÎÀŽˆ<-NGuL@´Ê¢j&+ëÄ~âS±ÿ~ãö́]¨¨±+ÖhoUH˜xåJ|YLWSÔÞÑ¢ð5® áA±Úàï²Åj´<R‰Ä-T„Œ“¹ÕÎ*䚏Ë8¾ÂGH%(k ‘B*I±)èàjÖâÓ ª(rp8 \ 6Øb˜‰­' nò*“‹–™Ñ©Aç¢l{iᰓlŽ(¢CÜìga Î@ÁĀ3"S¯äearE”€¢Ê)‡Œ9‘ *¼Šc£ØŒuEÞ¬”#y³EšÌ!ó"ÐxПüö ?t™G²Õe€ œkRËÁ£tÑ8’4:€Y{‚eX»˜pl’Þ0‘˜yø°Gû@rñ8ÊÒÄP…ñhå¨3,!h` ›°3øâ)Ö;Ç-¡8Ë֕ª+™ÁKWd ÷yq‘‚aMBa°k“­ö¬­\WY#7ãB«*8K0¬©° ìi„MÀ5ÀÂi‡ìƒS>£pš»SV>QYàÄ X&RĬ‘3šˆ3Î ùB…§³( "ú5HìN< ɋ‘Ä

'hHþ@¤(SphW=j ¹Tt6¼¹jšw ÀÆD¥¼‡_oð̲—}HÒ ÞRÞ;*%ÀŒ({H*Õч,]‹dPX$´?øí#ÐvØQЁ„aZ´-‚ D–-Å‰}덨Øñ™½ ÌF¸\/¡ð­uGvM$Es/C^:‚<¯L+8&Î'N¦¶­(Œ2Œ`Ȁ¢è"‚‡µ´¨Ç8Š%0'Þ²G‘£tމ'|]6DàçÜ G¢—Rƒõ–<µIîr¸—¹@pǦöUnÅ64¤Î9:ZŸdf¡':‡0G‚jqÆÆ*×´`ý™—F®Á-ÇaH‰.â,¤ãµÙrÆ:Kýáí˜ëÒ8Ð[Ò՞ºŽqðÖTšÇèDPBLmBðÇZi +á<¿Wð")BÒŽÄV£|%ßîÄè•ÊQâ :ÂòÞZ‚ÄhxáÝÊ® GkqƒR•¶sO­ea¡Ö¢õ3eá#¾÷üå͛~zwýQ¿¿~«¯ß«n~̈́7»Í«Ÿ~ùðÓ¿RoþôáFýü7uýþÝõ²'_öüÒÝ *ªù¿øæÍ˜·s_CÐÔk+'zÙ|;/j7ìÇÇaù¢º£:Þê8ÕM;õ°ïúŽÆÃü»ã8Ojœd=ÃïÍ¿6¯úù´¬mßt–Iöu{u\ºÝ žî‡e“uØï‡E<‹‡?o^mO_ðä¾{Ô47óa=^ÎØžÖq֕®‡®¿W3ž64文eDˆãÚ˜÷ƒêçiwÃÒ¢e~òªÃ+üŸëùö^è+¾Ñê†Qb9\!`àpßÁ嬶Œz˜ÔöËsÈn9†éx9ö±ÛŸÄy?#vÄʇ ²a§îæy·ÚKÈï· ^©Qúê›·†Bs@ë… íÐþ´çê¶Ý²ŒÃòMrþô8š­í4‘o¿Ìk7õG­þ1? ¨üò¤%ÈûÛÐÇéî4nnøô«üÏ Ý=ÈýŽâŠÎë %kq‹Ûyb”ÿ¶CߝÖáB…åa}!H·ŽëSjBøRXý›¬—Ã3àߛ)Ä=Ný¼,ØÉ¦®ï‡‡c·ÝŸáû®ÒçLoGPo>Y¡âQÈÝñgúr®h« ¼ƒéØ£Z Éx÷ÝòBŠNݏwôԒ?Ó¤[æÓ¹KÖîСէiÏfàÓá‘Îóï:‰bÇ®i)w¬Ã]·ìZ.ŸOè)&ÿL:¢ó±•šÿë+ûã¯?ˆínKºe\qäu£`·]å48¢^Ž¿ú޼tNÁuëÿ+ßõWæãw©á°ó®·Ý*!¯§õaì%“黓çÝ©ÇIç>=7ߢ.œ?Ýސ•Dh!j<20šÿîȤ. Lô!*¯å}“Z¾$‹‡2jTíï»åNüœÄîŬï&†$äFyOçc†Q… ^ÂAû¡Yv[R†ý|5ÉÖ çZ¥·Ã4܎¢A»ù´=ªT 0Æ «/Ø<‡ú͟ºé( uPj„ßb§ÕsüWÄMܺÿ˜ÇnÜ ù>ŸF("égX÷-R„>,#Z€¢ÝíW¸Þ Ÿáê¥ÐúO؈«/G‰ð E뻋6> /Contents 6 0 R >> endobj 14 0 obj <> /Contents 15 0 R >> endobj 18 0 obj <> /Contents 19 0 R >> endobj 22 0 obj <> /Contents 23 0 R >> endobj 26 0 obj <> /Contents 27 0 R >> endobj 3 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [ 5 0 R 14 0 R 18 0 R 22 0 R 26 0 R ] /Count 5 >> endobj 1 0 obj <> endobj 4 0 obj <> endobj 12 0 obj <> endobj 13 0 obj <> endobj 17 0 obj <> endobj 21 0 obj <> endobj 25 0 obj <> endobj 29 0 obj <> endobj 8 0 obj <> endobj 9 0 obj <> endobj 10 0 obj <> endobj 11 0 obj <> endobj 2 0 obj <>endobj xref 0 30 0000000000 65535 f 0000018112 00000 n 0000020579 00000 n 0000018025 00000 n 0000018160 00000 n 0000017289 00000 n 0000000015 00000 n 0000003317 00000 n 0000018450 00000 n 0000018512 00000 n 0000019518 00000 n 0000019576 00000 n 0000018215 00000 n 0000018245 00000 n 0000017449 00000 n 0000003337 00000 n 0000006883 00000 n 0000018286 00000 n 0000017593 00000 n 0000006904 00000 n 0000010755 00000 n 0000018327 00000 n 0000017737 00000 n 0000010776 00000 n 0000014370 00000 n 0000018368 00000 n 0000017881 00000 n 0000014391 00000 n 0000017268 00000 n 0000018409 00000 n trailer << /Size 30 /Root 1 0 R /Info 2 0 R >> startxref 20629 %%EOF

More judgments on Section 37(1)

All 6,995 judgments and leading authorities on Section 37(1) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →