M/S L.H. SUGAR FACTORIES PVT. LTD. vs. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX AND ANOTHER

PDF · subscribers
IAPL/334/2016HC AllahabadUPHC01180199201615 August 20182 pages
AI SummaryRemanded

What did the High Court hold?

The Tribunal held that the addition made on account of bagasse was based solely on the recoveries made by another sugar factory. The assessee contended that it had produced material before the AO demonstrating its recoveries, and that all transactions were duly recorded in its books of account. The Tribunal found that the matter required reconsideration due to the AO's unsubstantiated addition and the assessee's submissions. Consequently, the Tribunal remanded the matter back to itself for reconsideration of the facts and the material already on record. The Tribunal directed that the matter on remand shall be decided in accordance with the law. The issue regarding sugarcane loss was not explicitly decided, as the appeals were disposed of on remand.

What were the facts?

The assessee, M/s L.H. Sugar Factories Pvt. Ltd., filed two appeals against orders of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT). The appeals pertain to the assessment year 2007-08. The core dispute revolves around additions made by the Assessing Officer (AO) and affirmed by the ITAT, concerning suppressed production and sale of bagasse, and sugarcane loss. The Commissioner of Income Tax (CIT) had previously examined the material and noted that the AO failed to consider factors affecting bagasse recovery, such as sugarcane quality and seasonal fluctuations. The CIT also observed that comparing one factory's recovery with another was inappropriate and that the AO had not provided justification for the addition beyond such a comparison. The CIT further noted no evidence of bagasse sales outside the books. The ITAT, however, seemingly acquiesced with the AO's assessment without delving into the CIT's reasoning.

What were the issues?

1. Whether, on the facts and circumstances, the ITAT was justified in affirming the AO's estimation of suppressed bagasse production and sale at Rs. 81,24,700, despite the assessee maintaining complete day-to-day bagasse records as per Excise records, which were not rejected by the AO? (Question of law and fact, concerning Section 69B of the Income Tax Act, 1961). 2. Whether the ITAT was justified in affirming the addition of Rs. 8,80,500 on account of sugarcane loss, when the revenue had accepted such losses in previous years? (Question of law and fact, concerning Section 37 of the Income Tax Act, 1961). Assessee's Contentions: The assessee argued that it maintained complete records of bagasse as per Excise records on a day-to-day basis, and these records were not rejected by the AO. For the sugarcane loss, the assessee contended that the revenue had accepted similar losses in prior years. Revenue's Contentions: The judgment does not record specific contentions made by the revenue before the Tribunal.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 69B,Section 37

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Court No. - 35 Case :- INCOME TAX APPEAL No. - 334 of 2016 Appellant :- M/S L.H. Sugar Factories Pvt. Ltd. Respondent :- Commissioner Of Income Tax And Another Counsel for Appellant :- Suyash Agarwal,Rakesh Ranjan Agarwal Counsel for Respondent :- S.C.,Piyush Agarwal And Case :- INCOME TAX APPEAL No. - 333 of 2016 Appellant :- M/S L.H. Sugar Factories Pvt. Ltd. Respondent :- Commissioner Of Income Tax And Anr. Counsel for Appellant :- Suyash Agarwal,Rakesh Ranjan Counsel for Respondent :- C.S.C.,Manish Goel Hon'ble Bharati Sapru,J. Hon'ble Ajay Bhanot,J. Heard learned counsel for the appellant Sri Suyash Agarwal and Sri Manish Goyal learned counsel for the department. As the controversy involved in both these appeals is identical, the same is being decided by a common judgment and order treating the Income Tax Appeal no.334 of 2016 as the leading case. The Income Tax Appeal no.334 of 2016 has been filed by the assessee under section 260A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 against an order passed by the tribunal dated 16.9.2015 for the assessment year 2007-08. The following questions of law sought are being sought to be answered: "(i) Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case ITAT was justified in affirming the action of the A.O. in estimating the suppressed production and sale of bagasse at Rs.81,24,700 (1,62,494x50) ignoring the fact that the assessee has maintained complete records of bagasse as per Excise records on day to day basis and the same has not been rejected by A.O.? (ii) Whether the ITAT was justified in affirming the addition made by A.O. on account of sugarcane loss of Rs.8,80,500/- when the revenue has accepted such losses in previous years?" The Assessing Officer has sought to make an addition towards the bagasse upon examining and comparing the production of bagasse in another sugar factory. The C.I.T. in appeal while examining the material on record, came to the conclusion that the Assessing Officer had failed to take into account the factors affecting the recovery of bagasse while making the assessment. The recovery of bagasse would necessarily depend upon the quality of sugarcane, at the start of the season and at the

maturity of cane, for reasons that the recovery from the sugarcane also fluctuates from the start to the end. By the end of the season, the sugarcane begins to dry, recoveries of both sugar and bagasse are naturally affected. C.I.T. has also taken into consideration the fact that one the recovery of one factory could not be compared with another and on the other hand, the C.I.T. has also noted that the Assessing Officer had not brought any record to show and justify the addition but simply on the basis of another sugar factory, had made the addition. C.I.T. also records that there was nothing found by the A.O. to suggest that the assessee has sold bagasse outside his books of accounts. The tribunal without going into the reasoning adopted by the C.I.T. had acquiesced with the Assessing Officer. However upon examining the material on record, we do find that the addition has been made simply on account of recoveries made by another sugar factory. The assessee on the other hand states that it did produce the material before the Assessing officer to show what recoveries had been made and that everything was duly recorded in the books of account. The matter requires reconsideration. We send the matter back to the tribunal for reconsideration of these facts and and the material which is already on record. The matter on remand shall be decided in accordance with law. The appeals are thus disposed of finally. No costs. Order Date :- 16.8.2018 rk

More judgments on Section 69B

All 1,579 judgments and leading authorities on Section 69B →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →