M/S. CENTRAL WAREHOUSING CORPORATION vs. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX

PDF · subscribers
ITA/329/2024HC DelhiDLHC01039136202429 July 2024Author: CASES PERTAINING TO SPL.DIVISION BENCHES4 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the appeal could not be entertained due to a clear concession made by the appellant. The Court noted that the ITAT's impugned order dated November 14, 2023, was based on this concession, as evident from paragraphs 19 to 22 of the order. These paragraphs reproduced the ITAT's reasoning from a previous order concerning assessment year 2006-07. In that prior order, the Tribunal had agreed with the assessee's contention that income from bonded warehouses, accounted for on a realization basis (cash basis), should be taxed on an accrual basis due to the assessee following the mercantile system. However, the Tribunal had directed the AO to ensure that income taxed on an accrual basis in the current year was not taxed again on a cash basis in subsequent years. The ITAT for the current year followed this precedent, restoring the issue to the AO for fresh determination, with directions to ascertain that income added on a mercantile basis was not taxed twice. The High Court found no justification to entertain the appeal given the concession.

What were the facts?

The appellant, M/s. Central Warehousing Corporation, is challenging an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) dated November 14, 2023. The appeal concerns the assessment year(s) not explicitly stated but relates to income from unclaimed goods stored at Customs Facilitation Centres (CFS) and Inland Container Depots (ICD). The core issue revolves around whether such income accrues for tax purposes. The ITAT's order was based on a concession made by the assessee's counsel, following a previous ITAT order for assessment year 2006-07. In that prior order, the Tribunal had restored the issue to the Assessing Officer (AO) to ascertain income from bonded warehouses added on a mercantile basis and not taxed again on a cash basis. The Revenue's counsel had no objection to this approach.

What were the issues?

1. Whether, under the mercantile system of accounting, only income that has actually 'accrued' is required to be offered for tax? (Question of law) 2. Whether income from unclaimed goods stored at CFS/ICDs can be considered accrued merely because the goods remain stored indefinitely? (Question of mixed law and fact) 3. Whether the ITAT's direction to telescope income already offered for tax on a receipt basis against income taxable on an accrual basis is misconceived or perverse, considering Section 150(2) of the Customs Act, 1962? (Question of mixed law and fact) Assessee's contentions: The assessee argued that identical issues were decided by the Tribunal in a prior order (dated May 31, 2021), which restored the matter to the AO to ascertain income from bonded warehouses added on a mercantile basis and not subjected to tax again on a cash basis. The assessee requested a similar direction for the current year. The assessee also concurred that there cannot be a mixed accounting system and income should be taxed on an accrual basis, but income already offered on a cash basis should be reduced. The assessee relied on the Tribunal's order in ITA No. 3942/Del/2011. Revenue's contentions: The Revenue's counsel had no objection to the assessee's submission for restoring the issue to the AO. The Revenue's prior appeal (ITA No. 3942/Del/2011) argued that the assessee, following a mercantile system, should be taxed on accrued income, and could not follow both cash and mercantile systems. The Revenue's counsel did not present any arguments against the assessee's concession in the present appeal.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 150(2)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

$~3 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI + ITA 329/2024 & CM APPL. 37727/2024

M/S. CENTRAL WAREHOUSING CORPORATION

....Appellant Through: Mr. S. Krishnan and Mr. Harshit Chauhan, Advocates

versus

COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX .....Respondent Through: Mr.Vipul Agrawal, SSC with Mr. Gibran Naushad, Ms. Sakshi Shairwal, Advs.

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE YASHWANT VARMA

HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE TARA VITASTA GANJU

O R D E R %

29.07.2024 CM APPL. 37727/2024 Bearing in mind the disclosures made, the delay in refiling the appeal is condoned.

The applications shall stand disposed of.

ITA 329/2024

1.

The appellant questions the correctness of the order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal [“Tribunal”] dated 14 November 2023 and posits the following questions for our consideration:- “a. Whether even under mercantile system of accounting, only income which has actually 'accrued', is required to be offered for tax? b. Whether income in respect of unclaimed goods stored at CFS / ICD's maintained by the Assessee can be said to accrue merely because the goods continue to be stored indefinitely? c. Whether ITAT's direction to merely telescope income already offered for tax on receipt basis against Income taxable on accrual basis is misconceived / perverse on the facts of the case, and on an interpretation of section 150(2) of the Customs Act 1962?”

2.

However and as has been rightly pointed out by Mr. Aggarwal, learned counsel for the respondent, the aforesaid aspects came to be decided on concession. This would be apparent from a reading of paragraphs 19 to 22 of the order impugned before us and which are reproduced hereinbelow:- “19. The Ld. Counsel for the assessee submits that identical issue has been decided by the Tribunal by order dated 31.05.2021 in paras 16 to 16.4 wherein the Tribunal restored the matter to the file of the Assessing Officer with a direction to ascertain income of the bonded warehouses which has been added on mercantile basis and is not subjected to tax on cash basis again in subsequent years. The Ld. Counsel submits that similar direction may be given for the year under consideration also.

20.

The Ld. DR has no objection.

21.

Heard rival submissions perused the orders of the authorities below. We observe that on perusal of the order of the Tribunal in ITA. No. 3942/Del/2011 for assessment year 2006-07 in Revenue's appeal the Tribunal restored the issue to the file of the Assessing Officer with the following observations. –

"16. The ground No. 6 of the appeal of the Revenue relate addition for income from bonded warehouses amounting to Rs. 7,24,44,000/-, which has been deleted by the Learned CIT(A).

16.1 The facts in brief qua the issue in dispute are that the assessee operates bonded warehouse under a license given by the customs department, where imported consignments are being deposited by the importers to enable them to take delivery of the consignment by paying custom duty and warehousing charges at the time of the actual release of the imported goods. These warehousing charges are being accounted by the assessee on realisation basis. The contention of the assessee that realization of such warehousing charges is uncertain as sometimes paying of custom duty and warehousing charges becomes commercially unviable to the importer and therefore importers are not induced to take delivery of such consignment. According to the Assessing Officer, the assessee is following Mercantile system and therefore income has to be booked as and when it is accrued to the assessee. The Assessing Officer noted that even if

the importer decided not to get his cargo released, the warehousing charges is payable to the assessee Corporation from the auction proceeds of the cargo. Accordingly, the learned Assessing Officer made addition for the amount of Rs. 7,24,44,000/-for bonding warehouse on accrual basis. The Ld. CITA) following the finding of his predecessor that there was uncertainty in the income of the bonded warehouse, he deleted the addition made on this account.

16.2 Before us, the learned DR submitted that the assessee cannot be allowed for both cash and Mercantile system of accounting i.e. mixed accounting system. He submitted that the assessee follows Mercantile system of accounting and accordingly the income is taxable whenever it is accrued or received whichever is earlier and thus income of bonded warehouse is liable to be assessed in the year under consideration.

16.3 On the other hand, the Learned Counsel of the assessee concurred that there cannot be mixed accounting system and income has to be taxed on the accrual basis in the case of the assessee, however, he submitted that the income offered by the assessee on cash basis should be reduced. Accordingly, he submitted that issue in dispute may be restored back to the file of the Learned Assessing Officer for working out the quantum of income to be taxed."

16.4 We have heard rival submission of the parties on the issue in dispute and perused the relevant material on record. In the case, the assessee has credited the income from the bonded warehouse on realisation basis i.e. cash basis, but the assessee is following Mercantile system of the accounting and therefore income has to be credited in the profit and loss account as and when it is accrued to the assessee. The Assessing Officer has added the income from warehousing charges which is accrued during the year under consideration. The learned Counsel has agreed in principle that warehousing charges is liable to be assessed on accrual basis in view of Mercantile system followed by the assessee, but he emphasized that income which has been tax on accrual basis in the year under consideration, should not subjected to tax twice i.e once on Mercantile basis and second on cash basis. We concur with the above contention of the Learned

Counsel of the assessee. Accordingly, the bonded warehouse income added by the Assessing Officer on accrual basis, is hereby confirmed, however, the Assessing Officer is directed to ascertain that, bonded warehouse income which has been added on mercantile basis in the year under consideration, is not again subjected to tax on cash basis in subsequent years. The ground No. 6 of the appeal of the Revenue is accordingly, partly allowed for the statistical purposes."

22.

Following the order of the Tribunal we restore this issue to the file of the Assessing Officer with direction to decide the issue afresh keeping in view the observations of the Tribunal for the assessment year 2006-07. Needless to say adequate opportunity of being heard to the assessee be provided by the Assessing Officer. Ground No. 3 of the grounds of appeal of the Revenue and ground Nos. 6 to 10 of grounds of appeal of the assessee are allowed for statistical purposes.”

3.

In view of the evident concession made by the appellant, we find no justification to entertain this appeal. 4. It shall consequently stand dismissed.

YASHWANT VARMA, J.

TARA VITASTA GANJU, J. JULY 29, 2024/neha

More judgments on Section 150(2)

All 36 judgments and leading authorities on Section 150(2) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →