HANS RAJ vs. THE COMMISSIONER OF WEALTH TAX

PDF · subscribers
CWP/4235/1988HC Punjab & HaryanaPHHC01008472198802 August 2013Author: MR. JUSTICE RAJIVE BHALLA,MR. JUSTICE DR. BHARAT BHUSHAN PARSOON5 pages
AI SummaryRemanded

What did the High Court hold?

The Tribunal held that the Commissioner of Wealth Tax committed an error of jurisdiction in dismissing the petitioner's application under Section 18-B of the Wealth Tax Act, 1957. The Tribunal noted that Section 18-B empowers the Commissioner to reduce or waive penalty and requires consideration of specific parameters outlined within that section. A perusal of the impugned order revealed that these statutory factors were not considered. Instead, the Commissioner's order focused on grounds related to the imposition of the penalty itself, quoting a passage that stated the conditions in Section 18-B were not fulfilled due to a claimed wrong exemption regarding land. The Tribunal found that the Commissioner's reasoning was not referable to Section 18-B. Consequently, the writ petition was allowed, the impugned order was set aside, and the matter was remitted back to the Commissioner of Wealth Tax, Patiala, for a fresh decision in accordance with the law and the parameters of Section 18-B.

What were the facts?

The petitioner, Hans Raj (HUF), is challenging an order dated February 22, 1988, passed by the Commissioner of Wealth Tax, Patiala. This order declined to exercise jurisdiction under Section 18-B of the Wealth Tax Act, 1957. The petitioner had filed wealth tax returns for assessment years 1977 to 1985 collectively and voluntarily on November 18, 1985. The Assessing Officer imposed penalties on May 30, 1986. The petitioner accepted the assessment but applied under Section 18-B for reduction or waiver of the penalty. The Commissioner rejected this application, allegedly considering grounds already used by the Assessing Officer for imposing the penalty, and without addressing the factors required by Section 18-B. The revenue contended that the order was not illegal or perverse, as the Commissioner considered the entire controversy and found the petitioner undeserving of relief due to late deposit of wealth tax, which the petitioner countered by stating tax was paid with the return.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the Commissioner of Wealth Tax erred in jurisdiction by not considering the factors enumerated in Section 18-B of the Wealth Tax Act, 1957, while deciding the petitioner's application for reduction or waiver of penalty? (Question of law) Assessee's arguments: The petitioner argued that the Commissioner failed to exercise jurisdiction under Section 18-B of the 1957 Act. The impugned order allegedly did not record any reasons referable to Section 18-B and instead considered grounds already used by the Assessing Officer for imposing the penalty. The petitioner emphasized that the returns were filed voluntarily and without notice, and the wealth tax was paid at the time of filing. Revenue's arguments: The respondent contended that the impugned order was not illegal or perverse. The Commissioner had considered the entire controversy and concluded that the petitioner did not merit penalty reduction or waiver because the wealth tax was deposited well after the due date.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 18-B,Section 18(1)(c)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

-: 1 :- IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATES OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH Date of decision: August 2, 2013. Hans Raj (HUF) ... Petitioner v. The Commissioner of Wealth Tax, Patiala ... Respondent CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJIVE BHALLA HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE DR. BHARAT BHUSHAN PARSOON Present: Shri Rajesh Garg, Advocate, for the petitioner. Mrs. Savita Saxena, Advocate for the respondent. Rajive Bhalla

, J. (Oral): The petitioner, lays challenge to order dated 22.2.1988 (Annexure P-2) passed by the Commissioner of Wealth Tax, Patiala, declining to exercise jurisdiction under Section 18-B of the Wealth Tax Act, 1957 (for short, the 1957 Act). Counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner was required to file wealth tax returns for assessment years, 1977 to 1985. The returns were filed collectively and voluntarily on 18.11.1985, without any notice from the Department. The Assessing Officer passed orders dated 30.5.1986 imposing penalty. The petitioner accepted the assessment but filed an application under Section 18-B of the 1957 Act, praying that the penalty may be reduced or waived. The Commissioner of Wealth Tax, Patiala has rejected the application by taking into consideration grounds considered by the Assessing Officer while

-: 2 :- imposing penalty and without considering factors set out for exercise of jurisdiction of Section 18-B of the 1957 Act. It is further submitted that a perusal of the impugned order would reveal that no reason, much less any reason referable to Section 18-B of the 1957 Act, has been recorded. Counsel for the respondent states that the impugned order does not suffer from any illegality or perversity so as to require interference. The Commissioner of Wealth Tax has considered the entire gamut of the controversy and has come to a conclusion that the petitioner does not deserve reduction or waiver of penalty as wealth tax was deposited well after the due date. In response to the latter argument, counsel for the petitioner states that the entire wealth tax was paid at the time of filing of the return. We have heard counsel for the parties, perused the impugned order and upon due consideration of Section 18-B of the 1957 Act, have no hesitation in holding that the Commissioner of Wealth Tax has committed an error of jurisdiction while dismissing the application. Section 18-B of the 1957 Act, empowers the Commissioner to reduce/waive penalty and for the said purpose, is required to confine his consideration to parameters set out in Section 18-B of the 1957 Act, which reads as under:- "18B. Power to reduce or waive penalty in certain cases. - (1) Notwithstanding anything containedin this Act, the 2 [3

-: 3 :- [*] Commissioner] may, inhisdiscretion, whether onhis own motion or otherwise, - (i)4 [*] (ii)reduce or waive the amount of penalty imposed or imposable on a person underclause (iii) of sub-section (1) of section 18, ithe is satisfied that such person, - (a)5 [*] (b)in the case referred to in clause (ii), has, prior to the detection by the 6 [AssessingOfficer], of the concealment of particulars of assets or of the inaccuracy ofparticulars furnished in respect of any asset or debt in respect of which thepenalty is imposable, voluntarily and in good faith made full and truedisclosure of such particulars, and also has co-operated in any inquiry relating to the assessment ofhis net wealth and has either paid ormade satisfactory arrangements for the payment of any tax or interest payable inconsequence of an order passed under this Act in respect of the relevant assessment year. Explanation7 [l].-For the purposes of this sub-section, a person, shall be deemed to have made full and true disclosure ofthe particulars of hisassets or debts in any case where the excess of net wealth assessed over the netwealth returned is of such a nature as not to attract the provisions of clause(c) of sub-section (1)of section 18. Explanation2. -8 [*](2) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1), if in a case falling under clause (c) of sub- section (1) of section18, the net wealth in respect of whichthe penalty is imposed or imposable for the relevant assessment year, or, where such disclosure relates to more than one assessment year, the net wealth for anyone of the relevant assessment years, exceeds five hundred thousand rupees, no order reducing or waiving the penalty under sub-section (1) shall be made by the 9 [Commissionerexcept with the previous approval of the Chief Commissioner, orDirector-General, as the case may be.]

-: 4 :- (3) Where an order has been made under sub-section (1)in favour of any person, whether such order relates to one or more assessment years, he shall not be entitled to any relief under this section in relation toany other assessment year at any time after the making of such order: 10 [Providedthat where an order has been made in favour of any person under sub-section (1) on or before the 24th day of July, 1991, such person snail be entitled tofurther relief only once in relation to other assessment year or years if hemakes an application to the wealth-tax authority referred to in sub-section (4) at any time before the 1st day of April, 1992]. (4) Without prejudice to the powers conferred on himby any other provision of this Act, the 11 [12 [*]Commissioner] may, on an application made in this behalf by an assessee, andafter recording his reasons for so doing, reduce or waive the amount of any penalty payable by the assessee under this Act or stay or compound any proceeding for the recovery of any such amount, if he is satisfied that- (i)to do otherwise would cause genuine hardship to the assessee, having regard tothe circumstances of the case, and (ii)the assessee has co-operated in any inquiry relating to the assessment or anyproceeding for the recovery of any amount due from him. (5) Every order made under this section shall be final and shall not be called into question by any court or any other authority.] 13 [(6) The provisions of this section as they stood immediately before their amendment by the Direct Tax Laws (Amendment) Act, 1989, shall apply to and in relation to any assessment for the assessment year commencing on the 1stday of April, 1988,or any earlier assessment year, and references in this section to the other provisions of this Act shall be construed as references to those provisions asfor the time being in force and applicable to the relevant assessment year.” A perusal of Section 18B of the 1957 Act would reveal

-: 5 :- that it commences with a non-obstante clause thereby indicating that while considering a prayer for reduction/waiver of penalty, a Commissioner shall consider such factors as are enumerated in Section 18-B of the 1957 Act and no other factor. A perusal of the impugned order, reveals that factors enumerated in Section 18-B of the 1957 Act have not been considered. A relevant extra from the impugned order reads as follows:- “On the basis of above facts, the assessee has claimed wrong exemption regarding one bigha of land given on rent to M/s Gokal Steel Indl. Barnala. I therefore, hold that the conditions mentioned in Section 18-B of the Wealth Tax Act are not fulfilled, the petition for all the nine assessment years is dismissed. In the result, the petition is dismissed.” In this view of the matter, we allow the writ petition, set aside the impugned order and remit the matter to the Commissioner Wealth Tax, Patiala to decide the petition filed under Section 18B of the 1957 Act afresh, in accordance with law. Parties are directed to appear before the Commissioner, Wealth Tax, Patiala on 9.9.2013.

[ Rajive Bhalla ]

Judge

[Dr. Bharat Bhushan Parsoon] August 2, 2013. Judge kadyan

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →