SARITA PURI vs. PR. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-18 & ANR.

PDF · subscribers
W.P.(C)/9020/2019HC DelhiDLHC01034052201922 January 2021Author: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW,HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA4 pages
AI SummaryRemanded

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court declined to delve into the factual controversy regarding the computation of the refund amount, stating that a mandamus could not be issued in such circumstances. The Court emphasized that the Income Tax Act provides a complete machinery for enforcing rights and liabilities and for challenging orders of Revenue authorities. Therefore, the petitioner must avail the statutory remedies available under the Act. The Court held that its wide jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution does not permit it to disregard the substantive provisions of the statute and the mechanism provided thereunder. Accordingly, the writ petition was disposed of with the observation that the petitioner is free to pursue her departmental/statutory remedies regarding any grievance concerning the calculation of the refund.

What were the facts?

The petitioner, Sarita Puri, filed a writ petition seeking directions for the payment of income tax refunds amounting to Rs. 6,13,020/- for Assessment Year (AY) 2011-12 and Rs. 3,43,117/- for AY 2013-14, along with accrued interest, due to her late husband, Sh. Bhupinder Pal Singh Puri. The Revenue, through its counsel, submitted that the amounts, including interest under Section 244A, had been paid and credited to the petitioner's bank account. The Revenue provided system-generated screenshots and computation of appeal effect orders as evidence. The petitioner contended that the refunds were only partly paid and that errors were committed in the calculation, seeking a direction for the respondents to decide her representation dated November 11, 2019.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the writ petition seeking directions for payment of income tax refunds is maintainable when the Revenue claims the refunds have been paid and disputes the calculation, turning on the availability of alternative statutory remedies. (Mixed question of law and fact, concerning the scope of writ jurisdiction and the Income Tax Act). Assessee's contentions: The respondents have only partly paid the refund, ignored payments made on completion of assessment and interest thereon, and committed errors in calculation. The petitioner seeks a direction for the respondents to decide her representation dated November 11, 2019. Revenue's contentions: The writ petition has become infructuous as the refunds along with interest under Section 244A have been paid and credited to the petitioner's account. The computation was based on details provided by the petitioner, and any grievances regarding calculation should be addressed by the petitioner through rectification of the return.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 244A,Section 250,Section 254,Section 143(3)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

W.P.(C.) 9020/2019 Page 1 of 4

$~9 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI + W.P.(C) 9020/2019

SARITA PURI

..... Petitioner

Through: Mr. Rajesh Mahna, Advocate.

versus

PR. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-18 & ANR. ..... Respondents Through: Ms. Adeeba Mujahid, Advocate for Ms. Lakshmi Gurung, Senior Standing Counsel.

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA

O R D E R %

22.01.2021

1.

The present writ petition has been filed seeking directions to respondents to pay refunds of Rs. 6,13,020/- for Assessment Year (AY) 2011-12 and Rs. 3,43,117/- for the AY 2013-14 respectively, along with interest accrued thereon, which were due to the Petitioner’s late husband Sh. Bhupinder Pal Singh Puri.

2.

Pursuant to the notice of this Court, respondents had filed counter affidavit giving details of the amounts that had been adjusted as well as details of the refunds credited to the account of the petitioner.

3.

Ms. Adeeba Mujahid, Senior Standing Counsel for Revenue submits that the writ petition has become infructuous for the reason that the amounts

W.P.(C.) 9020/2019 Page 2 of 4

along with interest under section 244A, that were computed to be due to Petitioner's late husband towards income tax refunds for AY 2011-2012 and AY 2013-2014, have been paid to the legal heir of late Sh. Bhupinder Pal Singh Puri and credited to the bank account of the Petitioner. She draws our attention to the System Generated Screenshots evidencing credit of refund for AYs 2011-12 and 2013-14. The Screenshots of computation of appeal effect orders for AYs 2011-12 and 2013-14 are also annexed to the counter affidavit. She explains that in respect of AY 2011-12, in pursuance to the order of ITAT, appeal effect has been given vide order u/S. 254/143(3) dated 01.10.2018 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, wherein the revised assessed income was computed at Rs. 2,14,89,170/- as against the returned income of Rs. 2,13,32,282/-. For AY 2013-14, pursuant to the order of CIT(A), appeal effect has been given u/S. 250/143(3) of the Act vide order dated 01.10.2018, determining total income of Rs. 3,92,04,750/-. She states that pursuant thereto, an amount of Rs. 7,92,270/- has been credited to the account of the petitioner in respect of the afore-noted AYs 2011-12 and 2013-14. She argues that since the assessee has been granted refund along with interest as per provisions of section 244A of the Income Tax Act, no further amount is due and payable to the petitioner. With respect to the grievance advanced by the Petitioner in the Rejoinder-affidavit, she contends that the computation has been worked out on the basis of details given by the Petitioner and she ought to take steps for rectification of the return, in the absence whereof, such claims cannot be sustained.

4.

Learned counsel for the petitioner however controverts the contentions of the respondent and submits that the respondents have only partly paid the

W.P.(C.) 9020/2019 Page 3 of 4

refund, ignored the fact that the petitioner is entitled to the credit of those payments which had been paid on the completion of assessment and also interest thereon, as per law. He states that by way of the rejoinder, the Petitioner has brought on record the errors committed by the respondents in calculating the refund. He further submits that Petitioner has also given a representation to the Department dated 11th November, 2019 bringing on record the errors committed and requests that this Court give a direction to the respondents to decide the said representation.

5.

We have enquired from the learned counsel for the petitioner as to what remedies are available under the Act in respect of an error committed by the Tax Authority in calculating the refund. Learned counsel for the petitioner however is unable to point out any specific provision and submits that these remedies lie before this Court.

6.

We would not like to be drawn into the factual controversy. Particularly, since there is a dispute regarding the computation of refund amount, a mandamus, as prayed for, cannot be issued to the respondents. In our view the Income tax Act not only creates rights and liabilities, but also provides for a complete machinery for enforcing the same, as well as a mechanism to challenge the orders of the Revenue authorities. Thus, the Petitioner must only avail the remedy as provided for by the statute. The fact that we have a wide jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution does not mean that we can disregard the substantive provisions of the statute and the mechanism provided thereunder. We are thus inclined to dispose of the present petition, observing that the petitioner shall be free to pursue its departmental/statutory

W.P.(C.) 9020/2019 Page 4 of 4

remedy as available in law with respect to any grievance regarding the calculation of refund made by the respondents.

7.

Accordingly, the writ petition is disposed of as stated above.

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW, J

SANJEEV NARULA, J

JANUARY 22, 2021 v

More judgments on Section 244A

All 1,453 judgments and leading authorities on Section 244A →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →