M.JAMES vs. THE INCOME TAX OFFICER, KANNUR AND OTHE

PDF · subscribers
WP(C)/9766/2009HC KeralaKLHC01051352200927 November 2012Bench: HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE ANTONY DOMINIC6 pages
AI SummaryPartly Allowed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the Additional Commissioner (R2) erred by adjudicating the merits of the waiver applications under Sections 139(8) and 217 after realizing he lacked jurisdiction. He should have returned the applications to the petitioner. Consequently, Exts. P8 and P9 were set aside, and the Assessing Officer (R1) was directed to consider the petitioner's subsequent applications (Exts. P12 and P13) under Rule 40 and Rule 117A of the Income Tax Rules. Regarding Ext. P10, the Court found that the Commissioner (R3) did not properly consider the waiver application under Section 220(2A). The insistence on the petitioner proving the financial hardship of other partners was inappropriate, as the application was for personal relief. Furthermore, attributing non-cooperation to a legal heir was incorrect, especially when the entire tax demand was paid in installments. The Court also noted that the reasons for default were not adequately considered. Therefore, Ext. P10 was set aside, and the Commissioner (R3) was directed to reconsider the application (Ext. P5) and pass fresh orders in accordance with the law.

What were the facts?

The petitioner, M. James, is the legal heir of late Sri. Chacko Mathew, a partner in Malanadu Liquors. The petitioner challenged orders rejecting his applications for waiver of interest on the firm's tax liability for assessment year 1981-82. Specifically, Exts. P8 and P9 rejected applications for waiver of interest under Sections 139(8) and 217 of the Income Tax Act, passed by the Additional Commissioner (R2) who lacked jurisdiction. Ext. P10 rejected an application under Section 220(2A) for waiver of interest under Section 220(2), passed by the Commissioner (R3). The petitioner had paid the entire principal demand by October 2008. The Tax Recovery Officer (R4) issued notices for recovery of arrears.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the Additional Commissioner of Income Tax (R2) erred in adjudicating the merits of the petitioner's applications for waiver of interest under Sections 139(8) and 217 of the Income Tax Act, despite lacking jurisdiction to entertain them? 2. Whether the Commissioner of Income Tax (R3) properly considered the petitioner's application for waiver of interest under Section 220(2A) of the Income Tax Act, particularly regarding the conditions of financial hardship and lack of co-operation? Assessee's Arguments: - The Additional Commissioner (R2) should have returned the applications for waiver under Sections 139(8) and 217 for want of jurisdiction, without deciding on merits. - The Commissioner (R3) erred in rejecting the waiver application under Section 220(2A) by insisting on proof of financial hardship of other partners, when the application was for relief from personal interest liability. - The Commissioner (R3) wrongly attributed non-cooperation to a legal heir and overlooked the fact that the entire tax demand was paid in installments. - The reasons justifying the default were not properly considered. Revenue's Arguments: - The judgment does not record specific arguments made by the revenue.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 139(8),Section 217,Section 220(2A),Section 220(2)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM PRESENT: THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE ANTONY DOMINIC TUESDAY, THE 27TH DAY OF NOVEMBER 2012/6TH AGRAHAYANA 1934 WP(C).No. 9766 of 2009 (M) -------------------------- PETITIONERS: ------------- M.JAMES,PP-VI/125,MANGARA HOUSE, OPP;ST.JUDE CHURCH,P.O.,THADIKKADAVU CHANOKUNDU,TALIPARAMBA TALUK,KANNUR DISTRICT. BY ADVS.SRI.T.M.SREEDHARAN SMT.C.K.SHERIN SRI.V.P.NARAYANAN RESPONDENTS: -------------- 1. THE INCOME TAX OFFICER, WARD-1,KANNUR. 2. THE ADDITIONAL COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX,RANGE 1,KANNUR. 3. THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, KANNUR. 4. THE TAX RECOVERY OFFICER, RANGE-1,KANNOTHUMCHAL,KANNUR. BY ADV. SRI.JOSE JOSEPH, SC, FOR INCOME TAX

THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 27-11-2012, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

APPENDIX(WPC 9766/2009) PETITIONER'S EXHIBTS: P1: TRUE COPY OF NOTICE DT.9.2.2009 ISSUED BY R4 TO THE PETITIONER. P2: TRUE COPY OF STATEMENT OF ARREARS FURNISHED BY R4. P3: TRUE COPY OF APPLICATION DT.23.8.08 FOR WAIVER OF INTEREST SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER BEFORE R2 UNDER SEC.139(8). P4: TRUE COPY OF APPLICATION DT.1.3.08 FOR WAIVER OF INTEREST SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER BEFORE R2 UNDER SEC.217. P5: TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION DT.23.2.09 SUBMITTED BEFORE R3 BY THE PETITIONER UNDER SEC.220(2). P6: TRUE COPY OF REPRESENTATION DT.12.2.2009 SUBMITTED BY PETITIONER TO R2. P7:TRUE COPY OF JUDGMENT DT.4.3.2009 IN WPC NO.6590/2009 OF THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA. P8: TRUE COPY OF ORDER DT.12.3.2009 PASSED RELATING TO WAIVER OF INTEREST U/S.139(8). P9: .DO. .DO. U/S.217. P10: TRUE COPY OF ORDER C.NO.220-6/CIT/KNR/08-09 DT.19.3.2009 PASSED BY R3. P11: TRUE COPY OF NOTICE DT.27.2.2009 UNDER RULES 38 AND 52 OF THE TAX RECOVERY RULES ISSUED BY R4. P12: TRUE COPY OF PETITION FILED UNDER RULE 40 OF THE IT RULES DT.12.3.2009 SUBMITTED BY PETITIONER BEFORE R1. P13: TRUE COPY OF PETITION UNDER RULE 117A OF THE IT RULES DT.12.3.2009 SUBMITTED BY PETITIONER BEFORE R1. P14: TRUE COPY OF ORDER DT.23.2.2007 PASSED BY R3. P15: TRUE COPY OF PROCEEDINGS DT.27.12.2001 PASSED BY R1. P16: TRUE COPY OF NOTICE OF DEMAND IN FORM NO.57 DT.6.8.2004 ISSUED BY R4. P17: TRUE COPY OF RECEIPT DT.30.3.2009 ISSUED BY THE TAX RECOVERY OFFICER, RANGE-1, KANNUR. P18: TRUE COPY OF RECEIPT DT.15.4.2009 ISSUED BY THE TAX RECOVERY OFFICER, RANGE-1, KANNUR. TRUE COPY pms P.S. to Judge

ANTONY DOMINIC, J. .................................................................... W.P.(C) No.9766 of 2009 .................................................................... Dated this the 27th day of November, 2012. JUDGMENT Heard learned Senior counsel for the petitioner and the learned counsel for the respondents. 2. Petitioner's father late Sri.Chacko Mathew was a partner in a firm by name Malanadu Liquors. His father expired on 20.6.1994. The challenge in this Writ Petition pertains to Exts.P8, P9 and P10 orders rejecting the applications made by the petitioner seeking waiver of interest on the tax liability of the firm for the assessment year 1981-82. In so far as Exts.P8 and P9 are concerned, those orders were passed on Exts.P3 and P4 applications filed by the petitioner, seeking waiver of interest levied under Sections 139(8) and 217 of the Income Tax Act. Reading of Exts.P8 and P9 orders passed by the second respondent shows that the authority competent to consider Exts.P3 and P4 is the Assessing Officer, the first respondent. However, after holding that he had no jurisdiction to entertain the application, he went into the merits of the claim and held that the petitioner is not eligible for waiver.

W.P.(C) No.9766/2009 2 3. In my view, once the second respondent has realised that he had no jurisdiction to have entertained Exts.P3 and P4, he had no reason to have adjudicated the entitlement to the petitioner on merits and instead he should have left the matter at that stage so that the petitioner could have moved the competent authority for waiver. In this case both sides submit that subsequently petitioner filed Exts.P12 and P13 before the first respondent, the competent authority, seeking waiver as permissible under Rule 40 and Rule 117A of the Income Tax Rules. In such circumstances, I set aside Exts.P8 and P9 and direct that the first respondent shall consider Exts.P12 and P13 in accordance with law and pass orders thereon. 4. Now what remains is Ext.P10. Ext.P10 order was passed by the third respondent on Ext.P5 application filed by the petitioner under Section 220(2A) of the Income Tax Act seeking waiver of interest levied on the petitioner under Section 220(2) of the said Act. Reading of this order shows that the claim of the petitioner has been rejected on merits on the ground that the petitioner has not cumulatively satisfied the conditions specified in Section 220(2A). In this order the third

W.P.(C) No.9766/2009 3 respondent has accepted that by October 2008 the petitioner has paid the entire principal demand of tax. However, as far as the financial hardship which is to be proved by the applicant is concerned, it has been held that the petitioner has failed in proving the financial hardship of the other partners of the firm also. As far as this aspect of the matter is concerned, in Ext.P5 what was sought by the petitioner is that he should be relieved of the interest liability. In such a situation he cannot be expected to prove the financial hardship of the other partners of the firm who are not the applicants. In such a case the Officer could not have insisted that the petitioner should prove the financial hardship of the other partners and should not have rejected his application on his failure. 5. It is also held that there was no co-operation in the assessment and recovery. First of all, such a non-operation could have been attributed against the assessees and could not have been attributed against a legal heir. On the other hand, the order itself discloses that the petitioner has paid the entire tax demand in instalments. The third condition is that the default should be for reasons beyond the control of

W.P.(C) No.9766/2009 4 the assessee. It is seen that the petitioner has filed a representation supplying the facts, which according to him, justifies his request that there has been no proper consideration of that aspect also. In such circumstances, I am not satisfied that there has been a proper consideration of the petitioner's request as required under Section 220(2A). For that reason I set aside Ext.P10. The third respondent is directed to consider Ext.P5 and pass fresh orders in accordance with law. Writ Petition is disposed of accordingly.

ANTONY DOMINIC Judge pms

More judgments on Section 139(8)

All 71 judgments and leading authorities on Section 139(8) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →