COMMISSIONER OF INCOME-TAX vs. SHRI DEEPAK M.KOTHARI
What did the High Court hold?
The Tribunal dismissed the departmental appeal, upholding the deletion of the addition of Rs. 2.60 crores. The Tribunal found that the Assessing Officer's addition was based on certain unsigned draft MOUs and a presumption that the assessee had invested Rs. 2.60 crores in the Karaka Property. The CIT(Appeals) had categorically stated that there was no evidence on record to suggest that the assessee had paid anything in excess of Rs. 1.5 crores. An affidavit filed by Shri Ashok Dalal, who was not a related person, was considered self-serving by the AO. The CIT(A) also noted that no corroborative evidence was recovered during the search, no corresponding assets were found, and there was no evidence to prove the investment of Rs. 2.60 crores. The Tribunal agreed with the CIT(A) that the addition was based on conjectures and surmises without any basis. Therefore, the Tribunal found no valid ground to interfere with the findings of the CIT(A), especially when the addition was made solely on the basis of presumption. The Tribunal concluded that no question of law arose as the matter was sealed by findings of fact, and answered the question in favour of the assessee.
What were the facts?
The Revenue, Commissioner of Income-Tax, filed an appeal under Section 260-A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, against an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) dated February 15, 2011. The ITAT had dismissed the departmental appeal, thereby deleting an addition of Rs. 2.60 crores made by the Assessing Officer (AO) for a block period ending November 18, 1999. The AO's addition was related to undisclosed investment in Karaka properties, based on documents seized during a search under Section 132 of the Act. The AO had passed an assessment order under Section 158 BC of the Act on December 28, 2001. The appeal challenges the ITAT's decision to uphold the deletion of this addition.
What were the issues?
1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Hon'ble ITAT was justified in law in dismissing the departmental appeal, thereby deleting the addition of Rs. 2.60 crores in respect of undisclosed investment in Karaka properties based on documents seized during the course of search under Section 132 of the I.T. Act, which has evidentiary value in terms of Section 132(4A) and Section 292C of the I.T. Act. Assessee's contentions: The ITAT held that the addition was based on unsigned draft MOUs and presumptions. The CIT(A) had found no evidence to suggest the assessee invested more than Rs. 1.5 crores in the Karaka property. An affidavit filed by Shri Ashok Dalal, who was not a related person, was considered by the AO as self-serving. The CIT(A) noted that no corroborative evidence was recovered during the search, nor were corresponding assets found with the assessee, and there was no evidence to prove the investment of Rs. 2.60 crores. The addition was deemed to be based on conjectures and surmises. Revenue's contentions: The Revenue argued that documents seized during the search, particularly under Section 132, have evidentiary value for assessment proceedings, including under Sections 132(4A) and 292C of the Act, and therefore the addition of Rs. 2.60 crores was justified.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 260-A,Section 132,Section 132(4A),Section 158 BC,Section 292C
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
Court No. - 35 Case :- INCOME TAX APPEAL No. - 162 of 2011 Appellant :- Commissioner Of Income-Tax Respondent :- Shri Deepak M.Kothari Counsel for Appellant :- Ssc/A.N.Mahajan,S.S.C. I.T. Counsel for Respondent :- S.K. Garg,A. Bansal,Abhinav Mehrotra Hon'ble Bharati Sapru,J. Hon'ble Salil Kumar Rai,J. This appeal under Section 260-A of the Income Tax Act, 1961(hereinafter referred to as the 'Act') has been filed by the department against the order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal dated 15.02.2011 and restore the Assessment order u/s 158 BC of the Income Tax Act, 1961 dated 28.12.2001 passed by the Assessing Officer for Block Period ending on 18.11.1999. The questions of law sought to be answered as as hereunder: "(1) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Hon'ble ITAT was justified in law in dismissing the departmental appeal thereby deleting the addition of Rs.2.60 crores in respect of undisclosed investment in Karaka properties based on documents seized during the course of search under Section 132 of the I.T. Act, which has the evidentiary value for the purpose of assessment proceedings also in terms of Section 132 (4A) generally and in specifically in terms of Section 292C of the I.T. Act." We have heard Shri Shubham Agrawal, learned counsel for the appellant and Shri Abhinav Mehrotra, learned counsel for the respondent. Upon perusal of the assessment order, the order of the CIT (Appeals) as well as the order of the Tribunal, the well established finding of fact is that the assessee had infact not invested more than 1.5 crores in the Karaka property and the addition which was sought to be made on the basis of the presumption that a total amount of Rs.2.60 crores was not supported or corroborated by any evidence. The findings of the Tribunal is recorded in para 18 of the Tribunal's order, which reads as hereunder:- "After considering the submissions of both the parties and the material on record, it appears that the Assessing Officer made the impugned additon on the basis of certain unsigned draft MOUs found at the premises of the Ramji Mehrotra and eh was of the view that the assesssee had invested a sum of Rs.2.6 crores in the Karaka Property. The learned CIT (A) categorically states that there was no evidence on record to suggest that the assessee had paid anything in excess of Rs.1.5 crore in respect of Karaka property and in this regard
affidavit of Shri Ashok Dalal was filed which the Assesing Officer considered it as a self- serving documents and did not giv e any gognizance to the same. According to erhe learned CIT (A), Shri Ashok Dalal was not a related person of the assessee. In the present case, the assessee made a draft memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with Shri Ashok Dalal for the tenanted property and it was presumed that if the said property got evicted from the tenants the market value would have become so as the assessee may get back a sum of Rs.2.6 crore on the investment of Rs.1.5 crores. However, nothing was found during the course of search or brought on record that he assessee in fact invested a sum of Rs.2.6 crores. The learned CIT(A) categorically stated in para (ix) at page 27 of the impugned order that no paper or corrborative evidence was recovered from the assessee or any of his premises at the time of search action and also no corresponding assets were found with the assessee and that there was not an iota of evidence to prove that the assessee had given a sum of Rs.2.60 crores. According to the learned CIT (A), the entire addition was based on conjectures and surmises without any basis, therefore, the impugned addition was deleted. Nothing contrary to the above observations of the learned CIT (A) has been brought on record.. We, therefore, considering the totality of the facts, as discussed in the former part of this order, do not see any valid ground to interfere with the findings of the learned CIT (A) particularly when the addition was made by the Assessing Officer only on the basis of presumption. In that view of the matter, we do not see any merit in this appeal of the Department." No question of law arises as the matter is completely sealed by the findings of fact. The question is therefore, answered in favour of the assessee and against the department. The appeal is accordingly dismissed. Order Date :- 1.10.2018 pks
More judgments on Section 260-A
- Principal Commissionier of Income Tax vs M/S. Trident Microsystems India Pvt LtdITA/227/20215 Nov 2026
- The Commissioner of Income Tax vs Huawei TechnologiesITA/451/201329 Oct 2026
- The Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax -Central… vs Huawei Telecommunications ( India) Co. Pvt…ITA/775/202629 Oct 2026
- The Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax -Central… vs Huawei Telecommunications ( India) Co. Pvt…ITA/774/202629 Oct 2026
- The Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax -Central… vs Huawei Telecommunications ( India) Co. Pvt…ITA/771/202629 Oct 2026
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- M/S Jaleswar Packaging, Bhubaneswar vs. Superintendent, CGST And Central Excise, BhubaneswarOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- Talasethi Sanmukharao vs. Commissioner, CT And GST, Odisha, CuttackOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- M/S Ramamani Behera (Trade Name S.V.Enterprises) Bhubaneswar vs. Addl Commissioner Of GST And Central Excise, BhubaneswarOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- Prasanta Kumar Biswal vs. The Chief Commissioner, CGST, Central Excise And Customs, BhubaneswarOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- M/S.Dibyanee Agency., Keonjhar. vs. Chief Commissioner Of CT And GST, Odisha, CuttackOrissa · 11 Nov 2026