COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX EXEMPTIONS LUCKNOW AND ANOTHER vs. MAJOR SHIV DAYAL SINGH CHIKITSA TRUST
What did the High Court hold?
The Tribunal upheld the order of the CIT(A) and dismissed the appeal of the Revenue. The Tribunal found that the assessee trust was registered under Section 12AA for charitable activity of "Education". While the AO alleged collection of capitation fee, no order from any regulatory authority was produced to substantiate this claim. The Tribunal noted that Supreme Court judgments permit educational institutions to fix their fee structure to generate a reasonable surplus for expansion, provided there is no profiteering or charging of capitation fees. The assessee demonstrated that for the relevant assessment year, no fee was fixed by the competent authority for MBBS and BAMS courses, and for paramedical courses, the fee charged was within the prescribed limits. The Tribunal concluded that the AO's computation of excess fee was based on presumption and lacked documentary evidence. Furthermore, there was no surplus generated, and the assessee was not engaged in profiteering. The Tribunal found no violation of Sections 11, 12, or 13 of the Act, as the income was applied for charitable purposes (education). Therefore, no substantial question of law was involved, and the appeal was dismissed.
What were the facts?
The assessee, Major Shiv Dayal Singh Chikitsa Trust, a charitable trust running a medical institution, filed its income tax return for Assessment Year 2014-15 declaring Nil income. The Assessing Officer (AO) completed the assessment under Section 143(3) on December 26, 2016, assessing income at Rs. 10,32,13,500/- due to alleged excess fee collection. The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [CIT(A)] allowed the assessee's appeal on June 19, 2017, deleting the additions. The Revenue appealed to the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), which dismissed the appeal on July 29, 2021, upholding the CIT(A)'s order. The present appeal is filed by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Exemptions) Lucknow and another against the ITAT's order.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the Tribunal has erred in law and facts in deleting the addition of Rs. 10,32,13,500/- made by the AO on the plea that the Income Tax Department concerns itself only with the application of income and not how it was earned? (Question of law) 2. Whether the order of the CIT(A) should be cancelled and the order of the AO restored? (Question of mixed law and fact) Assessee's Contentions (as reflected in the Tribunal's findings): - The trust is registered under Section 12AA for charitable activity of "Education", which is included in Section 2(15). - The AO alleged collection of capitation fee without referring to any order or finding from a regulatory authority. - Supreme Court decisions in P.A. Inamdar and Islamic Academy permit educational institutions to fix their own fee structure to generate reasonable surplus for expansion and augmentation, provided there is no profiteering or charging of capitation fees. - The Uttar Pradesh Private Professional Educational Institution (Regulation of Admission and Fixation of Fees) Act, 2006, and the fee fixation committee were in place. - For the academic year 2013-14 (relevant to AY 2014-15), no fee was fixed by the competent authority for MBBS and BAMS courses. For paramedical courses, the fee charged was within the permitted limit. - The AO's computation of excess fee was based on presumption and without documentary evidence. - There was no surplus generated in the year, and the assessee was not engaged in profiteering. - The AO did not point out any violation of Sections 11, 12, or 13 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. Revenue's Contentions (as reflected in the grounds of appeal): - The CIT(A) erred in deleting the addition of Rs. 10,32,13,500/- by stating that the department is concerned only with the application of income, not its earning. - The order of the CIT(A) should be cancelled, and the AO's order restored.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 12AA,Section 2(15),Section 143(3),Section 11,Section 12,Section 13
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
Court No. - 3 Case :- INCOME TAX APPEAL No. - 45 of 2022 Appellant :- Commissioner Of Income Tax Exemptions Lucknow And Another Respondent :- Major Shiv Dayal Singh Chikitsa Trust Counsel for Appellant :- Ashish Agrawal Hon'ble Surya Prakash Kesarwani,J. Hon'ble Jayant Banerji,J. Heard Sri Ashish Agrawal, learned counsel for the appellant-Income Tax Department. The respondent/assessee is a Charitable Trust and runs a Medical Institution. The society was granted Registration under Section 12AA of the Income Tax Act, 1961 by the competent authority. Return of the income was filed by the respondent-assessee on 30.09.2014 for the Assessment Year 2014-15 declaring total income of Rs."Nil". The case was selected for scrutiny and assessment was completed under Section 143(3) of the Income Tax Act on 26.12.2016, assessing the income of respondent-assessee of Rs. 10,32,13,500/- on account of some alleged excess fee charged by the respondent-assessee for various courses offered by the medical college. Aggrieved with the assessment order, the respondents-assessee preferred appeal before CIT(A) who vide order dated 19.06.2017 allowed the appeal of the assessee and deleted the additions made by the Assessing Officer. Aggrieved with the order of the CIT(A), the appellant herein preferred appeal before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal on the following grounds:- "1. The Ld. CIT(A) has erred in law and facts in deleting addition of Rs. 10,32,13,500/- made by the AO on the plea that Income Tax Department concerns only with the application of income and it is not significant how that income was earned. 2. The order of Ld. CIT(A) be cancelled and the order of the AO be restored. 3. Appellant craves leave to modify/amend or add any one or more grounds of appeal" Departmental appeal filed by the appellant herein before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, has been dismissed by the impugned order dated 29.07.2021. In the impugned order, while affirming the order of CIT(A), the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal has recorded the following findings of fact- (Relevant para nos. 6, 6.1.1, 6.1.2, 6.1.3, 6.2, 6.3, 6.4) "6. We have heard rival submission of the parties on the issue in dispute and perused the relevant material on record. We find that the society is registered under Section 12AA of the Act by the Competent Authority for Charitable activity of "Education" and said registration is in operation during the financial year relevant to the assessment year under consideration. In terms of section 2(15) of the Act, the activity of "Education" has been included in charitable activity. We find that the learned Assessing Officer has alleged the assessee of collecting capitation fee, however, no order or finding of any regulatory authority dealing with medical colleges of charges of collection of capital fee has been pointed out by the Assessing Officer. 6.1.1 The Hon'ble Supreme Court framed 11 questions and majority of judges
answered the Question No. 9 that there should not be capitation fee or profiteering, but reasonable surplus to meet cost of expansion and augmentation of facilities does not, however, amounted to profiteering. 6.1.2 In the case of Islamic Academy (supra) also held that each institute must have the freedom to fix its own fee structure taking into consideration the needs to generate funds to run the institution and to provide facilities necessary for the benefit of the students, however, there can be no profiteering and charging of capitation fees. 6.1.3 In P.A. Inamdar (supra), the Supreme Court while answering question no. 3 held that every institution is free to devise its own fee structure but the same can be regulated in the interest of preventing profiteering. No capitation fee can be charged. Leverage was allowed to educational institutions to generate reasonable surplus to meet cost of expansion and augmentation of facilities which would not amount to profiteering. The Court upheld the two Committees for monitoring admission procedure and determining fee structure as held in Islamic Academy was permissible as regulatory measures aimed at protecting the interest of the student community as a whole as also the minorities 6.2 Before the learned CIT(A), the assessee has submitted that pursuant to Supreme Court decision's mentioned above, the State Government of Uttar Pradesh enacted the Uttar Pradesh Private professional Educational Institution (Regulation of Admission and Fixation of Fees) Act, 2006 and fee fixation committee was constituted on 27.06.2008. As regard to fees, the assessee submitted beore the Id. CIT(A) as under:- 13, Pursuant to Supreme Court/ Govt. of U.P. order, the committee fixed provisional fee for Academic Year 2011-12 at Rs. 4.07 lacs vide G.O. no. 3392/71-2-11-W- 64/2007 dated 14.09.2011. Committee also decided to fix final fee and also fee for academic year 2012-13 and 2013-14 later on. Consequently, the Committee was required to fix the final fee for session 2011-12 and thereafter. This has not been done in the instant case, in fact the assessee has gone on record to make a request to this effect. In the G.O. it is also mentioned that final fee will be fixed later on and if the college has taken excess fee, the same will be refunded to students or adjusted against future dues. If fee paid by student is less than fixed, the college will collect the difference from student. 14. The fee fixation order came on 14.09.201, till then the admissions for academic year 2011-12 were almost completed and fee, as decided by the college committee, was deposited by students. Since the final fee was never fixed by the Government, there was no question of refund/ collection of different of fee. 15. The facts of the instant case would reveal that there is no surplus at all, that is earned by the assessee. Ld. Assessing Officer has herself accepted that total utilization of income was Rs. 28,59,66,154/- and total receipts was RS. 27,02,54,348.23 as per para 13 of assessment order. 16 That Ld. Assessing Officer have not referred to any fee fixation order in the assessement order but merely mentioned that the fee fixation committee order has been brought on records by the assessee or the fee fixation order is available in public domain. There after neither final fee for academic year 2011-12 nor fee for next academic years, as mentioned in para-3, been fixed by Govl DGME. It means no fee has been fixed by the competent authority for academic session 2013-14 relevant to A.Y. 2014-15 under consideration. As regards fee for BAMS course, the Govt./ DGME/ Fee Fixation Committee has fixed fee for Govt. Unani, Aurvedic and Homeopathic Medical Colleges only which is clearly mentioned in the order and
has no application on the private ayurvedic meadical colleges. As regards fee for paramedical courses, it is submitted that Uttar Pradesh State Medical Faculty, U.P., had granted permission to start the paramedical courses vide letter no. 3461/12 dated 23.05.2012. As per point 3 of the aforesaid letter the college is permitted to charge tution fee of Rs. 36000/- per student. The assessee college has charged the total fee of Rs. 37500/- which includes tution fee Rs. 36000/- and examination fee Rs. 1500/-. Thus the assessee has not charged any excess fee than fixed by the authorities. Ld. AO has taken the fee fixed of Rs.28000/- as per own imagination. The copy of letter of U.P. State Medical Faculty is enclosed and marked as Annexure-G. In view of the discussion and facts stated above it is very clear that no fee has been fixed by the Government, or and other competent authority for MBBS and BAMS courses run by the assessee, for the academic session 2013-14 (relevant to A. Y. 2014-15). 19. That with regards to question no 2 as to whether assessee has charged fee in excess of fee fixed by the Fee Fixation Authority, the question has no relevancy for MBBS and BAMS courses because, as discussed in para 18 above, no fee has been fixed by the Authority for F.Y. 2013-14 (relevant to A.Y. 2014-15) for these courses, hence there is no question of charging/ collecting fee in excess of fee fixed. As regards paramedical courses the assessee has charged the fee as permitted by Uttar Pradesh State Medical Faculty and no excess fee has been charged. 6.3 On perusal of submission of the assessee, it is clear that only extra fee of Rs.1,500/- was charged and that too was for examination fee. In such circumstances, it cannot be said that any capitation fee has been charged from the students. Moreover, there is no surplus has been generated in the year under consideration and the assessee cannot be alleged for engaged in profiteering also. 6.4 The assessee has contested that no fee was fixed by the state level fee fixation committee for the year under consideration and, therefore, computation of the excess fee by the Assessing Officer, is based on presumption and without any documentary evidence in support. The decisions relied upon 'by the Assessing Officer are in respect of the capitation fee and in absence of any such evidence of collection of capitation fee, the decisions relied upon are not applicable over the facts of the assessee. The Ld. CIT(A) has correctly held that once the assessee is registered section l2AA of the Act, the Assessing Officer has to examine applicability pf section 11, 12 and 13 of the Act. No such violation has been pointed out by the learned Assessing Officer of section 11, 12 and 13 of the Act. The Section 11 prescribe application of the income toward charitable purposes, which in the case of the assessee is for education and the assessee has duly applied its income for said purposes as per the rules specified in the Act. In view of the above facts and circumstances, we do not find any error in the order of the Ld. CIT(A) on the issue in dispute and, accordingly, we uphold the same. The ground of the appeal of the Revenue is accordingly dismissed". The findings recorded by CIT(A) and ITAT are findings of fact based on consideration of the relevant materiel on record. Thus, no substantial question of law involved in the present appeal. In view of the aforesaid, the appeal is dismissed. Order Date :- 7.7.2022 T.S. Digitally signed by TRIBHUWAN SINGH Date: 2022.07.08 15:16:11 IST Reason: Location: High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
More judgments on Section 12AA
- Lowes India Private Limited, Bangalore vs Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle…ITA 1245/BANG/2026[2022-23]Status: Disposed16 Nov 2026AY 2022-23
- Thirumangai Alwar Charitable Trust, Madurai vs Commissioner of Income Tax(Exemption)…ITA 1080/CHNY/2026[2026-27]Status: Disposed12 Nov 2026AY 2026-27
- Pooliah Thevar Krishnaveni, Madurai vs ITO, Ncw-2(3), MaduraiITA 3287/CHNY/2025[2016-17]Status: Disposed12 Nov 2026AY 2016-17
- Pooliah Thevar Krshnaveni, Madurai vs ITO, Ncw-2(3), MaduraiITA 3286/CHNY/2025[2015-16]Status: Disposed12 Nov 2026AY 2015-16
- Pooliah Thevar Krishnaveni, Madurai vs ITO, Ncw-2(3), MaduraiITA 3285/CHNY/2025[2014-15]Status: Disposed12 Nov 2026AY 2014-15
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- M/S Jaleswar Packaging, Bhubaneswar vs. Superintendent, CGST And Central Excise, BhubaneswarOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- Talasethi Sanmukharao vs. Commissioner, CT And GST, Odisha, CuttackOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- M/S Ramamani Behera (Trade Name S.V.Enterprises) Bhubaneswar vs. Addl Commissioner Of GST And Central Excise, BhubaneswarOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- Prasanta Kumar Biswal vs. The Chief Commissioner, CGST, Central Excise And Customs, BhubaneswarOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- M/S.Dibyanee Agency., Keonjhar. vs. Chief Commissioner Of CT And GST, Odisha, CuttackOrissa · 11 Nov 2026