RAUZAGAON CHINI MILLS THRU CHIEF GENERAL MANAGER vs. UNION OF INDIA MINISTRY OF FINANCE DEPTT. OF REVENUE and OTHER
What did the High Court hold?
The Tribunal held that the demand for duty under Section 11A of the Central Excise Act was unsustainable. It reasoned that Section 11A empowers recovery of duties not levied or paid, but the present case lacked any allegation or finding of clandestine removal in contravention of Rule 8. The Tribunal emphasized that the burden to allege and establish clandestine removal lies with the department, and no such presumption exists under the Act or Rules. Therefore, the demand of duty without such an allegation and establishment could not be accepted. Furthermore, the Tribunal found that the rejection of the remission application was contrary to the law laid down in the case of Balrampur Chini Mills Ltd. (supra), as the authorities considered the measurement by State Excise authorities as correct for valuation, ignoring that the remission claim was over a larger period. Consequently, the impugned orders rejecting the remission applications were set aside.
What were the facts?
The petitioners, manufacturers of sugar, are challenging orders that rejected their applications for remission of duty on molasses lost during storage. Molasses is a by-product falling under heading 1703 of the Central Excise Tariff Act. The petitioners claimed remission under Rule 21 of the Central Excise Rules for molasses lost due to natural causes. The department issued show-cause notices, proposing recovery of duty amounting to Rs. 1,79,670/- and Rs. 1,08,236/- (in one instance) under Section 11A of the Central Excise Act, along with interest under Section 11AB. The remission applications were rejected by the Order-in-Original, confirmed by the appellate authority, and subsequently by the revisional authority. The primary reason for rejection was the perceived unlikelihood of substantial loss occurring suddenly over a short period, casting doubt on the petitioner's claims.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the demand for Central Excise Duty under Section 11A of the Central Excise Act is sustainable in the absence of any allegation or finding of clandestine removal of molasses in contravention of Rule 8 of the Central Excise Rules? 2. Whether the rejection of the remission application under Rule 21 of the Central Excise Rules, based on the suspicion of loss over a short period, is contrary to the law laid down by this Court? Assessee's arguments: The petitioners argued that the authorities erred in rejecting the remission applications solely on the ground that the claimed loss within a short span was not justifiable. They contended that the demand for duty under Section 11A was unsustainable as there was no allegation or proof of clandestine removal. They also argued that the rejection of remission was contrary to established legal precedents. Revenue's arguments: The revenue contended that if goods are not found in the premises, there is a presumption of clandestine removal. They argued that the duty demanded was justified and the remission applications were rightly rejected.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
Reserved on: 31.8.2022
Delivered on: 23.9.2022 Court No. - 18 Case :- WRIT - C No. - 1000315 of 2014 Petitioner :- Rauzagaon Chini Mills Thru Chief General Manager Respondent :- Union Of India Ministry Of Finance Deptt. Of Revenue And Other Counsel for Respondent :- Deepak Seth CONNECTED WITH Case :- WRIT - C No. - 1001918 of 2013 Petitioner :- Tulsipur Sugar Company Tulsipur Balrampur A Unit Of Balramp Counsel for Petitioner :- Jai Prakash Tripathi,Sudeep Kumar Case :- WRIT - C No. - 1001920 of 2013 Petitioner :- Tulsipur Sugar Company Tulsipur Balrampura Unit Balrampur Case :- WRIT - C No. - 1002507 of 2013 Petitioner :- Mankapur Chini Mills Thru Authorised Signatory/G.M.Comm. Respondent :- Union Of India Min.Of Fin. Deptt.Of Revenue C.B.E.Andc. Andors Case :- WRIT - C No. - 1002512 of 2013 Petitioner :- Balrampur Chini Mills Ltd. Gonda Throu Authorised Signatory Respondent :- Union Of India Ministry Of Finance Deptt.Of Revenue And Ors.
Case :- WRIT - C No. - 1002513 of 2013 Petitioner :- Mankapur Chini Mills Ltd.Mankapur Gonda Thr.Authorised Sign. Respondent :- Union Of India Ministry Of Finance Deptt.Of Revenue And Ors. Case :- WRIT - C No. - 1002508 of 2013 Petitioner :- Balrampur Chini Mills Ltd. Balrampur Thru G.M.Commercial Respondent :- Union Of India Min.Of Fin. Deptt.Of Revenue C.B.E.Andc. Andors Case :- WRIT - C No. - 1001922 of 2013 Petitioner :- Tulsipur Sugar Company Tulsipur Balrampura Unit Balrampur Counsel for Respondent :- A.S.G.,Dipak Seth,Prem Shanker Shukla Hon'ble Pankaj Bhatia,J. 1. All the above referred writ petitions are being taken up together as they arise out of a similar order passed on the same day i.e. 28.01.2013 and deal with the same issue, except that in Writ – C No.1000315 of 2014 revisional order is dated 25.11.2013. 2. For the sake of brevity the facts as narrated in leading case Writ – C No.1000315 of 2014 are being taken up. The individual facts shall be dealt with subsequent in the body of the judgment. 3. The petitioners are manufactures of sugar, and molasses emerges as a by-product which falls under the heading 1703 of the Schedule to the Central Excise Tariff Act. The petitioners are registered with the Central Excise Department. 4. It is stated that the production, storage and sale of molasses is carried out by the petitioner under the physical control and supervision of the State
Authorities in accordance of U.P. Sheera Niyantran Niyamavali, 1974. It is argued that the Inspector of the State Excise Department is always posted at the factory to exercise the control and supervision as prescribed under the U.P. Sheera Niyantran Niyamawali, 1974. 5. It is stated that the molasses that emerged in the petitioners’ factory are stored in steel tanks which are provided with calibration charts for calculating estimated quantity of molasses by volumetric method for the financial year 2007 – 08; the petitioner claimed remission of duty on the molasses lost due to storage under Rule 21 of the Central Excise Rules (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Rules’) by filing a remission application as is prescribed under the Rules. The department was of the view that the remission applications have been filed only to enjoy the benefit that flows from Central Board of Excise and Customs (CBEC) Circular No.261/15-CC/ 1/80-CX Dated 06.08.1982 and the petitioner was called to show-cause as to why the remission application may not be rejected and why Central Excise Duty amounting to Rs.1,79,670/- may not be recovered under Section 11A of the Central Excise Act (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’) alongwith interest under Section 11AB of the Act. The duty demanded as referred above, was in respect of Steel Tank No.1 for the petitioner’s factory. With regard to Steel Tank No.3, the duty demanded was Rs.1,08,236/-. 6. The two show-cause notices, both dated 07.01.2009, were replied to by the petitioner mainly reiterating that the loss was within the prescribed limit and the petitioner was entitled to the benefit of the said circular. The demand mentioned in the show-cause notice was confirmed vide Order-in- Original dated 31.12.2009; the claim of the petitioner with regard to the remission of duty was rejected mainly on the ground that on physical verification as done from time to time, no substantial loss was found till 23.06.2008 and all of a sudden in 81 days, the loss as claimed by the petitioner, was deducted, which was unlikely. The petitioner preferred an appeal against the said order, which was rejected by the appellate authority vide Order-in-Appeal dated 28.06.2011. The petitioner preferred a revision
under Section 35EE of the Act, which too has been dismissed vide order dated 25.11.2013 affirming the findings as recorded by the Authorities while passing the order-in-original and appellate order. The said orders are under challenge by all the petitioners. 7. In all the cases, the application for remission of duty under Rule 21 of the Rule has been rejected on the same grounds. The chart showing the remission of duty as claimed by the petitioners in their various tanks, the date of filing of the applications, the date of issuance of the show-cause notice and the dates when the three orders, impugned herein, were passed, is reproduced herein below: Case No. Steel Tank Number and Total Production Total Qt. Lost (Qtl.) % of total qyt. Lost Value of molasses lost Remission application Show-cause notice/ Order-In- Original/ Order-In- Appeal/ Revisional Order Tank No.3 No.3 Tank No.3 No.1000315/2014 (Rauzagaon Chini 84296 qtl. 145180.62 qtl. + 23962.60 opening balance = 169143.22 1401.10 1.66 2325.82 1.38 1,79,670/- 1,08,236/- 30.06.2008 15.09.2008 07.01.2009/ 31.12.2009/ 28.06.2011/ 25.11.2013 No.1002508/2013 (Balrampur Chini Tank No.6 No.6 No.2 / Tank No.6 07.01.2009 21.04.2009/ 02.12.2009/ 02.09.2011/ 412085 302390 2681.20 0.65 2381.90 0.79 2,07,123/- 1,84,002/- No.1002507/2013 3787.30 2448.40 1.34 2,92,569/- 1,89,139/- No.1002513/2013 362320 312838 5743.70 5249.20 4,73,702/-
1.59 1.68 4,05,501/- No.1002512/2013 (Balrampur Chini No.4 No.4 Tank No.4/ 15.09.2008 09.09.2009/ 27.01.2010/ 31.03.2011/ 582338.
582338.80 3323.20 0.57 3250.60 1.48 2,56,717/- 2,51,109/- No.1001920/2013 362320 312838 5743.70 1.59 5249.20 1.68 4,43,702/- 4,05,50/- No.1001922/2013 (Tulsipur Sugar Co. v. U.O.I. & 23.08.2006 13.09.2007/ 28.12.2009/ 217036 4114.90 1.86 3,14,790/- No.1001918/2013 (Tulsipur Sugar Co. v. U.O.I. & Tank No.7 No.7 No.5 / Tank No.7 26.09.2008 11.09.2008 18.12.2008 as corrected on 13.11.2009/ 18.12.2009/ 05.09.2011/ 197431.
159221.60 3616 1.83 2945.60 1.85 2,79,336/- 2,27,548/- 8. Shri Rahul Agarwal, learned counsel holding brief of Shri Rishabh Pandey, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners argues that the Authorities have erred in rejecting the remission application mainly on the ground that within a short span of time the huge loss as claimed by the petitioner could not be justified. He attacks the said finding on the ground that the measurements are regularly taken by the State Excise Authorities by using a dip method, however, the actual value of loss can be ascertained only when the tanks are emptied. He argues that the dip method does not accurately depict the quantity stored as there is a formation of froth. In any case, he argues that the remission as claimed by the petitioner was well within the prescribed limit as accepted by the department while issuing the Circulars dated 18.07.1983, 22.10.1982 and 06.08.1982 wherein the claim of loss upto the extent of 2% is liable to be condoned.
Learned counsel for the petitioners argues that the said circulars issued by CBEC are binding on the department and the department could not have taken the view ignoring the said circulars as has been done by the impugned orders. He next submits that this issue as to the loss during a particular year or from the last date of the verification would be relevant and this Court while deciding the issue in Balrampur Chini Mills Ltd. V. Commissioner of C. Ex., Allahabad; 2017 (349) E.L.T. 206 (All.) has observed in Para – 4 as under: “4. Admittedly, there is no allegation made by respondents that there is an abrupt removal of molasses from storage tank so as not to justify remission of aforesaid loss. In absence of any such allegation as also any statutory provision providing that the period of “a year” will not include part of year, if loss is less than two per cent, which has caused due to natural reasons, in our view remission could not have been disallowed/ allowed to assessee. In taking an otherwise view, Tribunal has assumed certain facts which is not permissible for the reason that if any allegation is made against assessee by Revenue, the same would have to be proved by Revenue which burden cannot be side tracked by taking a plea that loss has caused in a very small period i.e. in an indirect way. Rule 8(4) of Rules, 1974, for its application, does not require that “year” would mean the entire period of 12 months, and not a smaller part thereof. In absence of any law otherwise taking a different view, we are clearly of the view that plain and simple interpretation should be given to Rule 8(4) of Rules, 1974 which permits remission in case loss is less than 2 per cent within the period of a year which includes ‘part of a year’ also.” 10. He further argues that in any case there is no allegation of removal of molasses without payment of duty, which is essentially to be alleged while issuing notices under Section 11A of the Act for recovery of the duty. He further argues that there is no allegation of clandestine removal against the petitioner even in the show-cause notice, nor any finding to that effect has been recorded in any of the orders passed and impugned herein. He further places reliance on the judgment of this Court in the case of The Kisan Sahkari Chini Mills Ltd. V. Union of India; Writ – C No.1000920 of 2012 decided on 22.08.2022. 11. In the light of the said, he argues that the petitions are liable to be allowed and orders impugned are liable to be set aside. 12. Shri Deepak Seth, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents argues that no error can be found in the order, inasmuch as it is
well settled that the claim of remission from payment of duty, is not automatic and the producer is still under obligation to establish the loss occurred despite due precaution and care as has been held by this Court in the case of Kesar Enterprises Ltd. (Sugar Div.) v. Commr. Of Cus. & C. Ex., Meerut-II; 2008 (221) E.L.T. 329 (All.). He argues that the S.L.P. preferred against the said judgment has been dismissed. 13. In reply to the argument of Shri Rahul Agarwal that there was no allegation of clandestine removal and for recovery of any duty it is essential to allege that the duty has not been paid at the time of removal or the goods have been clandestinely removed, he argues that if the goods are not found in the premises there is a presumption that the goods have been clandestinely removed. On the strength of the said, he argues that the writ petitions are liable to be dismissed. 14. To analyze the submissions made at the Bar it is relevant to refer to the statutory provisions as contained in the Act being Section 11A and Rule 4, 8 & 21 of the Central Excise Rules (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Rules’), which govern the issue. This Court while deciding the issue which arose in the case of The Kishan Sahkari Chini Mills Ltd. (supra) had considered the scope of Section 11A of the Act and Rule 4, 8, 21 & 25 of the Rules. The said Sections and Rules are quoted herein below: “SECTION 11A. Recovery of duties not levied or not paid or short-levied or short-paid or erroneously refunded. - (1) Where any duty of excise has not been levied or paid or has been short-levied or short- paid or erroneously refunded, for any reason, other than the reason of fraud or collusion or any wilful mis-statement or suppression of facts or contravention of any of the provisions of this Act or of the rules made thereunder with intent to evade payment of duty;- (a) the Central Excise Officer shall, within two years from the relevant date, serve notice on the person chargeable with the duty which has not been so levied or paid or which has been so short-levied or short- paid or to whom the refund has erroneously been made, requiring him to show cause why he should not pay the amount specified in the notice; (b) the person chargeable with duty may, before service of notice under clause (a), pay on the basis of, - (i) his own ascertainment of such duty; or (ii) the duty ascertained by the Central Excise Officer, the amount of duty along with interest payable thereon under section 11AA.
(2) The person who has paid the duty under clause (b) of sub- section (1), shall inform the Central Excise Officer of such payment in writing, who, on receipt of such information, shall not serve any notice under clause (a) of that sub-section in respect of the duty so paid or any penalty leviable under the provisions of this Act or the rules made thereunder. (3) Where the Central Excise Officer is of the opinion that the amount paid under clause (b) of sub-section (1) falls short of the amount actually payable, then, he shall proceed to issue the notice as provided for in clause (a) of that sub-section in respect of such amount which falls short of the amount actually payable in the manner specified under that sub-section and the period of two years shall be computed from the date of receipt of information under sub-section (2). (4) Where any duty of excise has not been levied or paid or has been short-levied or short-paid or erroneously refunded, by the reason of (a) fraud; or (b) collusion; or (c) any wilful mis-statement; or (d) suppression of facts; or (e) contravention of any of the provisions of this Act or of the rules made thereunder with intent to evade payment of duty, by any person chargeable with the duty, the Central Excise Officer shall, within five years from the relevant date, serve notice on such person requiring him to show cause why he should not pay the amount specified in the notice along with interest payable thereon under section 11AA and a penalty equivalent to the duty specified in the notice. (5) to (7) *
(7A) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1) or sub- section (3) or sub-section (4). the Central Excise Officer may, serve, subsequent to any notice or notices served under any of those sub- sections, as the case may be, a statement, containing the details of duty of central excise not levied or paid or short-levied or short-paid or erroneously refunded for the subsequent period, on the person chargeable to duty of central excise, then, service of such statement shall be deemed to be service of notice on such person under the aforesaid sub-section (1) or sub-section (3) or sub-section (4) or sub-section (5), subject to the condition that the grounds relied upon for the subsequent period are the same as are mentioned in the earlier notice or notices. (8) Where the service of notice is stayed by an order of a court or tribunal, the period of such stay shall be excluded in computing the period of two years referred to in clause (a) of sub-section (1) or five years referred to in sub-section (4), as the case may be. (9) Where any appellate authority or tribunal or court concludes that the notice issued under sub-section (4) is not sustainable for the reason that the charges of fraud or collusion or any wilful mis-statement or suppression of facts or contravention of any of the provisions of this Act or of the rules made thereunder with intent to evade payment of duty has not been established against the person to whom the notice was issued, the Central Excise Officer shall determine the duty of excise payable by such person for the period of two years deeming as if the notice were issued under clause (a) of sub-section (1). (10) The Central Excise Officer shall, after allowing the concerned person an opportunity of being heard, and after considering the representation, if any, made by such person, determine the amount of duty of excise due from such person not being in excess of the amount specified in the notice.
(11) The Central Excise Officer shall determine the amount of duty of excise under sub-section (10) - (a) within six months from the date of notice where it is possible to do so, in respect of cases falling under sub-section (1); (b) within two years from the date of notice, where it is possible to do so, in respect of cases falling under sub-section (4) (12) Where the appellate authority or tribunal or court modifies the amount of duty of excise determined by the Central Excise Officer under sub-section (10), then the amount of penalties and interest under this section shall stand modified accordingly, taking into account the amount of duty of excise so modified. (13) Where the amount as modified by the appellate authority or tribunal or court is more than the amount determined under sub-section (10) by the Central Excise Officer, the time within which the interest or penalty is payable under this Act shall be counted from the date of the order of the appellate authority or tribunal or court in respect of such increased amount. (14) Where an order determining the duty of excise is passed by the Central Excise Officer under this section, the person liable to pay the said duty of excise shall pay the amount so determined along with the interest due on such amount whether or not the amount of interest is specified separately. (15) The provisions of sub-sections (1) to (14) shall apply, mutatis mutandis, to the recovery of interest where interest payable has not been paid or part paid or erroneously refunded. (16) The provisions of this section shall not apply to a case where the liability of duty not paid or short-paid is self-assessed and declared as duty, payable by the assessee in the periodic returns filed by him, and in such case, recovery of non-payment or short-payment of duty shall be made in such manner as may be prescribed. Explanation 1.-For the purposes of this section and section 11AC,- (a) "refund" includes rebate of duty of excise on excisable goods exported out of India or on excisable materials used in the manufacture of goods which are exported out of India; (b) " relevant date", means, - (i) in the case of excisable goods on which duty of excise has not been levied or paid or has been short-levied or short-paid, and no periodical return as required by the provisions of this Act has been filed, the last date on which such return is required to be filed under this Act and the rules made thereunder; (ii) in the case of excisable goods on which duty of excise has not been levied or paid or has been short-levied or short-paid and the return has been filed, the date on which such return has been filed; (iii) in any other case, the date on which duty of excise is required to be paid under this Act or the rules made thereunder; (iv) in a case where duty of excise is provisionally assessed under this Act or the rules made thereunder, the date of adjustment of duty after the final assessment thereof; (v) in the case of excisable goods on which duty of excise has been erroneously refunded, the date of such refund; (vi) in the case where only interest is to be recovered, the date of payment of duty to which such interest relates. Explanation 2.- For the removal of doubts, it is hereby declared that any non-levy, short-levy, non payment, short-payment or erroneous
refund where no show cause notice has been issued before the date on which the Finance Bill, 2015 receives the assent of the President, shall be governed by the provisions of section 11A as amended by the Finance Act, 2015. RULE 4. Duty payable on removal. - (1) Every person who produces or manufactures any excisable goods, or who stores such goods in a warehouse, shall pay the duty leviable on such goods in the manner provided in rule 8 or under any other law, and no excisable goods, on which any duty is payable, shall be removed without payment of duty from any place, where they are produced or manufactured, or from a warehouse, unless otherwise provided: (1A) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-rule (1), every person who gets the goods, falling under Chapter 61 or 62 or 63 of the First Schedule to the Tariff Act, produced or manufactured on his account on job work, shall pay the duty leviable on such goods, at such time and in such manner as is provided under these rules, as if such goods have been manufactured by such person: Provided that where any person had, instead of paying duty, authorized job worker to pay the duty leviable on goods manufactured in his behalf under the provisions of sub-rule (1A) as it stood prior to the publication of this notification, he shall be allowed to obtain registration and comply with the provisions of these rules within a period of thirty days from the date of publication of this notification in the Official Gazette. (2) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-rule (1), where molasses are produced in a khandsari sugar factory, the person who procures such molasses, whether directly from such factory or otherwise, for use in the manufacture of any commodity, whether or not excisable, shall pay the duty leviable on such molasses, in the same manner as if such molasses have been produced by the procurer. (3)* (4) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-rule (1), Principal Commissioner or Commissioner, as the case may be may, in exceptional circumstances having regard to the nature of the goods and shortage of storage space at the premises of the manufacturer where the goods are made, permit a manufacturer to store his goods in any other place outside such premises, without payment of duty subject to such conditions as he may specify. RULE 8. Manner of payment.-(1) The duty on the goods removed from the factory or the warehouse during a month shall be paid by the 6th day of the following month, if the duty is paid electronically through internet banking and by the 5th day of the following month, in any other case: Provided that in case of goods removed during the month of March, the duty shall be paid by the 31st day of March: Provided further that where an assessee is eligible to avail of the exemption under a notification based on the value of clearances in a financial year, the duty on goods cleared during a quarter of the financial year shall be paid by the 6th day of the month following that quarter, if the duty is paid electronically through internet banking and in any other case, by the 5th day of the month following that quarter, except in case of goods
removed during the last quarter, starting from the 1st day of January and ending on the 31st day of March, for which the duty shall be paid by the 31st day of March. Explanation-1.- For the removal of doubts, it is hereby clarified that. - (a) * (b) an assessee, shall be eligible, if his aggregate value of clearances of all excisable goods for home consumption in the preceding financial year, computed in the manner specified in the said notification, did not exceed rupees four hundred lakhs. Explanation-2. The manner of payment as specified in this proviso shall be available to the assessee for the whole of the financial year. [ * *] Explanation. For the purposes of this rule - (a) the duty liability shall be deemed to have been discharged only if the amount payable is credited to the account of the Central Government by the specified date; (b) if the assessee deposits the duty by cheque, the date of presentation of the cheque in the bank designated by the Central Board of Excise and Customs for this purpose shall be deemed to be the date on which the duty has been paid subject to realization of that cheque. (1A) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-rule (1), the duty on the clearances in the month of November, 2015, by an assessee in the "State of Tamil Nadu and the Union Territory of Puducherry (except Yanam and Mahe)], payable by the 5th or the 6th of the December, 2015, as the case may be, shall be paid by the 20th December, 2015: Provided that where an assessee in the State of Gujarat is availing of the exemption under a notification based on the value of clearances in a financial year, the duty on goods cleared during the month of February, 2002 shall be paid by the 31st March, 2002. Explanation. For removal of doubts, it is hereby clarified that the duty liability shall be deemed to have been discharged only if the amount payable is credited to the account of the Central Government by the specified date: (1B) Every assessee shall electronically pay duty through internet banking: Provided that the Assistant Commissioner or the Deputy Commissioner of Central Excise, for reasons to be recorded in writing, allow an assessee payment of duty by any mode other than internet banking. (2) The duty of excise shall be deemed to have been paid for the purposes of these rules on the excisable goods removed in the manner provided under sub-rule (1) and the credit of such duty allowed, as provided by or under any rule. (3) If the assessee fails to pay the amount of duty by due date, he shall be liable to pay the outstanding amount along with interest at the rate specified by the Central Government vide notification under [section 11AA] of the Act on the outstanding amount, for the period starting with the first day after due date till the date of actual payment of the outstanding amount. (3A) If the assessee fails to pay the duty declared as payable by him in the return within a period of one month from the due date, then the assessee is liable to pay the penalty at the rate of one per cent. on such amount of the duty not paid, for each month or part thereof calculated from the due date, for the period during which such failure continues.
Explanation. For the purposes of this sub-rule, 'month' means the period between two consecutive dates for payment of duty specified under sub-rule (1) or the first proviso to sub-rule (1), as the case may be. (4) The provisions of section 11 of the Act shall be applicable for recovery of the duty as assessed under rule 6 and mentioned in the return filed under these rules, the interest under sub-rule (3) and penalty under sub-rule 3(A) in the same manner as they are applicable for recovery of any duty or other sums payable to Central Government. Explanation. For the purposes of this rule, the expressions 'duty' or 'duty of excise' shall also include the amount payable in terms of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004. RULE 21. Remission of duty. (1) Where it is shown to the satisfaction of the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner, as the case may be that goods have been lost or destroyed by natural causes or by unavoidable accident or are claimed by the manufacturer as unfit for consumption or for marketing, at any time before removal, he may remit the duty payable on such goods, subject to such conditions as may be imposed by him by order in writing: Provided that where such duty does not exceed ten thousand rupees, the provisions of this rule shall have effect as if for the expression "Principal Commissioner or Commissioner, as the case may be", the expression "Superintendent of Central Excise" has been substituted: Provided further that where such duty exceeds ten thousand rupees but does not exceed one lakh rupees, the provisions of this rule shall have effect as if for the expression "Principal Commissioner or Commissioner, as the case may be", the expression "Assistant Commissioner of Central Excise or the Deputy Commissioner of Central Excise, as the case may be," has been substituted: Provided also that where such duty exceeds one lakh rupees but does not exceed five lakh rupees, the provisions of this rule shall have effect as if for the expression "Principal Commissioner or Commissioner, as the case may be", the expression "Joint Commissioner of Central Excise or Additional Commissioner of Central Excise, as the case may be," has been substituted. (2) The authority referred to in sub-rule (1) shall, within a period of three months from the date of receipt of an application, decide the remission of duty: Provided that the period specified in this sub-rule may, on sufficient cause being shown and reasons to be recorded in writing, be extended by an authority next higher than the authority before whom the application for remission of duty is pending, for a further period not exceeding six months. RULE 25. Confiscation and penalty. - (1) Subject to the provisions of section 11AC of the Act, if any producer, manufacturer, registered person of a warehouse or an importer who issues an invoice on which CENVAT credit can be taken or a registered dealer, - (a) removes any excisable goods in contravention of any of the provisions of these rules or the notifications issued under these rules; or (b) does not account for any excisable goods produced or manufactured or stored by him; or (c) engages in the manufacture, production or storage of any excisable goods without having applied for the registration certificate required under section 6 of the Act; or
(d) contravenes any of the provisions of these rules or the notifications issued under these rules with intent to evade payment of duty, then, all such goods shall be liable to confiscation and the producer or manufacturer or registered person of the warehouse or an importer who issues an invoice on which CENVAT credit can be taken or a registered dealer, as the case may be, shall be liable to a penalty not exceeding the duty on the excisable goods in respect of which any contravention of the nature referred to in clause (a) or clause (b) or clause (c) or clause (d) has been committed, or five thousand rupees, whichever is greater. (2) An order under sub-rule (1) shall be issued by the Central Excise Officer, following the principles of natural justice. (Emphasis supplied) 15. Section 11A of the Act, on a plain reading confers the power upon the Central Excise Department to recover the dues not levied or not paid or short-levied or short-paid or erroneously refunded. It is well settled that the Central Excise Duty is a duty leviable on manufacture as defined under the Act i.e. the incidence of tax is manufacture. 16. Rule 8 prescribes that the time when the duty is payable on manufacture at the time of removal; that is to say, the duty is payable on the goods when they are removed from the factory or the warehouse. 17. In the case of molasses, there is a deeming fiction which provides that the molasses which are produced in Khandsar sugar factory is liable to duty “as if such molasses have been produced by the procurer”. Thus, in the case of molasses, there is a deeming fiction of manufacture of molasses, however, the fact remains that the duty is payable even on molasses at the time of removal as prescribed under Rule 8. 18. In the present case, the petitioners claimed remission on loss of molasses due to natural causes, which was doubted by the department and a show-cause notice was issued calling upon the petitioners to show-cause as to why the remission application may not be rejected and the duty may not be demanded.
In the entire show-cause notice, which is on record, there is no allegation that the petitioners had clandestinely removed the molasses in contravention of Rule 8 and had not paid the duty thereupon. In the absence of any allegation to the effect in the show-cause notice and a consequent finding that the goods were removed without payment of duty, the duty cannot be levied under Section 11A of the Act even if the remission application is liable to be dismissed. 20. In the present case, even with regard to the grounds for rejecting the remission application, the Authorities were of the view that the loss as claimed in a very small period makes the whole issue suspicious, this view was formed treating the measurement as done by the State Excise Authorities to be the correct method for valuation completely ignoring the fact that the remission as claimed by the petitioners was over a larger period of the assessment year, thus, the same is also contrary to the law as laid down by this Court in the case of Balrampur Chini Mills Ltd. (supra), as extracted above. 21. The submission of Shri Deepak Seth, learned Senior Counsel, that if the goods are not found in the premises, there is a presumption of clandestine removal, merits rejection inasmuch as the burden of alleging and establishing removal in contravention of Rule 8(4), is on the department; there is no presumption of removal available either under the Act or under the Rules. Thus, the demand of duty in pursuance to the impugned orders being without any allegation or establishment of clandestine removal without payment of duty cannot be accepted and to that extent the impugned orders are liable to be set aside. 22. Even otherwise, in view of the law laid down in the case of Balrampur Chini Mills Ltd. (supra), the impugned orders rejecting the remission application are contrary to the said judgment, as such, the impugned orders, mentioned in the chart as extracted above in Para – 7, are liable to be set aside on that ground also.
In view of the findings as recorded above, the writ petitions are allowed. 24. The impugned orders in each of the writ petitions are set aside. 25. No order as to costs. Order Date :- 23.09.2022 [Pankaj Bhatia, J.] nishant Digitally signed by NISHANT MOHAN Date: 2022.09.23 17:11:24 IST Reason: Location: High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, Lucknow Bench
More judgments on Section 11A
- Audi Automobiles vs Commissioner of Central Excise and Service…C.A. No.-010504-010506 - 201713 Aug 2026
- Commissioner of Central Excise Hyderabad IV… vs M/S Xerox India Ltd. and OrsC.A. No.-005939-005941 - 20105 Aug 2026
- M/S Rashtriya Chem. and Fer. Ltd vs Comm. of Central Ex. and Serv. Tax(Ltu)C.A. No.-002219-002220 - 201324 Mar 2026
- Uttarpratha Trust, Mumbai vs Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax Central…ITA 3469/MUM/2025[2018-19]Status: Disposed31 Jul 2025AY 2018-19
- Uttarpratha Trust, Mumbai vs Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax Central…ITA 3468/MUM/2025[2017-18]Status: Disposed31 Jul 2025AY 2017-18
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- M/S. Ashok Panda, Dhenkanal vs. Assistant Commissioner Of State Tax , CT And GST Circle, DhenkanalOrissa · 10 Nov 2026
- M/S Sahadev Malik vs. Additional Commissioner, BhubaneswarOrissa · 10 Nov 2026
- Dillip Kumar Sethy vs. The Deputy Commissioner, CGST And Central ExciseOrissa · 10 Nov 2026
- K Pushkara Rao vs. The State Of ApAndhra Pradesh · 9 Nov 2026
- M/S. Jayasundar Engg Works vs. The Assistant Commissioner (St)Andhra Pradesh · 9 Nov 2026