MERINO PANEL PRODUCTS LTD. vs. DY. EXCISE AND TAXATION COMMISSIONER

PDF · subscribers
CWP/12139/2006HC Punjab & HaryanaPHHC01049747200628 August 2018Author: MR. JUSTICE RAJESH BINDAL,MR. JUSTICE AMIT RAWAL,MR. JUSTICE AVNEESH JHINGAN15 pages
AI SummaryAllowed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court allowed the writ petition and set aside the revisional order. The Court held that the Deputy Excise & Taxation Commissioner lacked jurisdiction to issue the notice for revision under Section 40 of the 1973 Act after its repeal. This was based on the Supreme Court's decision in State of Haryana vs Hindustan Construction Company Limited, which affirmed that Section 61 of the 2003 Act only saved pending proceedings and did not permit the initiation of fresh revisional proceedings under the repealed Act. The Court found that the notice for revision was issued on 15.5.2006, long after the repeal of the 1973 Act, and no proceedings were pending. The revenue's contention that Section 61(2)(d) of the 2003 Act was applicable was rejected, as this provision did not pertain to the exercise of revisional power but rather saved benefits granted to industrial units. The ratio decidendi is that a repeal followed by a fresh enactment on the same subject, with a saving clause that explicitly limits the saving to pending proceedings, excludes the application of general saving provisions like Section 4 of the Punjab General Clauses Act, 1858, for initiating new actions.

What were the facts?

The petitioner, Merino Panel Products Limited, filed a writ petition challenging an order dated 27.3.2006 passed by the Deputy Excise & Taxation Commissioner (Revisional Authority) under Section 40 of the Haryana General Sales Tax Act, 1973 (the 1973 Act). The assessment year in question was 2002-03. The 1973 Act was repealed and replaced by the Haryana Value Added Tax Act, 2003 (the 2003 Act) effective from 1.4.2003. The Assessing Authority had passed its order on 21.6.2005, and a notice for revision was issued on 17.1.2006. The High Court, doubting its earlier judgment in Hindustan Construction Company Limited, referred the matter to a Larger Bench. The Supreme Court later upheld the High Court's view in State of Haryana vs Hindustan Construction Company Limited.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the Deputy Excise & Taxation Commissioner had the jurisdiction to issue a notice for revision under Section 40 of the Haryana General Sales Tax Act, 1973, after the said Act was repealed by the Haryana Value Added Tax Act, 2003, and in the absence of any pending proceedings under the repealed Act. Assessee's Contention: The petitioner argued that the revisional order was without jurisdiction because the notice for revision was issued after the repeal of the 1973 Act. They relied on the High Court's judgment in Hindustan Construction Company Limited, which was subsequently upheld by the Supreme Court in State of Haryana vs Hindustan Construction Company Limited, stating that only pending proceedings were saved, not the power to initiate fresh proceedings. Revenue's Contention: The revenue contended that the petitioner's case would fall under Section 61(2)(d) of the 2003 Act, implying that the revisional power could still be exercised. They did not dispute that the Supreme Court upheld the judgment in Hindustan Construction Company Limited.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 40,Section 61

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

CWP No. 12139 of 2006 (O&M) -1-

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH CWP No. 12139 of 2006 (O&M) Date of decision: 28.8.2018 Merino Panel Products Limited

.. Petitioner vs Deputy Excise & Taxation Commissioner (I)-cum Revisional Authority, Jhajjar

.. Respondent

Coram: Hon'ble Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal Hon'ble Mr. Justice Amit Rawal Hon'ble Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan

Present Mr. Sandeep Goyal and Mr. Avneet Singh, Advocates, for the petitioner.

Ms. Mamta Singla Talwar, Deputy Advocate General, Haryana. Rajesh Bindal, J. 1.

The petitioner has filed the present petition challenging the order dated 27.3.2006 passed by the Deputy Excise & Taxation Commissioner in exercise of power under Section 40 of the Haryana General Sales Tax Act, 1973 (for short, 'the 1973 Act'). 2.

Assessment of the petitioner for the assessment year 2002-03 was framed by the Assessing Authority vide order dated 21.6.2005. Notice for revision of the order was issued on 17.1.2006. It is important to note here that the 1973 Act was repealed with the enactment of Haryana Value Added Tax Act, 2003 (for short, 'the 2003 Act') with effect from 1.4.2003. This Court in Hindustan Construction Company Limited vs State of Haryana and others (2005) 141 STC 119, opined that no notice under Section 40 of the 1973 Act

CWP No. 12139 of 2006 (O&M) -2-

could be issued after the repeal thereof as in Section 61 of the 2003 Act, only the pending proceedings have been saved with no power to initiate fresh proceedings for suo-moto revision of assessment order passed under the 1973 3.

When the case came up for hearing before the Division Bench of this Court, the opinion expressed by the Division Bench of this Court in Hindustan Construction Company Limited's case (supra), was doubted and the matter was referred to be considered by a Larger Bench of this Court vide order dated 4.8.2006. This is how the writ petition has been listed before this Bench. 4.

Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that this Court while referring the matter to the Larger Bench had doubted the correctness of the earlier judgment of this Court in Hindustan Construction Company Limited's case (supra). The aforesaid judgment was challenged by the State before Hon'ble the Supreme Court and the same has been upheld vide judgment reported as State of Haryana and others vs Hindustan Construction Company Limited 2017 (9) SCC 463. In the aforesaid judgment, not only the provision of Section 61 of the 2003 Act as was existing at the time of enactment of the 2003 Act, but even the amendment carried out to the 2003 Act on 2.4.2010, with effect from 1.4.2003, was also considered. It was opined that the only saving was to the pending proceedings at the time of enactment of the 2003 Act with no power to initiate fresh proceedings. Hence, the revisional order passed by the authority deserves to be set aside.

CWP No. 12139 of 2006 (O&M) -3-

On the other hand, learned counsel for the State while not disputing the fact that judgment of this Court in Hindustan Construction Company Limited's case (supra) has been upheld by Hon'ble the Supreme Court, submitted that the case of the petitioner would fall in Section 61(2)(d) of the 2003 Act, as the petitioner unit was availing tax concession granted to the industrial unit. 6.

Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the records. 7.

Section 61 of the 2003 Act in the year 2003 and the amendments made therein, in the years 2006 and 2010 are quoted below:- Section 61 of 2003 Act (Before Amendment) Section 61 of 2003 Act after amendment on 18.9.2006 Section 61 of 2003 Act after amendment on 2.4.2010 61. Repeal and saving.- (1) 61. Repeal and saving.- (1) Provided that such repeal shall not- (a) affect previous operation of the Act so repealed or anything duly done or suffered thereunder; (b) affect any right, title, privilege, obligation liability acquired, accrued or incurred under the said Act; (c) affect any act done or any action taken (including any 61. Repeal and saving.- (1) Provided that such repeal shall not- (a) affect previous operation of the Act so repealed or anything duly done or suffered thereunder; (b) affect any right, power, title, privilege, obligation or liability acquired, accrued or incurred under the said Act; (c) affect any act done or any action taken (including any

CWP No. 12139 of 2006 (O&M) -4-

appointment, notification, notice, order, rule, form regulation, certificate) in the exercise power conferred by or under the said Act; and any such act done or any action taken in the exercise of the powers conferred by or under the said Act shall be deemed to have been done or taken in the exercise of the powers conferred under the said Act as if this Act were in force on the date on which such act was done or action taken; and all arrears of tax and other amount due commencement of this Act may be recovered as if the same had accrued under this appointment, notification, notice, order, rule, form regulation, certificate) in the exercise power conferred by or under the said Act; and any such act done or any action taken in the exercise of the powers conferred by or under the said Act shall be deemed to have been done or taken in the exercise of the powers conferred under the said Act as if this Act was in force on the date on which such act was done or action taken; and all arrears of tax and other amount due commencement of this Act may be recovered as if the same had accrued under this section (1),- authority under the said Act, pending section (1)- officer or authority under the said Act and pending at the section (1)- officer or authority under the said Act, and pending at the

CWP No. 12139 of 2006 (O&M) -5-

this Act as if it had been in force on the date on which application, appeal, were made or preferred; this Act as if the said Act had been in force on the date on which such application, appeal, revision or other proceedings were made or preferred. anything to the contrary contained in any judgement, decree or order of any court of other authority, where no review, revision or corrective action could be initiated or finalized in respect of any assessment, order, proceedings under the said Act prior to or after 1st April, 2003, because of judgement or decree of any court or Tribunal said assessment or order passed under the said Act had attained finality, limitation of five years as specified under section 40 of the said Act shall be deemed to be eight years; this Act as if the said Act had been in force on the date on which such application, appeal, revision or other proceedings were made or preferred. anything to the contrary contained in any judgment, decree or order of any court or other authority, where no review, revision or corrective action could be initiated or finalized in respect of any assessment, order, proceeding under the said Act prior to or after 1st April, 2003, because of judgment or decree of any court or Tribunal said assessment or order passed under the said Act had attained finality, limitation of five years as specified u/s 40 of the said Act shall be deemed to be eight years;

CWP No. 12139 of 2006 (O&M) -6-

CWP No. 12139 of 2006 (O&M) -7-

it, for a period of next five years or such shorter period for it, for a period of next five years or such shorter period for which it has availed of it, for a period of next five years or such shorter period for which it has availed of

CWP No. 12139 of 2006 (O&M) -8-

CWP No. 12139 of 2006 (O&M) -9-

Act; (inserted by Haryana Act No. 4 of 2004) (e) the tax chargeable under the Act of 1973 on the sale duty entitlement pass book, effected on or before 31st March, 2003, calculated at the rate of four per cent of the turnover of sale or purchase of such goods, as the case may be, and shall be paid voluntarily without payment of interest on or before 31st March, 2004, whereafter interest at the rate of 18 per cent per annum on the amount of tax due for the period of delay shall be charged: Provided that where a dealer has charged tax at a rate more than four per cent, the tax shall be calculated and payable at such rate; (f) the tax levied under section 6 read with section 17 of the Act of 1973 on the last paddy Act; (e) the tax chargeable under the Act of 1973 on the sale duty entitlement pass book, effected on or before 31st March, 2003, calculated at the rate of four per cent of the turnover of sale or purchase of such goods, as the case may be, and shall be paid voluntarily without payment of interest on or before 31st March, 2004, whereafter interest at the rate of 18 per cent per annum on the amount of tax due for the period of delay shall be charged: Provided that where a dealer has charged tax at a rate more than four per cent, the tax shall be calculated and payable at such rate; (f) the tax levied under section 6 read with section 17 of the Act of 1973 on the last paddy effected between 1st April, 1981 and 31st March, 2003

CWP No. 12139 of 2006 (O&M) -10-

effected between 1st April, 1981 and 31st March, 2003 (both days inclusive), by a dealer liable to tax under the said Act, shall be valid notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in any judgment, decree or order of any court or other authority, any levy, assessment, re- any amount by way of tax made or purporting to have been made in respect of purchase of paddy effected in the said period and used in the manufacture of rice sold in course of export of goods out of the territory of India within meaning section 5 of the Central Act and any action taken or thing done or purporting to have been taken or done in relation levy, assessment, reassessment or collection, shall be deemed to be as valid and effective as if such levy, assessment, re-assessment or collection, had been made or action taken or thing done under the said Act, and accordingly- (i) all acts, proceedings or things done or action taken by the State Government or by any officer of the State (both days inclusive), by a dealer liable to tax under the said Act, shall be valid notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in any judgment, decree or order of any court or other authority, any levy, assessment, re- any amount by way of tax made or purporting to have been made in respect of purchase of paddy effected in the said period and used in the manufacture of rice sold in course of export of goods out of the territory of India within meaning section 5 of the Central Act and any action taken or thing done or purporting to have been taken or done in relation levy, assessment, reassessment or collection, shall be deemed to be as valid and effective as if such levy, assessment, re-assessment or collection, had been made or action taken or thing done under the said Act, and accordingly- (i) all acts, proceedings or things done or action taken by the State Government or by any officer of the State Government authority, in connection with

CWP No. 12139 of 2006 (O&M) -11-

Government authority, in connection with the levy, assessment, re- tax for all purposes be deemed to be, and to have always been, done or taken accordance with law; (ii) no suit other proceedings maintained or continued in any court or before any authority for the refund of any such tax so collected; (iii) no court or authority shall enforce any decree or order directing the refund of any such tax so collected. the levy, assessment, re- tax for all purposes be deemed to be, and to have always been, done or taken accordance with law; (ii) no suit other proceedings maintained or continued in any court or before any authority for the refund of any such tax so collected; (iii) no court or authority shall enforce any decree or order directing the refund of any such tax so collected. 8.

This Court in Hindustan Construction Company Limited's case (supra), opined that after repeal of the 1973 Act with enactment of the 2003 Act with effect from 1.4.2003, no fresh proceedings could be initiated under Section 40 of the 1973 Act as only pending proceedings had been saved. Division Bench of this Court doubting the correctness of the abovesaid judgment referred the matter to be considered by a Larger Bench. The State also being aggrieved against the judgment of this Court in Hindustan Construction Company Limited's case (supra), filed appeal before Hon'ble the Supreme Court. While the matter was still pending in this Court, Hon'ble the

CWP No. 12139 of 2006 (O&M) -12-

Supreme Court has dismissed the appeal filed by the State upholding the judgment of this Court, with the following observations:

“8. We have considered the respective submissions. A simple repeal of an Act leaves no room for expression of a contrary opinion. However, if the repeal is followed by a fresh enactment on the same subject, the applicability of the General Clauses Act would undoubtedly require an examination of the language in the new enactment to see if it expresses a different intention from the earlier Act. The enquiry would necessitate an examination if the old rights and liabilities are kept alive or whether the new Act manifests an intention to do away with or destroy them. If the new Act manifests a different intention, the application of the General Clauses Act will stand excluded.

9.

There were no proceedings pending against the respondent under the Act of 1973 when the new Act came into force on 1-4-2003. The suo-moto revisional power under Section 40 of the former Act was exercised on 7-6-2004. The repeal and saving clause in Section 61 of the 2003 Act, saved only pending proceedings under the repealed Act. The intendment clearly was that matters which stood closed under the 1973 Act had to be given a quietus and could not be reopened. (emphasis supplied).

10.

The assessment under the Act of 1973 having been completed and refund ordered, the exercise of suo-moto revisional powers under Section 40 of the same after repeal was clearly unsustainable

CWP No. 12139 of 2006 (O&M) -13-

in view of the contrary intention expressed under Section 61 of the 2003 Act, saving only pending proceedings. Section 4 of the Punjab General Clauses Act, 1858 will have no application in view of the contrary intendment expressed in Section 61 of the repealing Act. Had a contrary intention not been expressed, the issues arising for consideration would have been entirely different. The observations in State of Punjab v. Mohar Singh Pratap Singh, as extracted below are considered relevant: (1955) 1 SCR 893) “8……….Whenever there is a repeal of an enactment, the consequences laid down in Section 6 of the General Clauses Act will follow unless, as the section itself says, a different intention appears. In the case of a simple repeal there is scarcely any room for expression of a contrary opinion. But when the repeal is followed by fresh legislation on the same subject we would undoubtedly have to look to the provisions of the new Act, but only for the purpose of determining whether they indicate a different intention. The line of enquiry would be, not whether the new Act expressly keeps alive old rights and liabilities but whether it manifests an intention to destroy them…..” The observations in Gammon India Ltd. (supra) at para 73 are to the same effect.

CWP No. 12139 of 2006 (O&M) -14-

11.

The legislature, in its wisdom having noticed the limitation and constraints under Section 61 of the 2003 Act, made necessary amendments to the same by Act No. 3 of 2010 on 2-4-2010. Any interpretation saving the revisional power under Section 40 of the Act of 1973, without any proceedings pending on the relevant date, by resort to Section 4 of the Punjab General Clause Act, 1858 would render the amendment redundant, and an exercise in futility, something which the legislature never intended to do. Such an incongruous interpretation leading to absurdity has to be avoided.” 9.

In the case in hand, it is undisputed fact on record that notice for revision of the order of assessment was issued to the petitioner after the repeal of the 1973 Act and enactment of 2003 Act, on 15.5.2006, which is much after the repeal of the 1973 Act. Hence, in view of the enunciation of law, as referred to above in Hindustan Construction Company Limited's case (supra), the proceedings initiated against the petitioner for revision of the order of assessment as well as the order passed are without jurisdiction and deserve to be set aside. 10.

There is no merit in the contention raised by learned counsel for the State that in the case of the petitioner provision of Section 61(2)(d) of the 2003 Act will be applicable, as the aforesaid provision does not deal with exercise of revisional power by the authorities rather only saves the benefits granted to the industrial units during the currency of the 1973 Act in terms of provisions of Section 13(B) and 25(A) thereof and the Rules framed

CWP No. 12139 of 2006 (O&M) -15-

thereunder. Any application, appeal, revision have not been referred to in the aforesaid sub-section. 11.

For the reasons mentioned above, the writ petition is allowed. The order of revisional authority dated 27.3.2006 is set aside.

(Rajesh Bindal)

(Amit Rawal)

28.8.2018

(Avneesh Jhingan) vs

Whether speaking/ reasoned Yes/No Whether Reportable Yes/No

More judgments on Section 40

All 64 judgments and leading authorities on Section 40 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →