SMT. NEELAM DUBEY vs. UNION OF INDIA THRU. SECY. REVENUE MINISTRY OF FINANCE , GOVT. INDIA , NEW DELHI AND OTHERS

PDF · subscribers
/113/2024HC AllahabadUPHC02030558202407 May 2024Author: SANGEETA CHANDRA,BRIJ RAJ SINGH10 pages
AI SummaryPartly Allowed

What did the High Court hold?

The Court held that the impugned notice dated 15.03.2023 for AY 2019-20 under Section 148A(d) and the final order passed under Section 148A(d) on 27.03.2023 for AY 2019-20 can be examined in the appeal pending before the Commissioner of Income Tax. The protective assessment order issued under Section 147 read with Section 144B, which was also challenged, is also subject to appeal. The Court noted that a show cause notice for penalty issued for AY 2019-20 could not have been issued unless the assessment order for that year had been finalized in appeal. Relying on the Gujarat High Court's decision in Bhailal Manilal Patel, the Court observed that a penalty notice under Section 271AAC cannot be issued unless the assessment is finalized. While the show cause notice for penalty mentioned the possibility of filing appeals, the time limit had expired. The Court noted that no final penalty order had been shown to have been imposed. Therefore, the Court directed that no final penalty order should be passed until the petitioner's appeal is decided by the Commissioner of Income Tax. The petitioner was granted liberty to approach the Assessing Officer and file a detailed reply to the penalty notice.

What were the facts?

The petitioner, Smt. Neelam Dubey, filed a writ petition challenging notices and orders related to reassessment proceedings for Assessment Year (AY) 2019-20. The proceedings were initiated based on information found during a search by the Income Tax Department against Omaxe Group, alleging the petitioner received unaccounted cash of Rs. 4,10,00,000/-. The petitioner's husband had invested Rs. 40 lakhs in 2014, which was later transferred to the petitioner's account after his death in 2016. The petitioner then invested Rs. 41 lakhs through banking channels. The department alleged the petitioner deposited cash of Rs. 4,10,00,000/- in 2016. The petitioner argues that Section 153C, not Section 147, should apply, and simultaneous notices for two AYs for the same amount are invalid. She also challenges a penalty notice issued based on a protective assessment order.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the reassessment notices issued under Section 147/148 for AY 2019-20, based on information from a search under Section 153A/153C, are legally valid, or if Section 153C should have been invoked instead (turning on Section 147, 148, 153A, 153C of the Income Tax Act, 1961). 2. Whether simultaneous reassessment notices for the same alleged cash transaction amount of Rs. 4,10,00,000/- for two different Assessment Years (2017-18 and 2019-20) are permissible. 3. Whether a penalty notice under Section 271AAC can be issued based solely on a protective assessment order, without a finalized assessment order (turning on Section 271AAC of the Income Tax Act, 1961). Assessee's Arguments: - Section 153C should have been applied, not Section 147/148, as the information was discovered during a search of a third party (Omaxe Group). - Issuing simultaneous notices for two AYs for the same transaction is bad in law. - A penalty notice under Section 271AAC cannot be issued on a protective assessment order; it requires a finalized assessment order. Reliance was placed on Lalji Haridas and Bhailal Manilal Patel. Revenue's Arguments: - Final orders for AY 2019-20 have been passed, and an appeal is pending. The petitioner can raise all factual arguments before the appellate authority. - The issues raised can be addressed in the reassessment proceedings and departmental remedies are available. - The scope of Section 148A(d) is limited to the existence of information suggesting escaped income, and interference under Article 226 is not warranted. Reliance was placed on Vivek Saran Agarwal and Anshul Jain.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 147,Section 148,Section 148A,Section 153A,Section 153C,Section 271AAC,Section 69,Section 144B,Section 246A

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Neutral Citation No. - 2024:AHC-LKO:35185-DB Court No. - 3 Case :- WRIT TAX No. - 113 of 2024 Petitioner :- Smt. Neelam Dubey Respondent :- Union Of India Thru. Secy. Revenue Ministry Of Finance , Govt. India , New Delhi And Others Counsel for Petitioner :- Manish Misra,Bhavini Upadhyay,Dileep Pandey,Gaurav Upadhyay Counsel for Respondent :- A.S.G.I.,Kushagra Dikshit Hon'ble Mrs. Sangeeta Chandra,J. Hon'ble Brij Raj Singh,J. 1. Heard Shri Manish Mishra, learned counsel for the petitioner, Dr. Ravi Kumar Mishra, learned counsel for respondent no.1 and Shri Neerav Chitravanshi along with Shri Kushagra Dikshit, learned counsel for respondent no. 2. 2. This writ petition has been filed with the following main prayers :- "(i). to issue a writ order or direction in the nature of certiorari to quash the impugned notice dated 15.03.2023 for the assessment year 2019-20 passed under section 148A clause (b) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. (Annexure No. 1). (ii). to issue a writ order or direction in the nature of certiorari to quash the impugned order dated 27.03.2023 for the Assessment Year 2019-20 respectively passed under section 148A clause (d) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. (Annexure No. 2). (iii). to issue a writ order or direction in the nature of certiorari to quash the impugned consequential notice U/s 148 dated 27.03.2023 for A.Y. 2019-20 for re-assessment of the case

of petitioner U/s 147 of the Income Tax Act. (Annexure No.3). (iv). to issue a writ order or direction in the nature of certiorari to quash the show cause notice for penalty dated 18.04.2024 for AY 2019-20. (Annexure No. 13)." 3. In addition to this, the petitioner has prayed for quashing of the two simultaneous assessments proceedings initiated against the same transaction amount and also questioning the amount of transaction for the same cause of action which has been arbitrarily shown as Rs.4,10,00,000/- (Four crore ten lakhs) instead of 41 lakhs. 4. It is the case of the petitioner that the husband of the petitioner was a Government employee working as an Assistant Accountant in U.P. Rajkiya Nirman Nigam and he retired on 31.08.2011 from a non-pensionable post. After retirement, he received certain amount which he invested in different port folio of Omaxe Infrastructure Scheme on 26.08.2014 through banking channel. There was no cash transaction for investment of Rs.40 lakhs so made by the husband of the petitioner in the year 2011-12. The husband of the petitioner got seriously ill and in the year 2016 died on 31.07.2016. After the death of the husband of the petitioner his account with Bank of Baroda was closed and the total amount including 40 lakhs which was invested by her husband again in a Omaxe Infrastructure Limited was transferred into the account of the petitioner by the Allahabad Bank now known as Indian Bank in the year 2016.

Thereafter, the Port Folio Manager approached her and advised her to invest Rs.40 lakhs for lucrative return in a new scheme namely Omaxe Avenue. Thus, the entire amount was transferred from the account of the petitioner to Omaxe Avenue Scheme in the year 2016 again through banking channel. 5. The petitioner has invested only Rs.41 lakhs in Omaxe Group through banking channel. In the year 2022, a search was conducted by the Income Tax Department against various offices and residential premises of the Omaxe Group. During search operations, certain excel sheets were found by the Income Tax Department and on the basis of such papers, the Income Tax Department had issued a notice for re-assessment to the petitioner under Section 147 for income that has escaped from assessment earlier. 6. The allegation against the petitioner is that she has received an un-accounted cash of Rs.4,10,00,000/- from Omaxe Group on 31.10.2018 which she had previously deposited in cash in Omaxe Group on 03.11.2016. The petitioner has received two simultaneous notices for re-assessment for the Assessment Year 2017- 18 and 2019-20. Both re-assessment notices relate to the same amount i.e. alleged cash transactions of Rs.4,10,00,000/-. 7. The petitioner has challenged such notices for two different Assessment Years 2017-18, 2019-20

simultaneously for the same amount. A show cause notice issued to the petitioner on 15.03.2023 under Section 148 A (d) for Assessment Year 2019-20 has been replied by the petitioner and the Assessing Officer has passed an order on 27.03.2023 under Section 148-A (d). 8. Consequently, a notice dated 27.03.2023 has also been issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act. It has been submitted by learned counsel appearing for the petitioner that in case of search of premises/offices of Omaxe Group, some papers have been discovered by the authorities then Section 153 A and 153 C would apply and not Section 147 and 148. It has been submitted that instead of issuing notice under Section 153-C, notice has been issued under Section 147 wrongly. It has been argued that since notice can be issued only for one Assessment Year at one time and not simultaneously for two Assessment Years for the same amount of rs.4,10,00,000/- such notice is bad. Moreover, the protective Assessment Order has been issued for the Assessment Year 2019-20 on 24.03.2024 and on the basis of such protective Assessment Order for the Assessment Year 2019-20, no show cause notice could have been issued for imposing penalty as has been done by the Department on 18.04.2024 and therefore, the said show cause notice has also been challenged on the ground of jurisdictional error. It has been argued that the penalty notice under Section 271 AAC can be

given only when income is determined finally against the Assessee including income under Section 69 of the Act. No penalty notice can be issued on an uncertain Assessment Order as no final or substantive assessment order has yet been issued. There can be no protective penalty order although there can be a protective Assessment Order. 9. Learned counsel for the petitioner has placed reliance upon the judgment passed by the Constitution Bench of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Lalji Haridas ; Chhotalal Haridas vs. Income Tax Officer decided on 25.07.1961 reported in 1961 43 ITR 387 where the Supreme Court has considered the possibility of passing of protective Assessment Order. Learned counsel for the petitioner has also placed reliance upon the judgment of the Division Bench of Gujarat High Court wherein it has been stated that even though protective Assessment Order can be passed, unless such assessment is finalised, no notice under Section 271 AAC can be issued for imposing penalty. Such judgment is reported in 2014 LawSuit (Guj) 1017 Bhailal Manilal Patel vs. Commissioner of Income Tax. 10. Learned counsel for the petitioner has taken this Court to the contents of impugned Annexures 1, 2 3 and also Annexure 13 of the writ petition to say that Section 153 C would have applied and not Section 147 and there is a jurisdictional error in issuance of notice and therefore, issuance of

notice and initiation of proceedings have also been challenged before this Court. 11. Learned counsel appearing for the respondents has pointed out to this Court that final orders have been passed for the Assessment Year 2019-20 and assessment is going on for the year 2017-18 after final Assessment Order for Assessment Year 2019- 20, the petitioner has also filed an appeal and all the arguments that have been raised by learned counsel for the petitioner regarding the facts of the case that her husband has actually deposited Rs.40 lakhs which was returned with interest and that she herself had deposited Rs.41 lakhs through banking channel on which she has earned interest can be raised before the appellate authority, i.e. the Commissioner of Income Tax in appeal filed by the petitioner already. It has been pointed out that the final Assessment Order has not been challenged and a show cause notices issued alone have been challenged before this Court. A show cause notice dated 15.03.2023 and 27.03.2023 for Assessment Year 2019-20 merged with the final order that has been passed against which appeal has also been filed by the petitioner. 12. It has also been argued on the basis of judgment rendered by the Division Bench of this Court in Writ Tax No.968 of 2023 (Vivek Saran Agarwal vs. Union of India and 3 others) decided on 03.10.2023 (2023:AHC:193486-DB) that an ultimate assessment made by the Assessing Officer under Section 147 for re-

asessment is otherwise subject to appeal under Section 246-A of the Act. Merits of the information referable to Section 148-A thus remains subject to the re-assessment proceedings initiated vide notice under Section 148 of the Act. It is for this reason that issues which require determination at the stage of re-assessment proceedings and in respect of which departmental remedy is otherwise available, are not required to be determined at the stage of decision by the assessing authority under Section 148 (A) (d). The scope of decision under Section 148 (A) (d) is limited to the existence or otherwise of information which suggests that income chargeable to tax has escaped assessment. The Division Bench has observed that the order issued under Section 148 (A) (d) of the Act and notice issued under section 148 would not warrant any interference under Article 226 of the Constitution of India as challenge to such the order would be available to an assessee while challenging the order passed in re-assessment proceedings consequent to the notice issued under Section 148 of the Act. The Division Bench has relied upon the observations made by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Anshul Jain vs. Principal Commissioner, Income Tax, reported in (2022) 143 taxman.com 38. 13. It has been argued by learned counsel appearing for the respondents that during the search operations conducted on Omaxe Group,

some papers were discovered which reveals that the petitioner had earned an annual income as interest of Rs.13 lakhs on her investment made in Omaxe Group and therefore, the Assessing Officer presumed that there was more investment made in cash than has been shown through banking channel as 41 lakhs since 2016 by the petitioner. 14. Learned counsel for the petitioner has stated that no such presumption can be raised without recording a finding of the amount of cash that was discovered to have been invested by the petitioner since 2016. He has also pointed out that such income of Rs.13 lakhs for the year 2017-18 has been derived on the basis of investments made from time to time by her husband in Fixed Deposits in Banks and in other Schemes, a total interest turn of Rs.13 lakhs cannot be pinned down to investment of Rs.41 lakhs only made through banking channel in Omaxe Group. 15. This Court is of the opinion that the impugned notice dated 15.03.2023 for Assessment Year 2019-20 under Section 148(A) (d) and the Final Order passed under Section 148(A) (d) on 27.03.2023 for Assessment Year 2019-20 can both be looked into in appeal that is pending before the Commissioner of Income Tax. The protective Assessment Order that has been issued under Section 147 read with Section 144 B of the Income Tax Act, has also been challenged in an appeal before the Commissioner of Income Tax. A show cause notice issued for imposing penalty for

Assessment Year 2019-20 (Anenxure 13 to the writ petition) which has been challenged could not have been issued unless the Assessment Order for the Assessment Year 2019-20 had been finalised in appeal. 16. We have come to this conclusion on the basis of observations made by a Division Bench of the Gujarat High Court in Bhailal (Supra). 17. The show cause notice does indeed say that in case the petitioner has filed an appeal or has filed objections, copy of such appeal/objections be submitted along with the answers by the Assessee but the time limit for such submission has already expired. The petitioner has not submitted any reply to the show cause notice for imposing penalty as the petitioner had challenged the jurisdiction of the Assessing Officer in issuance of such show cause notice only on the basis of a protective Assessment Order. 18. However, we have not been shown any document to say that even after time limit i.e. 25.04.2024 has expired, any final penalty has been imposed under Section 271 AAC of the Act therefore, this Court is of the opinion that no such final orders imposing penalty should be passed till the appeal of the petitioner is decided by the Commissioner of Income Tax. Petitioner is at liberty to approach the Assessing Officer and file a detailed reply along with documents to the notice issued under Section 271 AAC (1) of the Act.

19.

With these observations, the writ petition stands disposed of. Order Date :- 7.5.2024 Pks Digitally signed by :- POOJA SETH High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, Lucknow Bench

More judgments on Section 147

All 57,238 judgments and leading authorities on Section 147 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →