COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, BURDWAN vs. PASCHIM BANGYA GRAMIN BANK

PDF · subscribers
ITA/66/2009HC CalcuttaWBCHCO001086200919 December 20233 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court dismissed the appeal filed by the revenue. The Court noted that the impugned order of the ITAT dated 14.10.2008 was passed by following its earlier decision in ITA No.1094/Kol/2007, which involved similar facts and issues. Crucially, the revenue had filed an appeal against the ITAT's order in ITA No.1094/Kol/2007 before the High Court in ITA/460/2008, and this appeal was dismissed by a judgment and order dated 9.2.2023. Since the ITAT's decision in the present case was based on a precedent that had been affirmed by a coordinate bench of the High Court, the Court found no reason to interfere. The substantial question of law was answered against the revenue and in favour of the assessee. The operative direction was the dismissal of the appeal.

What were the facts?

The Commissioner of Income Tax, Burdwan (the revenue) is the appellant, and Paschim Bangya Gramin Bank (the assessee) is the respondent. The appeal concerns assessment years 2000-01, 2002-03, and 2005-06. The challenge is to an order dated 14.10.2008 passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Bench – C, Kolkata, which allowed the assessee's appeal. The ITAT had followed its earlier decision in ITA No.1094/Kol/2007. The revenue had appealed the ITAT's order in ITA No.1094/Kol/2007 to the High Court in ITA/460/2008, which was dismissed by a judgment and order dated 9.2.2023. The revenue's counsel could not confirm if a further appeal was filed before the Supreme Court against this High Court order.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the High Court should dismiss the appeal filed by the revenue, given that the ITAT's order followed its own prior decision, which was subsequently affirmed by a coordinate bench of the High Court. This is a question of law and procedure. Assessee's Contention: The assessee relies on the principle of consistency and the High Court's affirmation of the ITAT's earlier order in a similar case. The assessee would argue that the present appeal is rendered infructuous or should be dismissed in light of the High Court's prior judgment. Revenue's Contention: The revenue's primary contention, as implied by filing the appeal, would be to challenge the ITAT's order on merits. However, the judgment records that the revenue's counsel could not provide information regarding a further appeal to the Supreme Court against the High Court's prior dismissal, suggesting a lack of progress or a weak position on the merits.

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

OD – 13 IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA Special Jurisdiction [Income Tax] ORIGINAL SIDE

ITA/66/2009

COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, BURDWAN VS PASCHIM BANGYA GRAMIN BANK

BEFORE : THE HON’BLE JUSTICE SURYA PRAKASH KESARWANI

And THE HON’BLE JUSTICE RAJARSHI BHARADWAJ Date : 19th December, 2023

Appearance : Sri Vipul Kundalia, Adv. Sri Amit Sharma, Adv. Sri Anurag Roy, Adv. ..for the appellant.

Sri R.N. Dutt, Adv. Smt. Sutapa Roy Choudhury, Adv. Smt. Aratrika Roy, Adv. ...for the respondent.

1.

Heard Sri Vipul Kundalia, learned senior standing counsel for the appellant and Smt. Sutapa Roy Choudhury, learned counsel for the respondent. 2. By the impugned order dated 14.10.2008 in ITA Nos. 899, 900, 901 & 902/Kol/2008 (assessment years 2000-01, 2002- 03 and 2005-06) the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Bench – C, Kolkata allowed the appeal of the respondent/assessee, following its earlier decision inter parties in ITA No.1094/Kol/2007 involving similar question. Against the order of the Tribunal in the aforesaid ITA No.1094/Kol/2007, the Income Tax Department preferred an Income Tax Appeal being

ITA/460/2008 [Commissioner of Income Tax, Burdwan Vs. Paschim Bangya Gramin Bank] before this Court which was dismissed by a judgment and order dated 9.2.2023. Despite being asked, the learned counsel for the appellant could not state as to whether the department has preferred any appeal before the Hon’ble Supreme Court against the aforesaid judgment and order dated 9.2.2023 in ITA/460/2008 passed by a co-ordinate Bench of this Court. 3. In view of the aforesaid, since the Tribunal has formally followed its earlier order inter parties in ITA No.1094/Kol/2007 involving similar facts and issues, which have been affirmed by a co-ordinate Bench of this Court by the judgment and order dated 9.2.2023 in ITA/460/2008, therefore, we dismiss the appeal and answer the substantial question of law against the revenue and in favour of the assessee.

(SURYA PRAKASH KESARWANI, J.)

(RAJARSHI BHARADWAJ, J.)

S.Das/

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →