THE COMMERCIAL TAX OFFICER vs. M/S.SICILLIA HOTEL PRIVATE LIMITED

PDF · subscribers
RP/437/2017HC KeralaKLHC01041370201718 June 2018Author: HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P.R.RAMACHANDRA MENON,HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN8 pages
AI SummaryRemanded

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court allowed the review petitions and recalled the judgment under challenge. The Court noted that the Division Bench, in its earlier judgment, had relied solely on the Supreme Court's decision in Bhima Jewellery, which held that compounding orders are akin to concluded contracts and cannot be modified. However, it was not brought to the Bench's notice that another Division Bench of the same High Court in Kalika Hotel and Bar Amballur had taken a contrary view, holding that the tax paid at a compound rate would enable the Assessing Officer to arrive at the highest turnover tax payable for any of the previous three consecutive years, taking into account assessed tax as modified in appeal or other proceedings. The Court also considered the Supreme Court's judgment in M/s Hans Steel Rolling Mill Vs. Commissioner of Central Excise, Chandigarh, which suggested that compounding orders operate under an independent regime. Given the perceived conflict and the omission of a binding precedent, the Court found it appropriate to recall its earlier judgment. The appeals were directed to be placed before the appropriate Bench for fresh consideration.

What were the facts?

These review petitions were filed by the Commercial Tax Department of Kerala challenging a judgment of a Division Bench of the High Court of Kerala dated November 11, 2016. The original appeals (W.A. Nos. 121, 163, 220, 229, and 413 of 2015) had confirmed the judgments of a learned single judge, thereby dismissing the department's appeals. The core issue revolved around whether an order sanctioning the compounding of tax under the Kerala General Sales Tax Act could be automatically rectified or modified if the base years used for quantifying the compounded tax were subsequently rectified or reassessed, especially when the statutory limitation periods for such modifications had expired.

What were the issues?

1. Whether, under the regime of compounding of tax under the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, an order sanctioning compounding can be automatically rectified, modified, or changed solely due to a rectification or reassessment of the assessment of the previous three years (base years) used for quantifying the compounded tax, especially when the statutory limitation periods under Sections 43, 35, or 37 of the KGST Act have elapsed? Assessee's Contention (Revenue in the original appeals): The modification of the base year assessments should automatically lead to a modification of the compounding order. The Revenue relied on the judgment in Kalika Hotel and Bar Amballur (M/s) Vs. State of Kerala [2012 (3) KHC 85]. Revenue's Contention (Assessee in the original appeals): No modification could be made to the compounding order as the statutory limitation periods under Sections 43, 35, or 37 of the KGST Act had already elapsed. They relied on the Supreme Court judgment in Bhima Jewellery Vs. Assistant Commissioner (Assessment), Kerala and another [2014 (71) VST 100 (SC)].

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 43,Section 35,Section 37

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Heard together (7 matters)

RP.No. 437 of 2017
WA. 413/2015
R.P. NO. 439 OF 2017
W.A. No. 220 of 2015
W.A. No. 121 of 2015
W.A. No. 229 of 2015
W.A. No. 163 of 2015

Read from the judgment's own cause title. This page is filed under one of them.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM PRESENT: THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P.R.RAMACHANDRA MENON & THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN MONDAY, THE 18TH DAY OF JUNE 2018 / 28TH JYAISHTA, 1940 RP.No. 437 of 2017 IN WA. 413/2015 AGAINST THE JUDGMENT IN WA 413/2015 of HIGH COURT OF KERALA DATED 11-11-2016 REVIEW PETITIONER(S)/APPELLANTS 1 THE COMMERCIAL TAX OFFICER FIRST CIRCLE, OFFICE OF THE COMMERCIAL TAX OFFICER, THODUPUZHA. 2 THE INSPECTING ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER IDUKKI AT KATTAPPANA, IDUKKI DISTRICT. BY SENIOR GOVERNMENT PLEADER SRI. C. K. GOVINDAN RESPONDENT(S)/RESPONDENT: M/S.SICILLIA HOTEL PRIVATE LIMITED IDUKKI ROAD, THODUPUZHA, IDUKKI DISTRICT, PIN-685584, REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR, SRI.K.J.MATHEW.

BY SRI.RAJU JOSEPH (SR.) BY SRI.GEORGE KUTTY MATHEW THIS REVIEW PETITION HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 18-06-2018 ALONG WITH R.P. NO. 439 OF 2017 AND CONNECTED CASES, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY PASSED THE FOLLOWING:

P.R. RAMACHANDRA MENON &

DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN, JJ. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ R. P. No. 437 of 2017 in W. A. No. 413 of 2015, R. P. No. 439 of 2017 in W.A. No. 220 of 2015, R. P. No. 453 of 2017 in W.A. No. 121 of 2015, R. P. No. 463 of 2017 in W.A. No. 229 of 2015, and R. P. No. 484 of 2017 in W.A. No. 163 of 2015 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Dated, this the 18th day of June, 2018 O R D E R Devan Ramachandran , J. These applications for review have been preferred by the Deputy Commissioner and other functionaries of the of Commercial Taxes Department of the State of Kerala. 2. These applications are directed against the judgment of a Division Bench of this Court in W.A. Nos. 121, 163, 220, 229 and 413 of 2015 dated 11th of November, 2016, as per which, the judgments of the learned single Judge impugned therein were confirmed, thus dismissing the appeals. 3. We notice that the essential question placed for the consideration of the Division Bench when the above mentioned appeals were heard, was whether, under the regime relating to the compounding of tax under the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, when

: 2 : there is a rectification or reassessment of the assessment of the previous three years, which were the base years adopted for the purpose of quantifying the compounded tax, the order sanctioning the compounding of tax can be automatically rectified, modified or changed, solely on account of the modification in the assessment of the base years. 4. While the appellants took a stand that such a modification was axiomatic and automatic, the various writ petitioners/respondents in the appeal contended that no such modification could be done to the order sanctioning compounding, since the period of limitation statutorily fixed under Sections 43, 35 or 37 of the KGST Act had already concededly elapsed. 5. When the appeals were heard, the Bench relied upon the judgment of the Honourable Supreme Court in Bhima Jewellery Vs. Assistant Commissioner (Assessment), Kerala and another [2014 (71) VST 100 (SC)], which declared the law that orders of compounding are akin to the concluded contracts between the parties, and, therefore, that it cannot be modified, changed or varied later on. However when the judgment in the appeals was delivered, it was not brought to the notice of the Bench that another judgment by another

: 3 : Division Bench in Kalika Hotel and Bar Amballur (M/s) Vs. State of Kerala [2012 (3) KHC 85] had considered the very same issue and that in paragraph 8 of the said judgment it was held as follows : “8. On the strength of the above finding we hold that the tax paid would necessarily include the tax assessed and the payment of tax at compound rate in Section 7 applicable to the case of the assessee would definitely enable the Assessingofficer to arrive the highest turnover tax payable for any of theprevious three consecutive years; taking into account the assessed tax, as modified in appeal, revision or otherproceedings. The question raised by the assessee in STRs 59 & 61 of 2012, has to be answered in favour of the Revenue and against the assessee. However, since the assessment of the earlier year 2008-09 is remanded, the determination of the highest turnover tax for the purpose of granting facility of payment of tax at compound rates would also depend on such assessment proceedings directed to be de-novo completed. In the above circumstance, we answer the question of law in favour of the Revenue and against the assessee, but all the same remand the assessment to the Assessing Officer for de novo consideration in accordance with law.”

: 4 : 6. The learned senior Government Pleader Sri. C. K. Govindan submits before us that since the judgment in question has been delivered without the afore mentioned judgment in Kalika Hotels and Bar [supra], being brought to its notice, it should be deemed to be a case where the judgment is in error on the face of it, on account of the fact another judgment of a Bench of coordinate jurisdiction had spoke contrary to the view taken in the judgment sought to be reviewed in these petitions. 7. In response to this, the learned Senior counsel Sri. Raju Joseph, assisted by Sri. George Kutty Mathew, appearing for the various respondents in these cases, relies upon the judgment of this Court in KSEB, Tvm. and another Vs. Sulabha Marketing (P) Ltd. And others [2017 (4) KHC 547], which was authored by one among us [PRRM (J)], which, according to him, declares that instances of this nature cannot be seen to be one warranting invocation of the jurisdiction of review, since what is pleaded in the above Review Petitions is not that there is an error apparent on the face of it, but amounts to an attempt at rehearing of the entire case. 8. We have considered the submissions made on behalf of the parties as afore and we have also considered the various judgments

: 5 : that have been placed for our consideration. 9. We notice that in Kalika Hotels and Bar [supra], a Division Bench of this Court had already concluded in a particular manner as has been extracted above. Eventhough, the judgments in these appeals were delivered after Kalika Hotels and Bar [supra] had been delivered, this fact had not been brought to the notice of the Bench, leading to a situation where the binding precedent in Bhima Jewellery's case [supra] was alone noticed, based on which, the judgments called into question herein were delivered, confirming the impugned judgments of the learned single Judge, holding that even if the assessment of the base years are modified and varied, such modification cannot be made applicable to the orders permitting compounding thereafter, since the period of limitation had already elapsed. 10. Further, we are also drawn to a consideration whether another judgment of the Honourable Supreme Court in M/s Hans Steel Rolling Mill Vs. Commissioner of Central Excise, Chandigarh [AIR 2011 SC (Supp.) 202] would also apply to the facts of this case, because in this judgment the Hon'ble Supreme Court has taken a view, albeit under the Central Excise Tariff Act,

: 6 : 1985, that orders of compounding would have to be treated as an independent regime, not being guided by the various provisions of the Statute, under which regime had been brought in force. In particular, the views of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in paragraphs 9, 13 and 14 of the said judgment are relevant and pertinent and we are of the view, that for a proper adjudication of the issues in the appeals, a detailed examination of the declaration by the Hono'ble Supreme Court in Hans Steel Rolling Mill's case [supra] will also be germane and necessary. 11. In the said circumstances and being guided by the afore view, we deem it apposite to allow these review petitions and recall the judgment, against which these applications have been impelled. It is so ordered. 12. We are persuaded to allow these R.P.s also for the additional reason that another learned Judge of this Court has, in W.P. (C) No. 34002 of 2016, already issued a detailed order of reference, on account of the perceived conflict in the views in several judgments of this Court including in Kalika Hotels and Bar [supra] which appear to be stating law in a contrary manner as recorded in the judgments in the appeals from which these R.P.s have arisen.

: 7 : 13. Consequently, the Registry is directed to place all these appeals along with connected matters before the appropriate Bench as per the roster. sd/- P. R. RAMACHANDRA MENON, JUDGE sd/- DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN,

JUDGE kmd /True copy/ P.A. To Judge

More judgments on Section 43

All 78 judgments and leading authorities on Section 43 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →