M/S COMMERCIAL AUTOSALES PVT. LTD. vs. COMMISSIONER COMMERCIAL TAX U.P. LUCKNOW
What did the High Court hold?
The Tribunal held that the assessee's actions indicated an intention to evade tax liability. The chassis were purchased against Form 3A and sent out of state for body mounting, with final bills issued after the body was mounted, showing separate values for chassis and body. Temporary registration and transit insurance were in the assessee's name, and Form C was issued to the body manufacturer, indicating the chassis remained in the assessee's possession until after the body was mounted. The Tribunal noted that when the nature of goods purchased against Form 3A changes, a tax liability arises. The assessee had not paid tax on such altered goods in previous years. The court also addressed the issue of spare parts replaced under warranty, citing precedents like Mohd. Ekram Khan & Sons and S/S Maskat Motors Pvt. Ltd., which held such transactions liable to tax. The revision was dismissed.
What were the facts?
The assessee, M/s Commercial Autosales Pvt. Ltd., is an authorized dealer of Tata Motors. For assessment year 2005-06, the assessee purchased chassis against Form 3A and sent them to M/s CBECCO Limited, Jabalpur, for mounting bodies. Subsequently, the vehicles with mounted bodies were sold. On January 27, 2006, four dumpers were intercepted without Form 31 or 32, leading to their seizure. A security of Rs. 19,31,400, later reduced to Rs. 9,66,000, was demanded for release. Penalty proceedings under Section 15A(1)(o) of the UP Trade Tax Act were initiated, resulting in an initial penalty of Rs. 19,31,400, reduced to Rs. 4,38,400. The Tribunal dismissed the assessee's appeals, leading to the present revisions.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the Tribunal was justified in confirming the levy of penalty under Section 15A(1)(o) of the UP Trade Tax Act, despite no intention to evade tax? 2. Whether the Tribunal was justified in sustaining the penalty, given that Form-31 was produced before the seizure order and the transaction was recorded in the books of account? 3. Whether the Tribunal was justified in levying the penalty at an excessive rate? Assessee's contentions: The assessee argued that Form 31 was given but left behind due to the driver's human error. Form C was issued for body mounting, resulting in a lower Central Sales Tax rate. Transactions were recorded in books, ownership remained with the assessee, and Form 31 was submitted, indicating no intention to evade tax. Revenue's contentions: The revenue argued that mounting a body created a new commercial commodity, altering the original form of the chassis purchased against Form 3A. The assessee had not disclosed such sales in previous years and would not have disclosed them if the dumpers hadn't been intercepted. The use of Form 3A requires goods to be sold in the same form and condition, which was violated.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 15A(1)(o), Section 3AAA, Section 2(ac)
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
Reserved On: 09.11.2021 Delivered On:05.01.2022 Court No. - 1 Case :- SALES/TRADE TAX REVISION No. - 970 of 2010 Revisionist :- M/S Commercial Autosales Pvt. Ltd. Opposite Party :- Commissioner Commercial Tax U.P. Lucknow Counsel for Revisionist :- Krishna Agarwal Counsel for Opposite Party :- C.S.C. WITH Case :- SALES/TRADE TAX REVISION No. - 343 of 2013 Revisionist :- M/S Commercial Auto Sales P Ltd. Opposite Party :- Commissioner Of Commercial Tax Counsel for Revisionist :- Krishna Agrawal Counsel for Opposite Party :- C.S.C. Hon'ble Piyush Agrawal,J. 1. Heard Krishna Agarwal, learned counsel for the revisionist and Shri A.C. Tripathi, learned Standing Counsel for the opposite party. 2. These two revisions were listed together as the issue involved are interlinked and therefore, the same are being decided by the common order. SALES/TRADE TAX REVISION No. - 970 of 2010 3. The present revision has been filed against the order dated 18.09.2010 passed by Commercial Tax Tribunal, Allahabad in Second Appeal No. 120 of 2010 for the assessment year 2005-06. 4. The following questions of law have been framed in the present revision:- (i) Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances, the Tribunal was legally justified in confirming the levy of penalty U/s 15 A (1) (o) of UP Trade Tax Act in spite of the fact that there was no intention to
evade payment of tax? (ii) Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was legally justified in sustaining the penalty, inasmuch as, Form -31 has been produced before the seizure order and the transaction is recorded in the books of account of both consignee and consignor? (iii) Whether, the Tribunal was legally justified in levying the penalty at a so excessive rate? 5. Brief facts of the case are that the applicant is an authorized dealer of Tata Motors Limited and engaged in the business of sale of Tata vehicles and chassis etc. The revisionist purchases chassis against Form 3 A as prescribed under UP Trade Tax Act. In the disputed year, the applicant, after purchase of chassis against Form 3 A from Tata Motors Limited Lucknow and send the same to M/s. CBECCO Limited, Jabalpur to mount body on the said chassis. After the body was mounted on chassis, the sale were made to the respected buyers raising the bill. On 27.1.2006, 04 dumpers were intercepted by the Mobile Squad and it was found that only Bill No. 932 dated 25.1.2006 was available along with the drivers of 04 dumpers but no Form 31 or 32 was found along with the goods. The said goods were seized and security of Rs. 19,31,400/- was demanded for release of vehicles which was modified at Rs. 9,66,000/- out of which Rs. 4,00000/- were deposited in cash and for balance amount of Rs. 5,66,000/- bank guarantee was furnished for release of the goods. Thereafter the penalty proceeding under U/s 15 A (1) (o) of UP Trade Tax Act, was initiated and penalty of Rs. 19,31,400/- was imposed, which was reduced to Rs. 4,38,400/- on appeal against which cross appeals were filed before the Tribunal which were dismissed. Hence the present revision has been filed by the appellant. 6. Counsel for the revisionist submits that after purchase of chassis, the same was sent to Jabalpur for mounting the body over it and thereafter the same was coming back for which Form 31 was
given but due to human error of the Driver, the same was left at Jabalpur and was not accompanying with the goods. He further submitted that for mounting the body, Form C as contemplated under Central Sales Tax Act has been issued by the revisionist and therefore lower rate was charged by the body builder i.e. 4 %. He further submits that transactions were duly entered in the books of account, the ownership of the vehicle remained with the revisionist as clear from as Ground No. 3 as taken before the 1st appellate authority as well as the Tribunal and Form 31 was duly submitted therefore there was no intention to avoid any payment of tax. 7. Per contra, learned Standing Counsel submits that the revisionist purchases and sales chassis. Chassis were purchased against Form 3 A and thereafter before selling the chassis, the same were sent to Jabalpur for mounting body over it and thereafter the said chassis along with body was coming back, which was completely a new commercial commodity. He further submits that the assessee is an old registered dealer but in the previous year no such sale of chassis (purchased against Form 3 A) on which the bodies were got mounted, had been disclosed and in the event the dumpers in question were not intercepted, the revisionist would not have shown the sales as such, on which there was liability of tax as one of the condition for use of Form 3 A that the goods so purchased have to be sold in same form and condition but after the body was mounted, it losses its original form. Therefore, he tries to justify the initiation of penalty proceeding and prays for dismissal of the revision. 8. The court has perused the records. 9. It is not in dispute that the revisionist is an authorized dealer of Tata Motor Limited and chassis were being purchased against Form 3 A of UP Trade Tax Act. After purchase of chassis, same were sent to M/s CBECCO Limited, Jabalpur for mounting body
over it and thereafter the vehicles were coming back to the revisionist. On close scrutiny of the materials on record, it shows that the chassis, which were purchased against Form 3 A, were sent out side from the State of UP for mounting the body over it and thereafter final bills were issued to the respective customers mentioning the value of chassis as well as the body, separately. The record further reveals that while sending the chassis from the State of UP to Madhya Pradesh, temporary registration as well as transit insurance were taken in the name of the revisionist. Further the record reveals that the revisionist had issued Form C to the body manufacturer i.e. M/s CBECCO Limited, Jabalpur and on the strength of Form C lower rate of Central Sales Tax was charges @ 4% only. This only shows that the chassis were in possession of the revisionist and the same was not sold by the revisionist before body was mounted. Further before appellate authorities i.e. 1st appellate authority & Tribunal) ground no. 3 clearly mentions ownership remained with the revisionist which are quoted below:- Ground No. 3 of Appeal before the 1st appellate authority- 3. Because, the Ownership of four vehicles (Dumper) carried by challan no. 932 dated 25.1.2006 remained with the appellant purchaser. Hence there was no liability to carry form 31. Ground No. 3 before the Tribunal is quoted below:- 3. Because, the Ownership of the four vehicles (Dumper) carried by challan no. 932 dated 25.1.2006 remained with the appellant purchaser. Hence there was no liability to carry form -31. 10. The above facts are not in dispute. On bare perusal of the aforesaid, it clearly reveals that inference can be drawn that since requisite Form 3 A, as prescribed under UP Trade Tax Act and Form C as prescribed under Central Sales Tax Act, were issued with an intention to evade the tax liability. More over, when the temporary registration and the transit insurance were also in the name of the revisionist. The revisionist is an old dealer of Tata
Motors Limited and purchasing as well as selling the chassis purchased against Form 3 A but never paid any tax as contemplated under the Act, prescribed for purchase made against Form 3 A, after the body were mounted on so purchased chassis. The provisions provides that in the event any goods were purchased against Form 3 A, the respective dealer was required to sell the goods in same form and condition. As and when as the body mounted over the chassis, a new commercial commodity come into existence. Once nature of the goods, so purchased against Form 3 A, is changed, the liability of tax immediately occurs and the revisionist were liable for payment of tax. But the record reveals that the revisionist had never paid the tax, after the nature / character of the chassis were changed in the previous year. The intention of the revisionist was not to pay the tax due to the State. The chassis was not intercepted and seized. The method not to pay tax adopted by the revisionist could not be revealed and therefore, initiation and levy of penalty under section 15-A(1) (o) of the Act is justified. 11. The record further reveals that stand had been taken by the revisionist that an agreement was entered with the respective buyers and as per the agreement and on the request of the customers, after the sale of chassis, the revisionist was compeled to send the chassis for mounting the body over it and after the body was got mounted, the chassis were received back along with body mounted over it and thereafter final bills were prepared and the chassis along with the body were sold. The record further reveals that an agreement dated 10.1.2006 has been shown and one Bill C.A. No. 500776 dated 20.2.2006 was issued on which booking date of chassis was shown as 18.2.2006. Further on the agreement, the date of delivery of chassis was shown as 10.1.2006. The said fact clearly shows that the different stands have been taken by the revisionist at every stage. On the one hand, in the alleged agreement, the date of delivery has been
mentioned as 10.1.2006 but on the other hand while issuing the Bill for the vehicle, on the bill, booking date of chassis has been shown as 18.2.2006. This itself shows the intention of the revisionist for non-payment of legitimate tax due to the State. 12. In view of the aforesaid facts & circumstances, the Sales/Trade Tax Revision No. 970 of 2010 fails and is hereby dismissed. The questions of law are answered accordingly. SALES/TRADE TAX REVISION No. - 343 of 2013 13. The present revision has been filed against the judgement & order dated 20.03.2013 passed by the Commercial Tax Tribunal, Allahabad Division-1, Allahabad in Second Appeal No. 827 of 2011 for the assessment year 2005-06. 14. The present revision involves the following questions of law:- 1) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was legally justified in upholding the levy of tax under Section 3AAAA of the Act on the purchases of 16 chassis against Form 3-A under Section 3AAA when the same has been sold on the same form and condition? 2) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was legally justified in rejecting the agreements executed by the applicant with its customers which is a validly executed document and presuming the sale of Motor Vehicle instead of Chassis? 3) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was legally justified in ignoring the decision of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Vodafone as well that of the Tribunal in the case of M/s Soorajpur Kasna, Noida = -v- CCT wherein any agreement legally entered into which in effect is a part of tax planning cannot be taken as adverse? 4) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was legally justified to ignore the remand order passed by the appellate authority and direction issued therein as well as the judgement of the Rajasthan High Court in the case of Marudhara Motors Limited? 15. The brief facts of the case are that the revisionist in the disputed year, the revisionist had purchased motor vehicles and chassis against Form 3-A as the said commodity is taxable on the point of sale to the consumer under section 3AAA of the U.P. Trade Tax Act (hereinafter referred to as, 'the Act'). The goods so purchased against Form 3-A has to be sold in the same form and condition.
In the disputed year, 16 chassis were sold to the customers after body was constructed/moulded over it. The assessing authority held that the chassis were not sold in the same form & condition. Therefore, tax was levied on the same. Further, in the disputed year, the tax was also levied on spare parts, which were replaced against the warranty claimed by the respective customers, for which credit notes were received from the Company, i.e., Tata Motors Limited, the same has been affirmed upto the Tribunal. Hence, the present revision. 16. Learned counsel for the applicant submits that since the motor vehicles are taxable at the point of sale to consumer, therefore, Form 3-A was issued on the purchase of motor vehicles as well as chassis. During the normal course of business, on the request of 16 customers, the chassis were sent to Jabalpur for construction of body over it. Thereafter, after mounting of body on the said chassis, the chassis were received back along with body. Thereafter, final invoices were issued to the purchasers. He further submits that before sending chassis for mounting of body, an agreement was entered, which contemplates the responsibility of the dealer to get the chassis mounted from Jabalpur Body Builder – M/s CEBBCO, Jabalpur (MP). He further submits that under the agreement, the revisionist was compelled to perform the duty for sending the chassis and getting it back from the builder. He further submits that delivery of chassis was given to the respective buyers and the dealer has merely acted as an agent or facilitator of the said buyers for getting the body mounted on the chassis and after mounting of body on the chassis, the same was received back and final bills were issued separately mentioning the cost of chassis and the body and the amount was charged. Therefore, there is no violation in issuing Form 3-A. He further submits that the replacement of spare parts against warranty claim of the customers was done as per the agreement and warranty conditions of the Company, i.e., Tata Motors Limited, and
reimbursed of the said spare parts was made by way of credit notes. Therefore, the authorities were not justified in imposing the tax upon the applicant. 17. It is further submitted that the applicant procured the spare parts by three methods; firstly, the applicant has two godwons at Kanpur and Lucknow; secondly, certain items come directly from outside the State of Uttar Praesh; and thirdly, the applicant purchases the spare parts within the State of U.P. after due payment of tax on the same. In all the three conditions, the items/ goods were used against replacement of warranty claimed by the customers and the tax has already been paid and therefore, there was no question of any sale of the said items again and hence, the authorities were not justified in imposing tax on the spare parts replaced against warranty claimed by the customers. 18. Per contra, learned Standing Counsel submits that once the dealer issues Form 3-A for purchase of chassis, the same should have been sold in the same form and condition. Merely on the strength of agreement, the dealer cannot escape its liability for payment of tax and it is incorrect to suggest that merely the body was mounted on the chassis at the request of concerned buyers. Learned Standing Counsel further submits that the chassis does not remain as such and form and condition changes after mounting of body on it. He further points out that once the body is mounted on the chassis, it becomes at truck or bus as per the requirement of the purchaser. Chasis in question in itself, changes the character of the chassis and therefore, the authorities below were wholly correct/justified in taking the view that the goods have not been sold in same form and condition for which Form 3-A was issued. He further submits that in so far as the replacement of spare parts under warranty on the claim of the customers is concerned, the same is covered by the two judgements of this Court in Mohd. Ekram Khan & Sons Vs. CTT reported in 2004 NTN (Vol. 25) 1047/2004 UPTC 198,
which has been affirmed by the Apex Court and further, in Sales Tax Revision No. 163 of 2015 (CCT Vs. S/S Maskat Motors Pvt. Ltd.) decided by this Court on 08.12.2016. Hence, the issue involved in the present revision squarely covered by the said two judgements. Hence, the revision is liable to be dismissed. 19. The Court has perused the records. 20. Facts, as stated above, are not in dispute two issues are raised with regard to the first issue of purchases of 16 chassis made against Form 3-A, on which body was mounted and admittedly, the revisionist is liable to tax. It is undisputed that the said chassis were purchased against Form 3-A as the goods in question are taxable at the point of sale to the consumers under section 3AAA of the Act. The revisionist has stated that the chassis were handed over to the respective buyers in pursuance of agreement and on their request, the same were taken back and were sent to Jabalpur to Body Builder – M/s CEBBCO, Jabalpur (MP) for mounting of body over it. While sending the vehicles to Jabalpur, provisional registration of the chassis was taken in the name of the revisionist; not only that, even the insurance policy (transit insurance) was also taken in the name of the revisionist. On the one hand, the revision is taking the ground that the chassis have been sold to the customers, on the other hand, on his request the chassis were sent to Jabalpur for mounting of body over it and on the contrary, while sending the chassis to Jabalpur, transit insurance is taken in the name of the revisionist itself. Further, after mounting of body over the chassis, the complete vehicle was coming back, Form – 31 of the revisionist has been used, which itself shows that ownership of the chassis remained with the revisionist. Had it been the case that the delivery of chassis was given to the customers before mounting of body parts, then Form 32 as prescribed under the Trade Tax Act would have been used by the purchaser and not by seller. This itself shows that a contradictory stand has been taken by the revisionist. More
precisely, on the one hand, the stand taken that the delivery has been given to the respective purchasers before mounting of body on it and on the contrary, while the goods are coming back to the State of Uttar Pradesh, Form – 31 of the revisionist has been used. Insurance policy (transit insurance) and provisional registration was also in the name of the revisionist. The record further reveals that at Annexure No. 5 some agreements were being annexed, which are dated 10.01.2006, against which the sale invoices have been raised, one invoice no. CA 500779 dated 20.02.2006; wherein, booking date has been mentioned as 18.02.2006. Therefore, the agreement dated 10.01.2006 cannot, by any stretch of imagination, be treated to be connected with the said sale. In the agreement, delivery date has been mentioned as 10.01.2006 and while issuing common invoice for chassis and body was arrived. The agreement and the invoices are of no help to the revisionist. 21. Further, the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Kumar Motors Vs. Commissioner Commercial Tax reported in 2007 (13) NTN 132 has held that if the goods purchased against Form 3-A are not sold in the same form and condition, the sales tax under section 3AAA is liable to be imposed. 22. If the goods are purchased against Form 3-A, the same are required to be sold in the same form and condition. If the goods, so purchased against Form 3-A, were even altered in the existing product, it will take into sweep of a new product. The case in hand, admittedly, the body was mounted on the chassis and thereafter, final bill was issued, which itself is a violation of the Form 3-A. The benefit of Form 3-A can be availed from the payment of purchase documents only in the event the terms & conditions thereon are satisfied. Necessary condition is required to be satisfied. More precisely, if the dealer wants a exemption against purchases on Form 3-A, it must sell the goods so purchased in the same form & condition. In other words, the
requirement of the law is that the goods once sold to the registered dealer, must be sold in the same form and condition in which it had purchased the goods. 23. In the case in hand, it is admitted by the revisionist that final bill was issued after the body was mounted on the chassis, which were purchased against Form 3-A. Therefore, there is no doubt that the sale of chassis with mounted body made by the revisionist would be selling a product, which is in different condition from the chassis or the body and thus, the same would be liable to be purchase tax under section 3AAA of the Act. 24. So far as the second issue raised by the counsel for the revisionist that the spare parts, replaced against the warranty claimed of the customers, is concerned, the same were procured from three points; firstly, from two godwons at Kanpur and Lucknow; secondly, from outside the State of Uttar Praesh; and thirdly, from within the State of U.P. after due payment of tax on the same. When a pointed query was put as to whether such grounds were taken in the memo of appeal filed before the Tribunal (copy of which has been annexed as Annexure No. 4), the answering was only that the same can be proved by the requisite documents and material on record, but on perusal of the grounds of appeal, no specific ground to the said submission was raised and therefore, the said submission cannot be permitted to be raised in the revisioinal jurisdiction, for the first time. Moreover, the issue with regard to claim of replacement of warranty against the warranty of the customers, for which credit note has been received from the Company, is res integra as this Court as well as the Apex Court have decided the issue against the assessee in the case of Mohd. Ekram Khan & Sons (supra) and S/S Maskat Motors Pvt. Ltd (supra). 25. This court in the case of Maskat Motros Pvt. Ltd. (supra), in paragraph nos. 9 & 38 held as under:-
“8. Thus, the crux of submissions of the respondent-assessee are as under: i. The spare parts were purchased by the assessee from the manufacturer against form-C. ii. The relationship of seller (respondent-assessee) and purchaser (hereinafter referred to as the 'consumer') ceases after the vehicles are sold. iii. Warranty has been offered by M/s. Tata Motors Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as the 'manufacturer') to the consumer in respect to its product namely motor vehicles, under which, parts fitted in the vehicle are replaced, if claimed by a consumer and found defective during warranty period. iv. Respondent-assessee is an intermediary between the manufacturer and the consumer. For the purposes of replacement of parts, the respondent-assessee is a service provider. v. Respondent-assessee replaces defective parts of vehicles of consumer from his own stock. vi. The cost of spare parts given to consumer under the warranty offered by the manufacturer to the consumer, is reimbursed by the manufacturer to the respondent assessee through credit notes which is a commercial document issued by the manufacturer to the respondent-assessee for repayment of money or to set off a balance due, to eliminate the amount which the buyer has to pay. vii. The transaction is not a 'sale' under Section 2(ac) of the Act. …........ 38. The provision of Section 2(ac) of the U.P. Act, facts of the case and the judgments of Hon'ble Supreme Court as discussed above, leaves no manner of doubt that the respondent-assessee has sold spare parts for valuable consideration attracting liability to tax under the U.P. Act. Consequently, the question of law framed in para 9 above is answered in affirmative i.e. in favour of the revisionist and against the assessee.” 26. In view of the aforesaid facts & circumstances of the case, Sales/Trade Tax Revision No. 343 of 2013 fails and the same is hereby dismissed. 27. The questions of law are answered. accordingly. Both the Sales/Trade Tax Revision No. 970 of 2010 and Sales/Trade Tax Revision No. 343 of 2013 are dismissed. Order Date :-05/01/2022 Amit Mishra/Rahul Dwivedi
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- M/S Sun Shine Metal Works vs. State Of U.P And AnotherAllahabad · 4 Nov 2026
- M/S Bansal Sanitary Store vs. State Of U.P. And 2 OthersAllahabad · 4 Nov 2026
- M/S Princess Girls Collection vs. State Of U.P. And AnotherAllahabad · 4 Nov 2026
- Prabhat Kumar vs. The State Of BiharPatna · 4 Nov 2026
- Siddharth Barai (Prop- Siddharth Design Studio) vs. The Superintendent CGST And Central Excise, Balangir RangeOrissa · 4 Nov 2026