SURENDER KUMAR BENIWAL,NEW DELHI vs. ITO WARD 42(2), DELHI

PDF · subscribers
ITA 1711/DEL/2026Status: DisposedITAT Delhi18 November 2026AY 2015-164 pages
AI SummaryPartly Allowed

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal found that neither the assessee nor the Revenue had presented a complete case. The assessee failed to adequately explain the issues, and the Department/NFAC could not dismiss all evidence outright. In the interest of justice, the Tribunal decided to estimate the GP rate at 26.68% instead of the 35% adopted by the AO. Furthermore, the Tribunal deemed it appropriate to restrict the ad-hoc disallowance of expenses to 1/6th of the expenses (excluding auditor fees) instead of the 1/4th disallowed by the AO. The Tribunal directed that necessary computations should follow as per law. No specific issue was left undecided.

What were the facts?

The assessee, Surender Kumar Beniwal, filed an income tax return for Assessment Year 2015-16 declaring a total income of Rs. 19,87,822. The case was selected for limited scrutiny. The Assessing Officer (AO) rejected the assessee's books of account under Section 145(3) for not maintaining proper records and not reflecting a true and fair picture. The AO estimated the Gross Profit (GP) at 35% on a turnover of Rs. 4,83,21,600, leading to an addition of Rs. 64,70,841. Additionally, the AO disallowed 25% of expenses (excluding auditor fees), amounting to Rs. 21,89,108, for failure to produce supporting vouchers. The National Faceless Appeal Centre (NFAC) upheld the AO's actions. The assessee appealed to the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT).

What were the issues?

1. Whether the NFAC erred in confirming the AO's action in rejecting the assessee's books of accounts, despite the assessee's contention that non-maintenance of a stock register alone is insufficient grounds for rejection (Section 145(3)). 2. Whether the NFAC erred in confirming the AO's estimation of the GP at 35% without proper basis, contrary to the declared GP of 21.61% based on audited books (Section 144). 3. Whether the NFAC erred in confirming the disallowance of Rs. 21,89,108 out of expenses, which the assessee argued was arbitrary and without basis (Section 144). Assessee's arguments: The assessee contended that the books of account were maintained as per law, and the non-maintenance of a stock register was explained by the difficulty in valuing varied electrical items. The assessee argued that the AO's GP estimation at 35% was unjustified without comparable data and that the ad-hoc disallowance of expenses was not in accordance with the law. Revenue's arguments: The Revenue relied on the orders of the AO.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 145(3),Section 144,Section 143(3)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, DELHI BENCH “A’’ : NEW DELHI

Before: SHRI MAHAVIR SINGH, HON’BLE

For Appellant: Smt. Rano Jain, Adv
Hearing: 24.08.2026Pronounced: 18.11.2026

IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL

(DELHI BENCH “A’’ : NEW DELHI)

BEFORE SHRI MAHAVIR SINGH, HON’BLE VICE PRESIDENT AND SHRI AMITABH SHUKLA, HON’BLE ACCOUNTANT MEMBER

ITA No. 1711/Del/2026 Asstt. Year : 2015-16 SURENDER KUMAR BENIWAL, vs. ITO, WARD-42(2), SHOP NO. 8, 1ST FLOOR, Delhi SHIVA MARKET, PITAMPURA DELHI – 110 034 (PAN: AFOPB2933G) (Appellant) (Respondent) Assessee by : Smt. Rano Jain, Adv. Revenue by : Sh. Balkishan Gopal, Sr. DR

Date of Hearing 24.08.2026 Date of Pronouncement 18.11.2026

ORDER PER MAHAVIR SINGH, VP: This appeal filed by the assessee is directed against the order dated 06.01.2026 of the National Faceless Appeal Centre (NFAC), Delhi relevant to assessment year 2015-16 on the following grounds:- 1. On facts and circumstances of the case order passed by the National Faceless Appeal Centre (NFAC) is bad both in the eye of law and on facts. 2. (i) On facts and circumstances of the case the NFAC has erred both on facts and in law in confirming the action of the AO in rejecting the books of accounts of the despite the fact that the assessee is maintaining the books of accounts as per law. (ii) That the NFAC has erred in confirming the rejection of the books rejecting the contention of the assessee that only non maintenance of stock register cannot be the reason for such rejection.

3.

On facts and circumstances of the case the NFAC has erred both on facts and in law in confirming the action of AO in estimating the GP of the assessee at 35%, without there being any basis for the same. 4. (i) On facts and circumstances of the case the NFAC has erred both on facts and in law in confirming the disallowance of Rs. 21,89,108/- out of expenses made by the AO. (ii) That the said disallowance has been confirmed despite the same being made arbitrarily without there being any basis for the same. 2. The brief facts of the case are that the assessee filed his e-return of income for AY 2015-16 on 29.9.2015 declaring total income of Rs. 19,87,822/-. Subsequently, the case was selected for limited scrutiny under CASS and statutory notice u/s. 143(2) of the Act communicating the limited reasons of scrutiny was issued on 26.09.2016. In response to the statutory notices issued, assessee filed his submissions. AO noted that assessee was not maintaining the proper books of account and also not recording true and fair picture/results of such business activities. Thus, the claimed books of assessee were not correct. The AO satisfied that the claimed books are incomplete and thus invoked the provisions of section 145(3) and rejected the claimed books of account and trading results shown therein. Accordingly, the AO computed the business income of the assessee for AY 2015-16 by resorting to the provision of section 144 of the Act. Since, the assessee declared a GP of Rs. 1,04,41,740/- @21.61% on a turnover of Rs. 4,83,21,600/- however, on the based on the facts of the case, the GP rate was adopted by the AO@35% the turnover and the gross profit was worked by the AO at Rs. 1,69,21,581/-. Since out of the same, Rs. 1,044,41,470/- was already declared by the assessee, thereby an addition of Rs. 1,04,41,740/- was already declared by the assessee, thereby an addition of Rs. 64,70,841/- to the total business income of the assessee for AY 2015-16 was made by the AO. Besides above, as per the Profit and Loss Account, the AO observed that expenses to the tune of Rs. 87,86,435/- were claimed by the assessee under various heads and the expenditure included payment to auditors amounting to Rs. 30,000/-. Since the assessee failed to produce the books of account relevant/ vouchers of these expenses, therefore, 1/4th of the expenses excluding the payment to the auditors i.e. 25% of Rs. 87,56,435/- were also disallowed by the AO and added to the total income for the assessee for AY

2 | P a g e

2015-16, i.e. an addition of Rs. 21,89,108/- to the total income and determined the total income at Rs. 105,27,770/- u/s. 143(3) of the Act. Against the action of the AO, assessee preferred appeal before the Ld. CIT(A), and CIT(A) upheld the action of the AO by dismissing the appeal of the assessee. Aggrieved, assessee is in appeal before the Tribunal. 3. During the hearing, Ld. AR for the assessee submitted that NFAC has erred in confirming the action of the AO in rejecting the books of accounts of the despite the fact that the assessee is maintaining the books of accounts as per law. It was further submitted that rejection of the books by rejecting the contention of the assessee that only non maintenance of stock register cannot be the reason for such rejection. It was further submitted that action of the lower authorities in estimating the GP of the assessee @35%, without there being any basis for the same and confirming the disallowance of Rs. 21,89,108/- out of expenses made by the AO is not tenable. 4. On the other hand, Ld. DR relied upon the order of the AO. 5. We have heard both the sides and perused the records. We note that Assesse has declared a GP of Rs. 1,04,41,740/- @21.61% on a turnover of Rs. 4,83,21,660/-, but AO adopted the GP rate @35% by working out the gross profit at Rs. 1,69,21,581/- by making addition of Rs. 64,70,841/-, which was confirmed by the ld. CIT(A). Further, the assessee in Profit and Loss Account expenses to the tune of Rs. 87,86,435/- have been claimed under various heads. Expenditure includes payment to auditors amounting to Rs. 30,000/-. Since the assessee has failed to produce the books of account / relevant bills/vouchers of these expenses, 1/4th of expenses excluding the payment to auditors i.e. 25% of Rs. 87,56,435/- are disallowed and added to the total income for the assessee for AY 2015- 16, i.e. an addition of Rs. 21,89,108/- to the total income of the assessee, which was confirmed by the Ld. CIT(A). However, against the above action of the lower authorities, it was the contention of the Ld. AR for the assessee that assessee is maintaining the books of accounts as per law and rejection of the books by rejecting the contention of the assessee that only non maintenance of stock register cannot be the reason for such rejection, because the reasons for non maintenance of books of stock register have be explained before the AO that assessee is dealing in variety /quality of electrical items as such it is not practically possible for assessee to maintain the stock register, thus, valuation

3 | P a g e

of opening and closing stock is not possible for the AY 2015-16. It was the further submission that AO was not justified in adopting of GP rate @35% on declared turnover against the declared GP @21.61% declared on the basis of audited books of account leading to addition of Rs. 64,70,811/- and the absence of comparable, the AO’s action is not justified. It was the further contention that action of the AO of making adhoc disallowance of Rs. 21,89,108/- being 25% of the total expenses net of audit fees of Rs, 87,56,435/- is not tenable and accordingly, the basis for addition of Rs. 21,89,108/- out of expenses made by the AO is not in accordance with law. After hearing the rival submissions and perusing the records, we find no reason to accept either party’s stand(s) in entirety. This is for the precise reason that neither the assessee has been able to properly explain the issues nor the Department/Ld. CIT(A) could simply brush aside all the relevant evidences at one go. Be that as it may, the tribunal is of the considered view that in these peculiar facts, it is deemed appropriate in the larger interest of justice to estimate the GP rate @26.68% instead of GP@35% on the declared turnover and also it would be appropriate to restrict the adhoc disallowance @1/6th instead of @1/4th of the expenses excluding the payment to auditors. Necessary computation shall follow as per law. Ordered accordingly. 6. In the result, the assesseee’s appeal is partly allowed. Order pronounced in the Open Court on 18.11.2026. Sd/- Sd/-

(AMITABH SHUKLA) (MAHAVIR SINGH) ACCOUNTANT MEMBER VICE PRESIDENT Date: 18.11.2026 Copy forwarded to: - 1. Appellant 2. Respondent 3. DIT 4. CIT (A) 5. DR, ITAT Assistant Registrar, ITAT, Delhi Bench

4 | P a g e

More judgments on Section 145(3)

All 3,843 judgments and leading authorities on Section 145(3) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →