B.R. BHATIA AND SONS HUF vs. INCOME TAX OFFICER WARD44(6),DELHI & ORS.

PDF · subscribers
W.P.(C)/84/2022HC DelhiDLHC01002170202205 January 2022Author: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANMOHAN,HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE NAVIN CHAWLA21 pages
AI SummaryAllowed

What did the High Court hold?

The Delhi High Court held that the impugned reassessment notices issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, after March 31, 2021, were invalid. The Court found that the Explanations A(a)(ii)/A(b) to the Notifications dated March 31, 2021, and April 27, 2021, were ultra vires the Relaxation Act, 2020, and therefore, bad in law and void. The Court reasoned that the Legislature had introduced new provisions (Sections 147 to 151) with effect from April 1, 2021, and any reassessment notices issued thereafter had to comply with these substituted sections. The Court rejected the revenue's arguments based on the General Clauses Act, the substantial nature of the substitution, and the Covid-19 pandemic. The Court emphasized that the executive cannot use administrative powers to undermine parliamentary supremacy or frustrate the purpose of substituted statutory provisions. Consequently, the reassessment notices were quashed, and the writ petitions were allowed. The revenue was granted liberty to take further steps if permitted by law.

What were the facts?

The petitioners in these writ petitions challenged reassessment notices issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The core issue was that these notices were issued after March 31, 2021, without adhering to the procedure prescribed in the substituted Sections 147 to 151, which came into effect from April 1, 2021. The revenue contended that certain Explanations in notifications issued by the government extended the applicability of the old procedure or deferred the new one. The petitioners argued that these notices were invalid as they did not follow the newly enacted procedure. The matters were consolidated and decided based on a prior judgment of the same court in Mon Mohan Kohli vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax & Anr.

What were the issues?

1. Whether reassessment notices issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, after March 31, 2021, without following the procedure prescribed in the substituted Sections 147 to 151 (effective from April 1, 2021) are valid? (Question of law) Assessee's Contention: The petitioners argued that the notices were invalid because they were issued post-April 1, 2021, and did not comply with the new procedure introduced by the Finance Act, 2021. They contended that the Explanations in the notifications dated March 31, 2021, and April 27, 2021, were ultra vires the Relaxation Act, 2020, and thus void. Revenue's Contention: The revenue argued that the procedure for reassessment notices issued under Section 148 post-March 31, 2021, was saved by Section 6 of the General Clauses Act. They also contended that the substitution made by the Finance Act, 2021, was substantial and not applicable to past assessment years, and that the Covid-19 pandemic justified the extended timelines and procedures.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 147,Section 148,Section 151

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Heard together (4 matters)

W.P.(C) 1/2022
W.P.(C) 2/2022
W.P.(C) 4/2022
W.P.(C) 5/2022

Read from the judgment's own cause title. This page is filed under one of them.

$~16, 17, 19 to 23, 25, 26, 28 to 32, 34 to 37, 39 to 55, 57, 58, 60 to 67, 69, 70 & 72 to 78 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI W.P.(C) 1/2022 & CM Nos.1-2/2022

SHRI PARVEEN KUMAR GUPTA

Mr.S.Krishnan, Adv.

INCOME TAX OFFICER & ORS.

$~17 W.P.(C) 2/2022 & CM Nos.3-4/2022

AMANVEER SINGH

Mr.Ruchesh Sinha, Adv.

ACIT CIRCLE 28(1) NEW DELHI & ORS. Mr.Pratyaksh Gupta, Jr. SC

Mr. Aditya Dewan, Advocate for R-3. $~19 W.P.(C) 4/2022 & CM Nos.6-7/2022

MEENU GOEL

Mr.Ved Jain, Ms.Richa Mishra, Advs

INCOME TAX OFFICER WARD 28-1, DELHI & ORS. $~20 W.P.(C) 5/2022 & CM Nos.8-9/2022

KAILASH CHANDER DUGGAL

Mr.Dushyant Tiwari, Adv.

Mr.Satyanand,SPC for UOI. $~21 W.P.(C) 6/2022 & CM Nos.10-11/2022

KAILASH CHANDER DUGGAL

Mr.Dushyant Tiwari, Adv.

Mr.Satyanand,SPC for UOI.

$~22 W.P.(C) 7/2022 & CM Nos.12-13/2022

PREM KR. CHOPRA

ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CIRCLE 46(1) DELHI & ORS.

Sharma, Adv. for Revenue.

Mr.Niraj Kumar, SCGC for UOI.

$~23 W.P.(C) 9/2022 & CM Nos.14-15/2022

RANGOLI INFOCOM PRIVATE LIMITED Mr.Vikas Jain and Mr.Manjeet Singh Rathor, Advs.

UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.

Mr.Anil Dabas, Adv. for UOI.

$~25 W.P.(C) 11/2022 & CM Nos.18-19/2022

DS REALTY AND REALTOR PVT.LTD Mr.Satyen Sethi & Mr.Arta Trana Panda, Advs.

ASSTT. COMMISSIONER OFINCOME TAX, CIRCLE 7(1), & ORS.

Kadian, Jr.SC

$~26 W.P.(C) 13/2022

M/S OLIVE INFRASTRUCTURE PVT. LTD. ..... Petitioner

Mr.Aditya Swarup Aggarwal, Adv.

INCOME TAX OFFICER 19 (1) DELHI & ANR. ..... Respondents

$~28 W.P.(C) 15/2022 & CM Nos.29-30/2022

UK GRID SOLUTION LIMITED

Mr. Aditya Vohra, Advocate

DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX & ORS. Mr.Puneet Rai, Sr. Ms.Adeeba Mujahid, Jr. SC $~29 W.P.(C) 17/2022 & CM Nos.33-34/2022

MOTHERSON AUTO SOLUTIONS LIMITED

INCOME TAX OFFICER, WARD 17-1, DELHI & ANR.

$~30 W.P.(C) 19/2022 & CM Nos.37-38/2022

TARA SINGH VACHANI

Mr.Sandeep Chilana, Mr.Priyojeet Chatterjee, Mr.Shekhar Mr.Abdullah Tanveer, Ms.Yashodhara, Ms.Shambhavi,

PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX DELHI - 1 & ANR.

$~31 W.P.(C) 21/2022 & CM Nos.41-42/2022

MOHIT BAKSHI

Mr.Ishan Garg, Adv.

INCOME TAX OFFICER WARD 36(1) DELHI & ANR.

$~32 W.P.(C) 23/2022 & CM Nos.45-46/2022

SUDHANGSHU SHEKHAR BISWAL

Mr.Ishan Garg, Adv.

ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CIRCLE 28(1) DELHI & ANR.

Mr.Pratyaksh Gupta, Jr. SC for

Mr.Mahendra Singh, SPC for UOI. $~34 W.P.(C) 30/2022 & CM Nos.56-57/2022

ANURAG BHATNAGAR

Mr.Rohit Jain, Mr.Aniket D. Agrawal, Ms.Manisha

ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX & ORS.

Sharma, Adv. for Revenue.

Mr. Gaurav Varma, Adv for UOI.

$~35 W.P.(C) 36/2022 & CM Nos.67-68/2022

SNEH GUPTA

ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CIRCLE 28(1)DELHI & ORS.

$~36 W.P.(C) 39/2022 & CM Nos.70-71/2022

KINETIC CONSTRUCTIONS PVT LTD

Mr.Salil Kapoor, Ms.Ananya Kapoor and Mr.Sant Kapoor, Advs.

INCOME TAX OFFICER, WARD 14-3, DELHI & ANR.

$~37 W.P.(C) 46/2022 & CM Nos.82-83/2022

SHANJU RANI

Mr.Mukesh Gupta and Mr.S B Gandhi, Advs.

INCOME TAX OFFICER AND ANR

$~39 W.P.(C) 57/2022 & CM Nos.103-04/2022

NEERU CHAWLA

Ms.Surbhi Chandra, Adv.

INCOME TAX OFFICER WARD 49 (1) & ANR. ..... Respondents $~40 W.P.(C) 58/2022 & CM Nos.

RANJITGARH FINANCE COMPANY PRIVATE LIMITED

Mr.Mukesh Sukhija, Adv.

CENTRAL BOARD OF DIRECT TAXES & ANR. ..... Respondents $~41 W.P.(C) 59/2022 & CM Nos.105-06/2022

SUN AGRIFRESH INDUSTRIES PVT LTD Mr.Sharad Agarwal, Ms.Monika Ghai, Ms.Avani Agarwal, Advs.

ASST. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CIRCLE 22(2) DELHI & ORS.

$~42 W.P.(C) 60/2022 & CM Nos.107-08/2022

MANOJ MITTAL HUF

Mr.Mukesh Gupta and Mr.S B Gandhi, Advs.

INCOME TAX OFFICER AND ANR. WARD 35 (1) & ANR. Kadian, for Income Tax Department $~43 W.P.(C) 62/2022 & CM Nos.110-11/2022

SACHI GUPTA

INCOME TAX OFFICER WARD 30(1) DELHI & ORS. Mr.Pratyaksh Gupta, Jr. SC for $~44 W.P.(C) 74/2022 & CM Nos.135-36/2022

RAJNISH PURI

Mr.Ruchesh Sinha, Adv.

ACIT, CIRCLE 43(1), DELHI & ORS.

Mr.Prakash Kumar,CGSC for UOI.

$~45 W.P.(C) 75/2022 & CM Nos.137-38/2022

MADHU SUDAN GOYAL

$~46 W.P.(C) 76/2022 & CM Nos.139-40/2022

MANJU BANSAL

ACIT, CIR 43(1), DELHI & ANR.

$~47 W.P.(C) 77/2022 & CM Nos.141-42/2022

PANKAJ SINGLA

ITO, WARD 23(1), DELHI & ANR.

$~48 W.P.(C) 78/2022 & CM Nos.143-44/2022

JYOTI GOEL

ITO, WARD 43(6), DELHI & ANR.

$~49 W.P.(C) 79/2022 & CM Nos.145-46/2022

MADHU SUDAN GOYAL

$~50 W.P.(C) 80/2022 & CM Nos.147-48/2022

SHRI KAMAL PAHUJA

Mr.S.Krishnan, Adv.

THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX & ORS.

$~51 W.P.(C) 81/2022 & CM Nos.149-50/2022

$~52 W.P.(C) 82/2022 & CM Nos.151-52/2022

YOGRAJ ARYA

INCOME TAX OFFICER, WARD 71(1), DELHI & ANR. $~53 W.P.(C) 83/2022 & CM Nos.153-54/2022

INTERNET EXPORTS INDIA LLP

ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, CIRCLE 28(1)DELHI & ORS.

$~54 W.P.(C) 84/2022 & CM Nos.155-56/2022

B.R. BHATIA AND SONS HUF

INCOME TAX OFFICER WARD44(6),DELHI & ORS.

$~55 W.P.(C) 90/2022 & CM Nos.169-70/2022

$~57 W.P.(C) 107/2022 & CM Nos.288-89/2022

RAMAKRISHNA BUILDWELL PRIVATE LIMITED ..... Petitioner Mr.V.K.Sabharwal, Mr.Vinod Sabharwal, Mr.Jatin Sethi, Advs.

UNION OF INDIA THROUGH SECRETARY & ORS.

$~58 W.P.(C) 109/2022 & CM Nos.291-92/2022

SONAL GUPTA

ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX 28(1),DELHI & ORS.

$~60 W.P.(C) 113/2022 & CM Nos.300-01/2022

KULDEEP MANN

ACIT, CIR 34(1), DELHI & ANR.

Kadian, Jr.SC $~61 W.P.(C) 114/2022 & CM Nos.302-03/2022

R N KHEMKA ENTERPRISES PVT LTD

ITO, WARD 20(3), DELHI & ANR.

$~62 W.P.(C) 115/2022 & CM Nos.304-05/2022

MANJU BANSAL

ACIT, 43(1), DELHI & ANR.

$~63 W.P.(C) 116/2022 & CM Nos.306-07/2022

RAJESH KUMAR CHOUDHARY

INCOME TAX OFFICER, WARD 44(6), DELHI & ANR Mr.Puneet Rai, Sr. Ms.Adeeba Mujahid, Jr. SC

$~64 W.P.(C) 118/2022 & CM Nos.310-11/2022

J J TRADELINKS PVT LTD

Mr.Nagesh Kr. Behl, Mr.Rarjesh Kr. Aggarwal, Mr.Mayank Pachauri,

DCIT CIRCLE 13(1) DELHI & ANR.

$~65 W.P.(C) 122/2022 & CM Nos.312-13/2022

MADHU SUDAN GOYAL (HUF)

$~66 W.P.(C) 123/2022 & CM Nos.314-15/2022

R N KHEMKA ENTERPRISES PVT LTD

ITO, WARD 20(3), DELHI & ANR.

$~67 W.P.(C) 126/2022 & CM Nos.316-17/2022

JSL LIMITED

Mr.Rohit Jain, Mr.Aniket D. Agrawal, Ms.Manisha

DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX & ORS. Mr.Anant Ram Mishra, Adv. for Mr.Avnish Singh & Ms.Pushplata Singh, Advs for R-3/UOI.

$~69 W.P.(C) 132/2022 & CM Nos.334-35/2022

$~70 W.P.(C) 133/2022 & CM Nos.336-37/2022

SURESH KUMAR MUNJAL

Mr.Satyen Sethi & Mr.Arta Trana Panda, Advs.

INCOME TAX OFFICER, WARD 49(1) & ORS. ..... Respondents $~72 W.P.(C) 135/2022 & CM Nos.340-41/2022

MADHU SUDAN GOYAL HUF

$~73 W.P.(C) 136/2022 & CM Nos.342-43/2022

CHAMPION EL COM PVT LTD

ITO, WARD 6(1), DELHI & ANR.

$~74 W.P.(C) 141/2022 & CM Nos.368-69/2022

AARTI FABRICOTT PRIVATE LIMITED

INCOME TAX OFFICER, WARD 1(1), DELHI & ANR. $~75 W.P.(C) 142/2022 & CM Nos.370-71/2022

ARUN GUPTA

ITO, WARD 44(6), DELHI & ANR.

$~76 W.P.(C) 145/2022 & CM No.375/2022

VRAS AGRO INFRATECH PRIVATE LIMITED ..... Petitioner

Mr.Akhilesh Kumar, Adv.

Mr.S.S.Rai, SPC with Mrs.Roopam Rai, Adv. for UOI.

$~77 W.P.(C) 147/2022 & CM Nos.378-79/2022

ZEL JEWELLERS LIMITED

THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX & ORS. $~78 W.P.(C) 148/2022 & CM Nos.380-81/2022

SAIBA AGARWAL

THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CIRCLE34(1) & ANR.

Jr.SC for Revenue. Mr.Narendra Kumar Srivastava, SPC for UOI.

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANMOHAN

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE NAVIN CHAWLA

05.01.2022 O R D E R

1.

Learned counsel for the parties admit that as the impugned notices in the present matters have been issued post 31st March, 2021 without

following the procedure prescribed in the substituted Sections 147 to 151 w.e.f. 01st April, 2021, the present matters are covered by the judgment dated 15th 2. The conclusion reached by this Court in Mon Mohan Kohli (supra) is reproduced hereinbelow:- December, 2021 passed by this Court in the case of Mon Mohan Kohli vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax & Anr., W.P.(C) No.6176/2021.

“ 97. This Court is of the view that as the Legislature has introduced the new provisions, Sections 147 to 151 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 by way of the Finance Act, 2021 with effect from 1 CONCLUSION st April, 2021 and as the said Section 147 is not even mentioned in the impugned Explanations, the reassessment notices relating to any Assessment Year issued under Section 148 after 31st 98. It is clarified that the power of reassessment that existed prior to 31 March, 2021 had to comply with the substituted Sections. st March, 2021 continued to exist till the extended period i.e. till 30th June, 2021; however, the Finance Act, 2021 has merely changed the procedure to be followed prior to issuance of notice with effect from 1st 99. This Court is of the opinion that Section 3(1) of Relaxation Act empowers the Government/Executive to extend only the time limits and it does not delegate the power to legislate on provisions to be followed for initiation of reassessment proceedings. In fact, the Relaxation Act does not give power to Government to extend the erstwhile Sections 147 to 151 beyond

April, 2021. st March, 2021 and/or defer the operation of substituted provisions enacted by the Finance Act, 2021. Consequently, the impugned Explanations in the Notifications dated 31st March, 2021 and 27th April, 2021 are not conditional legislation and are beyond the power delegated to the Government as well as ultra vires the parent statute i.e. the Relaxation Act. Accordingly, this Court is respectfully not in agreement with the

view of the Chhattisgarh High Court in Palak Khatuja (supra), but with the views of the Allahabad High Court and Rajasthan High Court in Ashok Kumar Agarwal (supra) and Bpip Infra Private Limited (supra) respectively. 100. The submission of the Revenue that Section 6 of the General Clauses Act saves notices issued under Section 148 post 31st 101. The argument of the respondents that the substitution made by the Finance Act, 2021 is not applicable to past Assessment Years, as it is substantial in nature is contradicted by Respondents’ own Circular 549 of 1989 and its own submission that from 1 March, 2021 is untenable in law, as in the present case, the repeal is followed by a fresh legislation on the same subject and the new Act manifests an intention to destroy the old procedure. Consequently, if the Legislature has permitted reassessment to be made in a particular manner, it can only be in this manner, or not at all. st 102. Revenue cannot rely on Covid-19 for contending that the new provisions Sections 147 to 151 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 should not operate during the period 1 July, 2021, the substitution made by the Finance Act, 2021 will be applicable. st April, 2021 to 30th 103. Consequently, this Court is of the view that the Executive/Respondents/Revenue cannot use the administrative power to issue Notifications under Section 3(1) of the Relaxation Act, 2020 to undermine the expression of Parliamentary supremacy in the form of an Act of Parliament, namely, the Finance Act, 2021. This Court is also of the opinion that the Executive/Respondents/Revenue cannot frustrate the purpose of substituted statutory provisions, like Sections 147 to 151 of Income Tax Act, 1961 in the present instance, by emptying it of content or impeding or postponing their effectual operation.”

June, 2021 as Parliament was fully aware of Covid-19 Pandemic when it passed the Finance Act, 2021. Also, the arguments of the respondents qua non-obstante clause in Section 3(1) of the Relaxation Act, ‘legal fiction’ and ‘stop the clock provision’ are contrary to facts and untenable in law.

3.

Keeping in view the aforesaid, Explanations A(a)(ii)/A(b) to the Notifications dated 31st March, 2021 and 27th 4. Consequently, the impugned reassessment notices issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 are quashed and the present writ petitions are allowed. If the law permits the respondents/revenue to take further steps in the matter, they shall be at liberty to do so. Needless to state that if and when such steps are taken and if the petitioners have a grievance, they shall be at liberty to take their remedies in accordance with law. April, 2021 are declared to be ultra vires the Relaxation Act, 2020 and are therefore bad in law and null and void.

MANMOHAN, J

NAVIN CHAWLA, J JANUARY 5, 2022/Arya

More judgments on Section 147

All 57,238 judgments and leading authorities on Section 147 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →