AAP SINGH BARELA,MADHYA PRADESH vs. ITO,SEHORE, SEHORE

PDF · subscribers
ITA 187/IND/2026Status: DisposedITAT Indore13 November 2026AY 2017-1824 pages
AI SummaryRemanded

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal set aside the impugned order of the CIT(A) and remanded the case back to the file of the CIT(A) for de novo adjudication. The Tribunal took a benevolent view, considering the assessee's submission that he is an agriculturist, not well-versed in English or technology, and therefore could not effectively respond to the notices issued electronically. The assessee's Authorized Representative (AR) undertook to be compliant before the CIT(A) and submit all necessary documents and explanations on merits. The Tribunal noted that while the assessee was partly compliant during the assessment proceedings, he was totally non-compliant before the CIT(A). The Tribunal found that setting aside the order and remanding the case would meet the ends of justice. The appeal of the assessee was allowed for statistical purposes.

What were the facts?

The assessee, AAP Singh Barela, is appealing an order from the CIT(A) for Assessment Year 2017-18. The Assessing Officer (AO) had made additions of Rs. 25,83,400/- under Section 56(2)(viib) as income from other sources for a property purchased for Rs. 5,00,000/- where the stamp duty value was Rs. 30,83,400/-. Additionally, Rs. 38,00,688/- was treated as unexplained money under Section 69 for another property purchase. The assessee was a non-filer and did not respond to notices during assessment. The CIT(A) dismissed the assessee's first appeal ex-parte due to non-compliance and lack of response to hearing notices, despite multiple opportunities. The assessee is now before the ITAT challenging the CIT(A)'s order.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the learned CIT(A) erred in law and on facts in dismissing the appeal ex-parte, without properly appreciating the facts of the case and without deciding the appeal on merits, thereby violating the principles of natural justice? (Assessee's contention: The CIT(A) order is bad in law, illegal, and violates natural justice. The assessee, an agriculturist not well-versed in English or technology, did not receive or understand the notices. The assessee is willing to appear and submit documents. Revenue's contention: The issue is left to the wisdom of the Tribunal.) 2. Whether the learned CIT(A) erred in upholding the addition of Rs. 25,83,400/- made u/s 56(2) of the Act, ignoring that the property purchased was agricultural land and did not constitute a capital asset within the meaning of section 2(14) of the Act? (Assessee's contention: The property was agricultural land. Revenue's contention: Not recorded.) 3. Whether the learned CIT(A) failed to appreciate that stamp duty valuation cannot be mechanically adopted, and no opportunity was provided to the appellant to seek valuation under section 50C(2)/56(2) by referring the matter to the Valuation Officer? (Assessee's contention: No opportunity for valuation. Revenue's contention: Not recorded.) 4. Whether the learned CIT(A) erred in confirming the addition of Rs. 38,00,688/- u/s 69 r.w.s. 115BBE, without appreciating that the investments were made out of explained agricultural income, family savings and joint ownership resources? (Assessee's contention: Investments were out of explained sources. Revenue's contention: Not recorded.) 5. Whether the authorities below failed to consider the documentary evidence submitted, such as khasra, khatoni and landholding details, and rejected the explanation merely on conjectures and surmises? (Assessee's contention: Evidence was not considered. Revenue's contention: Not recorded.) 6. Whether the learned CIT(A) erred in law in placing an unreasonable burden on the appellant, an agriculturist, to produce formal records like mandi receipts, ignoring the ground realities of agricultural operations? (Assessee's contention: Unreasonable burden on agriculturist. Revenue's contention: Not recorded.) 7. Whether the assessment framed u/s 144 r.w.s. 147 is bad in law, arbitrary, excessive and unsustainable, as additions have been made without proper inquiry and appreciation of facts? (Assessee's contention: Assessment is bad in law. Revenue's contention: Not recorded.)

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 253,Section 250,Section 147,Section 144,Section 69,Section 56(2)(viib),Section 2(14),Section 50C(2),Section 115BBE,Section 148,Section 129,Section 142(1),Section 246A

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, INDORE BENCH, INDORE

Before: SHRI PARESH M JOSHI & SHRI ARVIND SONI

For Respondent: Shri Binay Kumar Rai, Sr.DR
Hearing: 02.11.2026Pronounced: 13.11.2026

Per Paresh M Joshi, J.M:

This is an appeal filed by the Assessee under section 253 of

the income tax Act 1961,[ hereinafter referred to as the Act

for the sake of brevity] before this tribunal, as & by way of a

second appeal .The Assessee is aggrieved by the order

bearing No:-ITBA/NFAC/S/250/2025-26/1082835523(1)

dated 20.11.2025 passed by the Ld. CIT(A) u/s 250 of the

Act, which is hereinafter referred to as the “Impugned

order”. The Relevant Assessment year is 2017-18 and the corresponding previous year period is from 01.04.2016 to

31.03.2017.

2.

Factual Matrix

2.1 That as and by way of an Assessment order made u/s

147 rws 144 of the Act, the total income of the assessee

was computed and assessed at Rs. 63,84,088/-. The

assessee was a non -filer. The Income from the other

sources was determined and computed at Rs. 25,83,400/-.

The unexplained money u/s 69 was quantified at Rs. 38,

00,688/-. That the aforesaid assessment order bears

number: - ITBA/AST/S/147/2024-25/1075232166(1) and

that the same is dated 29.03.2025, which is hereinafter

referred to as the “Impugned Assessment Order” for the

sake of brevity.

2.2 The department of Income tax had an information that

the assessee had purchased two properties at a price which

was far below the market value of the property of a total

consideration of Rs. 1,17,70,900/- for the FY 2016-17 relevant to AY 2017-18. It was further revealed that the

assessee had not filed return of income for AY 2017-18

within the prescribed time limit. Therefore a notice u/s

148 of the Act was issued electronically on 13.03.2024 which

was duly served on the assessee on 26.03.2024 through the

speed post. No return of income was filed in response to

section 148 notice. The case was transferred out to JAO.

Notice u/s 129 of the Act was issued. The two properties

were identified of the assessee which was valued at Rs. Five

Lakh and Rs. thirty two lakhs thirty six thousand only and

value of which as per stamp value authority was of Rs.

30,83,400/- and Rs. 86,87,500/- respectively. Notice(s)

u/s 142(1) dated 12.02.2025 was not complied. Notice u/s

142(1) dated 24.02.2025 was partly complied. Show cause

notice dated 17.03.2025 was partly complied by the

assessee. In reply to the final show cause notice dated

19.03.2025 the assessee submitted the ROI on

22.03.2025. In respect of the first property of which the

value was of Rs. 5 Lakh and the fair market value was Rs.

30,83,400/-. the additions of Rs. 25, 83,400/- [u/s 56(2)

(viib)] as “income from other sources” was made. In

respect of the second property which was of Rs. 32,36,000/-

and stamp duty value of which was of Rs. 86,87,500/-, the

sources of Rs. 32,36,000/- was not explained despite

opportunities and hence purchase price of Rs. 32,36,000/-

+ stamp fee of Rs. 5,64,688/- aggregating to Rs. 38,08,688/-

was treated as undisclosed income/unexplained money

u/s 69 of the Act.

2.3 That the assessee being aggrieved by the aforesaid

“Impugned Assessment Order” prefers the first appeal u/s

246A of the act before the Ld. CIT (A) who by the

“Impugned Order” has dismissed the first appeal of the

assessee on the grounds and the reasons stated therein. The

core grounds and the reasons for the dismissal of the first

appeal were as under:-

“5. During the appellate proceedings, notices

u/s. 250 of the Income-tax Act. 1961 were

issued to the appellant on 10.09.2025,

10.10.2025 and 30.10.2025 fixing the date for filing details/ submissions on 25.09.2025,

17.10.2025 and 07.11.2025 respectively. All

these notices were duly served electronically on

to the registered e-mail ID of the appellant and

the status of these notices on ITBA system is

showing as "Delivered". However, the appellant

has not responded to any of the hearing

notices.

6.8 On examination of the appellate records, it

is noted that the appellant has not filed any

written submission, explanation, or

documentary evidence in the course of the

present proceedings. Despite the issue of

notices and adequate opportunities being

afforded, no response has been filed either on

the ITBA portal or otherwise. The appellant

has, therefore, remained entirely non-

compliant from the date of filing of the appeal till date, leaving the matter to be decided on

the basis of material available on record.

6.9 In light of the appellant's continued non-

compliance as outlined above, it appears that

the appellant is not inclined to pursue the

appeal. Consequently, it is not feasible to keep

the appeal pending for an indefinite period.

Despite multiple opportunities and statutory

notices issued during the appellate

proceedings, the appellant has failed to

respond or comply. This indicates a lack of

interest in pursuing the appeal or,

alternatively, an absence of any substantive

defense against the additions made by the

Assessing Officer. Since the appellant has not

availed themselves of the opportunities

provided, they cannot now claim a violation of

the principles of natural justice. In view of

this, the appeal is liable to be dismissed.

7.1 I have carefully considered the grounds of

appeal, the assessment order, the statement of

facts, and the material available on record. It

is observed that the appellant has not filed any

written submissions, explanations, or

documentary evidence during the appellate

stage, despite being granted sufficient and

repeated opportunities. In the absence of any

further representation or supporting material

from the appellant, the present appeal is,

therefore, adjudicated on the basis of the

assessment order and the records available on

file.

7.2.1 Ground No. 1: The appellant has

challenged the addition made by the Assessing

Officer u/s. 56 of the Act in respect of Property

No. 1, contending that the findings of the Assessing Officer are contrary to law, factually

incorrect, and unsustainable.

7.2.2 I have carefully considered the

assessment order, the material placed on

record, the submissions of the appellant, and

the statutory provisions applicable to the

present case. It is an undisputed fact that

during F.Y. 2016-17 the appellant purchased

Property No. 1 for a stated consideration of Rs.

5,00,000/-, whereas the corresponding stamp

duty valuation was Rs. 30,83,400/-. The

Assessing Officer. considering the excess of the

stamp valuation over the declared

consideration to be a case of receipt of

immovable property for inadequate

consideration, invoked section 56(2) and

brought to tax Rs. 25,83,400/- under the head

"Income from Other Sources."

7.2.3 During the assessment proceedings, the

Assessing Officer specifically confronted the

appellant regarding the applicability of the

provisions of section 56(2) and gave adequate

opportunity to furnish an explanation or any

material to show that the transaction did not

fall within the provisions of the said section.

Other than general contentions, the appellant

did not place any documentary evidence to

rebut the statutory requirement arising from

the admitted difference between the stamp

duty value and the declared purchase

consideration.

7.2.4 Further, the Assessing Officer examined

the nature of the asset and concluded that the

property was not rural agricultural land but a

capital asset within the meaning of section

2(14), as the sale deed clearly established that

the land was located within the municipal limits. The appellant has neither in the

assessment proceedings nor at the appellate

stage produced any evidence to contradict this

finding, nor has any material been brought on

record to demonstrate that the property did not

constitute a "capital asset."

7.2.5 The appellant has also not shown any

infirmity in the procedure followed by the

Assessing Officer. The statutory pre-conditions

for invoking section 56(2) were duly satisfied

namely the receipt of immovable property and

the consideration being less than the value

adopted/ assessable by the stamp valuation

authority. The appellant had failed to show

how the addition is contrary to law, nor has

any factual error in the computation of the

differential amount been established.

7.2.6 It is settled law that where the

conditions of section 56(2) are met, the

addition becomes mandatory unless the

assessee demonstrates that the stamp duty

value does not represent the fair market value.

In the present case, the appellant did not

furnish any valuation report or any other

evidence to suggest that the stamp duty

valuation was excessive. Therefore, no fault

can be found in the action of the Assessing

Officer in adopting the value determined by the

stamp valuation authority.

7.2.7 In view of the foregoing discussion, it is

evident that the appellant purchased a capital

asset for a consideration substantially lower

than the stamp duty valuation. The statutory

ingredients for invoking section 56(2) stood

fully satisfied and the Assessing Officer

provided adequate opportunity and followed due process. The appellant failed to produce

any credible evidence or legal basis to show

that the addition was erroneous, excessive, or

contrary to law. The appellant has failed to

demonstrate any infirmity, procedural defect,

or factual discrepancy in the Assessing

Officer's conclusion.

7.2.8 Accordingly, the addition of Rs.

25,83,400/- made u/s 56 is upheld, and Ground

No. 1 of the appeal is dismissed.

7.3.1 Ground No. 2: The appellant has

challenged the addition made by the Assessing

Officer u/s. 69 of the Act in respect of the

investment relating to Property No. 2,

contending that the Assessing Officer was not

justified in requiring additional documents for

substantiating the source of investment and in

treating the amount as unexplained.

7.3.2 I have carefully considered the grounds

raised, the assessment order, the available

material on record. The facts reveal that the

appellant purchased Property No. 2 for a

stated consideration of Rs. 32,36,000/-. During

assessment proceedings, the appellant was

specifically asked to explain the source of

investment towards the purchase price as well

as the stamp duty of Rs. 5,64,688/-,

aggregating to Rs. 38,00,688/-.

7.3.3 It is undisputed that the appellant did

not file a return in response to the notice u/s.

148 and subsequently filed an ITR belatedly on

13.03.2025, declaring agricultural income of

Rs. 6,57,460/-. The Assessing Officer provided

multiple opportunities through notices dated

12.02.2025, 24.02.2025, 07.03.2025 and

19.03.2025, requiring the appellant to furnish supporting documents such as Khasra/ Khatoni

records, evidence of agricultural activity, crop

yield and mandi receipts, agricultural

expenditure, bank statements, documentary

proof of funds used for property purchase or

any other contemporaneous evidence

establishing the source of investment

7.3.4 However, despite these repeated

opportunities, the appellant failed to furnish

any credible documentary evidence

demonstrating the availability of sufficient

funds or the manner in which the purchase of

Rs. 32,36,000/- (plus stamp duty) was financed.

Other than stating that the land was jointly

held with family members and providing a

basic landholding statement, no reliable

evidence was produced to substantiate the

actual flow of funds or to explain the nature

and source of investment.

7.3.5 The Assessing Officer recorded that the

agricultural income disclosed in the belated

ITR was grossly inadequate to justify an

investment of such magnitude, especially

considering household expenses and lack of

supporting records. The appellant has not

rebutted this finding either during assessment

or during the present appellate proceedings.

Likewise, the failure to maintain or produce

even the most basic evidence of agricultural

activity such as crop receipts, mandi sale bills,

or proof of yield, further weakens the

appellant's claim.

7.3.6 It is well settled that the burden to prove

the nature and source of investment lies

squarely upon the assessee when invoking

section 69. The Assessing Officer has the

statutory authority to call for such evidence as may be necessary to determine whether the

investment has been explained. The appellant's

contention that the Assessing Officer was "not

justified in requiring additional documents" is

untenable, as the Assessing Officer is duty-

bound to verify the source of investment when

substantial unexplained funds are involved.

Mere assertions without documentary support

cannot constitute an explanation within the

meaning of section 69.

7.3.7 In the present case, the appellant failed

to discharge this burden. The explanation

offered was neither substantiated nor capable

of being verified, and therefore did not satisfy

the requirement of being a satisfactory

explanation as contemplated u/s. 69. The

Assessing Officer was fully justified, both in

law and on facts, in requiring additional

documents and in holding the investment as unexplained when no evidence was

forthcoming. The addition has been made after

due inquiry, application of mind, and

adherence to statutory procedure.

7.3.8 In view of the above, the addition of Rs.

38,00,688/- made u/s. 69 r.w.s. 115BBE is

upheld. Accordingly, Ground No. 2 of the

appeal is dismissed.

7.4 Ground No. 3 is general in nature, being a

standard and residuary ground seeking liberty

to add, alter, or amend the grounds of appeal

at the time of hearing. It does not involve any

specific issue requiring adjudication at this

stage. Since no additional grounds have been

raised during the course of appellate

proceedings. there remains nothing to be

decided under this ground. Accordingly,

Ground No. 3 is dismissed.

8.

In the result, the appeal is dismissed.”

2.3 That the assessee being aggrieved by the “Impugned

Order” has preferred the instant second appeal before this

tribunal and has raised the following grounds of appeal in

the form no. 36 against the “Impugned Order” which are as

under:-

“1. That the learned CIT(A) erred in law and on

facts in dismissing the appeal ex-parte,

without properly appreciating the facts of the

case and without deciding the appeal on

merits, thereby violating the principles of

natural justice.

2.

That the learned CIT(A) erred in upholding

the addition of 25,83,400/- made u/s 56(2) of

the Income Tax Act, 1961, 2 ignoring the fact

that the property purchased was agricultural land and did not constitute a capital asset

within the meaning of section 2(14) of the Act.

3.

That the learned CIT(A) failed to appreciate

that stamp duty valuation cannot be

mechanically adopted, and no opportunity was

provided to the appellant to seek valuation

under section 50C(2)/56(2) by referring the

matter to the Valuation Officer.

4.

That the learned CIT(A) erred in confirming

the addition of 38,00,688/- u/s 69 r.w.s.

115BBE, without appreciating that the

investments were made out of explained

agricultural income, family savings and joint

ownership resources.

5.

That the authorities below failed to consider

the documentary evidence submitted, such as

khasra, khatoni and landholding details, and rejected the explanation merely on conjectures

and surmises.

6.

That the learned CIT(A) erred in law in

placing an unreasonable burden on the

appellant, an agriculturist, to produce formal

records like mandi receipts, ignoring the

ground realities of agricultural operations

7.

That the assessment framed u/s 144 r.w.s.

147 is bad in law, 7 arbitrary, excessive and

unsustainable, as additions have been made

without proper inquiry and appreciation of

facts”

3.

Record of Hearing

3.1 The hearing in the matter took place before this Tribunal

on 02.11.2026 when the Ld. AR for & on behalf of the

Assessee appeared before us and interalia contended that

the “Impugned Order” is bad in law, illegal and not proper.

It is in the violation of the principle of natural justice. It

therefore deserves to be set aside.

3.2 The Ld. AR has placed on the record of this tribunal a

submission dated 30.10.2026 in support of grounds of the

appeal in two pages.

3.3 The Ld. AR submitted that at the stage of the assessment

proceedings partial compliances were made. In so far as the

Impugned Order is concerned the same is in the violation of

the principles of natural Justice. The assessee is an

agriculturist by the profession and is not well-versed in the

use of e-mail and does not understand the English

language. The notice(s) of opportunity as is recorded in Para

5 of the “Impugned Order” were not to his knowledge and

therefore the “opportunity offered” could not be utilised.

The Ld. AR basis submission dated 30.10.2026 has

contended that the assessee is now willing to appear and

undertakes to submit all the necessary documents,

explanations, supporting evidences etc. on merits of the case. Per contra the Ld. DR submitted that he leaves the

issue to the wisdom of this tribunal to take an appropriate

call basis law. The hearing was then over and closed.

4.

Observations Findings & conclusions

4.1 We have to decide the legality, validity and proprietary of the

“impugned order” basis records of the case & the rival

submission canvassed before us.

4.2 We have carefully perused the records of the case and have

heard the submissions.

4.3 We basis records of the case & after hearing & further

upon examining the rival contentions of the Ld. AR & the Ld.

DR canvassed before us are of the considered opinion that

in so far as the “Impugned Assessment Order” is concerned

the assessee was partly compliant whereas in the

“Impugned Order” the assessee was totally non-compliant.

The reason canvassed for non-compliant attitude is that the

assessee is an agriculturist and does not understand the

English language. He is not tech savvy too. Now the Ld. AR before us has undertaken to be compliant before the Ld. CIT

(A) as is recorded by us (supra). Under these facts and

circumstances of the case we set aside the Impugned Order

as and by way of remand back to the file of the Ld. CIT(A) by

taking a benevolent view in order to meet ends of the Justice.

4.4 In view of the above, we set aside the “Impugned Order”

and remand the case back to the file of the Ld. CIT (A) on de

novo basis.

5 Order

5.1 In the result Impugned Order is set aside as and by way of

remand back to the file of the Ld. CIT (A) on de novo basis.

5.2 The appeal of the Assessee is allowed for statistical

purpose.

Pronounced in open court on 13.11.2026.

Sd/- Sd/- (ARVIND SONI) (PARESH M JOSHI) ACCOUNTANT MEMBER JUDICIAL MEMBER

Indore Dated : 13/11/2026

Copies to: (1) The appellant (2) The respondent (3) CIT (4) CIT(A) Akhilesh Digitally signed by Akhilesh Kumar (5) Departmental Representative Kumar Date: 2026.11.16 18:23:12 +05'30' (6) Guard File By order UE COPY Senior Private Secretary Income Tax Appellate Tribunal Indore Bench, Indore

Page 24 of 24

More judgments on Section 147

All 57,238 judgments and leading authorities on Section 147 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →