RAMA GARG,NASRULLAHGANJ vs. INCOME TAX OFFICER SEHORE, INCOME TAX DEPARTMENT SEHORE

PDF · subscribers
ITA 251/IND/2026Status: DisposedITAT Indore13 November 2026AY 2015-201614 pages
AI SummaryRemanded

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal held that the "Impugned Order" passed by the CIT(A) was an ex-parte order, in violation of the principles of natural justice. The Tribunal noted that while the assessment order was bi-parte, the CIT(A)'s order was ex-parte. Upon examining the records, including the email address provided in Form 35 and the ITBA portal, the Tribunal found that the assessee or their Authorized Representative (AR) did not receive the nine notices issued by the CIT(A) between 03.03.2020 and 18.11.2025. The AR, during the hearing, could not view any information regarding these notices on the portal. The Tribunal observed that the first appellate authority should exercise extreme caution in issuing notices. Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the "Impugned Order" and remanded the case back to the file of the CIT(A) for de novo consideration. The appeal was allowed for statistical purposes. The Tribunal did not decide on the merits of the disallowances or other grounds raised by the assessee.

What were the facts?

The assessee, Rama Garg, is challenging an order dated 08.12.2025 passed by the CIT(A) for Assessment Year 2015-16. The original assessment order dated 24.11.2017, passed under section 143(3), had computed the assessee's total income at Rs. 22,98,430/-, an increase from the returned income of Rs. 14,06,090/-. This involved additions of Rs. 7,36,428/- and Rs. 1,55,903/-. The assessee, a sole proprietor of "M/s Gayatri Traders," engaged in wholesale trading and flour/rice milling, had their case selected for scrutiny under CASS. During the assessment, 50% of electricity and power expenses (Rs. 7,36,428/-) were disallowed as bills were in the name of "Garg Warehouse," which the assessee did not own, and no income from it was shown. Additionally, certain "Hammali & Tulai," machinery, and warehouse expenses (Rs. 1,55,903/-) were disallowed due to unsupported or handwritten bills. The assessee's first appeal before the CIT(A) was dismissed.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the order passed by the CIT(A) is bad in law, perverse, based on irrelevant material, unreasonable, and suffers from mis-application of law, violating principles of natural justice, as argued by the assessee. 2. Whether the CIT(A) erred in confirming the disallowance of Rs. 7,36,428/- out of electricity charges, as argued by the assessee, who contended that the warehouse was used for business purposes, electricity payments were for business, and the issue was not discussed by the AO. 3. Whether the CIT(A) erred in confirming the ad-hoc disallowance of Rs. 81,800/- from Hammali & Tulai expenses, Rs. 33,800/- from Machinery Expenses, and Rs. 40,303/- from Warehouse Expenses without providing an opportunity, as argued by the assessee. Assessee's Contentions: The assessee argued that the CIT(A)'s order was bad in law and violated principles of natural justice because notices were not received, being sent under the "for your information" tab instead of "for your action." The assessee claimed the CIT(A)'s order was ex-parte and a nullity. Regarding the electricity expenses, the assessee stated the warehouse was owned by family members, no rent was paid, and the electricity was used for stocking goods and running the flour mill, with payments made for business purposes. The assessee also argued that the disallowances of Hammali & Tulai, machinery, and warehouse expenses were made without providing an opportunity. The assessee relied on the fact that the assessment order was bi-parte, while the CIT(A)'s order was ex-parte. Revenue's Contentions: The Revenue's Senior Departmental Representative left the issue to the wisdom of the Tribunal.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 253,Section 250,Section 143(3),Section 246A,Section 234B,Section 234C,Section 274,Section 271(1)(c)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, INDORE BENCH, INDORE

For Respondent: Shri Binay Kumar Rai, Sr.DR
Hearing: 05.11.2026Pronounced: 13.11.2026

Per Paresh M Joshi, J.M:

This is an appeal filed by the Assessee under section 253 of

the income tax Act 1961, [hereinafter referred to as the Act

for the sake of brevity] before this tribunal, as & by way of a

second appeal. The Assessee is aggrieved by the order

bearing No: -ITBA/APL/S/250/2025-26/1083387309(1)

dated 08.12.2025 passed by the Ld. CIT (A) u/s 250 of the

Act, which is hereinafter referred to as the “Impugned

Order”. The Relevant Assessment year is 2015-16 and the corresponding previous year period is from 01.04.2014 to

31.03.2015.

2.

Factual Matrix

2.1 That as and by way of an Assessment order made u/s

143(3) of the Act, the total income of the assessee was

computed and assessed at Rs. 22,98,430/-[R/O]. Income as

per the Return of Income was at Rs. 14,06,090/-. An

addition of Rs 7,36,428/- was made by virtue of Para 3 and

yet another addition of Rs. 1,55,903/- was made by virtue of

aforesaid Assessment Order. That the aforesaid assessment

order is dated 24.11.2017, which is hereinafter referred to

as the “Impugned Assessment Order”.

2.2 That the Assessee is sole Proprietor of “M/s Gayatri

Traders” & is engaged in the business of trading as a

wholesaler, General Commissioner Agent, flour and rice

mills. The assessee has filed audit report in form no. 3 CB

and form no:- 3 CD. The case of the assessee was selected

for the scrutiny under CASS. Notice(s) u/s 143(2) and 142(1)

were issued and were served on the assessee. The assessee

was represented by Sh. Rakesh Mangal CA. The written

submissions were filed and were placed on the record, after

verification. Books of accounts, bills/vouchers and copy of

bank statements all have been produced and were examined

by the test check method. Electricity power expenses of

Rs. 14,72,855/- which was claimed as expense was

examined. The assessee was asked to produce all the bills

and the vouchers of the expenditure incurred in this regard.

Some of the expenses of the electricity & power were not

supported by the bills. Many of the bills were in the name of

“Garg ware house”. The assessee was found to be not a

proprietor of “Garg ware house”. No income of the said

ware house is shown in the financial statements as well as in

the ITR. It was discovered that in the earlier assessment

years such disallowances of these expenses were too

made on the same grounds. The AR could not give a

satisfactory explanation in this regard. The discrepancy

found was agreed upon and the disallowances too was agreed

upon. The Ld. AO disallowed 50% of such expenses aggravating to Rs. 7,36,428/- and such the same was

added to the income of the assessee. The second issue was

of “Hammali & Tulai” expenses of Rs. 8,18,197/-,

machinery expenses of Rs. 3,37,779/- and ware house

expenses of Rs. 40,303/-. The assessee was asked to

produce all the bills and vouchers of the above expenditure.

Some of the bills/ vouchers were found to be hand

written/kacche-pakke which are not supported. Therefore

the Ld. AO disallowed the Hammali and Tulai expenses of Rs.

81,800/-, machinery expenses of Rs. 33,800/- and ware

house expenses of Rs. 40,303/-. [Ware house not shown as

fixed asset nor any income from the ware house]. The

aggregate disallowance worked out to be of Rs. 1,55,903/-

[Rs. 81,800 + Rs. 33,800+ Rs. 40,303/-]

2.3 That the assessee being aggrieved by the aforesaid

“Impugned Assessment Order” prefers the first appeal u/s

246A of the act before the Ld. CIT (A) who by the

“Impugned Order” has dismissed the first appeal of the

assessee on the grounds and the reasons stated therein. The core grounds and the reasons for the dismissal of the first

appeal were as under:- 2.4 That the assessee being aggrieved by the “Impugned

Order” has preferred the instant second appeal before this

tribunal and has raised the following grounds of appeal in

the form no. 36 against the “Impugned Order” which are as

under: -

“1. That the Additional/JCIT (A)-2

Visakhapatnam erred in not holding that the

order was bad in law. It was perverse; (2) it

was based on irrelevant material; (3) it was un-

reasonable; (4) there was mis-application of the

provisions of law; (5) the authority misdirected

2.

That the learned Additional/JCIT (A)-2

Visakhapatnam erred in dismissal of appeal.

The Appellant could not see the notices sent

due to fact that all notices are sent under the

TAB "for your information" instead of "for your

action". The order of Additional/JCIT (A)-2

Visakhapatnam is without affording an

opportunity of being heard and without

following rule of natural justice and fair play

and was therefore a nullity and the same may

be declared null and void.

3.

That the learned Additional/JCIT (A)-2

Visakhapatnam erred in confirming

disallowance of Rs.7,36,428/- out of the

electricity charges paid. The mere reason for

disallowance is that the Electricity Bill is

drawn in the name of "Garg Warehouse". The

Appellant is using the warehouse owned by

family members without paying any rent. The Electricity is used for stocking of goods and

running of manufacturing unit of ATTA (flour).

The entire payment has been made for business

purposes and no element of personal expenses

involved. The issue was never discussed by the

learned AO and the disallowance has been

made by withholding the right with him. The

allegation made that the Appellant has

intentionally claimed these expenses are also

bad and based on assumptions. The

disallowance has been made on adhoc basis

which needs to be deleted.

4 That the learned Additional/JCIT (A)-2

Visakhapatnam erred in confirming adhoc

disallowance out of Hammali & Tulai expenses

Rs. 81800/-, disallowance of Machinery

Expenses Rs. 33800/- and Warehouse Expenses

Rs. 40303/- are made without providing any

opportunity. The fact can be verified from the case record. Therefore the entire addition

made is bad in law.

erred in 5. That the learned Additional/JCIT

(A)-2 Visakhapatnam confirming the interest

and penalty levied U/s 234B at Rs. 100122/-

and U/s 234C at Rs. 22524/- of the Act.

6.

That the learned Additional/JCIT (A)-2

Visakhapatnam erred in confirming proposal to

levy penalty U/s 274 r.w.s. 271(1) c) of the Act.

7.. That in the alternative and without

prejudice to the grounds stated above, the

additions made and assessed as income of the

appellant be held to be high, unreasonable and

unjustified and be deleted.

8 The appellant craves leave to add, amend or

alter any Ground of Appeal before or during the

course of appellate proceedings.”

3.

Record of Hearing

3.1 The hearing in the matter took place before this Tribunal

on 05.11.2026 when the Ld. AR for & on behalf of the

Assessee appeared before us and interalia contended that

the “Impugned Order” is bad in law, illegal and not proper.

It is in the violation of the principle of the Natural Justice. It

therefore deserves to be set aside.

3.2 The Ld. AR has placed on the record of this tribunal a

paper book containing pages 1 to 16. A loose booklet of 04

pages from ITBA portal [by email dated 04.11.2026].

3.3 The Ld. AR then contended that “Impugned Assessment

Order” is a bi-parte one whereas the “Impugned Order” is

an ex-parte one. It was submitted that in all total 09

notices from 03.03.2020 to 18.11.2025 [Para 5 of Impugned Order] were sent to the assessee but none were

received. In support the Ld. AR has relied upon loose

booklet of 4 pages showing in the records of e-

proceedings and stated that none of the notice(s) are seen

and can be viewed. The Ld. AR who was appearing online

was told to view the web page/ portal and after viewing

the same stated that nothing is seen with regard to above

9 notices. The Ld. AR therefore submitted that the

“Impugned Order” is passed without hearing the assessee

and same is in the violation of the principle of the natural

justice. Per contra the Ld. SDR left the issue to the wisdom

of this tribunal to take an appropriate call basis law. The

hearing was then over and closed.

4.

Observations Findings & conclusions

4.1 We have to decide the legality, validity and proprietary of the

“impugned order” basis records of the case & the rival

submission canvassed before us.

4.2 We have carefully perused the records of the case and have

heard the submissions.

4.3 We basis records of the case and after hearing and

further upon examining the rival contentions of the Ld. AR

and the Ld. DR canvassed before us, are of the considered

opinion that while the “Impugned Assessment Order” is a bi-

parte order and whereas the “Impugned Order” is an ex-

parte order one. Basis records we observe that in the form

no: - 35 there is an email address rkmangalca@gmail.com

and in the column no:- 17 same email address is there. We

are surprised as to how the 9 notices did not reach the

assessee or to the Ld. AR. Under these facts and

circumstances we observe that the first appellant authority

should exercise extreme caution and care in issuing the

notice(s). Even on the portal nothing could be viewed by the

Ld. AR during hearing too as was stated. Loose paper

booklet (04 pages) too does not show anything about the 9

notice(s) of the hearings. These facts and circumstances

clearly establishes that none of the 9 notice(s) were served

upon the assessee or to the Ld. AR by the Ld. CIT (A) and the

Impugned Order was passed ex-parte, which is in the

violation of the principles of the natural justice. We therefore set aside the Impugned Order and remand the case back to

the file of the Ld. CIT (A) on de novo basis.

5 Order

5.1 In result, the Impugned Order is set aside as and by way

of remand back to the file of the Ld. CIT (A) on de novo basis.

5.2 The appeal of the Assessee is allowed for the statistical

purpose.

Pronounced in open court on 13.11.2026.

Sd/- Sd/- (ARVIND SONI) (PARESH M JOSHI) ACCOUNTANT MEMBER JUDICIAL MEMBER Indore Dated : 13/11/2026

Copies to: (1) The appellant (2) The respondent (3) CIT (4) CIT(A) (5) Departmental Representative (6) Guard File Akhilesh Kumar Digitally signed by Akhilesh Kumar Date: 2026.11.13 00:47:45 +05'30' By order UE COPY Senior Private Secretary Income Tax Appellate Tribunal Indore Bench, Indore

Page 14 of 14

More judgments on Section 234B

All 10,750 judgments and leading authorities on Section 234B →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →