COTECNA INSPECTION SA vs. INCOME TAX OFFICER WARD INTERNATIONAL TAX 1 2 1 & ANR.

PDF · subscribers
W.P.(C)/14602/2021HC DelhiDLHC01039390202120 December 2021Bench: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANMOHAN,HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE NAVIN CHAWLA4 pages
AI SummaryRemanded

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the issues raised were no longer res integra and were fully covered by its previous judgments in Concentrix Services Netherlands B.V. and Nestle SA. The Court reiterated its finding in Concentrix Services Netherlands B.V. that no separate notification is required for the applicability of a protocol, as it forms an integral part of the convention. The Court also emphasized that the Department cannot refuse to follow binding jurisdictional decisions merely because an appeal is proposed. Citing the Supreme Court's decision in UOI v. Kamlakshi Finance Corpn Ltd., the Court stated that decisions of higher appellate authorities must be followed unreservedly. Consequently, the impugned order and certificate were set aside, and the respondent was directed to issue a fresh certificate under Section 197 of the Act, prescribing a tax rate of 5% on the dividend income, in line with the India-Switzerland DTAA as interpreted in Nestle SA.

What were the facts?

The petitioner, COTECNA INSPECTION SA, filed a writ petition challenging a certificate dated November 2, 2021, and a communication dated November 26, 2021, issued by the Income Tax Officer, Ward International Tax 1(2)(1). The petitioner sought a fresh certificate under Section 197 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, prescribing a withholding tax rate of 5% on a dividend of Rs. 21,05,26,160/- for FY 2021-22. This rate was sought based on the India-Switzerland Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA) read with its protocol and a Most Favoured Nation (MFN) clause. The impugned orders had prescribed a rate of 10%, contrary to the petitioner's claim.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the petitioner is entitled to a withholding tax rate of 5% on dividend income under the India-Switzerland DTAA, read with its protocol and the MFN clause, considering India's DTAAs with other OECD member countries (Slovenia, Lithuania, Colombia) that stipulate a lower rate of 5%? Assessee's arguments: The petitioner contended that the MFN clause in the India-Switzerland DTAA mandates the application of the lower rate of 5% from other DTAAs with OECD countries. They argued that the issue is settled by this Court's judgments in Concentrix Services Netherlands B.V. v. ITO (TDS) and Nestle SA v. Assessing Officer, Circle (International Taxation). The petitioner also cited Deccan Holdings B V v. Income Tax Officer & Anr. where similar arguments were accepted. Revenue's arguments: The revenue argued that the petitioner is not entitled to the lower rate of 5% as no notification has been issued by the Government of India. They stated that the decisions in Concentrix Services Netherlands B.V. and Nestle SA were not accepted by the revenue, and Special Leave Petitions were being filed before the Supreme Court.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 197

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

WP(C)14602/2021

Page 1 of 4

$~S-119 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI + W.P.(C) 14602/2021

COTECNA INSPECTION SA

..... Petitioner Through: Mr.Deepak Chopra, Advocate with Mr.Ankul Goyal, Advocate.

versus

INCOME TAX OFFICER WARD INTERNATIONAL TAX 1 2 1 & ANR.

..... Respondents

Through: Mr.Ruchir Bhatia, Advocate.

Date of Decision: 20th December, 2021

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANMOHAN

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE NAVIN CHAWLA

J U D G M E N T

MANMOHAN, J (Oral) 1. Present writ petition has been filed challenging the certificate dated 2 : nd November, 2021 and communication dated 26th 2. Learned counsel for the Petitioner states that vide the impugned orders, the application of the Petitioner under Section 197 of the Act had November, 2021 issued by Respondent No. 1. Petitioner also seeks directions to Respondent No. 1 to issue a fresh certificate under Section 197 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’) prescribing a tax withholding rate of 5% on dividend of Rs. 21,05,26,160/- for the Financial Year 2021-22 in accordance with the India Switzerland DTAA read with the protocol and Most Favoured Nation (“MFN”) clause. Digitally Signed By:KRISHNA BHOJ Signing Date:21.12.2021 19:37:41 Signature Not Verified

WP(C)14602/2021

Page 2 of 4

been disposed of prescribing a rate of 10% on the dividends distributed by Cotecna Inspection India Private Limited (“CIIPL”) to the Petitioner as opposed to the applicable rate of 5% under the India-Switzerland Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (“DTAA”) read with the MFN clause and the Amending Protocol to the DTAA. 3. He submits that the Protocol to India Switzerland DTAA provides for MFN clause in terms of which when India enters into a DTAA with another member country of the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (“OECD”), wherein India limits its tax deduction at source (“TDS”) to a lower rate than the agreed one between India and Switzerland, then from the date such agreement comes into force, the rates or scope contemplated in such other treaty shall apply to India-Switzerland DTAA. He states that though the India-Switzerland DTAA prescribes a withholding rate of 10%, yet as India has entered into DTAAs with other OECD member countries being Slovenia / Lithuania / Colombia wherein tax rate on dividend income was agreed at a lower rate of 5%, owing to the MFN clause, the lower withholding rate shall also be applicable to any dividend income covered under the India-Switzerland DTAA. 4. Learned counsel for the Petitioner states that the issue involved in the present writ petition is no longer res integra as it is covered by the judgment of this Court in Concentrix Services Netherlands B.V. v. ITO (TDS), W.P.(C) 9051/2020 [2021] 127 taxmann.com 43 (Delhi) and Nestle SA v. Assessing Officer, Circle (International Taxation), W.P.(C) 3243/2021. He states that the impugned order and certificate have been passed in contravention of the settled position of law. He further states that the Respondent cannot disregard the binding judgments of this Court on the Digitally Signed By:KRISHNA BHOJ Signing Date:21.12.2021 19:37:41 Signature Not Verified

WP(C)14602/2021

Page 3 of 4

ground that the revenue proposes to file an appeal against such decisions. 5. He also states that in the case of Deccan Holdings B V v. Income Tax Officer & Anr., WP(C) 11921/2021, decided on 25th 6. Issue notice. Mr.Ruchir Bhatia, Advocate accepts notice on behalf of the Respondents. He states that since no notification has been issued by the Government of India, the petitioner is not entitled to lower tax rate of 5% provided in India-Columbia DTAA, India-Lithuania DTAA and India- Slovenia DTAA. He further reiterates that the Revenue has not accepted the decision of this Court in the cases of Concentrix Services Netherlands B.V. v. ITO (TDS) and Nestle SA v. Assessing Officer, Circle v. ACIT WP(C) 3243/2021 and is in process of filing Special Leave Petitions before the Hon’ble Supreme Court. October, 2021, similar arguments advanced on behalf of the respondents were rejected and the Respondents therein were directed to issue a certificate under Section 197 of the Act prescribing a rate of 5% on dividend. 7. Having heard learned counsel for the parties, this Court finds that the issues raised in the present writ petition are no longer res integra, as they are fully covered by the judgments of this Court in Concentrix Services Netherlands B.V. (Supra) as well as in Nestle SA (Supra). In Concentrix Services Netherlands B.V. (Supra) it has been held that no separate notification is required insofar as the applicability of the protocol is concerned and the same forms an integral part of the Convention. 8. It is well settled law that the Department cannot refuse to follow binding jurisdictional decision merely on the basis that the Department proposes to file an appeal. The Supreme Court in UOI v. Kamlakshi Finance Corpn Ltd. AIR 1992 SC 711: (1992) 1 SCC 648 has held that Digitally Signed By:KRISHNA BHOJ Signing Date:21.12.2021 19:37:41 Signature Not Verified

WP(C)14602/2021

Page 4 of 4

order of higher appellate authorities should be followed ‘unreservedly’ and mere fact that decision is not acceptable to the Revenue cannot be a ground for not following the decision of higher authority. 9. Keeping in view the aforesaid, the impugned order and certificate are set aside and the respondent is directed to issue a certificate under Section 197 of the Act indicating therein that the rate of tax, on dividend, as applicable qua the Petitioner is 5% in India-Switzerland DTAA as held in Nestle SA (Supra) which was also under India-Switzerland DTAA. 10. With the aforesaid directions, the present writ petition is disposed of.

MANMOHAN, J

NAVIN CHAWLA, J DECEMBER 20, 2021 TS

Digitally Signed By:KRISHNA BHOJ Signing Date:21.12.2021 19:37:41 Signature Not Verified

More judgments on Section 197

All 362 judgments and leading authorities on Section 197 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →