SMT. SUSHILA KUMARI & ORS vs. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX

PDF · subscribers
CWP/7406/1991HC Punjab & HaryanaPHHC01020440199103 May 2012Author: MR. JUSTICE AJAY KUMAR MITTAL,MR. JUSTICE GURMEET SINGH SANDHAWALIA6 pages
AI SummaryAllowed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court allowed the writ petition and set aside the order of the Commissioner of Income Tax. The Court found that the petitioners had fulfilled the requirements for waiver under Section 273A of the Act. The enhanced compensation was received in February 1990 for assessment years 1987-88 and 1988-89. The petitioners had paid tax by way of self-assessment immediately upon receipt and made a true and full disclosure of income, as no additions were made. The Court noted that the amounts of interest and penalties were meagre, and it could not be said that the assessee had not made satisfactory arrangements for payment. The grounds for rejection by the Commissioner – lack of verification of full and true disclosure and failure to make satisfactory payment arrangements – were found to be contrary to the record. The Court, considering the substantial fulfillment of Section 273A conditions and the meagre quantum, allowed the applications for waiver, thereby setting aside the Commissioner's order. The applications filed by the petitioners under Section 273A were allowed.

What were the facts?

The petitioners, Smt. Sushila Kumari and others, filed a writ petition challenging an order dated 20.3.1991 passed by the Commissioner of Income Tax, Rohtak, under Section 273A of the Income Tax Act, 1961. Their agricultural land was acquired in 1985, and compensation was enhanced by the District Judge on 7.8.1989. The enhanced compensation was received in February 1990. Subsequently, returns were filed. The Assessing Officer proposed interest for late filing under Section 139(8) and penalties under Sections 271(1)(a) and 273(1)(b) for assessment years 1987-88 and 1988-89. The petitioners applied for waiver of interest and penalties under Section 273A, which was dismissed by the Commissioner.

What were the issues?

1. Whether interest under Section 139(8) and Section 217 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, and penalties under Section 271(1)(a) and Section 273(1)(b) of the Act should be waived when the enhanced compensation and interest thereon were received and became known only after the due date for filing returns for the relevant assessment years. Assessee's contention: The petitioners argued that since they were unaware of the enhanced compensation and interest amounts at the time of filing returns for the earlier years, the charging of interest and imposition of penalties were unjustified. They relied on the Division Bench judgment in Shanti Sarup Sharma v. Commissioner of Income Tax and another (1999) 237 ITR 376, which held that interest under Sections 139(8) and 217 should be waived if compensation and interest are received on a subsequent date not ascertained at the return filing due date. They also contended that the amounts of interest and penalties were meagre, indicating no intention to evade tax. Revenue's contention: The judgment does not record any specific arguments made by the revenue.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 139(8),Section 271(1)(a),Section 273(1)(b),Section 273A,Section 217,Section 143(1),Section 140A

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH Date of decision: 03.05.2012 Smt.Sushila Kumari and others -----Petitioners Vs. Commissioner of Income Tax, Rohtak (Haryana) ----Respondent CORAM:- HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AJAY KUMAR MITTAL HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE GURMEET SINGH SANDHAWALIA Present:- Mr. Pankaj Jain, Mr. D.K.Goyal, and Mr. Rishabh Kapoor, Advocates for the petitioners. Mr. Yogesh Putney, Standing Counsel for the revenue. Ajay Kumar Mittal,J. 1. The petitioners through the present petition filed under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution of India have impugned the order dated 20.3.1991, Annexure P.8 passed by the Commissioner of Income Tax, Rohtak – respondent on a petition filed by them under Section 273A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (in short, “the Act”). 2. Briefly, the facts as narrated in the petition may be noticed. Agricultural land of the petitioners was acquired by the Haryana Urban Development Authority in the year 1985. The petitioners made a reference for enhancement of compensation before the District Judge under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act,1894. The amount of compensation was enhanced on 7.8.1989 by the District Judge. The said amount was received by the petitioners in

February 1990. Thereafter, the petitioners filed their return. While framing the assessment under section 143(1) of the Act, the Assessing Officer proposed to issue notice to levy interest for late filing of the return under section 139(8) of the Act and for imposition of penalty under Section 271(1)(a) and 273(1) (b) of the Act as per assessment orders in respect of petitioner No.1 for the assessment years 1987-88 and 1988-89 vide Annexures P.1 and P.2 respectively. Similar orders were passed in respect of other petitioners. The Assessing Officer imposed penalty under section 271(1) (a) amounting to ` 2852/-, ` 966/- and under Section 273(1) (b) of the Act amounting to ` 342/-, ` 342/-. Similar amounts of penalty have been imposed on the other petitioners. The petitioners moved an application before the respondent under Section 273A of the Act for waiver of interest charged under sections 217 and 139(8) of the Act and for penalty proceedings under sections 271(1) (a) and 273(1) (b) of the Act. The respondent dismissed the application vide order impugned herein (Annexure P.8). Hence the present petition by the petitioners. 3. Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the enhanced compensation and interest thereon was received and it was on that basis that the returns were filed for the earlier years and since the assessees had not known the amount of enhanced compensation and the interest in those years, charging of interest under section 139 (8) and 217 of the Act and penalties imposable under Section 271(1) (a) and 273 (1) (b) of the Act should have been waived. He placed

reliance upon a Division Bench judgment of this Court in Shanti Sarup Sharma v. Commissioner of Income Tax and another, (1999) 237 ITR 376 to submit that the compensation and interest received from the Government on a subsequent date which was not ascertained at the time of due date for filing of the return for a particular assessment year, it was held that interest under sections 139(8) and 217 of the Act was liable to be waived. Further, equally the penalties under Sections 271(1)(a) and 273 of the Act for not filing the returns when it was not known to the assessee that the amount of enhanced compensation and the interest received would make them liable to file the return and pay tax, there was no justification for the same. Learned counsel for the assessee further submitted that the amount of interest and penalties levied which is sought to be waived is ` 2852/-, ` 966/-, ` 342/- and ` 342/-, Annexures P.4 to P7 respectively which is very meagre and thus, it could not be held that there was any intention to evade payment of tax. 4. After hearing learned counsel for the parties and perusing the record, we find that the writ petition deserves to succeed. 5. A Division Bench of this Court while considering the provisions relating to Section 18B of the Wealth Tax Act, 1957 which are pari materia to those in Section 273A of the Act, in Parkash Devi (Smt.) v. CWT (1983) 141 ITR 122, held that the following five conditions are required to be fulfilled:- “1) that the returns were filed by the petitioner prior to the issuance of a notice to her under sub-section (2) of section 14 of the Act;

2) that these were filed voluntarily and in good faith; 3) that the petitioner had made full and true disclosure of her net wealth; 4) that she had cooperated in the inquiry relating to the assessment of her net wealth; and 5) that she had paid or made satisfactory arrangements for the payment of the tax or interest payable in consequence of an order passed under the Act in respect of the relevant assessment years.” 6. Further, this Court while delving into the scope of Section 273A of the Act in Shanti Sarup Sharma's case (supra) held as under:- “Section 273A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, empowers the Commissioner to reduce or waive interest and penalty. The power under Section 273A is discretionary. The Commissioner is given the discretion, when the requisite conditions envisaged by that section are satisfied, that he may waive or reduce the penalty or the interest imposable under the Act. However, the exercise of discretion cannot be either arbitrary or capricious and has to be judicious and objective. Section 273A does not confer absolute discretion upon the Commissioner to pass any order which he pleases to make. He is required to consider the application on the merits.” 7. Adjudicating the issue in favour of the assessee, it was observed that the petitioner therein had received compensation in February 1991 and, therefore, there was no justification in charging interest for the earlier period. 8. The respondent had rejected the petition for waiver of interest and penalty vide Annexure P.8 primarily on the grounds that

there was no verification regarding full and true disclosure made by the assessee and the assessee had not paid or made satisfactory arrangements for the payment of interest etc. 9. Adverting to the factual matrix in the present case, the assessee-petitioner had received enhanced compensation in February 1990 relating to assessment years 1987-88 and 1988-89. As per assessment orders dated 21.5.1990, Annexures P.1 and P.2 appended alongwith the petition, the petitioners had paid the tax by way of self assessment under Section 140A of the Act immediately and had made true and full disclosure of their income as no addition was made to their declared income. The assessee having paid the tax under self assessment and had filed the application for waiver of interest and penalty especially when the amount of interest and penalty was meagre, it cannot be said that the assessee had not made satisfactory arrangements for payment of interest etc. Thus, both the grounds of rejection taken by the respondent are contrary to the record and cannot be sustained. 10. In such circumstances, ordinarily we would have referred the matter back to the respondent after setting aside order Annexure P.8, for passing order afresh in accordance with law. However, keeping in view that the quantum of penalties and interest is not very substantial and we have arrived at the conclusion that the assessee fulfilled the requirements as envisaged under Section 273A of the Act, we allow this writ petition and set aside order Annexure P.8. Consequently, in the peculiar facts and circumstances of this case,

the applications filed by the petitioners before the respondent under Section 273A of the Act are allowed. There shall, however, be no order as to costs.

(Ajay Kumar Mittal) Judge May 03, 2012 (Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia) 'gs' Judge

More judgments on Section 139(8)

All 71 judgments and leading authorities on Section 139(8) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →