NARENDRABHAI BABUBHAI HIRPARA,SURAT vs. ITO, WARD-3(2)(1), SURAT

PDF · subscribers
ITA 1255/SRT/2025Status: DisposedITAT Surat13 November 2026AY 2022-237 pages

In favour of the assessee: the assessee's appeal was allowed. From the AI summary of this appeal.

AI SummaryAllowed

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal held that the appeal filed by the assessee is allowed. The Tribunal noted that the assessee received remuneration and interest from the partnership firm, which were correctly offered as taxable income. The Tribunal observed that in past years, the Revenue had treated profits from the firm in the firm's hands and taxed salary/remuneration and interest in the hands of the assessee. Therefore, expenses related to earning this interest income by the individual assessee were rightly claimed. The Tribunal referred to the decision in Sudhir Dattaram Patil vs. DCIT, which held that remuneration received by a partner from a firm is to be assessed under the head 'profits and gains of business or profession' as per Section 28 of the Income Tax Act. Consequently, any interest paid by the partner for the purpose of earning such remuneration must also be deductible under Section 36(1)(iii) of the Act. The Tribunal found this decision apt and applicable. Furthermore, the Revenue had allowed similar claims in earlier and subsequent years for the assessee. The assessee had established a direct nexus between unsecured loans for capital introduction in the partnership firm and the investment made. Therefore, the addition of Rs. 15,90,000/- by the Assessing Officer was deemed not justifiable. The Tribunal did not explicitly mention the Rs. 18,500/- addition for agricultural income in its decision.

What were the facts?

The assessee, Narendrabhai Babubhai Hirpara, filed an appeal against the order of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) - National Faceless Appeal Centre (NFAC), Delhi, for Assessment Year 2022-23. The assessee has business income, capital gains, and income from other sources. During the year, the assessee purchased and sold immovable properties, declaring short-term and long-term capital gains. The Assessing Officer (AO) noted that the assessee declared stamp duty value as sale consideration for capital gains. The AO also observed that the assessee received remuneration and interest from partnership firms, deducted expenses against these, and credited the net amounts to his capital account. The AO disallowed expenses of Rs. 15,90,000/- claimed by the assessee against remuneration and interest received from partnership firms, holding that these amounts were already allowed as deductions to the firms. The AO also made an addition for agricultural income. The CIT(A) dismissed the assessee's appeal.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the Tribunal had to decide if the disallowance of expenses amounting to Rs. 15,90,000/- from the assessee's business income was legally sustainable. Assessee's contentions: The assessee argued that remuneration and interest received from partnership firms are taxable in his hands. Expenses claimed against these taxable incomes are therefore allowable. The net profit from the firm is exempt under Section 10(2A), but interest on capital and salary are taxable. The assessee contended that to become a partner, capital investment was a pre-condition, and unsecured loans were taken for this investment, establishing a direct nexus between income earned and interest paid on loans. The assessee relied on judgments from the Supreme Court (CIT vs. Ramniklal Kothari), ITAT Bangalore (Shri Suresh Sreeram), ITAT Mumbai (Ishwardas Satyanarayan Gupta), ITAT Delhi (Aman Tandon), and ITAT Visakhapatnam (Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax v. Maganti Bhaskara Murthy). The assessee also cited decisions from ITAT Mumbai (Sudhir Dattaaram Patil) and ITAT Surat (Rajesh Natvarlal Nandiwala), and pointed to past and subsequent years where similar claims were allowed by the Revenue. Revenue's contentions: The Revenue relied on the assessment order and the CIT(A)'s order. The Revenue argued that the assessee failed to provide details on how unsecured loans were utilized for capital investment in the partnership firm, and thus, a direct nexus was not established.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 10(2A),Section 28,Section 36(1)(iii)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, SURAT BENCH, SURAT

Before: MS. SUCHITRA KAMBLE & SHRI B.M. BIYANI

Pronounced: 13.11.2026

IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL SURAT BENCH, SURAT BEFORE MS. SUCHITRA KAMBLE, JUDICIAL MEMBER AND SHRI B.M. BIYANI, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER ITA No.1255/SRT/2025 (निर्धारण वर्ा/Assessment Year: 2022-23) NARENDRABHAI BABUBHAI Income Tax Officer, HIRPARA, WARD-3(2)(1) 27, KANTARESHWAR SOCIETY, AAYAKAR BHAVAN, KATARGAM, Vs. MAJURA GATE, SURAT-395004, GUJARAT OPP. NEW CIVIL HOSPITAL, SURAT-395001, GUJARAT अपीलधर्थी Appellant प्रत्यर्थी Respondent

Permanent Account Number of Assessee: ACIPP2691J

अपीलधर्थी द्वारा/Appellant represented by: Shri Manish J Shah, AR and Shri Rushin Patel, AR प्रत्यर्थी द्वारा/Respondent represented by: Shri Ashish Kumar, Sr. DR सुनवाई की तारीख / Date of conclusion of hearing: 03.09.2026 घोषणा की तारीख / Date of pronouncement: 13.11.2026 O R D E R PER : SUCHITRA KAMBLE, J M:

This appeal filed by the assessee is against the order passed by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), National Faceless Appeal Centre (NFAC), Delhi [in short “CIT(A)”] even dated 24.10.2025 for the Assessment Year (in short “AY”) 2022-23.

2.

The assessee has raised the following grounds of appeal: “1. The Ld. CIT(A) erred in law and on facts of the case, in sustaining the disallowance of expenses amounting to Rs.15,90,000/-from business income of the assessee. 2. The appellant craves leave to add, amend or alter the grounds of appeal at the time of hearing, if need arise.”

3.

The assessee is having income from partnership firm in which he is partner as well as business income, income from capital gain, agriculture income and income from other sources during the year under consideration. The assessee filed original return of income for A.Y. 2022-23 on 11.10.2022 by declaring total income of Rs.10,84,130/-. The return was processed u/s. 143(1) of the Act Income Tax Act, 1961 (in short “the Act”). The case was selected for scrutiny and Notice u/s. 143(2) dated 23.06.2023 was issued and served. Further notice u/s. 142(1) of Act along with questionnaire were issued on 06.07.2023. The assessee submitted details and submissions on 21.07.2023. Thereafter notice u/s. 142(1) was issued & the same was responded by the assessee on 06.09.2023. During the year, the assessee purchased four immovable properties on 25.03.2021 for total purchase cost of Rs.51,58,240/- and sold them for a sale consideration of Rs.52,50,000/- on 12.08.2022 & 30.03.2022. The profit derived from sale of the immovable properties is shown by the assessee as short term capital gain of Rs.1,91,760/-. Further the assessee sold immovable property on 31.03.2022 for a sale consideration of Rs. 25,30,939/- which is purchased on 26.11.2019 at purchased cost of Rs. 12,75,163/-. The profit derived from the sale of immovable property is shown by the assessee as long term capital gain of Rs. 9,05,314/-. The Assessing Officer observed that in computing capital gain, the assessee has declared the stamp duty value of the properties as sale consideration for computing the capital gains. Besides this the Assessing Officer observed that the assessee has received remuneration and interest from various partnership firms in which he is partner & assessee deducted a considerable amount from the remuneration and interest as expenses. The Assessing Officer further observed that the assessee had credited the remuneration and interest received from partnership firms into his partner's capital account without deducting the expenses. In the instant case, the assessee received remuneration of Rs.13,56,000/- and interest of Rs.2,47,051/- from the partnership firm in which he is partner. These amounts are already allowed as a deduction to the partnership firm as per the Assessing Officer, therefore, Assessing Officer held that further expenses of Rs. 15,90,000/- claimed by the assessee was not allowable expenditure. Thus, the Assessing officer made addition. The Assessing officer also made addition of Rs.18,500/- which claimed as Agricultural income for rate purpose.

4.

Being aggrieved by the assessment order, the assessee filed appeal before the CIT(A). The CIT(A) dismissed the appeal.

5.

The Ld. Authorised Representative (in short “the Ld. AR”) submitted that the assessee has received taxable income from firm in the form of interest and salary. Both these incomes are taxable in the hands of assessee and expenditure is claimed against these taxable income. So long as profit from firm is concerned, the same has been excluded from income under section 10(2A) and then after expenditures related to taxable income is claimed as deductions. Net profit from firm is exempt u/s 10(2A) but interest on capital investment & salary from firm are taxable in assessee hands. The said interest & salary is nothing but taxable income earned by assessee from firm in which assessee is partner & in the said firm assessee has invested capital & hence assessee has received said interest & salary. To be a partner in firm, there was pre-condition to invest in capital in firm. If assessee has not invested in the capital in firm then assessee would not have been partner in the firm. If assessee was not partner in the firm then assessee has not received the said taxable income i.e. interest & salary. Hence, to be a partner in firm, there was pre-condition to invest in capital in firm and so unsecured loan taken to make investment in the firm. Hence there is direct connection with income earned & interest paid to unsecured loans. Because, appellant has received income from firm out of invested capital in firm & worked done for firm. So, it is quite allowable from taxable income generated from firm(except net profit which is exempted). The funds invested in the firm has been sourced from interest bearing loan taken & hence then is direct nexus for taxable income and interest claimed as expenses. Without prejudice to above alternatively, even if, the interest- bearing loans not taken then the same fund must have been withdrawal from firm & hence which would have resulted in to lower interest income or Nil interest income as the case may be. Hence, there would have been lower taxable income in the hand of partner. So under any circumstances, the assessee is submitted to have lower income. Hence, the expenses claimed taxable income is correct. The assessee has legally, logically, validly & correctly claimed eligible expenditure against taxable income & it is as per not only were settled law but quite as per purpose of provision of the income tax Act. But the Ld. A.O. has incorrectly assumed that These amounts are already allowed as a deduction to the partnership firm. Therefore, the further expenses of Rs.15,90,000/- claimed by the assessee is not allowable expenditure without application of mind. The taxable income received from firm has nothing to do with partnership firm. So long tax ability of the same income is concerned. Claim of such expenses is as per law & firm is eligible to have deduction of interest on capital & salary to partners became both income are taxable in the hand of partner. So any income can never be taxed twice one in hands of firm & another in the hand of partner. Whatever taxable income received by partners from firm is taxable income received in lieu of one kind reward from firm as a partner. So now such income is exclusive income of partner of his Individual Capacity & he is legally entitled to have claim of deductions of expenses related to earn such income. Partnership firm has nothing to do with such claim as it has been illogically & illegally observed by Assessing Officer So question of claim of double deduction ceases to exist right from the beginning. In absence of such expenses, income of such nature cannot be earned. So, there is direct nexus between income & expenses claimed. Assessee relied on the following judgments:-

1.

The Supreme Court in CIT vs. Ramniklal Kothari (1969) 74 ITR 57 (SC)] 2. Shri. Suresh Sreeram Vs ITO (ITAT Bangalore) ITA No.1605/Bang/2019 28/01/2021. 3. Ishwardas Satyanarayan Gupta Vs ITO (ITAT Mumbai) ITA No. 2058/MUM/2023. 4. Aman Tandon Vs ACIT (ITAT Delhi) ITA No. 3469/Del/2015 5. Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax v. Maganti Bhaskara Murthy (2015) 66 (II) ITCL 589 (Visakha-Trib)

The Ld. AR submitted the chart of past & subsequent years wherein the said claim was allotted by Revenue. The chart is as follows:

The Ld. AR also relied upon the decision of Mumbai Tribunal in case of Sudhir Dattaaram Patil vs. DCIT (ITA No. 5430/Mum/2001 order dated 28.12.2004) & decision of Surat Tribunal in case of Rajesh Natvarlal Nandiwala vs. ACIT (ITA No. 242/SRT/2024 order dt. 27.05.2024).

6.

The Ld. Departmental Representative (in short “Ld. DR”) relied upon the assessment order and the order of the CIT(A). The Ld. DR submitted that the assessee has not provided the details as to how the unsecured loans were utilised for making investment in capital of the partnership firm. The direct nexus between the unsecured loans and the investment in the partnership firm was not established by the assessee.

7.

We have heard both the parties and perused all the relevant material available on record. At is pertinent to note that the assessee received remuneration from partnership firm as he is the partner and this remuneration was his taxable income which he rightly shown. The assessee also received interest income which has rightly shown as taxable income as per the chart given in para 5 hereinabove. In the past also the assessee received remuneration and interest income which was taxable income in the hands of assessee. In the past also the contention of the Ld. AR that so far, profit from firm is concerned, the same is rightly excluded from income u/s 10(2A) as Net profit from firm is exempt u/s 10(2A). In the past also the Revenue has treated profit from business in firms hand and taxed salary / remuneration as well as interest earn in the hands of assessee. Thus, expenses related to earning interest income of the individual assessee, the assessee has rightly claimed it. The decision of Tribunal, Mumbai Bench in case of Sudhir Dattaram Patil (supra) held that: “8. Still we have to answer whether an individual in the capacity of a partner in a firm is entitled for claim of any expenditure against the salary remuneration etc. received from the firm. To answer this question it is pertinent to mention at the outset that the legislature has provided two different segments one for the purpose of share of profit from a firm as mentioned in section 10(2A) and the other segment in respect of salary remuneration etc. as provided in section 28 of IT Act. Both these claims thus, function in two different directions. Now we are concerned only in respect of assessability of salary remuneration etc. and deduction there-from. These heads of income are provided to be taxed by the legislature under section 28 of Income-tax Act i.e., as 'profits and gains of business or profession'. With the result though the term salary or remuneration are used but the character of the income is nothing but profits and gains of business. Otherwise also when the section 67 was in operation which now stands omitted w.e.f. 1-4-1993, the salary, remuneration etc. were used to be treated as profits from the firm while computing the income of a partner from the firm. The legislature has recognized this principle and only then enacted a fiction in section 28. Now as per these amendments a remuneration is to be treated as a return of business profits by the firm to a partner and if it is so a result follows that the partner is entitled to all the deduction which he hitherto was entitled while computing the profits and gains from business including the deduction in respect of interest paid on moneys borrowed for investment in the firm. When the statute has by fiction provided that the remuneration received by the partner from the firm is to be assessed under the head 'business' under section 28 then automatically any interest paid by the partner for the purpose of earning the remuneration must also be deducted as per section 36(1)(iii). Under this section in computing the income referred to in section 28 the deduction is provided of the amount of the.. Interest paid in respect of capital borrowed for the purposes of the business or profession. The objection as raised by the Revenue authorities was that the interest was not paid for the purposes of earning the remuneration and in any case share of profit is not taxable in the hands of the partner. Strictly speaking share of profit is subject to exemption but not the remuneration or salary. Otherwise also any payment of salary to a partner is only a mode of sharing business profits and the character of receipt of salary/remuneration remains the same character of the income enjoyed by the firm.” This decision is very apt and applicable in present assessee's case. Besides this, the Revenue in earlier years and in subsequent years allowed these claims in assessee's case. The assessee has established direct nexus between the unsecured loans which was for capital introduction in partnership firm and the investment of the same in partnership firm. Thus, the addition of Rs.15,90,000/- by the assessee office is not justifiable. 8. In result, appeal filed by the assessee is allowed. Due to non-sitting of Bench on account of Deepawali Vacation as approved by order of the Hon’ble Vice-President (AZ), this order is pronounced by putting up on notice board as per Rule 34 of ITAT Rules, 1963 on 13.11.2026

Sd/- Sd/- (B.M. BIYANI) (SUCHITRA KAMBLE) ACCOUNTANT MEMBER JUDICIAL MEMBER Surat; Dated: 13.11.2026 * Kishore, Sr. P.S. Copy of the Order forwarded to: 1. The Appellant 2. The Respondent 3. CIT- concerned 4. DR, ITAT, Surat 5. Guard File By order, Digitally signed by HEMA KISHORE HEMA KISHORE JAKKA JAKKA Date: 2026.11.17 16:28:04 +05'30' Assistant Registrar/Sr.PS/PS ITAT, Surat Bench

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →