SUSHIL AJMERA,RATLAM vs. ITO, RATLAM

PDF · subscribers
ITA 1035/IND/2025Status: DisposedITAT Indore13 November 2026AY 2017-1818 pages
AI SummaryRemanded

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal set aside the impugned order and remanded the case back to the Assessing Officer (AO) for de novo adjudication. The Tribunal noted the assessee's assertion that all details were filed on 06.11.2019 in response to a notice under Section 142(1), although without proof of acknowledgement. The Tribunal directed the assessee to meet all requirements of the AO regarding the addition of Rs. 34,32,604/-, providing proper explanation and justification based on law to claim deduction under Section 57. The AO is to exercise due diligence, conduct necessary inquiries and verification, and then pass a reasoned and speaking order on merits. The appeal of the assessee was allowed for statistical purposes.

What were the facts?

The assessee, Sushil Kumar Ajmera, is in appeal before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Indore Bench, against the order of the CIT(A) dated 21.10.2025 for Assessment Year 2017-18. The Assessing Officer (AO) had made an addition of Rs. 46,34,830/- to the total income, which was Rs. 12,02,230/- as per the return. This addition was primarily due to the disallowance of a deduction of Rs. 34,32,604/- claimed under Section 57 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, towards brokerage, consultancy charges, and interest paid to others. The case was selected under limited scrutiny due to salary and large deduction claims against income from other sources. The assessee was non-compliant with notices issued under Section 142(1) of the Act, failing to furnish details and supporting documents for the claimed expenses.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the disallowance of expenses amounting to Rs. 34,32,604/- claimed under Section 57 of the Act is justified, considering the assessee's alleged non-compliance and failure to provide supporting documentary evidence for brokerage, consultancy, and interest payments. Assessee's Contention: The assessee argued that all details were furnished vide a reply dated 06.11.2019 in response to a notice under Section 142(1) dated 02.11.2019, and the AO overlooked these. The assessee also contended that the interest and brokerage paid should be deducted from interest income as per Section 57(iii), as it was incurred wholly and exclusively for earning such income. The assessee further argued that the AO was not justified in disallowing the interest and brokerage paid. Revenue's Contention: The revenue contended that the assessee failed to substantiate the claim of expenditure with supporting evidence, despite several opportunities. The CIT(A) observed that while certain ledger extracts were filed, no supporting documentary evidence like loan agreements, confirmations, PANs, purpose of borrowings, or proof of utilization of funds was placed on record. The revenue relied on the findings of the lower authorities that the mere filing of ledger accounts does not discharge the onus of proving the nexus between expenditure claimed and income earned.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 253,Section 250,Section 144(3),Section 57,Section 143(3),Section 142(1),Section 246A,Section 57(iii)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, INDORE BENCH, INDORE

For Appellant: CA & Sh
For Respondent: Shri Binay Kumar Rai, Sr.DR
Hearing: 02.11.2026Pronounced: 13.11.2026

Per Paresh M Joshi, J.M:

This is an appeal filed by the Assessee under section 253 of

the income tax Act 1961,[ hereinafter referred to as the Act

for the sake of brevity] before this tribunal, as & by way of a

second appeal .The Assessee is aggrieved by the order

bearing No:-ITBA/APL/S/250/2025-26/1081885463(1)

dated 21.10.2025 passed by the Ld. CIT(A) u/s 250 of the

Act, which is hereinafter referred to as the “Impugned

order”. The Relevant Assessment year is 2017-18 and the corresponding previous year period is from 01.04.2016 to

31.03.2017.

2.

Factual Matrix

2.1 That as & by way of an assessment order made u/s

144(3) of the Act, the total Income of the assessee was

computed and assessed at Rs. 46,34,830/- [R/O]. The total

income as per the return of income was at Rs. 12,02,230/-.

The deduction u/s 57 of the act was made at Rs.

34,32,604/-. That the aforesaid assessment order bears

Number: - ITBA/AST/S/143(3)/2019-20/1021343448(1)

and that the same is dated 29.11.2019 which herein after

referred to as the “Impugned assessment order”.

2.2 That the assessee had filed a return of Income for the

Assessment Year 2017-18 on 14.03.2018 declaring total

income of Rs. 12,02,230/-.

2.3 That the case of the assessee was selected under limited

scrutiny through CASS on the basis of salary and large

deduction claim against the income from other sources.

2.4 Notice u/s 143(2) was issued on 09.08.2018 and served

upon the assessee on 06.09.2018.

2.5 That vide notice u/s 142(1) dated 05.04.2019 the

assessee was asked to furnish the information/details on

22.04.2019. No compliance was made by the assessee.

2.6 That once again a notice u/s 142(1) dated 05.08.2019

was issued to the assessee & that he was asked to furnish

the information/details on 13.08.2019. The assessee filed

details of expenses of Rs. 34,34,551/- on 13.08.2019. On

the examination of details of the expenses in was noticed

that the assessee Paid brokerage of Rs. 77,400/- & that

interest paid to others of Rs. 33,54,039/-.

2.7 That vide notice dated 09.10.2019 the assessee was

asked to furnish the information/details i.e. names, address

& the amounts to for which of the persons (“the interest”)

was paid & their ledger copy. The Assessee was asked to

furnish reply on 18.10.2019. However it is recorded in the

“Impugned assessment order” that No compliance was

made.

2.8 That in view of the principles of natural justice a notice

u/s 142(1)/show cause notice dated 02.11.2019 was issued

calling upon the assessee to show cause as to why the

deduction claimed of brokerage of Rs. 77,400/-, consultancy

charges of Rs. 1165/- & interest amounts paid to others of

Rs. 33,54,039/- u/s 57 of the act should not be disallowed &

added the total income of the assesse. In this regard also the

assessee was non-compliant which fact is recorded in the

“Impugned assessment order”.

2.9 That it is recorded in the “Impugned assessment order”

by the Ld. Assessing Officer as under:-

“On examination of computation of total

income from other sources of Income Tax

Return for the A.Y.2017-18, it was noticed that

the assessee has received interst of Rs.

31,36,396/- from firm and others and claimed

deduction amounting to Rs. 34,34,551/-.

Further. On examination of record it was

noticed that the assessee claimed brokerage of

Rs. 77,400/-, consultancy charge of Rs. 1165/- and interest paid others of Rs. 33,54,039/-.

Vide above mentioned notices u/s 142(1), the

assessee was asked to furnish the

information/details of expenses with cogent

and supporting documents. No compliance was

made by the assessee. Hence, the assessee has

failed to furnish the details of deduction claim

of expenses. Therefore, claim of deduction

amounting to Rs. 34,32,604/- is disallowed and

added to the total Income of the assessee”.

(Addition of Rs. 34,32,604/-)

2.10 That the Assessee being aggrieved by the aforesaid

“Impugned Assessment Order” prefers the first appeal u/s

246A of the Act before the Ld. CIT (A) who by the

“Impugned Order” has dismissed the first appeal of the

Assessee on the grounds & the reasons stated therein. The

core grounds & the reasons for the dismissal the first

appeal was as under:- “6. The Assessing Officer observed that during

the course of assessment proceedings, despite

several opportunities, the assessee failed to

substantiate the claim of expenditure with

supporting evidence. The assessee was required

to furnish party-wise details, confirmations,

and purpose of payment in respect of interest,

brokerage, and consultancy charges. The AO

held that no such verifiable evidence was

produced and accordingly disallowed

34,32,604/-.In the appellate proceedings, the

assessee contended that all details were

furnished vide reply dated 06.11.2019 in

response to notice under section 142(1) dated

02.11.2019, and that the AO nad overlooked

the same. However, on careful perusal of the

assessment records and written submissions, it

is noticed that while certain ledger extracts

were filed, no supporting documentary evidence

such as loan agreements, confirmation from parties, PANs, purpose of borrowings, or proof

of utilization of funds was placed on record.

The mere filing of ledger accounts does not

discharge the onus of proving the nexus

between expenditure claimed and income

earned. Therefore, the contention of the

assessee that details were submitted and not

considered is not substantiated. The AO's

finding that no proper evidence was filed is

correct.

7.

The assessee claimed that interest

expenditure of 34,33,662/- was allowable under

section 57(iii) as it was incurred wholly and

exclusively for earning interest income. Section

57 (iii) allows deduction for expenditure "laid

out or expended wholly and exclusively for the

purpose of making or earning such income."

The onus is on the assessee to establish a

direct nexus between the expenditure claimed and the income earned.In the present case, no

evidence was produced to demonstrate that the

borrowed funds were utilized for earning

interest income or that brokerage and

consultancy payments had any proximate

connection with the income shown. The claim

remains unsubstantiated In the absence of

documentary proof establishing the purpose

and nexus, the Assessing Officer's disallowance

of the said expenditure is Held to be correct in

law and on facts.

8.

The appellant has also not submitted the

individual Unsecured Loan party Ledgers to

cross check the Loans received in the bank

account and the interest paid to those parties.

The assessee has received interest as per the

P&L account and the appellant has not

properly highlighted the interest received in

the bank account. As per section 57of the IT Act 1961, the appellant should establish the

direct nexus between the Income and the

expenditure claimed as deduction to avail the

claim along with proper documentary

evidences. The appellant has also mentioned

that he has submitted all the necessary details

before the AO during the assessment

proceedings but the appellant has not

uploaded any proof such as the

acknowledgement letter/ or proof of actually

submitting the same to the AO, before the

appellate proceedings and failed to establish

the proof with respect to the Grounds of appeal

raised in point No.1, 2 and 3 and the appellant

was given reasonable opportunity during the

assessment proceedings which are detailed in

Para 5.1 above and in which it is seen that the

appellant has responded only once during the

entire assessment proceedings as per the

assessment order and during the appeal proceedings the appellant has furnished the

details which are listed in the para 5.4 above

and the final reply given by the appellant is

given below for ready reference:-

8.1 From the above reply it is seen that the

appellant has stated that the TDS was made

and the Loans were received through account

payee cheques but the appellant has not

uploaded the necessary Ledger account of the

parties to cross check with the bank statement

and also the bank statement is also not legible

and the TDS made proof also not submitted

and the appellant has not satisfactorily proven

the Grounds raised by him. After careful

consideration of the assessment order,

submissions, and material on record, it is held

that the Assessing Officer's addition of

34,32,604/- towards disallowance of brokerage,

consultancy charges, and interest expenditure is confirmed. The assessee has not been able to

furnish satisfactory evidence to establish the

genuineness or allow ability of the said

expenditure under the provisions of the Act.

8.2 In view of the above discussion the Grounds

in Point No. 1, 2 and 3 are DISMISSED. The

appellant also failed to establish the direct

nexus between the income earned ant he

expenditure claimed with documentary

evidences. Hence the Ground No 4 is also

DISMISSED.

9.

In the result, the appeal is DISMISSED.

2.11 That the Assessee being aggrieved by the “Impugned

Order” has preferred the Instant Second Appeal before this

Tribunal & has raised the following grounds of appeal in the form

No: -36 against the “Impugned Order” which are as under: - “1. The Assessee took unsecured loans for

business purpose only. He submitted/uploaded

electronically the copies of unsecured loan A/Cs

duly confirmed by the respective parties with their

PAN and also copies of interest A/C and brokerage

A/C. Therefore the AO is not fair and reasonable in

disallowing interest and brokerage expenses of Rs.

3438604/-paid by the Assessee.

2.

The Assessee paid interest and brokerage of Rs.

3431439/- and also earned interest income of Rs.

3136396/-. As per provisions of Sec. 57(iii) also -

The income should be computed after making

deduction of expenditure for the purpose of

making such income. Therefore the Interest

expense and the brokerage paid should be

deducted from interest income. The AO is therefore

also not fair and justified in disallowing interest

and brokerage of Rs. 3438604/- paid by the

Assessee.”

3.

Record of Hearing

3.1 The hearing in the matter took place before this Tribunal

on 02.11.2026 when the Ld. AR for & on behalf of the

Assessee appeared before us and interalia contended that

the “Impugned Order” is bad in law, illegal and not proper.

It therefore deserves to be set aside.

3.2 The Ld. AR has placed on the record of this Tribunal a

paper book containing pages 1 to 60. Paper book page 61 to

62 was tendered by the Ld. AR across bar on 02.11.2026.

3.3 The Ld.AR submitted that the assessee has income from

the salary [Partnership Firm] and in addition interest income

too, during the year under consideration. In this regard our

attention was invited to the paper book page 58 & 59. There

is the repayment of interest on the loans amounting to Rs.

33,54,000/- approximate. The assessee in personal capacity

had taken loans form the several parties for the purpose of

making investment in the firm where he was a partner. The

Ld. AR fairly stated that no details of loans were there

together with the interest before the Ld. Assessing Officer as nothing is mentioned in the “Impugned Assessment Order” in

this regard. However all the details were furnished vide reply

dated 06.11.2019 in response to notice u/s 142(1) dated

02.11.2019 asserted the Ld. AR but same were not

considered by the Ld. Assessing Officer in the “Impugned

Assessment Order”. Upon a query by the Bench whether

there is an acknowledgement of such a filing and/or proof

the Ld. AR fairly stated that there is no such

acknowledgement/proof of delivery. Per contra the Ld. SDR

Shri Rai appearing for the revenue submitted that by virtue

of section 57(iii) of the Act there is no nexus between income

and expenditure and orders of the lower authorities are

correct and proper. The Ld. Sr. DR then has placed reliance

on para 5.4 of the “Impugned order” & then basis para 6 pf

the “Impugned order” it was contended that Ld. CIT(A) has

rightly held that “However, on careful perusal of the

assessment records and written submissions, it is

noticed that while certain ledger extracts were filed, no

supporting documentary evidence such as loan

agreements, confirmation from parties, PANs, purpose of borrowings, or proof of utilization of funds was placed

on record. The mere filing of ledger accounts does not

discharge the onus of proving the nexus between

expenditure claimed and income earned. Therefore, the

contention of the assessee that details were submitted

and not considered is not substantiated. The AO's

finding that no proper evidence was filed is correct.

In the rejoinder argument Ld. AR prayed that in view of the

peculiar facts & circumstances which has emerged where

there is assertion by Ld. AR & denial by Ld. DR it would be

in fitness of the things, that the matter be rejected back to

the file of Ld. Assessing Officer for denovo adjudication

where full facts can be verified by Ld. Assessing Officer. The

Hearing was then over & was closed.

4.

Observations Findings & conclusions

4.1 We have to decide the legality, validity and proprietary of the

“impugned order” basis records of the case & the rival

submission canvassed before us.

4.2 We have carefully perused the records of the case and have

heard the submissions.

4.3 We basis records of the case & after hearing & further

upon examining the rival contentions of the Ld. AR & the Ld.

DR canvassed before us, are of the considered opinion that

the “Impugned assessment order” is under section 143(3)

of the act where we notice & observe that by & large the

assessee was non-compliant which led to disallowance of Rs.

34,32,604/- u/s 57 of the act. The Ld. AR during the hearing

has emphasised that all details were filed on 06.11.2019 in

response to notice u/s 142(1) dated 02.11.2019 but without

any proof of acknowledgement. Be that as it may we now

direct the assessee to meet all the requirement of Ld.

Assessing Officer with regard to the additions made of Rs.

34,32,604/- & to give proper explanation & justification

basis law in order to claim deduction u/s 57. We accordingly

set aside the Impugned order & remand the case to the Ld.

Assessing Officer with directions that upon furnishing full &

complete particulars to his satisfaction, the Ld. Assessing

Officer would exercise due diligence, conduct all necessary inquiries & verification & then shall proceed to pass a

reasoned & speaking order on merits.

4.4 In view of the above, we set aside the “Impugned Order”

& remand the case back to the file of the Ld. Assessing Officer on

denovo basis, which shall now pass a speaking & well-reasoned

order.

5 Order

5.1 In result the impugned order is set aside as and by way of

remand back to the file of the Ld. Assessing Officer.

5.2 The appeal of the Assessee is allowed for statistical purpose.

Pronounced in open court on 13.11.2026.

Sd/- Sd/- (ARVIND SONI) (PARESH M JOSHI) ACCOUNTANT MEMBER JUDICIAL MEMBER

Indore Dated: 13 /11/2026

Copies to: (1) The appellant (2) The respondent (3) CIT (4) CIT(A) (5) Departmental Representative (6) Guard File Akhilesh Kumar Digitally signed by Akhilesh Kumar Date: 2026.11.13 00:31:05 +05'30' By order UE COPY Senior Private Secretary Income Tax Appellate Tribunal Indore Bench, Indore

More judgments on Section 57

All 1,287 judgments and leading authorities on Section 57 →

Latest GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →