MANOHAR LAL PARASWANI AND SONS JEWELLERS vs. UNION OF INDIA AND 2 OTHERS

PDF · subscribers
WTAX/1215/2022HC AllahabadUPHC01174437202216 October 20222 pages
AI SummaryRemanded

What did the High Court hold?

The Tribunal held that the order dated 30.7.2020 passed under Section 148A(d) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, was a non-speaking order. The language of the impugned order did not disclose the mind of the adjudicating authority concerning the objections raised by the assessee. The Tribunal referred to the Supreme Court's decision in Union of India vs. Ashish Agarwal, highlighting that Section 148A was introduced to streamline the procedure, mandating the Assessing Officer to conduct an enquiry, provide an opportunity of being heard, and pass an order on the basis of material available, including the assessee's reply. Since the impugned order failed to demonstrate consideration of the assessee's reply and lacked proper reasoning, it could not be sustained. The Tribunal rejected the revenue's request for time to file a counter-affidavit, stating that reasons must be evident from the order itself. Consequently, the order was set aside, and the matter was relegated for fresh consideration in accordance with the law.

What were the facts?

The petitioner, Manohar Lal Paraswani And Sons Jewellers, is challenging an order dated 30.7.2020 passed under Section 148A(d) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The petitioner submits that they had duly submitted a reply under Section 148 of the Act, but this reply was summarily rejected with a one-line statement that it was 'not acceptable'. The revenue, represented by Union of India and two others, sought time to file a counter-affidavit. The Tribunal noted that reasons for an order must be found within the order itself and cannot be supplemented by a counter-affidavit.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the order passed under Section 148A(d) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, is a speaking order that duly considers the assessee's reply. (Question of law and fact) The assessee argued that their reply under Section 148 was not duly considered and was rejected in a non-speaking manner. They relied on the Supreme Court's observations in Union of India vs. Ashish Agarwal regarding the procedure under Section 148A, emphasizing the need for the Assessing Officer to consider the assessee's reply and pass an order based on available material. The revenue, through their counsel, sought time to file a counter-affidavit, implying a need to provide further justification for the order.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 148A,Section 148

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Court No. - 39 Case :- WRIT TAX No. - 1215 of 2022 Petitioner :- Manohar Lal Paraswani And Sons Jewellers Respondent :- Union Of India And 2 Others Counsel for Petitioner :- Abhinav Mehrotra Counsel for Respondent :- A.S.G.I.,Gaurav Mahajan Hon'ble Mrs. Sunita Agarwal,J. Hon'ble Vipin Chandra Dixit,J. Heard Sri Abhinav Malhotra, learned counsel for the petitioner and Sri Manu Gildiyal, learned counsel for respondent. The order dated 30.7.2020 passed under Section 148A Clause (d) of Income Tax Act, 1961 is subject matter of challenge in the present petition. It is demonstrated by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the reply under Section 148 of Income Tax Act, 1961 was duly submitted by the petitioner. The said reply was not duly considered and was rejected in one line by saying that the reply of the Assessee has been found not acceptable. The attention of the Court is invited to the observation made by the Apex Court in the case of Union of India and Others vs. Ashish Agarwal decided on 4.5.2022. The said decision has been placed before us which is relevant to quote hereunder:- "6.3 But prior to pre-Finance Act, 2021, while reopening an assessment, the procedure of giving the reasons for reopening and an opportunity to the assessee and the decision of the objectives were required to be followed as per the judgment of this Court in the case of GKN Driveshafts (India) Ltd. (supra). 6.4 However, by way of Section 148 A, the procedure has now been streamlined and simplified. It provides that before issuing any notice under Section 148, the assessing officer shall (i) conduct any enquiry, if required, with the approval of specified authority, with respect to the information which suggests that the income chargeable to tax has escaped assessment; (ii) provide an opportunity of being heard to the Assessee, with the prior approval of specified authority; (iii) consider the reply of the Assessee furnished, if any, in response to the showcause notice referred to in clause (b); and (iv) decide, on the basis of material available on record including reply Assessee of the , as to whether or not it is a fit case to issue a notice under Section 148 of the IT Act and (v) the AO is required to pass a specific order within the time stipulated. 6.5 Therefore, all safeguards are provided before notice under Section 148 of the IT Act is issued. At every stage, the prior approval of the specified authority is required, even for conducting the enquiry as per Section 148A(a). Only in a case where, the assessing officer is of the opinion that before any notice is issued under Section 148A(b) and an opportunity is to be given to the Assessee, there is a requirement of conducting any enquiry, the assessing officer may do so and conduct any enquiry. Thus if the

assessing officer is of the opinion that any enquiry is required, the assessing officer can do so, however, with the prior approval of the specified authority, with respect to the information which suggests that the income chargeable to tax has escaped assessment." A careful reading of the said observation about the object of insertion of Section 148A of the Act, shows that the said provision has been incorporated with a view to streamline the procedure, mandating the Assessee Officer to make an enquiry and providing opportunity of being heard. A show-cause notice is required to be furnished to the Assessee and the order under Section 148A of the Act, has to be passed on the basis of the material available on record considering the reply of the Assessee. The language of the order impugned does not disclose the mind of the adjudicating authority on the objection taken by the Assessee. As the order impugned is a non-speaking order, we do not find any reason to sustain the same. Sri Manu Gildiyal, learned counsel for respondents, however, prays for time to file counter affidavit. We may record that the reasoning given in the order has to be found from the order itself and nothing can be supplemented by way of counter affidavit. We, therefore, turn down the request of Mr. Manu Gildiyal, learned counsel for the respondent to file counter affidavit. While setting aside the order dated 30.7.2022 passed by respondent No.2 namely Income Tax Officer Ward 1(1)(1), Kanpur, we relegate the matter for fresh consideration strictly in accordance with law. In view of the above, the writ petition is disposed of. Order Date :- 17.10.2022 S.K. Digitally signed by SWEETY KANOJIA Date: 2022.10.21 13:32:52 IST Reason: Location: High Court of Judicature at Allahabad

More judgments on Section 148A

All 9,462 judgments and leading authorities on Section 148A →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →