COMMISSIONER INCOME TAX vs. M/S PHONEX LAMPS INDIA LTD.

PDF · subscribers
IAPL/246/2007HC AllahabadUPHC01139755200718 February 20182 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The Tribunal decided all three questions of law in favor of the assessee and against the Revenue. Regarding question 1, the Tribunal noted that the issue of depreciation on foreign exchange fluctuation had already been decided against the Revenue in CIT v. Woodward Governor India (P) Ltd. (2009) 312 ITR 254 (SC). For question 2, the Tribunal relied on multiple judgments, including Autolite India Ltd. v. CIT (2003) 264 ITR 117 (Raj), which held that expenses incurred on issuing shares or debentures, including prospectus-related costs, are eligible for Section 35D benefits. Therefore, questions 1 and 2 were decided against the Revenue. Concerning question 3, the Tribunal found concurrent judgments from the CIT and the Tribunal that pre-operative expenses, incurred before the business commenced or existed, are capital expenditures. The Tribunal upheld the capitalization of these expenses and the allowance of depreciation, as they were incurred prior to the business setting up and profit generation. The appeal was dismissed.

What were the facts?

The Revenue, Commissioner of Income Tax, filed an appeal under Section 260-A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, against an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) dated April 28, 2006, for the assessment year 1993-94. The appeal challenged the ITAT's decision to allow certain claims made by the assessee, M/s Phonex Lamps India Ltd. The ITAT's order was the subject of challenge. The appeal was heard by the Hon'ble Bharati Sapru, J. and Hon'ble Neeraj Tiwari, J.

What were the issues?

The Tribunal had to decide three substantial questions of law. 1. Whether the ITAT was justified in allowing depreciation of Rs. 59,48,096/- on foreign exchange fluctuation, considering Section 43A of the Act and the notional nature of such fluctuations? 2. Whether the ITAT was justified in allowing relief under Section 35D(2)(C)(iv) when the assessee had not made such a claim before the Assessing Officer, and the expenses were not related to plant, machinery, or infrastructure construction? 3. Whether the ITAT was justified in allowing capitalization of expenses incurred on advertisement, salary, wages, travelling, conveyance, and staff welfare, which were not in connection with plant, machinery, or infrastructure construction? The Revenue argued that foreign exchange fluctuation was notional and varied annually, questioning depreciation under Section 43A. For question 2, the Revenue contended that the claim under Section 35D was not made before the Assessing Officer and the expenses were not for plant, machinery, or infrastructure. For question 3, the Revenue argued that the specified expenses were not related to plant, machinery, or infrastructure construction. The Assessee did not present arguments as the issues were decided based on existing precedents.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 260-A,Section 43A,Section 35D(2)(C)(iv)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Court No. - 35 Case :- INCOME TAX APPEAL No. - 246 of 2007 Appellant :- Commissioner Income Tax Respondent :- M/S Phonex Lamps India Ltd. Counsel for Appellant :- S.S.C. I.T.,Shubham Agarwal Counsel for Respondent :- Sujeet Kumar,Shashwat Bajpai Hon'ble Bharati Sapru,J. Hon'ble Neeraj Tiwari,J. Heard Sri Shubham Agrawal, learned Counsel for the revenue and Dr. Shashwat Bajpai, Advocate assisted by Sri Sujeet Kumar, learned Counsel for the respondent-assessee. This is an appeal filed by the revenue under Section 260-A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 against an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal dated 28.04.2006 for the assessment year 1993-94. The questions of law as framed are quoted hereunder:- "1. Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case, the ITAT is legally justified in allowing the claim of depreciation of Rs.59,48,096/- on Foreign Exchange Fluctuation without appreciating the provisions of Section 43A of the Act and the fact that the Foreign Exchange Fluctuation showed notional fluctuation and varied from year to year ? 2. Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case, the ITAT is legally justified in law in allowing the relief under Section 35D(2) (C) (iv) of the Act, when no such claim was made by the assessee before the Assessing Officer during the assessment proceedings in as much as the expenses claimed were not incurred in connection with the installation of Plant and Machinery or construction of the infrastructure of the Company ? 3. Whether on the fact and circumstances of the case, the ITAT is legally justified in law in allowing capitalization of expenses, which were incurred on advertisement, salary and wages, travelling and conveyance and staff welfare expenses and not incurred in connection with installation of Plant and Machinery or constructions of infrastructure of Company ?" Three Substantial Questions of law were framed in this appeal while ultimately it is only question no.3, which is being pressed for reasons that question no.1 has already been decided against the revenue by way of a judgement in the case of CIT v. Woodward Governor India (P) Ltd. reported in

(2009) 312 ITR 254 (SC). The question no.2 has also been decided against the revenue by way of several judgements all over India including the case of Autolite India Ltd. v. CIT reported in (2003) 264 ITR 117 (Raj) in which it has been categorically held that the expenses incurred on issue of public subscription of shares or of debentures of the company, any payment made against commission, brokerage and charges for drafting, typing, printing and advertisement of the prospectus would be eligible for benefit of Section 35D. The questions no.1 & 2 are, therefore, decided against the revenue and in favour of the assessee. Insofar as the question no.3 is concerned, there are concurrent judgements of the CIT as well as that of the Tribunal that any amounts expended by an assessee, which are pre-operative in nature and are in fact made prior to coming in or the existence of the business itself would no doubt be a capital expenditure and, therefore, both the CIT as well as the Tribunal have allowed the assessee to capitalise the expenses made prior to the existence or the formation of the Company and have allowed depreciation on them as capital expenses and rightly so on facts there is no doubt that these amounts, which were expended by the assessee were prior to the setting up of the business and prior to the date when the business ran or started making profits. Accordingly, question no.3 is also answered in favour of the assessee and against the revenue. In view of the above, this appeal is dismissed. No costs. Order Date :- 19.2.2018 S.P.

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →