COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, KOLKATA-II, KOLKATA vs. BIRLA CORPORATION LTD.

PDF · subscribers
ITA/133/2012HC CalcuttaWBCHCO003826201216 January 20249 pages
AI SummaryPartly Allowed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court addressed each substantial question of law. For question 1, it held that the issue had been decided in favour of the revenue and against the assessee in a previous judgment (ITA No.158/2010), thus answering question 1 in favour of the revenue. For question 2, the Court held that the compensation paid by the assessee was for damages caused to the land surface during mining operations, which were incidental to business operations. No interest in land was acquired by this payment. Therefore, the expenditure was revenue in nature and deductible. The Court distinguished the Supreme Court's decision in Enterprising Enterprises. Thus, question 2 was answered in favour of the assessee. For questions 3 and 4, the Court noted that the assessee reduced the written down value of its block assets by the sale proceeds of part of the assets, as permitted by Section 43(6)(c)(i)(B) of the Income Tax Act. This provision allows for reduction of moneys payable in respect of an asset sold from the block of assets. Therefore, the ITAT and CIT(A) did not err in allowing the deduction. Questions 3 and 4 were answered in favour of the assessee. The appeal was partly allowed.

What were the facts?

This appeal by the Revenue challenges the order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) concerning Assessment Year 2006-07. The ITAT had decided certain substantial questions of law in favour of the assessee, Birla Corporation Ltd. The appeal concerns four substantial questions of law. The first question relates to the taxability of operational subsidies. The second question pertains to the disallowance of a deduction claimed by the assessee for compensation paid for damages to land surface during mining operations. The third and fourth questions are interconnected and relate to the treatment of profit on the sale of machinery from a closed-down unit and the application of Section 43(6) of the Income Tax Act regarding the block of assets.

What were the issues?

The Tribunal had to decide the following substantial questions of law: 1. Whether subsidies that can be used freely are operational subsidies and thus taxable as revenue income, or capital subsidies. - Revenue argued that subsidies are operational and taxable as revenue income. - Assessee's argument is not explicitly recorded on this point. 2. Whether the ITAT erred in deleting the disallowance made by the Assessing Officer on account of the claim of deduction of proportionate leasehold land written off of Rs. 20,50,052/- - Revenue contended that compensation paid for damages to land surface during mining operations is a capital expenditure, not business expenditure. - Assessee argued that since the compensation was for carrying out business activity, it is an expenditure for business operations and thus deductible. 3. Whether the ITAT erred in deleting the addition made by the Assessing Officer on account of profit on sale of machinery of a closed-down unit for Rs. 2,41,44,000/- 4. Whether the Tribunal was incorrect in rejecting the Revenue's appeal on the issue of treatment of accounting profit from sale of certain depreciable fixed assets, on the basis that accounting treatment cannot affect statutory provisions like Section 43(6) and the block of assets concept. - Revenue's arguments on these questions are not explicitly recorded, but the context implies they sought to tax the profit on sale of machinery differently. - Assessee argued that the reduction in the written down value of block assets by the sale proceeds of part of the block assets is in accordance with Section 43(6)(c)(i)(B) of the Act.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 43(6),Section 43(6)(c)(i)(B)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

OD–5 ITA/133/2012 IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA Special Jurisdiction [Income Tax] ORIGINAL SIDE

COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, KOLKATA –II, KOLKATA -Versus- BIRLA CORPORATION LTD. BEFORE : THE HON’BLE JUSTICE SURYA PRAKASH KESARWANI And THE HON’BLE JUSTICE RAJARSHI BHARADWAJ Date : 16th January, 2024 Appearance : Sri Vipul Kundalia, Adv. Smt. Oindrilla Ghosal, Adv. ...for the appellant. Sri J.P. Khaitan, Sr. Adv. Sri Sanjoy Bhaumik, Adv. Smt. Swapna Das, Adv. ...for the respondent. 1. Heard Sri Vipul Kundalia, learned senior standing counsel for the appellant/revenue and Sri J.P. Khaitan, learned senior advocate assisted by Sri Sanjoy Bhaumik and Smt. Swapna Das, learned advocates respondent/assessee. 2. This appeal was admitted by this Court by an order dated 30.11.2012 on the following substantial questions of law: “1) Whether in view of the facts and circumstances of the instant case the Tribunal erred by not considering that subsides which may be used freely, are operational subsidies and not capital subsides and thus the same are taxable as revenue income? 2) Whether the Hon’ble ITAT has erred in law as well as on facts by deleting the disallowance made Assessing Officer on account claim deduction of proportionate amount of lease hold land written off of Rs.20,50,052? 3) Whether the Hon’ble ITAT has erred in law as well as on facts by deleting the addition made by the Assessing Officer on account of profit on sale machinery a closed down unit Rs.2,41,44,000/-? 4) Whether the learned Tribunal was incorrect in rejecting the appeal preferred by the Revenue Department, on the issue of treatment of accounting profit from sale of certain depreciable fixed assets chargeable of tax on the basis that the accounting treatment cannot effect operation statutory provisions contained in Section 43(6) of the said Act and for the purpose of income tax the block of assets concept was followed as per the statutory provisions?” Substantial Question of Law No.1 3. So far as the afore-quoted substantial question of law no.1 is concerned, we find that this issue has been decided in favour of the revenue and against the assessee a judgment and order dated 18.12.2023 in ITA No.158/2010 (Commissioner of Income Tax, Kolkata – II, Kolkata Vs. M/s. Birla Corporation Limited). Following the aforesaid judgment, the substantial question of law no.1, as afore-quoted, is answered in favour of the revenue and against the assessee. The present appeal of the revenue stands allowed in respect of the substantial question of law no.1 and to that extent the impugned order of the Tribunal dated 29.7.2011 in ITA No.1936(Kol) of 2010 (Assessment Year 2006-07) is set aside. Substantial Question of Law No.2 4. Briefly stated facts of the present case having bearing on the afore-quoted substantial question of law no.2 are that the respondent/assessee had acquired mining lease of 9.99 kilometer land in village- Chittorgarh for mining of lime stone for use as raw material for manufacture of cement.

To carry operation/business operation, in terms of the lease deed as well as pursuant to the provision of Section 89 of the Rajasthan Land Revenue Act, the compensation for damages caused to the surface of the lease area or for infringement of rights of any person by the occupation or disturbance of the surface of such land, was to be paid. In the matter of the respondent/assessee, the compensation for damages caused to the surface or infringement of rights was determined by the Collector and it was paid by the assessee. Accordingly, the respondent/assessee claimed Rs.20,55,052/- as expenditure deductible from income, which was disallowed by the assessing officer relying upon a decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Enterprising Enterprises v. Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, reported in (2007) 293 ITR 437. Aggrieved by the aforesaid disallowance made by the assessing officer, the respondent/assessee filed an appeal before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals). Before the CIT(A), respondent/assessee restricted its claim deduction to Rs.19,38,232/-. The CIT(A) had set aside the disallowance made by the assessing officer and accepted contention assessee that compensation paid was an expenditure incidental to the business activity. Aggrieved by the order of the CIT(A), the revenue had filed the ITA No,.1936(Kol)/2010 which was dismissed by the impugned order passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, “B” Bench, Kolkata. 5. Learned senior standing counsel for the revenue has submitted that the compensation paid by the assessee to land owners for damage caused to the surface of the land falling in mining lease area for carrying out mining operation or allied activity, is a capital expenditure and not a business expenditure and the CIT(A) has committed a manifest error of law to set aside the disallowance of Rs.19,38,232/-. 6. Learned counsel for the respondent/assessee has submitted that once it is undisputed that the compensation paid to land owners was for carrying out business activity by the assessee in mining lease area, then necessarily it is an expenditure carrying business operation. Therefore, the CIT(A) and the Tribunal have not committed any error of law to hold that the aforesaid amount is a business expenditure and its deduction from income was lawfully claimed by the respondent/assessee. Therefore, the appeal of the revenue deserves to be dismissed on this question and the question deserves to be answered in favour of assessee and against the revenue. 7. We have carefully considered the submissions of learned counsel for the parties and perused the records of the appeal. 8. It is undisputed that the assessee acquired a mining lease of 9.99 kilometers situated in village- Chittorgarh for obtaining lime stone used as raw material for manufacture cement.

To carry operation/business activity, the assessee has paid the amount in question to land owners for damage caused to the surface of the land or for infringement of rights of land owner by conducting mining operations and the business operations. The amount paid by the assessee was determined by the Collector in terms of the statutory provision Rajasthan Revenue Act read with Rajasthan Land Acquisition Act. The event to pay compensation arose to the assessee only on account of damage caused to the surface of the land falling in lease area operation/business operation. There was no requirement to pay had there been no damage caused to the surface of the land by mining/business operation. Thus, the payment in question made by the respondent/assessee was in the nature of expenditure for carrying out business operations. No interest in land has been acquired respondent/assessee by payment of such compensation. Thus, the payments are in the nature of incidental expenditure to conduct the mining and business operation. Therefore, expenditure so incurred respondent/assessee is revenue in nature. Consequently, the CIT(A) and the Income Tax appellate Tribunal have not committed any error of law to hold the aforesaid expenditure of Rs.19,38,232/- as revenue in nature and accordingly allowed the deduction. 9. The judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Enterprising Enterprise (supra) relied upon by learned counsel for the appellant has no bearing on facts of the present case inasmuch as the controversy involved in that case was as to whether the lease rent paid by the mining lessee for acquiring leasehold right for extracting minerals from mineral bearing land would be a capital expenditure or a revenue expenditure ? In the present set of facts there is no such controversy and, instead, the controversy is with regard to the expenditure in the form of compensation incurred by the respondent/assessee course mining/business operation. Therefore, the judgment relied upon by the learned counsel for the appellant is clearly distinguishable and is of no help. 10. In view of the aforesaid, the substantial question of law no.2 is answered in favour of the assessee and against the revenue. To this extent, the appeal of the revenue deserves to be dismissed. Substantial Question of Law Nos.3 & 4 11. These two substantial questions of law are inter- connected. Briefly stated facts having bearing on the substantial question of law nos.3 and 4 are that the respondent/assessee reduced the written down value of its block assets by Rs.2,41,44,000/- in terms of Section 43(6)(c)(i)(B) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The aforesaid amount represented the sale of part of some block assets. Section 43(6)(c)(i)(B) is reproduced below: 43. Definitions of certain terms relevant to income from profits and gains of business or profession.- (1) ... (6) “written down value” means – (a)... (b)... (c) in the case of any block of assets,- (i) in respect of any previous year relevant to assessment year commencing on the 1st day of April, 1988, the aggregate of the written down values of all the assets falling within that block of assets at the beginning of the previous year and adjusted,- (A)... (B) by a reduction of the moneys payable in respect of any asset falling within that block, which is sold or discarded or demolished or destroyed that previous year together with the amount of the scrap value, if any, so, however, that the amount of such reduction does not exceed the written down value as so increased;” 12. Thus, reducing the block assets by the amount in question representing the sale of some of the assets out of the block assets is in terms of the afore-quoted provisions of Section 43(6)(c)(i)(B) of the Act, 1961 which permits reduction of money in respect of any asset falling within that block which is sold or discarded or demolished or destroyed during the previous year together with amount of scrap value, if any, so, however, that the amount of such deduction does not exceed the written down value as so increased. The deduction by the amount in question is undoubtedly under the aforesaid provisions of Section 43(6)(c)(i)(B) of the Act, 1961. Therefore, the CIT(A) and the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal have not committed any manifest error of law to reduce the sale proceeds from the written down value and allowed the depreciation on reduced written down value. 13. In view of the aforesaid, the substantial question of law nos.3 and 4 are answered in favour of the assessee and against the revenue. To this extent the appeal deserves to be dismissed. 14. For all reasons afore-stated, substantial question of law no.1 is answered in favour of the revenue and against the assessee. The substantial question of law nos.2, 3 and 4 are answered in favour of the assessee and against the revenue. 15. Thus, the appeal (ITA/133/2012) is partly allowed to the extent indicated above.

(SURYA PRAKASH KESARWANI, J.)

(RAJARSHI BHARADWAJ, J.) S.Das/As.

More judgments on Section 43(6)

All 192 judgments and leading authorities on Section 43(6) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →