DR. GOPAL DASS AGARWAL vs. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX

PDF · subscribers
IAPL/138/2018HC AllahabadUPHC01207447201804 December 20183 pages
AI SummaryAllowed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the Tribunal possesses an inherent power of procedural review to recall its orders, especially when passed in violation of the principles of natural justice or by fraud. This inherent power is distinct from the power of substantive review or rectification. Furthermore, the Court found that Rule 25 of the Income Tax (Appellate Tribunal) Rules, 1963, explicitly provides for the setting aside of an ex-parte order and restoration of an appeal if the respondent appears afterwards and satisfies the Tribunal that there was sufficient cause for non-appearance. Therefore, the Tribunal was not justified in rejecting the assessee's recall applications solely on the ground of lacking review power. The impugned orders of the ITAT were set aside, and the matters were remanded to the ITAT for reconsideration of the assessee's applications for recall of the judgments dated 23.10.2017. The ITAT was also directed to consider whether any adjournment application was moved and considered before the final order was pronounced. The appeals were allowed with no order as to costs.

What were the facts?

The assessee, Dr. Gopal Dass Agarwal, filed two appeals before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) against orders of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) for assessment years 2005-06 and 2011-12. The Revenue had filed appeals before the ITAT, which were decided ex-parte on 23.10.2017 against the assessee. The assessee subsequently filed applications for recall of these orders, contending that adjournment applications on personal grounds of the counsel, filed on 10.10.2017, were not considered. The ITAT rejected these recall applications on 18.06.2018, holding that it lacked the power to review its orders and that the orders did not require rectification. The assessee then filed appeals before the High Court against the ITAT's rejection orders.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the Tribunal has the power to recall an order passed by it in violation of the principles of natural justice, even if there is no specific power of review vested in it? 2. Whether Rule 25 of the Income Tax (Appellate Tribunal) Rules, 1963, confers a statutory power on the Tribunal to set aside an ex-parte order and restore an appeal if the respondent satisfies the Tribunal that there was sufficient cause for non-appearance? Assessee's Contentions: The assessee argued that the ITAT's orders were passed without proper opportunity of hearing, as adjournment applications were not considered. They contended that the ITAT has an inherent power to recall orders passed in violation of natural justice, and that Rule 25 of the ITAT Rules provides a statutory basis for setting aside ex-parte orders. The assessee relied on the principle that quasi-judicial authorities possess inherent procedural review powers. Revenue's Contentions: The revenue argued that the Tribunal has no power to review its orders, and that the orders did not require rectification. The judgment does not explicitly record the revenue's arguments regarding Rule 25 or natural justice.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Rule 25

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

A.F.R. Court No. - 29 Case :- INCOME TAX APPEAL No. - 138 of 2018 Appellant :- Dr. Gopal Dass Agarwal Respondent :- Commissioner Of Income Tax Counsel for Appellant :- Shambhu Chopra Counsel for Respondent :- S.S.C.,Manu Ghildyal,Piyush Agrawal With Case :- INCOME TAX APPEAL No. - 139 of 2018 Appellant :- Dr. Gopal Dass Agarwal Respondent :- Commissioner Of Income Tax Counsel for Appellant :- Shambhu Chopra Counsel for Respondent :- S.S.C.,Manu Ghildyal,Piyush Agrawal Hon'ble Pankaj Mithal, J. Hon'ble Pankaj Bhatia, J. Heard Sri Shambhu Chopra, learned counsel for the appellant and Sri Manu Ghildyal, learned counsel for the respondents. Both the aforesaid appeals arise out of a common dispute, therefore, are being decided together by this common order. The appellant has preferred these appeals against the orders of the tribunal dated 18.6.2018 by which the applications for recall of the order dated 23.10.2017 have been rejected. The facts of the case reveal that against the order of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), Meerut pertaining to the assessment years 2005-06 & 2011-12., the Revenue had preferred appeals before the Tribunal. The appeals were decided on 18.6.2018 against the assessee. The assessee moved applications for recall of the above orders on the ground that it had moved applications on 10.10.2017 for adjournment of the appeals on the personal ground of the counsel, but without considering the said applications, the appeals were heard and the judgment was delivered on 23.10.2017. Therefore, the orders were passed without proper opportunity of hearing to the assessee and are liable to be recalled. The Tribunal has rejected the above applications on the

ground that the order of the Tribunal does not require any rectification and there is no power of review vested in the Tribunal. The moot question which raised for consideration is whether the Tribunal is divested of the power to recall an order passed by it in violation of the principles of natural justice, if so established. The power of rectification and the power of substantive review are two different things distinct from procedural review which encompasses the power to recall an order. The power of procedural review to recall an order is inherent in every authority which exercises quasi judicial jurisdiction. Therefore, even if there is no specific power of review vested in the Tribunal, it has inherent power to consider the application for recall of an order passed by it if it is established that it has been passed in violation of the principles of natural justice or by playing fraud upon it. This apart, Rule 25 of the Income Tax (Appellate Tribunal) Rules, 1963 provides for the hearing of the appeal ex- parte for default of the respondents. It lays down that in an appeal where the appellant appears and the respondents does not appear when the appeal is taken up for hearing, the Tribunal may dispose of the appeal on merits after hearing the appellants. It further provides that where the appeal has been disposed of in the above manner and the respondents appears afterwards and satisfies the Tribunal that there was sufficient cause for his non appearance, the Tribunal shall set aside the order and restore the appeal for hearing on merits. The aforesaid Rule 25 is reproduced herein below :- "25. Hearing of appeal ex parte for default by the respondent.- Where, on the day fixed for hearing or any other day to which the hearing may be adjourned, the appellant appears and the respondent does not appear in person or through an authorised representative and the appeal is called on for hearing, the Tribunal may dispose of the appeal on merits after hearing the appellant : Provided that where an appeal has been disposed of as provided above and the respondent appears afterwards and satisfies the Tribunal that there was sufficient cause for his non-appearance when the appeal was called on for hearing, the Tribunal shall make an order setting aside the ex-parte order and restore the appeal." In view of the above Rule, it is implicit that the Tribunal has statutory power to recall its order if it is satisfied that

the respondent has failed to appear before it for sufficient cause, at the time of hearing and to restore the appeal. Thus, it cannot be said that the Tribunal has no authority of law to consider the application of the assessee for recall of an order by which the appeal was decided ex- parte. In view of the above, the Tribunal is not justified in rejecting the applications of the appellant-assessee on the ground that it has no power to review the order already passed by it. Accordingly, we answer the above question in favour of the appellant-assessee and holds that the Tribunal has inherent power of procedural review as has also been conferred upon it under Rule 25 of the Income Tax (Appellate Tribunal) Rules, 1963. The impugned orders dated 18.6.2018 for the assessment years 2005-06 and 2011-12 are hereby set aside and the matters are remanded to the Tribunal for reconsideration of the applications of the appellant- assessee (wrongly filed by mentioning Rule 234-A of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal Rules, 1963 instead of Rule 25) for recall of the judgments and orders dated 23.10.2017. It is also pertinent to mention that the Tribunal in considering the above applications afresh would also consider, if any adjournment application as stated by the appellant-assessee was moved and was considered before pronouncing the final order. The appeals are accordingly allowed with no order as to costs. Order Date :- 5.12.2018 Hasnain

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →