ST. JUDE'S HOSPITAL SOCIETY AND ANOTHER vs. State of U.P. AND 3 OTHERS
What did the High Court hold?
The Tribunal held that the petitioner's submission that exemption under Section 12-A of the Income Tax Act automatically entitles them to house tax exemption was without substance. The Court noted that the petitioner's counsel failed to provide any material to support this contention. Furthermore, the Court observed that previous orders from February 5, 2015, indicated that assessment orders existed against which the petitioner had filed objections. The Tribunal found that several factual disputes were involved in the matter of house tax assessment, which could not be effectively adjudicated in a writ petition. Therefore, the Tribunal was not inclined to interfere and dismissed the writ petition, while leaving it open for the petitioner to avail the remedy of appeal if advised.
What were the facts?
The petitioners, St. Jude's Hospital Society and another, filed a writ petition challenging a demand notice dated August 23, 2017, for Rs. 1,28,07,011/- and a consequential order dated April 6, 2018, passed by the Municipal Commissioner, Nagar Nigam Jhansi. The petitioners contended that as a charitable organization, they are exempted from house tax. This writ petition followed previous writ petitions filed in 2006, 2008, and 2009, which were disposed of on February 5, 2015, directing the competent authority to decide the petitioner's objections after providing a hearing. Another writ petition in 2017 was dismissed for no cause of action. The Municipal Commissioner's order noted the hospital's facilities and charges, concluding that exemption under Section 12-A of the Income Tax Act did not automatically grant house tax exemption.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the petitioner-hospital, being a charitable organization with an exemption certificate under Section 12-A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, is entitled to exemption from house tax, as argued by the petitioner. The revenue contended that Section 12-A exemption does not automatically confer house tax exemption. 2. Whether the petitioner has provided sufficient material to support their claim for house tax exemption, as questioned by the Court. The petitioner's counsel failed to provide such material. 3. Whether factual disputes regarding house tax assessment proceedings exist, which are more appropriately adjudicated by the concerned authority or appellate authority, as indicated by the Court's observation of previous assessment orders and pending objections.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
Court No. - 21 Case :- WRIT TAX No. - 677 of 2018 Petitioner :- St. Jude'S Hospital Society And Another Respondent :- State Of U.P. And 3 Others Counsel for Petitioner :- Sanjiv Singh,Mary Puncha (Sheeb Jose) Counsel for Respondent :- C.S.C.,Nagendra Nath Mishra Hon'ble Krishna Murari,J. Hon'ble Ashok Kumar,J. Against the recovery of house tax the petitioner has filed the present writ petition contending that the petitioner-institution being a charitable organization is exempted from payment of house tax. Heard Sri Sanjeev Singh, learned counsel for the petitioner and learned standing counsel. By means of the present writ petition the petitioner has challenged the demand notice dated 23.8.2017 for a sum of Rs. 1,28,07,011/- and the consequential order dated 6.4.2018 passed by the respondent no.3. Earlier the petitioner had filed Writ Petition Nos. 1317 of 2006, 425 of 2008 and 912 of 2009. All the aforesaid writ petitions are disposed of vide orders dated 5.2.2015. By the said orders this Court has disposed of the petitions by directing the competent authority to decide the objections of the petitioner by a reasoned order after providing an opportunity of hearing to the petitioner within a period of three months from the date a certified copy of the orders are produced. From the aforesaid orders dated 5.2.2015 this Court has clarified that till disposal of the objections the interim order granted by the Court will continue to operate. We have noticed that another writ petition being Writ Petition No. 690 of 2017 was also filed, which was dismissed by this Court vide order dated 26.10.2017 on the ground that no cause of action survives. Learned counsel for the petitioner has placed before us the impugned order dated 6.4.2018 passed by Municipal Commissioner, Nagar Nigam Jhansi, respondent no.3. In this order dated 6.4.2018 the respondent no.3 has taken into consideration the orders passed by this Court in writ petitions
filed by the petitioner dated 5.2.2015. In the impugned order the respondent no.3 has considered and has discussed whatever facts related to the activities of the petitioner hospital/institution. It is clearly mentioned that the hospital which is being run by the petitioner having 185 beds so far as the general ward is concerned and there are other private wards of containing air condition facilities as well as non-air condition facility. It is further mentioned that the petitioner institution/hospital is charging Rs.150/- from all the patients who are availing the facility as patient in general ward. It is further mentioned that the petitioner's hospital is charging fee for providing the private wards according to the status of the patient. The respondent no.3 has therefore concluded that apart from the exemption certificate issued in favour of the petitioner- hospital by the Commissioner of Income Tax under Section 12- A of the Income Tax Act there is no other material which entitles the petitioner to get the exemption from the house tax and in other words that the petitioner-hospital is solely and exclusively run for charitable purposes. On asking by the Court learned counsel for the petitioner failed to provide any material which can support his submission that the petitioner-hospital is entitled to be exempted from demand of house tax on the basis of exemption allowed under Section 12-A by the Commissioner of Income Tax. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and we find no substance in the submissions of the learned counsel for the petitioner nor the counsel for the petitioner produced any material to support his contention that only because of having the exemption from payment of income tax being the charitable trust under Section 12-A of the Income Tax, the petitioner is entitled to get the exemption from payment of house tax. The counsel for the petitioner has failed to satisfy the query of the Court with regard to the assessment proceedings related to house tax of the properties of the petitioner-hospital. He has only placed the copy of the recovery notice issued by the Chief Assessment Officer, Nagar Nigam, Jhansi (Annexure-6) which clearly indicates that the annual assessment of the petitioner- hospital is of Rs.71,94,950/- and the house tax is chargeable at the rate of 10% and there are dues to the tune of Rs.1,07,92,425/- on which the interest is calculated to the tune of Rs.12,95,091/-. The current year tax is assessed being 10% of the annual assessment of the property which comes to Rs.7,19,495/- and the outstanding dues are shown to the tune of Rs.1,15,11,920/-. The actual outstanding amount is calculated at Rs.1,28,07,011/-. The Court has enquired from the counsel for the petitioner about the assessment of the property and the
assessment orders. Learned counsel for the petitioner could not place any material nor satisfactory reply is given whereas he has denied that any assessment order has ever been passed. The contentions of the counsel for the petitioner have no legs whereas we find that while deciding the writ petitions vide orders dated 5.2.2015 (Writ Petition Nos.1317 of 2006, 425 of 2008, 912 of 2009) this Court has clearly mentioned as follows : "In this regard, the petitioner has filed an objection for withdrawal of the assessment order, which is pending consideration." This observation by the Division Bench clearly indicates that when earlier petitioner has approached this Court there were assessment orders against which the petitioner may have filed his objections. In view of the aforesaid facts, we are not inclined to interfere in the present case as several factual disputes are involved, which can appropriately be adjudicated by the authority concerned including the appellate authority. The writ petition has no merit and it is accordingly dismissed. It shall however be open to the petitioner to avail the remedy of appeal in case he is so advised. Order Date :- 7.5.2018 S.S. . (Ashok Kumar, J.) (Krishna Murari, J.)
More judgments on Section 12-A
- Tilok Tirath Vidyawati Chuttan vs Commissioner of Income TaxCWP/350/200017 Jan 2025
- The Commissioner of Income Tax Exemptions… vs Mukand Lal College SocietyITA/115/20216 Feb 2023
- M/S. Toiling Masses Welfare vs Deputy Commissioner ofTCA/760/201622 Sept 2021
- C.I.T., Jabalpur vs Namra Mahila Avam Bal Kalyan SamitiMAIT/71/200411 Feb 2020
- V. Gopalappa vs The SecretaryWP/11581/201824 Sept 2019
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Subrat Kumar Samal vs. The Commissioner, CGST, Cx And Customs, BhubaneswarOrissa · 3 Nov 2026
- Laxmipriya Biswal vs. Assistant Commissioner Of State Tax,BhubaneswarOrissa · 3 Nov 2026
- M/S Shree Jagannath Engineering,Angul vs. Assistant Commissioner, Angul Division ,AngulOrissa · 3 Nov 2026
- M/S. Archana Agro, Nayagarh vs. The Chief Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes And Goods And Services Tax, CuttackOrissa · 3 Nov 2026
- M/S.Shree Jagannath Associates, Angul vs. The Chief Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes And Goods And Services Tax, CuttackOrissa · 3 Nov 2026