PACIFIC PROJECTS LIMITED vs. ASSTT CIT,

PDF · subscribers
W.P.(C)/2080/2020HC DelhiDLHC01013778202023 December 2020Bench: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANMOHAN,HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA6 pages
AI SummaryAllowed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the ITAT had erroneously concluded that the miscellaneous application was barred by limitation. The Court found that the petitioner was not served with the ITAT's ex-parte order because the address used by the Department was the petitioner's former address. The Court agreed with the petitioner that the limitation period under Section 254(2) should commence from the date of actual receipt of the order, or when the affected party had actual or constructive knowledge of the order, not merely from the date the order was passed. This principle was supported by the Division Bench judgment in 'Golden Times Services Pvt. Ltd. Vs. DCIT'. The Court quashed the ITAT's order dated July 29, 2019, and set aside the ex-parte order dated September 1, 2017. The ITAT was directed to hear and dispose of the appeal on merits after affording parties an opportunity of hearing. The petitioner also stated they would apply under the 'Vivad Se Vishwas' scheme.

What were the facts?

The petitioner, Pacific Projects Limited, filed a writ petition challenging an order dated July 29, 2019, passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT). This ITAT order dismissed the petitioner's miscellaneous application filed under Section 254(2) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, seeking recall of an ex-parte order dated September 1, 2017. The ex-parte order had remanded the matter to the Assessing Officer. The petitioner contended that it had changed its address and was not properly served with the ITAT's ex-parte order. The ITAT had dismissed the miscellaneous application, holding it was filed beyond the six-month limitation period from the date the order was passed.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the miscellaneous application filed by the petitioner under Section 254(2) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, seeking recall of the ITAT's ex-parte order dated September 1, 2017, was barred by limitation, considering the petitioner's claim of non-service and lack of knowledge of the order. Assessee's Contentions: The petitioner argued that the limitation period for filing a miscellaneous application under Section 254(2) should commence from the date of actual receipt of the order, not from the date it was passed, especially when there was no proper service or knowledge of the order. They relied on the Division Bench judgment of the Delhi High Court in 'Golden Times Services Pvt. Ltd. Vs. DCIT' (W.P. (C) No. 402/2020). Revenue's Contentions: The judgment records that the learned counsel for the respondent took time to obtain instructions. No specific arguments or reliance on authorities by the revenue are recorded.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 254(2),Section 254(3)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

WP(C) 2080/2020

Page 1 of 6

$~1 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

+ W.P. (C) 2080/2020 & CM APPLs.7346-7347/2020

PACIFIC PROJECTS LIMITED

..... Petitioner Through: Mr. Salil Kapoor with

Mr. Vetakesh Chaurasia, Mr. Sumit Lalchandani, Ms. Ananya Kapoor.

versus ASSTT CIT

...... Respondent Through: Mr. Kunal Sharma, Advocate.

Date of Decision: 23rd December, 2020 CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANMOHAN HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA

J U D G M E N T MANMOHAN, J (Oral) 1. Present writ petition has been filed challenging the order dated 29 : th July, 2019 passed by the ITAT dismissing the miscellaneous application filed by the petitioner/assessee under Section 254(2) for recall of the ex-parte order dated 01st 2. The ITAT in its order dated 29 September, 2017 whereby the matter was remanded to the Assessing Officer to decide the matter afresh after examining all documents, including additional evidences as well as books of accounts, bills and vouchers, etc. th July, 2019 held that it had no power to condone the delay in filing the application under Section 254(2) as the petitioner had filed the miscellaneous application after six months from the end of the month in which the impugned order

WP(C) 2080/2020

Page 2 of 6

had been passed. 3. It is the case of the appellant/assessee that it had changed its address and shifted to 301-307, 3rd Floor, Plot No. 9, DDA Service Centre, Rohini, Delhi-110085 from Safeway House, D-4, Commercial Complex, Prashant Vihar, New Delhi-110085 w.e.f. 15th November, 2008 and this fact had been mentioned in the appeal filed by the assessee in Form No. 35 against the order dated 02nd 4. On the last date of hearing, learned counsel for the respondent had taken time to obtain instructions. December, 2018 passed by the DCIT, Circle 14(1) New Delhi. 5. Having heard learned counsel for parties and having perused the paper book, we find that the address of the appellant mentioned in the appeal before the ITAT by the respondent/Department was its former address and not the new address, which had been mentioned in the appeal filed by the petitioner before the Commissioner, Income Tax (Appellate) in form No. 35. 6. Consequently, the petitioner was never served in the appeal filed by the Department before the ITAT. 7. This Court is also of the view that the ITAT has erroneously concluded that the miscellaneous application filed by the petitioner was barred by limitation under Section 254(2) of the Act inasmuch as the petitioner had filed the miscellaneous application within six months of actual receipt of the order. If the petitioner/assessee had no notice and no knowledge of the order passed by the ITAT, it cannot be said that the limitation would start from the date the order was pronounced by the Tribunal.

WP(C) 2080/2020

Page 3 of 6

8.

In fact, the issue raised in the present petition is squarely covered in favour of the petitioner/assessee by way of the Division Bench judgment of this Court in ‘Golden Times Services Pvt. Ltd. Vs. DCIT’ being W.P. (C) No. 402/2020 dated 13th “10. Be that as it may, the real question before us is as to what would be the relevant date for the purpose of commencement of period of limitation. To hold the date of the order to be the relevant date for the purpose of calculating the period of six months envisaged under Section 254(2) of the Act, can lead to several absurd and anomalous situations. An order passed without the knowledge of the aggrieved party, would render the remedy against the order meaningless as the same would be lost by limitation while the person aggrieved would not even know that an order has been passed. Such an interpretation would not advance the cause of justice and would not be the correct approach and thus cannot be countenanced. A person who is aggrieved or concerned with an order would legitimately be expected to exercise his rights conferred by the provision and unless the order is communicated or is known to him, either actually or constructively, he would not be in a position to avail such a remedy. The words “six months from the end of the month in which the order was passed” therefore, cannot be given a narrow and restrictive interpretation. There are several decisions of the Apex Court and other High Courts, where similar question came up for consideration. The Courts have always leaned in favour of an interpretation which would enable an aggrieved party to avail its remedy in a meaningful manner, so that the right conferred by a provision does not remain fanciful or illusionary.

xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx

January, 2020 wherein it has been held as under:

WP(C) 2080/2020

Page 4 of 6

12.

As noted above, Section 254(2) of the Act has undergone certain amendments. However, there is no dispute that the provision still retains the distinctive two parts as observed by the Supreme Court in the abovenoted case. We are presently concerned with a scenario under Section 254 (2) of the Act where the assessee has invoked its jurisdiction seeking rectification / amendment of the order passed by the ITAT. In this situation, the assessee has claimed that it did not have the knowledge of the earlier order passed by the ITAT on 18.10.2016 and the period of limitation of six months should commence from the date of the receipt of the order. In our opinion, the limitation would begin to run when the affected person has the knowledge of the decision. The date when the order was passed cannot be solely determined by referring to the date when the same was signed by the ITAT. We further find that under Section 254 (3) of the Act, the law stipulates that the ITAT shall send a copy of the order passed by it to the assessee and the Principal Commissioner. Further, Rule 35 of the ITAT Rules also requires that the orders are required to be communicated to the parties. For ready reference, Section 254 (3) of the Act and the relevant rule are reproduced hereinunder:

“254. Orders of Appellate Tribunal.

xxxx xxxx xxxx

(3) The Appellate Tribunal shall send a copy of any orders passed under this section to the assessee and to the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner.

35.

Order to be communicated to parties. The Tribunal shall, after the order is signed, cause it to be communicated to the assessee and to the Commissioner.”

WP(C) 2080/2020

Page 5 of 6

13.

From the abovenoted provisions, it emerges that the Section and the Rule mandates the communication of the order to the parties. Thus, the date of communication or knowledge, actual or constructive, of the orders sought to be rectified or amended under Section 254(2) of the Act becomes critical and determinative for the commencement of the period of limitation. The ITAT has not applied its mind on this aspect and has been swayed by the literal and mechanical construction of the words “six months from the end of the month in which the order was passed”. The ITAT failed to even delve into the question whether the affected party, either actually or constructively, was in knowledge of the order passed by the ITAT. xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx

15.

The assessee had challenged the ex parte order dated 18.10.2016 and consequently, keeping in view, the aforesaid decisions, we are of the considered opinion that the starting point of limitation provided under Section 254 (2) of the Act has to commence from the date of the actual receipt of the judgment and order passed by the ITAT which is sought to be the reviewed.”

9.

For the foregoing reasons, the course adopted by the ITAT at the first instance, by dismissing the appeal for non-prosecution, and then compounding the same by refusing to entertain the application for recall of the order, cannot be sustained. We, therefore have no hesitation in quashing the impugned order. Accordingly, the present petition is allowed. The order dated 29th July, 2019 is quashed and in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case, we also set-aside the ex-parte order dated 1st September 2017 with a direction that the

WP(C) 2080/2020

Page 6 of 6

ITAT shall hear and dispose of ITA No. 6686/De1/2013 on merits after affording the parties an opportunity of hearing. 10. At this stage, learned counsel for petitioner states that the petitioner shall apply under the Amnesty Scheme being “Vivad Se Vishwas”. The statement made by learned counsel for appellant is accepted by this Court and the matter is held bound by the same.

MANMOHAN, J

SANJEEV NARULA, J DECEMBER 23, 2020 AS

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →