COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, KOLKATA - X vs. USHA RANJAN SARKAR
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court held that the ITAT's finding was a finding of fact based on the consideration of relevant material on record. The Court noted that the ITAT had affirmed the order of the CIT(A), which in turn was based on a remand report from the AO admitting errors in voucher numbers and dates for the disputed amounts. The learned counsel for the appellant (Revenue) could not point out any perversity or infirmity in the impugned order of the Tribunal. Therefore, the substantial question of law was answered in favour of the assessee and against the revenue. The appeal was dismissed as having no merit. The operative direction was the dismissal of the appeal.
What were the facts?
The Revenue, Commissioner of Income Tax, Kolkata-X, filed an appeal before the High Court at Calcutta against an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT). The ITAT had upheld an order of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [CIT(A)] that deleted an addition of Rs. 3,90,25,235/- made by the Assessing Officer (AO) for Assessment Year 2004-05. The CIT(A)'s order was based on a remand report from the AO, who admitted to having wrongfully entered voucher numbers and dates for the disputed amounts. The High Court noted that the ITAT's finding was a finding of fact based on relevant material, and the Revenue had not filed the paper book for over 13 years.
What were the issues?
1. Whether, in the facts and circumstances of the case, the decision of the Learned Tribunal in deleting the addition made by the Assessing Officer without assigning any valid reasons was perverse in law, in as much as it failed to take into consideration relevant facts and evidence (ignoring the report of the Executive Engineer to establish the said deletions solely on the basis of the order of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeal) which was totally irrelevant and not germane for consideration)? Assessee's contentions: The judgment does not record any specific contentions made by the assessee before the High Court. However, the ITAT's order, which was affirmed, was based on the AO's admission of error in the remand report, leading the CIT(A) to delete the addition. The ITAT considered this a finding of fact based on relevant material. Revenue's contentions: The Revenue argued that the ITAT's decision was perverse in law, as it deleted the addition without valid reasons, failed to consider relevant facts and evidence, and relied on the CIT(A)'s order which was irrelevant. The Revenue framed the issue as a substantial question of law regarding the perversity of the ITAT's order.
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
O-29 ITA/2/2011 IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA SPECIAL JURISDICTION (Income Tax) ORIGINAL SIDE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, KOLKATA-X -Versus- USHA RANJAN SARKAR BEFORE : THE HON’BLE JUSTICE SURYA PRAKASH KESARWANI And THE HON’BLE JUSTICE RAJARSHI BHARADWAJ Date : 15th January, 2024 Appearance: Mr. Prithu Dudheria, Adv. …for the appellant. The Court : Heard learned counsel for the appellant. This appeal was admitted by an order dated 25.08.2010, which is reproduced below: “This appeal is admitted on the following substantial question of law relating to Assessment Year 2004-05 : “Whether in the facts and circumstances of the case, the decision of the Learned Tribunal in deleting the addition made by the Assessing Officer without assigning any valid reasons was perverse in law in as much as it failed to take into consideration relevant facts and evidence (ignoring the report of the Executive Engineer to establish the said deletions solely on the basis of the order 2 of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeal) which was totally irrelevant and not germane for consideration ? Let requisite number of paper books be filed within two months from date. Mr. Khaitan appearing on behalf of the respondent waives service of notice of appeal. All parties shall act on a xerox signed copy of this order on usual undertakings.” More than 13 years have passed but the appellant/income tax department has not filed paper book. We find that the income tax appeal No.1452(Kol)/2009 for the Assessment year 2004-05, (ACIT, Circle-30, Kolkata v. Usha Ranjan Sarkar, Kolkata) filed by the appellant herein was dismissed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, “A” Bench, Kolkata by order dated 05.10.2009 affirming the order of the CIT(A). We further find that the CIT(A) had passed the order on the basis of remand report submitted by the assessing officer in which the assessing officer himself had stated that voucher numbers and dates for the five amounts in question have been wrongfully entered by the assessing officer. Based on that, the CIT(A) passed the order deleting the addition of Rs.3,90,25,235/-. By the impugned order, the ITAT has affirmed the order of the CIT(A). Discussion in this regard has been made by the ITAT in paragraph 5 of the impugned order. 3 We find that the finding recorded by the ITAT in the impugned order is a finding of fact based on consideration of relevant material on record. Learned counsel for the appellant could not point out any perversity or infirmity in the impugned order of the Tribunal. Under the circumstances, the question of law as framed above is answered in favour of the assessee and against the revenue. The appeal (ITA/2/2011) has no merit and is, therefore, dismissed. (SURYA PRAKASH KESARWANI, J.) (RAJARSHI BHARADWAJ, J.) As.
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Voltas Limited vs. M/S Shiv Shakti Enterprises & Ors.Delhi · 6 Nov 2026
- The Commissioner Of Central Tax (Appeals-Ii) vs. Perikal Chick Munisamappa MallappaKarnataka · 6 Nov 2026
- Sri. R. Veerabhadrappa vs. The State Of KarnatakaKarnataka · 6 Nov 2026
- Shaista Praween vs. The Assistant Commissoner Of GST And Central Excise, RourkelaOrissa · 6 Nov 2026
- Prakash Chand Kabra S/O Sh. Satya Narayan Kabra vs. Union Of INDIARajasthan · 5 Nov 2026