M/S PRAG OIL MILLS LIMITED ALIGARH vs. THE COMMISSIONER TRADE TAX U.P. LUCKNOW

PDF · subscribers
STRE/2194/2007HC AllahabadUPHC01024535200706 May 20193 pages
AI SummaryAllowed

What did the High Court hold?

The Tribunal held that the applicant had filed a revised return showing the sale of mustard oil and had deposited the tax along with interest before the assessment order was passed. Section 15-A(1)(c) of the Act is attracted only if a person has concealed particulars of their turnover or deliberately furnished inaccurate particulars. Since the applicant filed a revised return which was accepted by the Assessing Authority, and the sale of mustard oil was duly shown in the books of account, it could not be said that the applicant had violated the provisions of Section 15-A(1)(c). Therefore, the levy of penalty was not justified. The questions of law were answered in favour of the revisionist and against the Revenue. The revision was allowed, and the penalty was set aside.

What were the facts?

M/s Prag Oil Mills Limited (the applicant) is engaged in the manufacture and sale of edible oil. The applicant filed its monthly returns and deposited taxes. The assessing authority initiated penalty proceedings under Section 15-A(1)(c) of the U.P. Sales Tax Act, alleging that revised returns for mustard oil sales amounting to Rs. 15,53,515/- were filed, and the tax was neither shown in monthly returns nor deposited. The applicant contended that these sales were made through a commission agent, whose responsibility it was to deposit the tax. The applicant also stated that upon discovering the discrepancy, tax and interest were deposited before the assessment order was passed. The Assessing Authority imposed a penalty of Rs. 39,000/-. The Deputy Commissioner Appeals quashed this penalty, finding no concealment or deliberate furnishing of inaccurate particulars. The Trade Tax Tribunal, however, restored the penalty order, leading to the present revision.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the Trade Tax Tribunal was legally justified in restoring the penalty order under Section 15-A(1)(c) of the Act solely based on a difference in turnover between books and returns, which was explained and accepted in the assessment order? 2. Whether the Trade Tax Tribunal was legally justified in setting aside the first appellate authority's order without reversing its finding that there was no concealment or deliberate furnishing of inaccurate particulars of turnover? 3. Whether the Tribunal was justified in restoring the penalty without establishing mens rea, given that penalty proceedings are quasi-criminal in nature? 4. Whether the Tribunal was legally justified in imposing the penalty under Section 15-A(1)(c) against judicial pronouncements of the High Court? Assessee's arguments: The applicant argued that tax and interest were deposited along with a revised return, which was accepted by the Assessing Authority. Therefore, there was no concealment or deliberate furnishing of inaccurate particulars to attract penalty. The applicant relied on the fact that the discrepancy was rectified before penalty proceedings were initiated. Revenue's arguments: The learned Standing Counsel supported the impugned order passed by the Tribunal.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

15-A(1)(c)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Court No. - 39 Case :- SALES/TRADE TAX REVISION No. - 2194 of 2007 Applicant :- M/S Prag Oil Mills Limited Aligarh Opposite Party :- The Commissioner Trade Tax U.P. Lucknow Counsel for Applicant :- N.R. Kumar,Vishwjeet Counsel for Opposite Party :- S.C. Hon'ble Piyush Agrawal,J. This revision has been filed against the order dated 8.6.2007 by which the penalty under Section 15-A(1)(c) of Sales Tax Act was imposed wherein following questions of law have been framed :- i) Whether on the facts and circumstances of the instant case the Member Tribunal Trade Tax was legally justified to restore the penalty order passed by the assessing officer under Section 15-A(1)(c) of the Act merely on the basis of difference in the turnover as per books and returns which was explained and accepted by the assessing officer in the assessment order? ii) Whether on the facts and circumstances of the instant case the Trade Tax Tribunal was legally justified to set aside the order of first Appellate authority without reversing the finding of Ist Appellate authority who quashed the penalty imposed under Section 15-A(1)(c) of the Act on the ground that there was no concealment of turnover and there is no deliberate furnishing of the inaccurate particulars of turnover? iii) Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case the Tribunal was justified to restore the penalty imposed by the Assessing officer without establishing mensrea on the part of the applicant which is a necessary ingredient, as the penalty proceedings are quasi criminal in nature? iv) Whether on the facts and circumstances of the instant case the Tribunal was legally justified to impose the penalty under Section 15-A(1)(c) of the Act, against the judicial pronouncements of this Hon'ble Court? The applicant being a limited company incorporated under Indian Company Act and engaged in the business of manufacture and sale of all kinds of edible oil. The applicant is registered under U.P. Sales Tax Act (as it then was). The applicant in its normal course of business selling the goods directly to the dealer as well as through its commission agent within the state of U.P. and to ex-U.P. selling Commission Agents. The Commission Agents were selling the goods and accordingly depositing the due taxes. Therefore, there was no liability of the applicant to deposit the tax. The applicant filed its monthly return and accordingly, depositing the tax within the time prescribed under the Act. The assessing authority while framing the assessment order, has

made a best assessment on the ground that the applicant has filed revise return of the sale of mustard oil and the same was neither shown in the monthly return nor the tax was deposited along with the same. On the basis of said finding, the penalty proceeding under Section 15-A(1)(c) of the U.P. Sales Tax Act was initiated against the applicant. In reply to the notice for initiation of penalty proceedings the applicant submitted that the mustard oil to the tune of Rs. 15,53,515/- were sent to the Commission Selling Agent and it was his responsibility for depositing the tax due on it. Therefore, neither the tax could be deposited nor was shown in the monthly return. It was further stated that as soon as the said discrepancy was found even before passing of the Assessment order, tax along with interest was deposited. Therefore, there was no mens-rea on the part of the revisionist for concealing the particular of his turnover or has deliberately furnished inaccurate particulars of such turnover and prayed for dropping of the penalty proceedings. The Assessing Authority on 9.6.1999, has passed the penalty order imposing the penalty of Rs. 39,000/-. The said order was assailed before Deputy Commissioner Appeals, Aligarh who by its order dated 23rd February, 2001, had quashed the penalty order on the ground that the revisionist has shown the turnover of Rs. 15,53,515/- in its books of account as well as the tax and interest had also been deposited. Therefore, the condition as prescribed under Section 15-A(1)(c) is not attracted. The revenue assailed the order before Trade Tax Tribunal, Aligarh, who vide impugned order, has restored the penalty order. Feeling aggrieved by the impugned order, the present revision has been filed by the applicant. Heard Mr. Vishwjeet, learned counsel for the applicant and learned Standing Counsel for the respondent. It was argued on behalf of the revisionist that prior to passing of the original assessment order, tax along with interest was duly deposited and, moreover, revise return was also filed which has been accepted by the Assessing Authority while passing the assessment order. Therefore, there was no concealment of particular of his turnover or neither deliberately furnishing inaccurate particulars

turnover or neither deliberately furnishing inaccurate particulars of his turnover by the applicant to attract levy of penalty under the Act. On the contrary, the learned Standing Counsel has supported the order impugned. The perusal of record reveals that the applicant has submitted its revise return duly showing the sale of mustard oil of Rs. 15,53,515/- and also deposited the tax along with interest. Section 15-A(1)(c) of the Act prescribed as under:- "has concealed the particulars of his turnover or has deliberately furnished inaccurate particulars of such turnover." Bare perusal of above section shows that if any revisionist has concealed the particulars of his turnover or has furnished inaccurate particulars of such turnover then only penalty can be imposed under the act. The case in hand, the revisionist has not only filed the revise return, but, also has deposited the tax along with interest before passing of the original assessment order or any penalty proceedings has been initiated against the revisionist. Once the revisionist has submitted the revise return which has been accepted by the Assessing Authority then it cannot be said that the revisionist had violated the provision of Section 15- A(1)(c) of the Act. Moreover, the revisionist has produced its books of account in which the sale of mustard oil value of Rs. 15,53,513/- was duly shown, therefore, levy of penalty under the said provision is not justified and is set aside. In view of the matter, the question of law is answered, accordingly, in favour of the revisionist and against the Revenue. The revision is allowed. Order Date :- 7.5.2019 SY

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →