THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX AND ANOTHER vs. M/S METRO and METRO

PDF · subscribers
IAPL/115/2010HC AllahabadUPHC01164321201011 March 20183 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The Tribunal held that the questions of law were answered in favour of the assessee and against the department. The Tribunal found that the AO's order and the Tribunal's own order had discussed each aspect of the matter. The AO had taken into account that the assessee was exporting shoes and that fluctuations in accounts were due to exchange rates. On other counts, such as travelling expenses, there was a complete discussion, and the expenses were found to be justified. The Tribunal explicitly stated that after examining the entire record, it found nothing erroneous in the AO's order and no prejudice caused to the revenue. The Tribunal relied on the Supreme Court decision in Malabar Industries Company Limited Vs. CIT to conclude that the revisional order passed by the CIT was not valid. The Tribunal had examined each head questioned by the CIT, including the difference in pairs of footwear manufactured, travelling expenses, and health insurance expenses of the partner, and concluded that the AO had made no error. Therefore, the Tribunal restored the assessment order. The appeal was dismissed.

What were the facts?

The Commissioner of Income Tax (CIT) filed an appeal under Section 260-A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, against an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) dated October 16, 2009. The ITAT had set aside an order passed by the CIT under Section 263 of the Act for the assessment year 2004-05. The CIT's order under Section 263 had revised the assessment order passed by the Assessing Officer (AO). The appeal challenges the ITAT's decision to restore the AO's assessment order, arguing that the AO's assessment was erroneous and prejudicial to the revenue's interest. The dispute concerns several grounds raised by the CIT, including discrepancies in export incentives, consumption of raw materials, foreign travel expenses, and health insurance expenses of a partner.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the CIT rightly invoked the statutory provisions of Section 263 of the Act, as the assessment made by the AO was not only erroneous but also prejudicial to the interest of the Revenue? 2. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal is justified in law in setting aside the order passed u/s 263 of the Act by the CIT and restoring the assessment order by completely overlooking the reasons recorded in the order passed u/s 263 of the Act? Assessee's Arguments: The assessee contended that the AO's order was not erroneous nor prejudicial to the interest of the revenue. The Tribunal, after examining the entire record, found that the AO had discussed each aspect of the matter, including fluctuations in export incentives due to exchange rates, travelling expenses, and other counts, and found them justified. The Tribunal relied on the decision in Malabar Industries Company Limited Vs. CIT (2000) 243 ITR 83 (SC) to hold that the revisional order passed by the CIT was not valid. Revenue's Arguments: The department argued that the Tribunal wrongly set aside the CIT's order under Section 263 because the CIT had raised four grounds that were not adequately explained by the AO's order or the Tribunal's decision. These grounds pertained to a decrease in export incentives percentage, a discrepancy in the number of shoe pairs manufactured versus sole/insole consumed, an inquiry into foreign currency purchase for travel expenses at the end of the financial year, and the allowability of health insurance expenses for a partner as a business expenditure.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 260-A,Section 263

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Cited by 4 judgments on BharatTax

See all citing judgments →

Counted from the text of the judgments hosted here. Most recent first.

Court No. - 35 Case :- INCOME TAX APPEAL No. - 115 of 2010 Appellant :- The Commissioner Of Income Tax And Another Respondent :- M/S Metro & Metro Counsel for Appellant :- S.S.C. I.T.,Gaurav Mahajan Counsel for Respondent :- R.R. Agarwal,Rishi Raj Kapoor Hon'ble Bharati Sapru,J. Hon'ble Neeraj Tiwari,J. Heard Shri Gaurav Mahajan, learned counsel for the appellant and Shri R.R. Kapoor, learned counsel for the respondent-assessee. This appeal under Section 260-A of the Income Tax, 1961(hereinafter referred to as the 'Act') has been filed by the department against the order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal dated 16.10.2009 for the assessment year 2004-05. The questions of law sought to be answered are as hereunder: "(1) Whether the CIT rightly invoked the statutory provisions of Section 263 of the Act as the assessment so made by the A.O. was not only erroneous but also pre-judicial to the interest of the Revenue within the meaning of the provisions of Section 263 of the Act? (2) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal is justified in law in setting aside the order passed u/s 263 of the Act by the CIT and restoring the assessment order by completely overlooking the reasons recorded in the order passed u/s 263 of the Act?" Shri Gaurav Mahajan, learned counsel for the department has sought to argue that the Tribunal has wrongly set aside the order passed by the CIT under Section 263 of the Act because four grounds were raised by the CIT, which have not been explained by the department by the A.O.'s order and by the Tribunal. The grounds reads as hereunder" "(i) From the records, it is seen that the assesse had disclosed export incentive in the form of duty draw back amounting to Rs.1,31,15,713/- on

total export turnover of Rs.52,93,21,557/-, which in terms of percentage works out to 2.47%. In the preceding year total export incentive in the from of draw back was shown at Rs.2,76,41,554/- on total export turnover of Rs.47,47,16,835/- i.e. 5.82 per cent. The decreases in percentage of export incentive in comparison to preceding year has not been inquired into by the A.O. (ii) As the quantitative details of stock enclosed with the 3CD report filed along with the return of income it is seen that total number of pairs manufactured were shown at 793975 as against total number of pairs of sole/insole consumed at 961984. Thus, there remains a difference of 168009 pairs manufactured from the sole/insole consumed and the consumption of sole/insole has been claimed at much higher figure than the pairs manufactured. This has not been inquired into the Asseessing Officer. (iii) An expenditure of Rs.2,11,896/- was claimed on 27.3.2004 for purcahse of foreign currency in respect of travelling of one of the partner of the firm Mr. Ajit N. Kaisi. The AO has not made any inquiry about the consumption of foreign exchange in the year under consideration particularly when the foreign currency was purcahsed at the fag end of the financial year. (iv) From the details of the expenses in respect of Germany office, it is seen that the assessee firm has claimed expenditure in respect of health insurance of one of the partner, namely, Mr. Ajit N. Kaisi. This being a personal expenditure of the partner is not allowable in the hands of the firm?" However, upon a joint reading of the A.O's order and the Tribunal's order we find that each and every aspect of the matter was discussed and the A.O. has taken into account the fact that the assessee was exporting shoes and the fluctuations, if any, in its accounts were due to fluctuating rates of exchange. on other counts also like travelling expenses etc., there is a complete discussion and expenses made by the assessee found to be justified. The Tribunal while discussing the matter at length has recorded that after examining the entire record he found that there was nothing erroneous in the order passed by the A.O. and also that no prejudiced has been caused to the revenue. The Tribunal, therefore, while relying on a

decision of the Apex Court in the case of Malabar Industries Company Limited Vs. CIT reported in (2000) 243 ITR 83(SC) has come to the conclusion that in the facts of the present case it could not be said that the revisional order passed by the CIT was valid and therefore, he restored the order of assessment dated 29.09.2006. The Tribunal as has been said earlier has examined each and every head as questioned by the Commissioner and has answered in respect of every issues raised by him whether it was a question of difference of pairs of footwears manufactured during the year or whether it was the travelling expenses of the partner or whether it was the health expenses and insurance expenses of the partner of the firm, has come to the conclusion that A.O. had made no error in passing the orders on these issues. There is no quarrel with the settled law that it is always open to the CIT under the provisions of Section 263 of the Act to make a detailed inquiries with regard to any issue that may seem doubtful, but while passing the order under Section 263 of the Act he has to make a clear and firm decision that the order passed by the A.O. is either erroneous or to be prejudicial to the interest of the revenue. Neither has been found in the present. In view of above, the questions of law are answered in favour of the assessee and against the department. The appeal is accordingly dismissed. Order Date :- 12.3.2018 pks

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →