NALWA INVESTMENTS LIMITED vs. PR COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX DELHI 4 & ORS.

PDF · subscribers
W.P.(C)/2592/2021HC DelhiDLHC01010805202105 May 2021Author: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJIV SHAKDHER,HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TALWANT SINGH6 pages
AI SummaryPartly Allowed

What did the High Court hold?

The Delhi High Court held that the rejection of the petitioner's Forms 1 and 2 under the Direct Tax Vivad Se Vishwas Act, 2020, by the Revenue could not be sustained. The Court accepted the assessee's version that the appeal was pending adjudication post-remand by the ITAT, based on the preponderance of probability. The Court noted that the Revenue had not been able to place any material to persuade it to reach a different conclusion. The assessee's claim was backed by an affidavit, and the correspondence regarding record transfer and reconstruction supported their contention. The Court found the Revenue's reliance on Form-35 as a weak defence, especially considering the assessee's explanation that it primarily listed penalty-related proceedings. Consequently, the rejection orders dated 07.12.2020 and 21.01.2021 were set aside. The designated authority was directed to take further steps as per the 2020 Act, including issuing Form-3 to the petitioner by 25.05.2021. The writ petition was disposed of in these terms.

What were the facts?

The petitioner, Nalwa Investments Limited, filed Forms 1 and 2 under the Direct Tax Vivad Se Vishwas Act, 2020, for Assessment Year 1993-1994. The Revenue rejected these forms, stating that their records did not show the appeal filed by the assessee before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [CIT(A)] post a remand order from the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) was pending adjudication. The assessee contended that after an assessment order dated 19.05.1995, an appeal was filed with CIT(A)-V, which was dismissed. The ITAT remanded the matter to CIT(A) on 05.08.1997. Due to departmental restructuring, the record was not transferred from CIT(A)-V to CIT(A)-XVI. The assessee had requested record reconstruction on 13.02.2012 and filed an affidavit. The Revenue's records were unable to retrieve the appeal details for AY 1993-1994.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the petitioner's appeal for AY 1993-1994, remanded by the ITAT to the CIT(A), was pending adjudication on the specified date under the Direct Tax Vivad Se Vishwas Act, 2020, despite the Revenue's inability to locate the record. (Question of mixed law and fact, turning on the interpretation and application of the Direct Tax Vivad Se Vishwas Act, 2020 and the procedural history of the appeal). Assessee's Contentions: - The assessee argued that the appeal was pending adjudication post-remand by the ITAT. - They relied on a letter dated 08.12.2011 from CIT(A)-XVI to CIT(A)-V requesting record retrieval, indicating the appeal's pendency and the issue of record transfer post-restructuring. - They also relied on their own letter dated 13.02.2012 for record reconstruction and an affidavit filed in support. - The assessee contended that their Form 35 disclosure, while not mentioning this specific appeal, referred to penalty proceedings, whereas the subject appeal did not deal with penalty issues. Revenue's Contentions: - The Revenue's primary contention was that their records did not show the appeal was pending adjudication on the relevant date. - They pointed to Form-35 filed by the petitioner, which referred to pending proceedings for several AYs but excluded the subject appeal for AY 1993-1994, as evidence that the appeal was not pending.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 143(3)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

$~5 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI + W.P.(C) 2592/2021 & CM APPL. No.7660/2021

NALWA INVESTMENTS LIMITED

..... Petitioner Through: Ms. Kavita Jha, Mr. Vaibhav Kulkarni and Mr. Anant Mann, Advs.

versus

PR COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX DELHI 4 & ORS.

..... Respondents Through: Ms. Vibhooti Malhotra, Sr. Standing Counsel for revenue.

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJIV SHAKDHER

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TALWANT SINGH

O R D E R %

05.05.2021 [Court hearing convened via video-conferencing on account of COVID-19]

1.

The grievance, as articulated before us, by the petitioner/assessee through its counsel, Ms. Kavita Jha, was recorded in our order dated 25.02.2021. For the sake of convenience, the same is extracted hereafter: “CM APPL. 7661/2021 1. Allowed, subject to just exceptions. W.P.(C) 2592/2021 and CM APPL. 7660/2021 2. The limited grievance of the petitioner is that Forms 1 and 2, preferred under the Direct Tax Vivad Se Vishwas Act, 2020 [in short “the Act”] were not accepted as the Revenue has taken the position that its record does not show that appeal lodged before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [in short “CIT (Appeals)”], as contended by the petitioner, has not been adjudicated after the remand order. 2.1. Apart from anything else, Ms. Kavita Jha, who appears on behalf of the petitioners, has drawn our attention to a

1/6

communication dated 08.12.2011 sent by CIT (Appeals) – XVI, New Delhi to CIT (Appeals) – V, New Delhi. 2.2. A perusal of this letter, which is appended on page 162 of the paper book, would show that CIT (Appeals)-XVI seeks retrieval of the record from CIT (Appeals)-V. 2.3. It is Ms. Jha's contention that once the Assessing Officer [in short“AO”] had passed an order, an appeal was preferred by the assessee with CIT (Appeals)-V which was rejected. 2.4. Ms. Kavita Jha says that a second appeal was preferred before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (Delhi Bench: A) [in short “Tribunal”]. The Tribunal, via its order dated 05.08.1997, remanded the matter to CIT (Appeals). 2.5. It is Ms. Jha's contention that in financial year 2000-2001, there was a restructuring in the Revenue Department, and therefore, the adjudication of the appeal had to be done by CIT (Appeals)-XVI post the remand, as indicated hereinabove. 3. Presently, it appears that the petitioner’s record has been lost. It is in that context that the petitioner on 13.02.2012 wrote to CIT (Appeals)- XVI for the reconstruction of the appeal record. [See page 163 of the paper book.] 3.1. Ms. Jha says that the petitioner has also filed an affidavit in that behalf. [See page 164 of the paper book.] 4. Issue notice to the respondents. 5. Ms. Vibhooti Malhotra accepts service on behalf of the respondents. Ms. Malhotra will revert with instructions on the next date of hearing as to how best, the Revenue proposes, to move forward in the case. 6. In case, the Revenue is desirous of opposing the reliefs claimed in the writ petition, it will file a counter-affidavit in the matter before the next date of hearing. 7. Since the deadline for filing Forms 1 and 2, admittedly, expires on 28.02.2021, and we don't expect the Revenue to revert with an answer before that date, for the moment, without prejudice to the rights and contentions of the Revenue, it will provisionally accept Forms 1 and 2 concerning the petitioner.

2/6

7.1. Accordingly, the petitioner will have leave to file Forms 1 and 2 on or before 28.02.2021. 8. List the matter on 16.03.2021.” 1.1. A perusal of the order dated 25.02.2021 would show that the respondents/revenue had rejected the petitioner/assessee’s forms, i.e., Forms 1 and 2, preferred under the Direct Tax Vivad Se Vishwas Act, 2020 [in short “the 2020 Act”], only on the ground that their record did not show that the appeal filed by it before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [in short “CIT(A)”] post the remand order, passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal [in short “Tribunal”], was pending adjudication on the specified date under the 2020 Act. 1.2. Ms. Kavita Jha, who appears for the petitioner/assessee, on 25.02.2021 had, inter alia, brought to our notice, the letter dated 13.02.2012, which was addressed by the petitioner/assessee to CIT(A)-XVI, New Delhi, for the purpose of the construction of the appeal record. Furthermore, Ms. Jha had also drawn our attention to an affidavit filed in that behalf. 1.3. These documents, as noticed in our order dated 25.02.2021, are appended on pages 163 and 164 of the electronic paper book. 1.4. Ms. Vibhooti Malhotra, who appears for the respondents/revenue, sought an accommodation on 25.02.2021, to revert with instructions as to how best the revenue would like to move forward in the present case. 1.5. The matter was, accordingly, listed for further proceedings on 16.03.2021. On 16.03.2021, Ms. Malhotra informed us that although, a counter-affidavit had been filed on behalf of respondent nos.1 and 4 [now,

3/6

respondent no. 4 is shown as respondent no. 3], she would like to gather necessary information from National Faceless Appeal Centre [now, National Faceless Assessment Centre, and hereafter referred as “the Centre”] presently arrayed as respondent no.2, since the original respondent nos.2 and 3 stood deleted from the array of parties, as indicated in our order dated 16.03.2021. 2. It is in these circumstances, that the matter has come up before us today, i.e., 05.05.2021. 3. Ms. Malhotra says that, since the matter pertains to the assessment year (“AY”) 1993-1994, the Centre has not been able to retrieve the record. 3.1. We are informed by Ms. Malhotra that the Centre has, however, available with it, the letter dated 08.12.2011, which was addressed by CIT(A)-XVI, New Delhi to CIT(A)-V, New Delhi. This communication was also noticed in our order dated 25.02.2021. For the sake of convenience, the relevant part of the said communication is extracted hereafter: “…M/s Nalwa Investments Ltd. has filed an application before the Chief Commissioner of Income-tax, Delhi - V, New Delhi regarding issue of directions for fixation of old pending appeal with CIT(A). In its letter, it has stated that assessment order was passed u/s 143(3) dated 19.05.1995 for A.Y.1993-94 by DCIT. Spl. Range - I, New Delhi. The appellant company filed an appeal with the then CIT(A)-V. Delhi on 20.06.1995 against the said order. The appeal was dismissed by the then CIT(A)-V, New Delhi by passing Appellate Order vide A.No.339/1995-96 dated 28.02.1996. Aggrieved by the Appellate Order, the appellant filed second appeal and the Hon’ble ITAT vide its order dated 5th August, 1997 restored the matter to the file or the CIT(A) for re-examination.

4/6

New Delhi. Now, the appellant's contention is that after restructuring of the Department, the appeal records have not been transferred from CIT(A)-V, New Delhi to CIT(A)-XVI, New Delhi. You are therefore. Requested to look into the matter and transfer the records of the appellant to this office. If the records have already been transferred, a copy of the transfer memo may please be provided so that we can trace out the appeal from our records…” 4. Given this position, the preponderance of probability is, that the version set up by the petitioner/assessee before us, that the appeal filed before the CIT(A) post the remand by the Tribunal is pending adjudication, should be accepted. 4.1 Since the respondents/revenue have not been able to place before us any material, which would persuade us to reach a different conclusion, we are inclined, as noticed above, to accept the version put forth by the petitioner/assessee. The claim made by the petitioner/assessee is backed by an affidavit on oath, and therefore, one would to assume that, what is stated before us, is true and correct. 5. We must also state that, although, Ms. Malhotra had drawn our attention to Form-35 filed by the petitioner/assessee [wherein, inter alia, the details of the proceedings pending qua the petitioner/assessee qua several A.Y.s are referred to, save and except, the subject appeal pertaining to AY 1993-1994], to demonstrate that the assertion of the petitioner/assessee that its appeal was pending is not correct, to our minds, in the given facts and circumstances, appears to be a weak defence, if one were to have regard to the aforementioned correspondence on the subject.

5/6

5.1. Besides this, it is Ms. Jha’s contention that while making a disclosure of pending proceedings in Form 35, the petitioner had referred almost entirely to those proceedings which were of like nature, i.e., those which dealt with imposition of penalty. Ms. Jha has, therefore, stressed on the fact that the subject appeal was not adverted to, as it did not deal with the issue concerning penalty. 5.2. As noticed above, the balance, in our opinion, given the material on record, weighs in favour of the petitioner/assessee. 6. The net result would be that since we have concluded that the appeal was pending on the specified date, based on the test of preponderance of probability, the decision taken by the respondents/revenue to reject Forms 1 & 2, filed by the petitioner/assessee, under the 2020 Act, cannot be sustained. 6.1 Consequently, the rejection orders dated 07.12.2020 and 21.01.2021 are set aside. 6.2. The designated authority, i.e., respondent no.1 will take next steps in the matter as per the provisions of the 2020 Act, which would entail, inter alia, the issuance of Form-3 to the petitioner/assessee. The designated authority will issue Form-3, at the earliest, though not later than 25.05.2021. 7. The writ petition is disposed of in the aforesaid terms. Pending application shall stand closed too. The case papers shall stand consigned to record.

RAJIV SHAKDHER, J

TALWANT SINGH, J MAY 5, 2021/pmc Click here to check corrigendum, if any

6/6

Latest GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →