M/S AMRITVARSHA INDUSTRIES vs. COMMISSIONER OF COMMERCIAL TAX

PDF · subscribers
STRE/467/2013HC AllahabadUPHC01184713201312 November 20194 pages
AI SummaryRemanded

What did the High Court hold?

The Tribunal erred in sustaining the penalty. The Court noted that the assessee was a manufacturer who had paid excise duty and other applicable duties on the imported raw material. It was undisputed that the goods were raw material for manufacturing excisable goods, entitling the assessee to CENVAT credit. The revenue did not allege clandestine import and sale. The Court emphasized that intention to evade tax is a state of mind requiring careful weighing of all available material. Relying on M/s. Rama Pulses Vs. State of U.P. & Ors., the Court held that a finding of intention to evade tax requires proper reasoning and supporting material, not just discrepancies in forms. The order of the Tribunal was set aside, and the matter was remitted back for fresh decision.

What were the facts?

The assessee, M/s Amritvarsha Industries, engaged in manufacturing iron and steel structurals, imported sponge iron as raw material. Goods were seized and a penalty imposed under Section 54(1)(14) of the U.P. Value Added Tax Act, 2008, for alleged violation. The revenue noted defects in the Import Declaration Form, including blank fields and overwriting on the vehicle description. However, the goods were accompanied by valid excise invoices showing payment of excise duty, additional duties, and cess. The transportation documents were found to be in order. The assessee's explanation was disbelieved by the assessing authority and the Tribunal, inferring an intention to evade tax.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the authorities were justified in imposing penalty under Section 54(1)(14) of the U.P. Value Added Tax Act, 2008, without assigning reasons to support the finding of intention to evade payment of tax? Assessee's contention: The assessee argued that the authorities erred in imposing the penalty without adequately considering the evidence of excise duty payment and the fact that the imported goods were raw material for their manufacturing activity. They relied on the Division Bench judgment in M/s. Rama Pulses Vs. State of U.P. & Ors., 2009 NTN (Vol 41) 189, which held that a finding of intention to evade tax must be supported by material evidence. Revenue's contention: The revenue's stance, as inferred from the lower authorities' decisions, was that the blank fields and overwriting on the Import Declaration Form indicated an intention to evade tax, despite the presence of excise documents.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 54(1)(14), Section 14(iv)(v)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Court No. - 59 Case :- SALES/TRADE TAX REVISION No. - 467 of 2013 Revisionist :- M/S Amritvarsha Industries Opposite Party :- Commissioner Of Commercial Tax Counsel for Revisionist :- Nishant Mishra Counsel for Opposite Party :- C.S.C . Hon'ble Saumitra Dayal Singh,J. 1. Present revision has been filed by the assessee against the order of the Commercial Tax Tribunal, Ghaziabad dated 12.02.2013 in Second Appeal No. 1148 of 2011 for A.Y. 2008- 09 (penalty). By that order, the Tribunal has sustained the penalty imposed on the assessee under Section 54(1)(14) of the U.P. Value Added Tax Act, 2008 (hereinafter referred to as the 'Act'). 2. During the assessment year in question, the assessee was engaged in manufacture of products of iron and steel namely structurals. For conducting that activity, it imported raw materials including sponge iron. Amongst others, it imported quantities of sponge iron against invoice no. 687 and 688, both dated 21.12.2008, issued by M/s. Om Agencies, Surat at Gujarat. These quantities were being imported by truck bearing registration number UP15AT-0733, when the same were detained for checking and seized for violation of Section 54(1) (14) of the Act. As to the documents accompanying the goods, the revenue does not dispute that the goods were accompanied with the regular excise invoice issued by the seller containing details of payments for value of goods, central excise and additional duties and cess. Also, the goods were found accompanied with the documents of transportation with respect to which it found no defect. Also Form-38 was found blank except the description of registration number of the vehicle. Even in that regard, the revenue authorities noted that there was

overwriting. In such circumstances, the goods were seized and penalty imposed, inferring intention to evade tax. 3. The present revision had been admitted on the following question of law: "Whether authorities are justified in imposing penalty under Section 54 (1) (14) of the U.P. Value Added Tax Act, 2008 without assigning reasons to support the finding of intention to evade payment of tax?" 4. Having heard Shri Nishant Mishra and Shri Tanmay Sadh, learned counsel for the assessee and Shri B.K. Pandey, learned Standing Counsel for the revenue, it appears that the finding of intention to evade tax had been recorded by the assessing authority on account of various fields of Import Declaration Form being found blank and the vehicle description being overwritten on that Form. The assessing authority also disbelieved the explanation furnished by the assessee on the strength of the excise documents and the fact that the assessee was a manufacturer. 5. However, it is material to note that, in the present case, undisputedly, the assessee is a manufacturer who is found to have paid excise duty and additional duties and cess at the rate of 10.30 percent amounting to Rs. 20,630.85 against invoice no. 687. Similarly, duty had been paid against the other invoice. Again, it is undisputed that the assessee was a manufacturer of excisable goods for which the goods forming subject matter of penalty proceedings were raw material. Therefore, it cannot be disputed that the assessee would have been entitled to avail CENVAT with respect to the duty paid on such raw material. 6. Again, one cannot lose sight of the fact that according to the assessee, the commodity in question was iron and steel and, the end product manufactured by the assessee was iron and steel structural. Unndisputedly, iron and steel structurals fall under

Section 14(iv)(v) of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956, and would be taxable at the rate of 4 percent for that reason. 7. At any rate, CENVAT credit proportionate to 10.30 percent of the value of the goods would be available to the assessee, being a manufacturer. 8. It is not the case of the revenue that the assessee was engaged in clandestine import and sale of sponge iron. In absence of such allegation, the explanation offered by the assessee merited very serious consideration than has been offered by the assessing authority or the Tribunal. The Tribunal has merely rejected the explanation and relied heavily on the fact that the Import Declaration Form was left blank in material fields. 9. A Division Bench of this Court in the case of M/s. Rama Pulses Vs. State of U.p. & Ors., 2009 NTN (Vol 41) 189, had held as below: "13. We are of the view that the law laid down in Jain Shudh Vanaspati Ltd. Ghaziabad is still good law and holds the field even after enforcement of VAT Act and that before imposing penalty the authority has to give notice under Section 54(1) and to record a finding either on the basis of the material before it, or produced by the dealer, or any other person, or the department and which may include incomplete Form 38, (which may be a ground for seizure of the goods), that there was an intention to evade the payment of tax." 10. Once it was not disputed that the excise documents were accompanied with the goods which disclosed payment of excise duty and it was also admitted to the revenue that the assessee was engaged in manufacture of goods wherein the goods being imported were to be used as raw material, the Tribunal ought to have given more meaningful consideration to this material and its consequences, before dismissing the appeal filed by the assessee. 11. Intention to evade tax is a state of mind. Direct evidence for

such fact is rarely available. Therefore, all the more, before reaching a positive conclusion as to existence of mens rea or guilty intention of mind, the Tribunal must carefully weigh all material available on record and examine their consequence in light of the law laid down by this Court and in the context of the fact allegations made by the revenue. 12. Accordingly, the order of the Tribunal dated 12.02.2013 is set aside. The matter is remitted to the Tribunal to decide the appeal afresh, preferably within a period of three months from today on the strength of the evidence available on record. 13. Revision is disposed of. Order Date :- 13.11.2019 AHA

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →