CAMIONS LOGISTICS SOLUTIONS PRIVATE LIMITED vs. JOINT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, OSD, TDS CIRCLE-73 -1, NEW DELHI & ANR.

PDF · subscribers
W.P.(C)/8524/2020HC DelhiDLHC01029403202023 December 2020Bench: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANMOHAN,HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA5 pages
AI SummaryPartly Allowed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the Assessing Officer failed to apply the mandatory considerations stipulated in Rule 28AA(2) of the Income Tax Rules, 1962, for determining the existing and estimated tax liability. Instead of computing the tax liability, the officer rejected the assessee's estimates based on a generalized reasoning about projected turnover increase. The Court found this decision-making process to be contrary to law and vitiated by non-application of mind. Consequently, the impugned order and reasons were set aside, and the matter was remanded to the Assessing Officer for fresh determination in accordance with law. The Court also directed that the petitioner be given the benefit of revised TDS rates for FY 2019-2020, read with the 25% rebate on account of the Covid-19 crisis, as per the Ministry of Finance press release dated May 13, 2020. The writ petition was allowed with these directions.

What were the facts?

The petitioner, Camions Logistics Solutions Private Limited, filed a writ petition challenging a certificate dated June 30, 2020, issued by the Joint Commissioner of Income Tax under Section 197(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The certificate refused to grant a NIL rate for deduction of tax at source on payments made to the petitioner by its customers. The petitioner contended that the respondent did not compute its tax liability as required by Rule 28AA and arbitrarily rejected the application based on a projected increase in turnover. The respondent argued that the writ petition was not maintainable as the petitioner had not exhausted the alternative remedy under Section 264 of the Act and that judicial review of Section 197 orders is limited to the decision-making process, not the rates themselves.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the writ petition is maintainable when an alternative remedy under Section 264 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, is available to the petitioner? (Question of law) 2. Whether the Assessing Officer failed to follow the mandatory procedure prescribed under Rule 28AA of the Income Tax Rules, 1962, in rejecting the petitioner's application for a NIL rate TDS certificate? (Question of mixed law and fact) Assessee's Contentions: The petitioner argued that the respondent failed to compute its tax liability as mandated by Rule 28AA and arbitrarily rejected the application based on mere guesswork regarding increased turnover. It was also argued that challenging an order approved by the CIT via revision under Section 264 would be akin to an 'appeal from Caesar to Caesar'. Revenue's Contentions: The revenue contended that the writ petition was not maintainable due to the availability of an alternative remedy under Section 264. It was further argued that the scope of judicial review for orders under Section 197 is limited to the decision-making process, and interference is warranted only in cases of patent illegality or non-application of mind. The revenue also submitted that the tax liability depends on estimated profits, which are linked to turnover, and the petitioner itself projected a significant rise in turnover.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 197,Section 264

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

WPC 8524/2020

Page 1 of 5

$~6 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

+ W.P. (C) 8524/2020 & CM APPL.27471 /2020

CAMIONS LOGISTICS SOLUTIONS PRIVATE LIMITED

..... Petitioner Through: Mr. V.N. Jha, Advocate.

versus

JOINT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, OSD, TDS CIRCLE-73-1, NEW DELHI & ANR. ...... Respondents Through: Ms. Adeeba Mujahid, Advocate for Ms. Lakshmi Gurung, Sr. Standing Counsel.

Date of Decision: 23rd December, 2020 CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANMOHAN HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA

J U D G M E N T MANMOHAN, J (Oral) 1. Present writ petition has been filed challenging the Certificate dated 30 : th June, 2020 issued by respondent No.1 under Section 197(1) of the Income Tax Act refusing to grant a certificate of deduction of tax at source at NIL rate, on payments to the petitioner company by its customers. Petitioner also prays for a direction to the respondent No.1 to reconsider the petitioner’s application and grant Certificate under Section 197 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 for deduction of tax at source at NIL rate.

WPC 8524/2020

Page 2 of 5

2.

In the writ petition it has been averred that the respondent did not compute the tax liability of the petitioner which is a mandatory requirement of Rule 28AA and has arbitrarily concluded on mere guess work that there would be increase in tax liability as the petitioner’s turnover is projected to increase. 3. The learned standing counsel for respondent submits that present writ petition is not maintainable as the petitioner has not exhausted the alternative efficacious remedy available under Section 264 of the Act. She relies upon the judgment of this court in the case of Sis Live Vs. Income Tax Officer, (2011) 333 ITR 13 (Del.), wherein the court declined to entertain a similar writ petition and directed the petitioner to file a revision petition. 4. She further submits that the scope of judicial review of an order passed under Section 197 of the Act is limited as it is directed not against the rates prescribed in the certificate, but against the decision making process. She submits that it is settled law that till there is a patent illegality and/or error apparent on the face of the decision or non-application of mind by the Officer, this Court would not interfere with the decision arrived at by such officer. In support of her submission, she relies upon the judgment dated 20th 5. She submits that the tax liability depends on the estimated profits, which in turn, depends on the turnover. She states that in financial year 2020-21, the petitioner has itself projected a rise of more than 60% in the turnover. December, 2019 passed by this Court in National Petroleum Construction Company Vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle-2(2)(2).

WPC 8524/2020

Page 3 of 5

6.

This court, in similar facts, in the case of Manpowergroup Services India Pvt. Ltd Vs. Commissioner Of Income Tax (Tds)-1, New Delhi & Anr., being WP(C) 5865/2020, decided on 21st 7. This court also held in Manpowergroup Services India Pvt. Ltd Vs. Commissioner Of Income Tax (Tds)-1 (supra) that the assessing officer cannot ignore the mandate of Rule 28AA and proceed on any other basis as the Government is bound to follow the rules and standards they themselves had set on pain of their action being invalidated. The relevant portion of Rule 28AA of the Income Tax Rules reads as under:-

December, 2020, has held that since the impugned order was passed after an approval from the CIT, it cannot be challenged by way of a revision petition before the CIT under Section 264 of the Act. To hold otherwise, would amount to directing the petitioner to file an ‘appeal from Caesar to Caesar’. “28AA. (1) Where the Assessing Officer, on an application made by a person under sub-rule (1) of rule 28 is satisfied that existing and estimated tax liability of a person justifies the deduction of tax at lower rate or no deduction of tax, as the case may be, the Assessing Officer shall issue a certificate in accordance with the provisions of sub-section (1) of section 197 for deduction of tax at such lower rate or no deduction of tax.

(2) The existing and estimated liability referred to in sub-rule (1) shall be determined by the Assessing Officer after taking into consideration the following:—

(i) tax payable on estimated income of the previous year relevant to the assessment year;

WPC 8524/2020

Page 4 of 5

(ii) tax payable on the assessed or returned [or estimated income, as the case may be, of last four] previous years;

(iii) existing liability under the Income-tax Act, 1961 and Wealth-tax Act, 1957;

(iv) advance tax payment [tax deducted at source and tax collected at source for the assessment year relevant to the previous year till the date of making application under subrule (1) of rule 28] 8. Perusal of the aforesaid Rule shows that the considerations and parameters prescribed under clause (2) are mandatory and the department is bound to take the same into consideration for the purpose of computation of existing and estimated liability referred in sub-rule (1). We have perused the impugned reasons furnished by the Revenue in support of the impugned Lower Tax Deduction Certificate and note that as opposed to estimation of tax liability, the assessing officer has instead rejected the estimates provided by the assessee, on a broad and generalized reasoning. Thus, in absence of determination, as provided under the above-noted Rule, the reasons for rejections cannot be termed as valid in eyes of law. Consequently, decision making process in the present case is contrary to law. ;” (emphasis supplied)

9.

In view of the aforesaid discussion, this court finds that there is non-application of mind which vitiates the impugned order and reasons. Accordingly, we set aside the impugned order and reasons and remand the matter to the Assessing Officer for fresh determination in accordance with law as expeditiously as possible preferably within three weeks.

WPC 8524/2020

Page 5 of 5

10.

In the interim, we direct that the benefit of revised TDS rates prescribed for financial year 2019-2020 (determined vide order dated 26th July, 2019) read with rebate of 25% given by Ministry of Finance on account of Covid-19 crisis from the rates applicable in the preceding year 2019-20 vide Press Release dated 13th May, 2020 be given to the petitioner. Respondents should ensure compliance of this order forthwith. With the aforesaid directions, the writ petition is allowed and pending application(s) stand disposed of.

MANMOHAN, J

SANJEEV NARULA, J DECEMBER 23, 2020 AS

More judgments on Section 197

All 362 judgments and leading authorities on Section 197 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →