M/S SRI MAHAVIR ROLLING MILLS P LTD. vs. THE COMMISSIONER OF COMMERCIAL TAX U.P.LUCKNOW
What did the High Court hold?
The Court allowed the revisions in favour of the assessee. It held that the benefit under Section 4-BB of the U.P. Trade Tax Act should be granted. The reasoning was that while Section 4-BB stipulates 'tax paid', the manner of payment is not restricted to physical tender. When tax is assessed on a dealer who is exempted under Section 4-A, and this assessed tax is adjusted against the eligibility certificate, it amounts to payment of tax by way of adjustment. The Court relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Punjab and others Vs. Perfect Synthetics and others (2008 (3) SCC 702), which held that exemption is given to dealers, not goods, and assessment and deduction from eligibility amounts to payment of tax. The Tribunal had found that the dealer was assessed to tax at 2% and this was adjusted from the eligibility amount, thus presumed to be paid. The Court noted that the revenue's counsel did not dispute that the issues were covered by the cited judgment. Therefore, the assessee was granted the same benefit as extended in the previous judgment. The questions of law were answered in favour of the assessee and against the Department.
What were the facts?
The assessee, M/s Sri Mahavir Rolling Mills P Ltd., filed two revisions before the Allahabad High Court challenging the order of the Commercial Tax Tribunal, Kanpur Bench. The Tribunal had rejected the assessee's claim for benefit under Section 4-BB of the U.P. Trade Tax Act for assessment years 1999-00 and 2000-01. The assessee, engaged in manufacturing iron and steel products, purchased raw materials from M/s Sri Mahavir Iron Industries (P) Ltd., which was granted exemption under Section 4-A of the Act. The assessee claimed a set-off of tax on finished goods based on these purchases. The assessing authority and the first appellate authority rejected the claim. The Tribunal also upheld this rejection, leading to the present revisions. The disputed amounts were Rs. 3,99,461/- for 1999-00 and Rs. 7,37,035/- for 2000-01.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the Tribunal was legally justified in confirming the orders of the authorities below and denying the benefit under Section 4-BB of the U.P. Trade Tax Act on the ground that raw material was purchased from a dealer exempted under Section 4-A of the Act? 2. Whether the Tribunal was justified in not allowing the benefit of set-off under Section 4-BB of the Act, despite the assessee fulfilling the conditions and a Division Bench of the Tribunal having allowed the benefit for the preceding assessment year 1998-99? 3. Whether the impugned order of the Tribunal is sustainable in law, having been passed in ignorance of material on record and with erroneous findings? Assessee's Contentions: The assessee argued that having purchased raw materials from a new industry granted exemption under Section 4-A, it became entitled to the benefit under Section 4-BB. It further contended that the issue was decided in its favour by this Court in a previous case (Commissioner, Trade Tax, U.P. Lucknow Vs. S/s Shri Mahaveer Rolling Mills (P) Ltd., Kanpur, 2010 UPTC 977). The assessee also argued that for Section 4-BB, the mode of tax payment is immaterial; what matters is assessment and payment, which can be through adjustment. The revenue's contention, as noted by the Tribunal, was that Section 4-BB stipulates actual payment of tax for set-off, which was not made in this case.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 4-BB, Section 4-A
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
Court No. - 59 Case :- SALES/TRADE TAX REVISION No. - 540 of 2010 Revisionist :- M/S Sri Mahavir Rolling Mills P Ltd. Opposite Party :- The Commissioner Of Commercial Tax U.P.Lucknow Counsel for Revisionist :- Praveen Kumar,Ashok Kumar Counsel for Opposite Party :- C.S.C. AND Case :- SALES/TRADE TAX REVISION No. - 541 of 2010 Revisionist :- M/S Sri Mahavir Rolling Mills P Ltd. Opposite Party :- The Commissioner Of Commercial Tax U.P.Lucknow Counsel for Revisionist :- Praveen Kumar,Ashok Kumar Counsel for Opposite Party :- C.S.C. Hon'ble Piyush Agrawal,J. In these two revisions, similar facts and controversy are involved. Hence, they have been heard together and are being disposed of by this common order. The present revisions have been filed against the common order dated 18.02.2010 passed by the Commercial Tax Tribunal, Kanpur Bench – 1st, Kanpur in Second Appeal No. 34 of 2003 (for the assessment year 1999-00) and Second Appeal No. 597 of 2003 (for the assessment year 2000 – 01); by which, the claim of the revisionists under section 4-BB of the U.P. Trade Tax Act has been rejected. In both the revisions, common questions of law have been framed, which are as under:-
“1. Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case, the Tribunal is legally justified in law in confirming the orders of the authorities below and in not granting the benefit claimed by the revisionist under section 4-BB of the Act of setting off of tax on finished goods on the ground that it purchased the raw material from a dealer which is exempted under section 4-A of the Act? 2. Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case and material on record, the Tribunal is justified in law in not allowing the benefit of setting off of tax on finished goods under section 4-BB of the Act despite the fact that the revisionist fulfilled the requisite conditions for the same and the Division Bench of the Tribunal in the preceding assessment year 1998-99 has already allowed the benefit of the same? Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case the impugned order of the Tribunal is sustainable under law specially when the same has been passed in utter ignorance of the material on record and by recording erroneous and perverse findings?” The facts of the case are that the revisionist is a Private Limited Company and engaged in the business of manufacturing and sales of iron and steel products. The revisionist is registered under the U.P. Trade Tax Act as well as under the Central Sales Tax Act. The revisionist purchases various raw materials from various dealers in the normal course of its business. Certain raw materials were purchased from M/s Sri Mahavir Iron Industries (P) Ltd., who was granted exemption from payment of Trade Tax under section 4-A of the Act. The revisionist claimed the benfit of section 4-BB of the U.P. Trade Tax Act, but the same was rejected by the assessing authority while framing the assessment orders. The claim, which was rejected by the assessing authority for the assessment year 1999 – 2000, was to the tune of Rs. 3,99,461/-. The claim for the assessment year 2000-01 to the tune of Rs. 7,37,035/- was also rejected by the assessing authority.
Aggrieved by the assessment order, the revisionist preferred first appeal before the Joint Commissioner (Appeal – 1st), Trade Tax, Kanpur. The first appellate authority rejected the first appeal, against which second appeal under section 10 of the Act was filed before the Tribunal, which was also dismissed upholding the rejection of claim made by the revisionist under section 4-BB of the Act. Aggrieved by the order of the Tribunal, the present revisions have been filed. Heard learned counsel for the parties. Learned counsel for the revisionist submits that the purchase has been made from the new industry, who was granted exemption under section 4-A of the Act and on the strength of the exemption being granted, the revisionist became entitled as per the provisions of section 4-BB of the Act to claim the benefit as provided therein and the claim has wrongly been rejected upto the Tribunal. Learned counsel for the revisionist further submits that the issue involved in the present revisions has already been decided by this Court in the inter-parties case of the Commissioner, Trade Tax, U.P. Lucknow Vs. S/s Shri Mahaveer Rolling Mills (P) Ltd., Kanpur (2010 UPTC 977); wherein, following observation has been made:- “Section 4-A of the Act permits exemption to new dealers/ manufacturers from payment of tax for a particular period and to a particular limit on the establishment of new units or investment for the purposes of expansion, diversification and modernization of any of them, if the State Government is of the opinion that it is necessary so to do in granting protection to any goods or for permitting the development of any industry in the state in general or any district or part of the district in particular. Section 4-BB of the Act provides that where any tax has been paid on purchase or sale of raw material or packing material within the State of U.P. and such
material is used in manufacturing or packing of any finished goods as notified, the amount of tax paid on purchase of such raw material or packing material shall be deducted from the tax payable on sale of such finished goods. There is no dispute that dealer M/S Mahaveer Rolling Mills (P) Limited from whom assessee has purchased raw material/ packing material is fully exempt from the payment of tax under Section 4-A of the Act and has been issued an eligibility certificate in that regard. The raw material/ packing material so sold to the assessee is within the permissible limits of the eligibility certificate. The material so sold has been used by the assessee in manufacture of the finished goods. Therefore, the assessee claimed set off of the value of tax assessable on the purchase of said raw material/ packing material from the above dealer from the tax payable by the assessee on the sale of the finished goods. However, the said deduction/set off was refused to the assessee by the assessing authority on the ground that there is no actual payment of tax on sale/purchase of the raw material. Tribunal however, has reversed the same and has allowed the said deduction/ set off to the assessee. In the back drop of the above facts and circumstances the following question of law has been raised for determination in this revision.
"Whether under the facts and circumstances the assessee is entitle to set off under section 4-BB of the Act from the gross turnover of the purchase value of the raw material which the assessee has purchased from the dealer who is exempt from payment of tax under section 4-A of the Act ?" For considering the above question of law it would be beneficial to refer to Section 4-BB of the U.P.Trade Tax Act. which read as under:- "4BB. Set off of tax paid on raw material and packing material in certain cases:- Where tax has been paid on the purchase of sale of raw material or packing material inside the State and such raw material or packing material has been used in manufacture or packing of such goods as are notified by the State Government in this behalf and such goods are sold in the State or in the course of Inter State trade or commerce, the amount of tax paid on the purchase or sale of the raw material or packing material shall, subject to such conditions and restrictions as may be specified in the said notification, be deducted from the tax payable on the sale of such goods- (a) inside the State, to the extent the tax has been paid on the purchase or sale of raw material or packing material from which the goods sold inside the State were manufactured or packed; (b) in the course of inter State trade or commerce, to the extent the tax has been paid on the purchase or sale of raw material or packing material from which the goods sold in the course of inter State trade or commerce were manufactured or packed: Provided that the amount of tax to be deducted under clause (a) or clause ( b) shall not exceed the amount of tax payable separately under this Act or the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956" The submission of the learned Standing counsel is that Section 4-BB stipulates payment of actual tax for the purposes of grant of set off/ deduction and as there is no actual payment, the tribunal erred in allowing the said benefit to the assessee. In rebutting the above argument Sri Praveen Kumar, learned counsel
appearing for the assessee has submitted that for the purposes of benefit of Section 4-BB of the Act the mode and manner of payment of tax is immaterial. What is relevant is assessment and payment of tax on the purchase/ sale of raw material or packing material. The Scheme of the Act envisages issuance of eligibility certificate to dealer granting exemption under Section 4-A of the Act The said eligibility certificate discloses the amount to the extent of which exemption is permissible to the dealer and the time limit during which said exemption can be availed. The sale and purchase of the goods of the dealer are accounted for and the tax liability on the same on being determined is periodically adjusted from the limit of the exemption provided in the eligibility certificate. In this way there is assessment of tax on the sale and purchase of the dealer and corresponding adjustment of the tax payable by him from the eligibility certificate. Accordingly, there is payment of tax in the books by way of adjustment without actual payment of tax. The provision of Section 4-BB stipulates payment of tax. The manner in which the said tax is payable is not described. The payment of tax can be by tendering the amount physically by cash, cheque or draft or it can also be by some adjustment. There is no prohibition in the Act from making payment of tax by way of an adjustment. When the amount of tax determined and payable by the dealer is accounted for and is given due adjustment in the eligibility certificate, it amounts to payment of tax or receipt of tax by the revenue. Thus, non grant of the set off/ deduction to the assessee under Section 4-BB of the Act of the amount of tax payable by him on the purchase of raw material / packing material from the dealer Mahaveer Rolling Mills ( P) Ltd. which is fully exempt from payment of tax under Section 4 -A of the Act was not legally justified and as such the tribunal committed no error of law in allowing the said benefit to the assessee by the order impugned. The Apex Court in the case of Punjab and others Vs. Perfect Synthetics and others, 2008 (3) SCC 702 while dealing with a similar situation in connection with the Punjab General Sales Tax ( Deferment and Exemption) Rules, 1991, has observed that the exemption is given to the dealers and not to the goods and that the assessment of tax of the dealer and deduction of the same from the eligibility amount amounts to payment of tax. Similar is the situation in the present case. The dealer M/S Mahaveer Iron Industry Pvt Ltd. who has been given full exemption under section 4-A of the Act was assessed to tax on the material sold to the assessee/revisionist and the tax so assessed on the sale of the of the said goods was deducted from his eligibility certificate. Accordingly, it amounts the payment of tax by way of adjustment. Section 4-BB has not prescribed the manner of payment of tax and manner of payment cannot be confined to payment by actual tender but it would include payment of tax by adjustment also. In view of the above discussion, the question raised in this revision is answered against the revenue and in favour of the assessee as above. The Tribunal has recorded a finding that the aforesaid dealer was assessed to tax @ 2% and the same was adjusted by way of mode of payment from the eligibility amount available to the said dealer and therefore, it would be presumed that the said payment of tax has been made.” Learned counsel for the respondents does not dispute that the issues involved in the present revisions are covered by the said judgement and order.
In view of the aforesaid fact, the revisionists in the assessment years in question are also given the same benefit as extended above. Accordingly, both the revisions are allowed in the same terms. The questions of law are answered in favour of the assessee and against the Department. Order Date :-19/11/2019 Amit Mishra
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- B.S. Automobiles vs. The State Of Meghalaya And Ors.Meghalaya · 17 Nov 2026
- Jingso Tayang vs. The Union Of INDIA And 3 OrsGauhati · 15 Nov 2026
- The Assistant Commissioner Of Central Tax vs. M/S Volvo Group INDIA Private LimitedKarnataka · 13 Nov 2026
- Sri Bheema Setu Munivrunda Mutt vs. Government Of KarnatakaKarnataka · 12 Nov 2026
- Sri. Bhimasethu Munivrunda Matha vs. The State Of KarnatakaKarnataka · 12 Nov 2026