COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, CENTRAL - I vs. AVINASH AGARWAL
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court dismissed the appeal, respectfully following a co-ordinate Bench's decision in Principal Commissioner of Income Tax-I, Kolkata vs. Rakesh Kumar Khemuka (ITAT/163/2021). In that case, the Department's submission clarified that the exception for penny stock cases from the monetary limit stipulation would be operable only from 16.09.2019, i.e., for appeals filed on or after that date. Since the present appeal was filed in 2011, it did not fall within the exception. Therefore, the Court held that there was no substantial question of law arising for consideration and dismissed the appeal. The operative direction was the dismissal of the appeal.
What were the facts?
This appeal by the Commissioner of Income Tax (CIT) concerns assessment years 2005-06, 2006-07, and 2007-08. The tax effect for these years was Rs. 47,71,530/-, Rs. 7,71,250/-, and Rs. 5,78,131/-, respectively. The Revenue argued that the case involved a "penny stock" controversy, which should be an exception to the monetary limits for filing appeals as per Circular No. 17/2019. However, the appeal was filed in 2011, prior to the circular dated 16.09.2018 which introduced exceptions for penny stock cases. The High Court was to decide if the appeal was maintainable.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the appeal, filed in 2011, is maintainable despite the tax effect being below the monetary limit stipulated in Circular No. 17/2019, given that the controversy involves "penny stock" and the appeal was filed before the exception for such cases was introduced by Circular dated 16.09.2018. Assessee's Contention: The judgment does not record any specific contentions from the assessee's side regarding the maintainability of the appeal. Revenue's Contention: The Revenue contended that the "penny stock" issue constitutes an exception to the monetary limit for filing appeals, as per Circular No. 17/2019. However, they admitted that the appeal was filed in 2011, before the circular dated 16.09.2018, which carved out exceptions for penny stock cases even when the tax effect was below the stipulated limit.
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
ORDER O – 41 IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA SPECIAL JURISDICTION (INCOME TAX) ORIGINAL SIDE ITA/13/2012 COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, CENTRAL – I VERSUS AVINASH AGARWAL BEFORE: The Hon'ble Justice SURYA PRAKASH KESARWANI The Hon'ble Justice RAJARSHI BHARADWAJ Date : 15th January 2024. Appearance: Mr. Amit Sharma, Advocate … for appellant. Mr. Saumya Kejriwal, Advocate Ms. Ananya Rath, Advocate Mr. Navin Mittal, Advocate … for respondent. 1. Heard learned counsel for the parties. 2. This appeal relates to assessment years 2005-06, 2006-07 and 2007- 08. The tax effect involved in the three appeals before the Tribunal are Rs.47,71,530/- for assessment year 2005-06, Rs.7,71,250/- for assessment year 2006-07 and Rs.5,78,131/- for assessment year 2007-08. Thus, the tax involved in the aforesaid three assessment years involved in this appeal are much below the tax limit provided for filing the appeal under Circular No.17/2019 dated 08.08.2019. 3. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that this case falls under the exception given in the said circular inasmuch as the controversy of 2 penny stock is involved. He admits that this appeal was filed in the year 2011 and not after the circular dated 16.09.2018 carving out exceptions for filing appeal in matters of penny stock even though the tax effect is below the limit provided in the circular for filing appeal by the Income Tax Department. 4. We find that similar issue arose before a co-ordinate Bench of this Court in ITAT/163/2021 (Principal Commissioner of Income Tax-I, Kolkata vs. Rakesh Kumar Khemuka) which was dismissed by order dated 20.07.2012 observing as under : “In terms of the above direction the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax (Judicial), Kolkata has addressed the learned Standing Counsel for the appellant by letter dated 3rd March, 2022. Along with the said letter, notes on submission dated 7th March, 2022 has been appended. The said notes of submission reads as follows : “Notes on Submissions 1. The issue before the Hon’ble High Court is seen to be the retrospective or prospective applicability of Central Board of Direct Taxes Circular No. 23 dated 06.09.2019 and Central Board of Direct Taxes OM dated 16.09.2019 by which exception to the tax effect was allowed for filing appeals in Long Term Capital Gain/Penny Stock in ITAT in respect of appeals which were dismissed by ITAT. 2. I am therefore to submit that in view of the facts of the impugned matter, the exception to penny stock cases from the stipulation of monetary limit would be indeed operable from 3 16.09.2019 that is only in the cases where appeal was filed on or after 16.09.2019.” In the light of the stand taken by the Department, the monetary limit would be operable from 16th September, 2019, that is, only in cases where appeal was filed on or after 16th September, 2019. In the light of the above clarification, we find that the order passed by the learned Tribunal does not call for any interference. Accordingly, we hold that there is no substantial question of law arising for consideration in these appeals and they are dismissed. With the dismissal of the appeals, the connected applications also stand dismissed.” 5. Respectfully following the judgment of the co-ordinate Bench in the case of Rakesh Kumar Khemuka(supra) this appeal (ITA 13/2012) is also dismissed. (SURYA PRAKASH KESARWANI, J.) (RAJARSHI BHARADWAJ, J.) S. Kumar / As.
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Kamdhenu Udyog Private Limited And Anr vs. The Assistant Commissioner Of Revenue Office Of The Charge Office, CT, Bhabanipur Charge And OrsCalcutta · 12 Nov 2026
- Keshab Joshi vs. State Of West Bengal And Ors.Calcutta · 12 Nov 2026
- Binayak Nayak vs. The Assistant Commissioner, GST And Central Excise, BbsrOrissa · 12 Nov 2026
- M/S Sunil Kumar Agrawal LLP, Raipur vs. State Of OdishaOrissa · 12 Nov 2026
- Life Insurance Corporation Of INDIA vs. The Insurance Ombudsman And 2 OrsGauhati · 11 Nov 2026