SRI. VIJAY MALLYA,UNITED KINGDOM vs. DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME-TAX CENTRAL CIRCLE-1(1), BANGALORE

PDF · subscribers
ITA 685/BANG/2024Status: DisposedITAT Bangalore04 November 2026AY 2016-1719 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal upheld the CIT(A)'s finding that the compensation received by the assessee under the Deed of Disengagement was taxable in India. The Tribunal agreed with the CIT(A)'s conclusion that the payment was for relinquishing rights and benefits attached to the assessee's position at USL, thus attracting Section 28(ii)(a) of the Act. Consequently, the assessee's appeal was dismissed. Regarding the Revenue's appeal, which challenged the restriction of the addition to the amount actually received (USD 40 million) and argued for the taxation of the entire USD 75 million in AY 2016-17, the Tribunal found that the grounds raised by the Revenue did not survive as the assessee's appeal, which dealt with the taxability of the amount received, was dismissed. Therefore, the Revenue's appeal was also dismissed. The Tribunal noted that the CIT(A) had rightly concluded the taxability of the amount received arising out of the Deed of Disengagement.

What were the facts?

The assessee, Shri Vijay Mallya, a non-resident individual and ex-Chairman of United Spirits Limited (USL), filed his return for AY 2016-17 declaring Rs. 3,99,37,114. He entered into a Deed of Disengagement (DOD) with Diageo PLC and its subsidiaries on February 25, 2016, agreeing to receive USD 75 million (approx. Rs. 515,23,50,000) for resigning from USL. This amount was not declared in his return. The Assessing Officer (AO) reopened the assessment under Section 147, issuing a notice under Section 148. The assessee filed a revised return declaring Rs. 3,99,37,140 and exempt income of Rs. 2,16,59,724. The AO added the entire USD 75 million as business income, considering it accrued in India. The assessee appealed to the CIT(A), who, after condoning a delay and admitting additional evidence, restricted the addition to Rs. 274,79,20,000 (USD 40 million), the amount actually received during the AY.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the compensation received under the Deed of Disengagement, entered into with foreign companies by a non-resident assessee, is taxable in India as income accruing or arising in India, under Section 5(2) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. 2. Whether the compensation received for relinquishing management of an Indian company falls under Section 28(ii)(a) of the Act. 3. Whether the compensation received for a global non-compete agreement is taxable under Section 28(va) of the Act. Assessee's Contentions: - The income did not accrue in India as the assessee was a tax resident of Dubai until 2016 and could avail DTAA benefits. - The sum received was compensation for a global non-compete, not solely for exiting USL, and thus not taxable under Section 28(va). - The Deed of Disengagement involved company law provisions for appointment and removal, and the sum was for non-compete obligations. Revenue's Contentions: - As per Section 5(2), total income of a non-resident includes all income accruing or deemed to accrue or arise in India. - The compensation for exiting the management of an Indian company is taxable in India as the source is in India. - The entire USD 75 million should be taxed in AY 2016-17 as the assessee complied with the agreement by exiting USL.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 5(2),Section 147,Section 148,Section 143(1),Section 143(2),Section 142(1),Section 28(ii)(a),Section 28(va),Section 2(45)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, BANGALORE BENCHES, BANGALORE

Before: SHRI BALAKRISHNAN S & SHRI KESHAV DUBEY

Pronounced: 04.11.2026

Heard together (2 matters)

ITA Nos.685/Bang/2024
ITA Nos.826/Bang/2024

Read from the judgment's own cause title. This page is filed under one of them.

आदेश / ORDER

PER SHRI BALAKRISHNAN S, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER: These appeals filed by the assessee and by the Revenue against the order of the Learned Commissioner of Income Tax Appeals-11, Bengaluru (in short ‘Ld CIT(A)’) order dated 29th February 2024 arising out of the assessment order passed under section 147 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, (in short ‘Act’) dated 30th September 2021. Firstly we take up assessee appeal in ITA/685/2024, and the facts are culled out therefrom.

2.

The facts of the case are that assessee (Shri Vijay Mallya) being an individual non resident and who is the Ex-Chairman of the Indian company M/s United Spirits Limited, (for short ‘USL’) filed his return of income for the assessment year 2016-17 on 28th July 2016 declaring a total income of Rs.3,99,37,114/-. The return of income was summarily processed under section 143(1) of the Act dated 8th August 2016. It was noticed that the assessee has entered into a Deed of Disengagement (for short ‘DOD’) with M/s Diageo PLC, (for short ‘Diageo’), M/s Relay BV and M/s Diageo Holdings Netherlands BV dated 25th February 2016. M/s Diageo PLC through its wholly owned subsidiary M/s Relay and M/s Diageo PLC is the majority shareholder and holding company of the Indian company M/s United Spirits Limited. As per the agreement for disengagement which includes the resignation of the assessee from the Indian company M/s United Spirits Limited, M/s Diageo PLC agreed to pay an amount of USD 75 million to the assessee, which converts into Indian Rs.515,23,50,000/- as on the date of the agreement. It was noticed that the assessee has not declared this amount in the return of income filed for the assessment year 2016-17. Thereafter the Learned Assessing Officer (for short ‘Ld AO’) considering that income is escaping assessment, therefore issued a notice under section 148 of the Act dated 19.03.2020, requiring the assessee to file the return of income for the AY 2016-17. In response to the notice under section 148 of the Act dated 19th March 2020, the assessee filed return of income 17th December 2020 declaring a total income Rs.3,99,37,140/- and exempt income of Rs.2,16,59,724/-. The Ld AO thereafter issued notice u/s 143(2) of the Act on 21st December 2020. Subsequently notice under section 142(1) of the Act was issued on 28th October 2020 and 25th January 2021. The assessee sought reason for reopening of case under section 148 of the Act. The assessee raised some objections for the reopening vide letter dated 15th February 2021 which is reproduced in the Assessment Order. The assessee also made a submission by objecting regarding the transactions with Diageo, since assessee being a non resident this income does not accrue to him in India for the reason that he was a tax resident of Dubai till 2016 and therefore he can avail the benefit of DTAA. The Ld AO while disposing the objections, stated that assessee being a non resident, the total income of any previous year of a person who is a non-resident includes all income from whatever source derived as per Section 5(2) of the Act. Since the assessee has agreed to receive the compensation towards termination of his engagement with the management of the Indian company M/s United Spirits Limited and accordingly income received or is deemed to be received in India, and shall be included in the total income of the assessee during the relevant AY. The Ld AO therefore concluded that since the source is in India, the income is taxable in India. The Ld AO noted that since the compensation is for exiting as director of the Indian company M/s United Spirits Limited arising out of the deed of disengagement, it shall be deemed to accrue or arise in India. The assessee has received part payment USD 40 million out of the total USD 75 million on the date of entering into the Deed of disengagement on 25th February 2016. The assessee also further agreed to receive the balance amount in five equal installments over the course of next five years. Subsequently the assessee resigned from the Board of USL. He received a sum of Rs.274,79,20,000/-, equivalent to USD 40 million as on the date of agreement, in part settlement. Observing that the assessee has resigned as Director and Chairman of USL immediately on the execution of the disengagement Deed, the Ld AO considered that the compensation shall be squarely covered under Section 28(ii)(a) of the Act. The Ld AO therefore made an addition of Rs.515,23,50,000/-, equivalent to USD 75 million as business income in the hands of the assessee for the AY 2016-17 while passing the order u/s 147 dt. 30.09.2021.

3.

Being aggrieved by additions made by Ld AO, the assessee carried the matter in appeal before the Ld CIT(A), with a delay of 153 days. On perusal of petition for condonation of delay, including the affidavit filed by the assessee, the Ld CIT(A) noticed that delay is covered by decision of the Honorable Supreme Court in view of Covid Pandemic 19, and therefore after condoning the delay of 153 days, admitted the appeal. The assessee during the course of appellate proceedings filed additional evidences before the Ld CIT(A) which was forwarded to the Ld AO calling for remand report. Ld AO submitted his reply on 16th January 2024, which was forwarded to the assessee for rejoinder. The assessee submitted rejoinder on 22nd January 2024. The Remand report and the rejoinder is extracted in order of Ld CIT(A). Considering the reply of the assessee the Ld CIT(A) admitted the additional evidence submitted by the assessee. After examining the reply including the documents furnished by the assessee’s representative the Ld CIT(A) partly allowed the appeal of the assessee, by restricting the addition to Rs.274,79,20,000/-. being the actual receipt by the assessee during the impugned AY 2016-17.

4.

Being aggrieved by the order of the Ld CIT(A), the assessee is in appeal before the Tribunal by raising the following grounds:

1.

That the Orders of the authorities below are wholly arbitrary, contrary to facts and circumstances, violative of principles of natural justice, and without jurisdiction. 2. That the total income assessed, and the assessed tax is erroneous. 3. That the assessment order passed only under section 147 without reference to section 143 is bad in law. 4. That the Authorities below erred in not extending the reformed system of reassessment in respect of which several provisions were substituted vide Finance Act 2021 and which were already in force during the pendency of the assessment proceedings in the case of the Appellant. 5. That the Ld. CIT(A) erred in holding that the Deed of Disengagement dated 25.02.2016 entered into between the Appellant as a non-resident and foreign companies of the Diageo Group , under which part payment was also received by the Appellant outside India, resulted in income accruing and arising in the hands of the Appellant in India which was not offered to tax. 6. That the Ld. CIT(A) erred in not considering the governing provisions of Company Law for the appointment and removal to the office of Chairman/ Director and rather attributing the entire sum under the Deed of Disengagement to the position, rights, association of the Appellant with United Spirits Limited ('USL'), an Indian company, disregarding that the said sum is a compensation for non- compete owing to the restriction in the Deed of a five-year global non-compete (excluding the UK) binding the Appellant, his lineal descendants and their spouses. 7. That the Ld. CIT(A) erred in not considering that amount received for not carrying on any activity in relation to any profession was not chargeable to tax u/s 28(va) of the Act for the relevant assessment year. 8. That the Ld. CIT(A) erred in holding that mere holding of an office of Chairman/ Director of USL, an Indian company, tantamount to strong linkage of the Appellant with USL and its affiliates and therefore it is in the nature of business connection as per Section 9(1) of the Act. 9. That the Ld. CIT(A) erred in holding that the office of a Chairman/ Director is in the nature of 'property' used in Section 9(1) of the Act and therefore the sum under the Deed of Disengagement is in the nature of income arising through property in India as per Section 9(1) of the Act. 10. That the Authorities below overlooked the fact that the Appellant was Chairman/ Director of other Indian companies also for many years apart from holding such office in USL. 11. That the Ld. CIT(A) erred in not accepting that the Appellant is a fiscal resident of the UAE even when the Tax Residency Certificate ('TRC') dated 18.03.2015 issued by the Ministry of Finance, United Arab Emirates explicitly states so. 12. That the Ld. CIT(A) has misread the aforesaid TRC that it is solely for the purposes of enjoying benefits of the Agreement between UAE and French Republic for avoidance of double taxation, when even such an inference of its scope does not take away the fact of fiscal residency of the Appellant in the UAE and the TRC contains all such relevant information as prescribed for the purposes of Form 10F. 13. That the Ld. CIT(A) has proceeded to hold the Appellant as a resident of the UK based on extraneous material and disregarding a valid TRC issued by the Ministry of Finance, United Arab Emirates, when such contention was not even raised in the reassessment order. 14. That the Ld. CIT(A) erred in holding that the amount under the Deed of Disengagement is covered by Section 28(ii)(a) of the Act, when the Appellant was holding only the office of a Chairman/ non whole- time Director of USL, which office does not confer any power of managing the whole or substantially the whole of affairs of the company, and therefore the compensation or payment for termination of such an office cannot fall within the scope of Section 28(ii)(a) of the Act. 15. That the Ld. CIT(A) failed to appreciate that the Deed of Disengagement having been contested in a Court of Law in England and Wales, renders contingent any consideration stated in such Deed. 16. All the grounds are without prejudice to each other. 17. Appellant craves leave to add to, amend, alter, vary, omit, or substitute the grounds of appeal.

5.

Ground No. 1, 2, 16 and 17 are general in nature and needs no adjudication.

6.

Ground No 3 challenges the assessment order passed by Ld AO without reference to section 143. Section 292B was introduced with effect from October 1, 1975 to protect the validity of procedural actions under the Income Tax Act, 1961. It states that no return of income, assessment, notice, summons, or other proceeding shall be deemed invalid merely because of a mistake, defect, or omission, as long as the action is in substance and effect in conformity with the intent and purpose of the Act. The primary objective of Section 292B is to prevent procedural irregularities or technical errors from invalidating tax proceedings. This includes situations where notices or summons may contain minor errors, such as typographical mistakes, incorrect assessment years, or omissions that do not cause confusion or prejudice to the assessee. The section embodies the “substance over form” principle, emphasizing that the legal effect of a proceeding depends on its substantive compliance with the Act rather than minor formal defects. Since the mistake, in the instant case is curable under section 292B of the Act, this ground raised by the assessee is dismissed.

7.

Ground No 4 is against not extending the substituted re-assessment provisions vide Finance Act 2021 to the assessee. The reassessment provisions have been amended /substituted by Finance Act 2021 which clearly provides that these provisions apply prospectively. There is no merit in the ground raised by the assessee and hence dismissed.

8.

With respect to Ground No 5 and 6 the learned Authorised Representative (Ld AR) of the assessee Shri Ramasamy Vijayanand, Chartered Accountant, through his written submissions stated that the deferred obligations cannot accrue on day one if the recipient must continuously fulfil a negative covenant over the deferred period. He also submitted that under the unamended provisions of section 28(va) of the Act, only non-compete fees in relation to business where chargeable to tax whereas non-compete fees in relation to profession or personal convenants are outside the taxable net for the Assessment Year 2016-17. The Office of the Chairman/Director of USL is a statutory position governed by the Companies Act, 2013, and the assessee has no discretion or proprietary right to relinquish in exchange for a private compensation. He reiterated that the right to receive the sum arose strictly in lieu of accepting future global restrictions. The Ld AR relied on the following decisions: (a) Guffic Chem P Ltd v CIT [2011]332 ITR 602 (SC) (b) CIT v Tara Sinha TS-6185-HC-2017 (Delhi)

9.

With respect to Ground No 7, 8 and 9, Ld AR stated that a total consideration of US$ 75 million was agreed upon but the assessee has received only US$ 40 million on the date of disengagement. The balance was structured to be received in 5 equal annual instalments of US$ 7 million per annum. He further stated that Clause 2 of the DOD clearly mentions that the pay out was tied to a 5 year global non-compete restriction (excluding the UK) which is binding on all the future descendants of the assessee. He also submitted that a corporate position is strictly intangible in nature and is governed by the rule of mobilia sequuntur personam (movables follow the person). Therefore, he vehemently argued that the situs of the intangible asset shall be domicile / residence of its owner and therefore the alleged asset in the instant case was outside India. He also stated that under Article 13(3) of the India-UAE DTAA any gain derived from the alienation / relinquishment of the property or assets other than the immovable property or PE assets, is taxable only in the contracting state of which the alienator is a resident and hence India cannot tax the same. Since the contracting parties are offshore, the income does not accrue in India. He also stated that the Directorship and Chairmanship is a personal statutory office of service and not a capital asset. Therefore it cannot sold or commercially transferred. The learned AR placed reliance on the decision of Co-ordinate Bench of Mumbai in BCCI Vs. DCIT in ITA No.5492/Mum/2017 dated 11.05.2023 wherein the Tribunal clarified that termination compensation does not arise from any operational activities in India. The Ld AR also relied on the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in E. D. Sassoon & Co. Ltd., Vs. CIT in TS-1-SC-1954- 0 26 ITR 27 (SC) defines accrual as that income which accrues only when a person acquires a complete vested and legally enforceable right to receive the amount. He also submitted that Diageo has filed a litigation in UK courts against the assessee for the refund of the money. He also submitted that Diageo cancelled the agreement and has not paid the balance US$ 35 million.

10.

With respect to Ground No 10, 11, 12 and 13, Ld AR submitted that the assessee has produced 9 valid Tax Residency Certificates (TRCs) issued by the United Arab Emirates (UAE) covering a consecutive period from 01.01.2007 to 03.03.2016. It was the submission of the learned AR that the DOD took place on 25.02.2016 which is covered by the TRCs produced. He submitted that the learned CIT(A) rejected the UAE TRCs by stating that the TRC was obtained under the UAE-France DTAA rather than India-UAE DTAA. The learned CIT(A) also treated the assessee as resident of UK. He submitted that TRC is an official sovereign declaration that satisfies the criteria to be a fiscal resident of that country. He also submitted that an individual cannot be a fiscal resident of UAE when dealing with France but a non-resident when dealing with India. Further, section 90(2) of the Act dictates that the DTAA overrides the Act.

11.

With respect to Ground No 14 the Ld AR submitted that as per Section 28(ii)(a) of the Act, it applies to the compensation received by a person managing the whole or substantially the whole of affairs of the Indian company. The assessee being a Non Executive Chairman and Non Whole Time Director of USL, any payment for termination or disengagement falls completely outside the provisions of Section 28(ii)(a).

12.

With respect to Ground No 15 the Ld AR submitted that DOD has been contested in the court of law in England and Wales and therefore the income remains contingent and therefore it cannot be considered as accrued to the assessee.

13.

He therefore prayed that the reassessment proceedings are void-ab-initio.

14.

Per contra, the learned Senior Standing Counsel for the Revenue Shri. Raviraj Y V, (Ld DR) relied on the provisions of section 9(1)(b) of the Act. The Ld DR also further placed reliance on Explanation 2 to Section 5 of the Act wherein the income accrued shall be subjected to tax in India. The Ld DR submitted that as per section 2(45) of the Act ‘total amount’ of income referred to in section 5 is computed in the manner in accordance with the Act. He also referred to section 5 of the Act, by stating that sub-section 2 to section 5 of the Act states that total income of a non resident includes all income from whatever source derived which is accruing or is deemed to accrue or arise in India during that year. He also relied on the Explanation 2 to Section 5 wherein it was clarified that income which has been included in the total income on the basis of accrual shall not be again included in the total income on the basis of the receipt. Further he also submitted that the TRC was obtained under UAE-France DTAA and cannot be applied to India-UAE DTAA. He therefore prayed that the order of the Learned AO be upheld.

15.

We have heard the rival contentions and perused the material available on record including the written submissions furnished by the assessee.

16.

This Deed of Disengagement between the assessee and the Diageo clearly states that assessee has agreed to receive USD 75 million for exiting as Director and Chairman of USL and its affiliates. The assessee has also received part payment of USD 40 million as on the date of Deed of Disengagement on 25th February 2016. Further the assessee has also agreed to receive the balance amount in five equal installments over the course of next five years. As per the terms the Deed of Disengagement the assessee resigned from all his capacities as Director and Chairman of the Board of USL. This clearly indicates that the assessee has terminated his employment with the Indian Company with effect from 25th February 2016. According to Section 4 of the Act, income tax shall be charged on income of the previous year. Section 5 contains the scope of total income and provides that it shall comprise of income received, or deemed to be received in India, income arising or accruing in India or deemed to accrue or arise in India and income accruing or arising to a resident outside India. A resident is thus taxed on global income while a non-resident can be taxed only in respect of income received deemed to be received or income accruing or arising or deemed to accrue or arise in India. At the same time a non resident shall be taxable in India only if the income is sourced in India. The income is considered as sourced in India if it accrues or arises in India. Section 9 of the Act defines whether the income may or may not accrue or received in India. A non resident assessee is taxable in respect of the income accruing or arising in India unless the DTAA gives relief. According to section 9(1)(i) of the Act the following income shall be deemed to accrue arise in India:

 Any income accruing or arising whether directly or indirectly through or from : Business connection in India or Through art from any property in India or through from any asset or source of income in India or through the transfer of a capital asset situated in India.

17.

The term ‘business connection’ is not defined in the Act, but the Honorable Supreme Court in Barendra Prasad Ray v ITO [1981] 6 Taxman 19 (SC), has pointed out that the expression business connection does not necessarily mean trade or manufacture only; it is being used as including within its scope profession and vocations. It was opined that the context in which the expression “business connection” is used in section 9(1) clearly shows that there is no warrant for giving a restricted meaning to it by excluding “professional connections” from its scope. Section 9 of the Act being a deeming provision having widest amplitude to include income accruing or arising directly or indirectly. The income arise from an asset in India because of assessee position, rights and benefits of being a chairman and director in USL. The position remain extinguished for the consideration received by the assessee. The charge of income tax is on the total income. Broadly, India seeks to tax any income, the source of which can be traced to India. A non-resident is liable to pay tax on all income sourced from India as also incomes deemed to be received, accruing or arising in India. The question as to the source of the income is relevant because subsection (2) of section 5 provides that all income "from whatever source derived" is to be included in the total income of the non- resident assessee if the income accrues or arises in India during the relevant year. Section 9 of the Act which enumerates the incomes that shall be "deemed to accrue or arise in India". But the income in this case has in fact accrued in India and no question arises whether it should be "deemed" to accrue or arise in India.

18.

The learned CIT(A) in para 6.1.3 to 6.1.7 observed and held as follows:

“6.1.3 The AO in the detailed order has established the fact the sum received by the appellant is taxable in India as per Section 5(2) of the Act. Further even as per Section 9(1) of the Act as discussed earlier the sum received by the appellant is chargeable to tax.

6.1.4 The AO also makes note of the fact that out of the sum of USD 75 million the appellant as per the Deed has already received a sum of USD 40 million on 25- 02-2016 and the balance sum of USD 35 million was to be given by Diageo in five equal instalments of USD 7 million over the period of next five years. The view of the appellant that the sum is assessed in the hands of the appellant on a notional basis is incorrect, as the appellant has received a sum USD 40 million as on date of signing of agreement. The AO has brought to tax the sum deeming it to have accrued or arisen in India u/s 5(2) r.w.s 9(1) and therefore it cannot be said that the sum is assessed on notional basis.

6.1.5 It is also a fact that Diageo did not make the payment of the balance sum of USD 35 million due to alleged violation of contractual obligations by the appellant. Therefore, the appellant has received only a sum of USD 40 million for the PY 2015-16 relevant to the AY 2016-17 as on date of signing the Deed of disengagement and therefore it is this sum that ought to be taxable under the Act for the AY 2016-17. Further the appellant has also admitted to having received USD 40 million on signing the agreement and therefore what is being taxed is real income and not notional income. Therefore the claim of the appellant with regard to the amount being taxed on a notional basis is without merits and deserves to be rejected.

6.1.6 Therefore, the balance amount of USD 35 million would be taxed whenever received as per the scheme of instalments in the respective years, succeeding the PY 2015-16. Therefore under the Act the taxability in the hands of the appellant is restricted to USD 40 million.

6.1.7 The taxability under the DTAA is also discussed in the subsequent paragraphs and it has been held that the sum received by the appellant is also taxable under the DTAA.”

19.

On perusal of the DOD it is very clear that the payment is made to the assessee only to give up the rights and benefits attached to the position as Chairman and Non Executive Director of USL. Therefore we are in agreement with the findings of the learned CIT(A) we find no infirmity in the Order of the learned CIT(A) calling for any interference. Accordingly, the Ground No 5,6,7,8,9 & 10 raised by the Assessee is dismissed.

20.

On the issue of applicability of India-UAE DTAA it was submitted that assessee is a tax resident of UAE for many years and therefore the payment made to him in UK cannot be taxed in India. The Ld AR by relying on TRC produced from UAE under UAE-French DTAA and stated that assessee is not taxable under Article 7 of India-UAE DTAA. A copy of the TRC dated 18.03.2015 is reproduced below for reference:

21.

Similar TRCs were produced for the nine years. The assessee could not submit TRC for India-UAE DTAA. The assessee has not been able to prove that he is a resident of UAE as per India-UAE DTAA. The assessee is a permanent resident of UK and for the purpose of India-UK DTAA he is a resident of UK, however claimed that he is a tax resident of UAE. Considering the above facts the Ld CIT(A) in para 6.5.8 observed and held as follows:

6.5.8 The summary of the conclusions drawn above is that appellant is taxable under the DTAA. Further,  appellant is presently not able to prove that he is a resident of UAE by furnishing TRC as per India-UAE DTAA. If at a later stage it is held that appellant is a resident of UAE as per the India-UAE DTAA, then as per Article 14(a) of the DTAA, sum of UDS 40 million is taxable in the hands of the appellant.  the evidence presently indicates that appellant is a resident of UK. If it is held that appellant is a resident of UK, as per India- UK DTAA, then the , appellant is held to be taxable under Article 15(1)(a) or 15(1)(b) of the DTAA and without prejudice, it is also held that appellant is taxable under Article 23(3) of the DTAA.

22.

We are in agreement with the findings of the Ld CIT(A) as we find no infirmity calling for any interference. Accordingly, the Ground No 11 to 13 and 15 raised by the Assessee is dismissed.

Further with respect to the applicability of Section 28(ii)(a) of the Act it was the submission of the Ld AR that this provision is not applicable to the assessee in the instant case. We extract below the provisions of Section 28(ii)(a) of the Act for reference: 28. The following income shall be chargeable to income-tax under the head "Profits and gains of business or profession",— (i) the profits and gains of any business or profession which was carried on by the assessee at any time during the previous year ; (ii) any compensation or other payment due to or received by,— (a) any person, by whatever name called, managing the whole or substantially the whole of the affairs of an Indian company, at or in connection with the termination of his management or the modification of the terms and conditions relating thereto;

On perusal of the DOD, it is noticed that the resignation of the assessee relates to his appointment and governance rights and therefore the payment for relinquishing the rights and benefits attached to his position at USL. Therefore in our view the provisions of 28(ii)(a) of the Act are attracted and therefore we dismiss the Ground No 14 raised by the assessee.

23.

In the result, appeal of the Assessee is dismissed.

Revenue appeal in ITA 826/Bang/2024

24.

With regard to the Revenue appeal in ITA 826/Bang/2024, facts remaining the same as narrated in detail in Assessee Appeal, the only contention of the Revenue is that the assessee entered into DOD, on 25th February 2016 by agreeing to receive a sum of USD 75 million in consideration to resign as Chairman and Director of USL. However the assessee has not declared this income while filing the return of income for the assessment year 2016-17. The Ld AO considering income escaping assessment of Rs.515,23,50,000 (Approximately Converted INR on the date of disengagement, Equivalent to USD 75 million), reopened the assessment after taking approval from competent authorities. On appeal the Ld CIT(A) restricted the income to the actual amount received by the assessee, amounting to USD 40 million (Approximately Rs.274,79,20,000/-). Aggrieved, the Revenue has raised the following grounds before the Tribunal:

1.

Whether the CIT(A) was correct in law and facts in restricting the addition to the tune of Rs. 274.79 cr (USD 40 million) only for the AY 2016-17, holding it as based on accrual of income to that extent. 2. Whether the CIT(A) was correct in law and facts in holding that the balance amount Of USD 35 million can be taxed by the AO Whenever it is received as Scheme Of settlement. 3. Whether the CIT(A) was correct in law and fact in not appreciating the Facts that the issue of taxation of income based on accrual concept, cannot be held subservient to contractual disputes between Ovo private parties.

25.

The Ld DR submitted that as per section 2(45) of the Act ‘total amount’ of income referred to in section 5 computed in the manner in accordance with the Act. He also referred to section 5 of the Act, by stating that sub-section 2 to section 5 of the Act states that total income of a non resident includes all income from whatever source derived which is accruing or is deemed to accrue or arise in India during that year. He also relied on the Explanation 2 to Section 5 wherein it was clarified that income which has been included in the total income on the basis of accrual shall not be again included in the total income on the basis of the receipt. He therefore prayed that the order of the Learned AO be upheld.

26.

Per Contra The learned AR submitted that since assessee being a non resident and also a tax resident of UAE, the non compete fees agreed by the assessee cannot be taxable in India. The Ld AR further submitted that detailed argument were made regarding taxability in the assessee appeal in ITA 685/Bang/2024. He therefore prayed that the addition made by the Ld AO and partly confirmed by Ld CIT(A) be deleted.

27.

We have heard the rival contentions and perused the material available on record.

28.

The grounds raised buy the revenue pertains to taxability of the USD 35 million proposed to be received by the assessee on a deferred basis in 5 equal instalments. It is the contention of the revenue that this amount of USD 35 million shall be taxable in the previous year in which the Deed of Disengagement was agreed and entered by the assessee, since the assessee complied with agreement by exiting from USL. While adjudicating the assessee appeal in ITA No.685/Bang/2024 in the above paragraphs we have dismissed the appeal of the assessee by observing that Ld CIT(A) has rightly concluded the taxability of the amount received by the assessee arising out of Deed of Disengagement. Therefore, the appeal of the revenue does not survive and hence dismissed.

29.

In the result, both the appeals of the assessee as well as the Revenue are dismissed.

Pronounced in the open court on the date mentioned on the caption page.

Sd/- Sd/- (KESHAV DUBEY) (BALAKRISHNAN S) JUDICIAL MEMBER ACCOUNTANT MEMBER Bangalore Dated: 04.11.2026 /NS*/ Copy to: 1. Appellants 2. Respondent 3. CIT 4. CIT(A) 5. DR 6. Guard file By order P G Digitally signed by P G RAJANI RAJANI Date: 2026.11.18 12:07:29 +05'30' Assistant Registrar, ITAT, Bangalore.

More judgments on Section 5(2)

All 454 judgments and leading authorities on Section 5(2) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →