COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, KOLKATA- XII vs. M/S. TARA EXPORTS
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court, in view of the joint submission by both parties, held that the substantial question of law is squarely covered by the Supreme Court judgments in Topman Exports v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Mumbai (342 ITR 49 SC) and Johnson G. Onmen v. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) ((2023) 295 Taxman 221 SC) concerning the prospectivity of Tax Amendment Laws, 2005. The Court further noted the joint submission that the question of law is covered by the Topman Exports judgment against the revenue. Consequently, the High Court answered the substantial question of law in favour of the assessee and against the revenue. The appeal filed by the Revenue was dismissed. No issue was expressly left undecided.
What were the facts?
The Commissioner of Income Tax (Revenue) appealed an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) which had allowed the appeal of M/s. Tara Exports (Assessee). The appeal was admitted by the High Court on February 14, 2011, on a substantial question of law concerning the ITAT's reliance on a Special Bench decision that was subsequently set aside by the Bombay High Court. The dispute pertains to the assessment year(s) not explicitly stated in the provided text. The procedural history involves the Revenue filing an appeal before the High Court against the ITAT's order.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the Learned Tribunal below committed substantial error of law in allowing the appeal of the assessee by relying upon the decision of the Special Bench ITAT Mumbai in the case of M/s. Top Man Exports & Ors., which has been set aside by the Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in the case of Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. Kalpataru Colours & Chemicals reported in 2010 (328) ITR 451 (Bombay)? Assessee's contentions: The assessee, through its counsel, jointly stated with the revenue that the substantial question of law is covered by the Supreme Court judgment in Topman Exports v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Mumbai reported in 342 ITR 49 SC and Johnson G. Onmen v. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) reported in (2023) 295 Taxman 221 (SC) on the prospectivity of Tax Amendment Laws, 2005. They further jointly stated that the question is covered by the Topman Exports judgment against the revenue, implying the question should be answered in favour of the assessee. Revenue's contentions: The revenue, through its counsel, jointly stated with the assessee that the substantial question of law is covered by the Supreme Court judgments in Topman Exports and Johnson G. Onmen concerning the prospectivity of Tax Amendment Laws, 2005. They also jointly stated that the question is covered by the Topman Exports judgment against the revenue, indicating agreement that the question should be answered in favour of the assessee.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
None explicitly mentioned in the provided text, other than reference to Tax Amendment Laws, 2005.
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
ORDER OD – 7 IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA SPECIAL JURISDICTION (INCOME TAX) ORIGINAL SIDE ITA/73/2011 IA NO: GA/2/2010 (Old No: GA/3227/2010) COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, KOLKATA – XII VERSUS M/S. TARA EXPORTS BEFORE: The Hon'ble Justice SURYA PRAKASH KESARWANI The Hon'ble Justice RAJARSHI BHARADWAJ Date : 6th December 2023. Appearance: Mr. S.S. Sarkar, Advocate … for appellant. Mr. Avra Mazumder, Advocate Mr. B.N. Paul, Advocate Mr. Samrat Das, Advocate Ms. Elina Dey, Advocate … for respondent. 1. Heard learned counsel for the appellant and learned counsel for the respondent. 2. This appeal has been admitted by order dated 14.02.2011, on the following substantial question of law:- “Whether the Learned Tribunal below committed substantial error of law in allowing the appeal of the assessee by relying upon the decision of the Special Bench ITAT Mumbai in the case of M/s. Top Man Exports & Ors., which has been set aside by the Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in the case of 2 Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. Kalpataru Colours & Chemicals reported in 2010 (328) ITR 451 (Bombay)?” 3. Both the learned counsel for the parties jointly state that the question raised in the present appeal is squarely covered by the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in Topman Exports v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Mumbai reported in 342 ITR 49 SC and another judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in Johnson G. Onmen v. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) reported in (2023) 295 Taxman 221 (SC) on the question of prospectivity of the Tax Amendment Laws, 2005. Both the learned counsel for the parties jointly state that the afore-quoted substantial question of law is covered by the judgment in the case of Topman Exports (supra) against the revenue and therefore, the question needs to be answered in negative i.e. in favour of the assessee and against the revenue. 4. In view of the aforesaid, the appeal is dismissed. The substantial question of law as framed above is answered in favour of the assessee and against the revenue. (SURYA PRAKASH KESARWANI, J.) (RAJARSHI BHARADWAJ, J.) S. Kumar
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- M/S Jaleswar Packaging, Bhubaneswar vs. Superintendent, CGST And Central Excise, BhubaneswarOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- Talasethi Sanmukharao vs. Commissioner, CT And GST, Odisha, CuttackOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- M/S Ramamani Behera (Trade Name S.V.Enterprises) Bhubaneswar vs. Addl Commissioner Of GST And Central Excise, BhubaneswarOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- Prasanta Kumar Biswal vs. The Chief Commissioner, CGST, Central Excise And Customs, BhubaneswarOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- M/S.Dibyanee Agency., Keonjhar. vs. Chief Commissioner Of CT And GST, Odisha, CuttackOrissa · 11 Nov 2026