SHIV MITTER JINDAL vs. ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CIRCLE-28(1), DELHI & ANR.

PDF · subscribers
W.P.(C)/4202/2022HC DelhiDLHC01010292202214 March 2022Author: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANMOHAN,HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUDHIR KUMAR JAIN24 pages
AI SummaryAllowed

What did the High Court hold?

The Delhi High Court held that the Legislature introduced new provisions, Sections 147 to 151 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, via the Finance Act, 2021, effective from April 1, 2021. The Court found that reassessment notices issued under Section 148 after March 31, 2021, had to comply with these substituted sections. The Court ruled that Section 3(1) of the Relaxation Act, 2020, empowers the government only to extend time limits, not to legislate on procedural provisions for initiating reassessment proceedings or to defer the operation of substituted provisions. Consequently, the Explanations A(a)(ii)/A(b) to the Notifications dated March 31, 2021, and April 27, 2021, were declared ultra vires the Relaxation Act, 2020, and thus void. The Court quashed the impugned reassessment notices. The ratio is that executive notifications cannot override parliamentary legislation, and procedural changes enacted by Parliament must be followed.

What were the facts?

The petitioners, including Arvind Bengani and Sons HUF, Kawarjeet Singh, and others, filed writ petitions before the Delhi High Court challenging reassessment notices issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. These notices were issued after March 31, 2021. The core issue was whether these notices were validly issued, given the substitution of Sections 147 to 151 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, by the Finance Act, 2021, effective from April 1, 2021. The revenue contended that certain explanations in notifications issued by the government extended the applicability of the old provisions. The High Court consolidated these petitions for a common decision.

What were the issues?

1. Whether reassessment notices issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, after March 31, 2021, are valid if they do not comply with the substituted Sections 147 to 151 of the Act, which came into effect from April 1, 2021? (Question of law) Assessee's Contention: The assessee argued that since the Finance Act, 2021, substituted Sections 147 to 151 with effect from April 1, 2021, any reassessment notices issued thereafter must comply with these new provisions. They contended that the government's notifications extending the old provisions were ultra vires the Relaxation Act, 2020, and the parent statute. Revenue's Contention: The revenue argued that Explanations in notifications dated March 31, 2021, and April 27, 2021, allowed for the issuance of notices under the old regime even after March 31, 2021, until June 30, 2021. They also relied on Section 6 of the General Clauses Act to save notices issued under Section 148 post March 31, 2021.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 148,Section 147,Section 151

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Heard together (3 matters)

W.P.(C) 4072/2022
W.P.(C) 4166/2022
W.P.(C) 4167/2022

Read from the judgment's own cause title. This page is filed under one of them.

$~111, 144-149, 152, 155, 157, 158, 161-164, 166, 168-174, 176-189, 191, 193-205, 207, 209, 210, 214, 216, 218, 219, 221(148 matters) * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI W.P.(C) 4072/2022 with CM APPLs. 12111-12/2022 ARVIND BENGANI AND SONS HUF ACIT, CIRCLE 61(1) AND ORS. $~144 W.P.(C) 4166/2022 with CM APPLs. 12503-04/2022 KAWARJEET SINGH Mr. Rahul Kumar, Adv. ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CIRCLE 54(1), $~145 W.P.(C) 4167/2022 with CM APPLs. 12505-06/2022 PRITEE PAL GUPTA Agrawal, Ms.Hemlata

ITO WARD 43(1), DELHI AND ANR $~146 W.P.(C) 4170/2022 with CM APPLs. 12511-12/2022 NEW TECH PNEUMATICS PVT LTD Mr. Sharad Agarwal and Ms. Monika Ghai, Advs. INCOME TAX OFFICER WARD 18(3) & ORS. $~147 W.P.(C) 4171/2022 with CM APPLs. 12513-14/2022 Mr. Alok Singh, SPC with Ms.Sonam Awasthi, Adv. for UOI. $~148 W.P.(C) 4172/2022 with CM APPLs. 12515-16/2022 SUNIL TIKU Mr. Rajiv Sharma and Mr. Aditya Sharma, Advs.

INCOME TAX OFFICER AND ANR. $~149 W.P.(C) 4173/2022 FETLOCK BUILDTECH INDIA PVT. LTD. Mr. Bhupesh Narula, Adv. ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, DELHI $~152 W.P.(C) 4176/2022 with CM APPLs. 12519-20/2022 WEALTH DISCOVERY COMMODITIES PRIVATE LIMITED INCOME TAX OFFICER, WARD 27(1), DELHI & ANR. $~155 W.P.(C) 4180/2022 with CM APPLs. 12526-27/2022 SHIV PYARI SONI

Through: Mr. Ruchir Bhatia, Advocate. $~157 W.P.(C) 4184/2022 with CM APPL. 12537/2022 MANSUKH SECURITIES AND FINANCE LIMITED Mr. Mudit Bansal, Adv. DCIT CIRCLE 16 (1), DELHI. $~158 W.P.(C) 4185/2022 KIRTI KUMAR DAWAR Mr. Bhupesh Narula, Adv. ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, DELHI $~161 W.P.(C) 4188/2022 with CM APPLs. 12541-42/2022 ARVIND BENGANI AND SONS HUF ACIT CIRCLE 61(1) AND ANR. Anand, Adv. for R-2/UOI.

$~162 W.P.(C) 4189/2022 with CM APPL. 12543/2022 RAVI CHOPRA INCOME TAX OFFICER, WARD 58(1), DELHI AND ORS. Mr. S.S. Rai, SPC with Ms. Roopam Rai, Adv. for R-3 & R-4. $~163 W.P.(C) 4190/2022 with CM APPLs. 12544/2022, 12550/2022 MANOJ KUMAR SONI $~164 W.P.(C) 4191/2022 with CM APPLs. 12545-46/2022 WEALTH DISCOVERY COMMODITIES PRIVATE LIMITED

INCOME TAX OFFICER, WARD 27(1), DELHI & ANR. $~166 W.P.(C) 4195/2022 with CM APPL. 12551/2022 SANJAY MADAN Mr. Bhupinder Jit Kumar and Mr.Shreyansh Kushwaha, Advs. INCOME TAX OFFICER AND ORS. $~168 W.P.(C) 4198/2022 with CM APPL. 12556-57/2022 MANOJ SEHGAL Mr. Aseem Chawla, Ms. Manu K. Giri and Ms. Pratistha Chaudhary, ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX AND ANOTHER $~169 W.P.(C) 4201/2022 with CM APPLs. 12559-60/2022 RC INFO SYSTEMS PRIVATE LIMITED

$~170 W.P.(C) 4202/2022 with CM APPLs. 12562-63/2022 SHIV MITTER JINDAL ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CIRCLE-28(1), DELHI & ANR. $~171 W.P.(C) 4203/2022 with CM APPLs. 12564-65/2022 MANVI GUPTA INCOME TAX OFFICER, WARD 2(1), DELHI & ANR. $~172 W.P.(C) 4204/2022 with CM APPLs. 12566-67/2022 HANS FOUNDATION Mr. Manu K. Giri and Mr. Deepak Malik, Advs.

INCOME TAX OFFICER AND ANOTHER $~173 W.P.(C) 4205/2022 with CM APPLs. 12568-69/2022 NAMITA CHADHA Mr. Nitesh Kumar Sinha, Advs. ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX AND ORS. Ms. Zehra Khan, Jr. SC and Mr.Shrey Mr. Gagan Kumar and Ms. Nishtha Kaur, Advs for R-3. $~174 W.P.(C) 4206/2022 with CM APPLs. 12571-72/2022 M/S ADI SPORTS INDIA PRIVATE LIMITED ACIT, CIRCLE 1(1)- DELHI AND ANR $~176 W.P.(C) 4208/2022 with CM APPLs. 12574-75/2022 CHURCHIT AGRAWAL Mr. Gaurav Jain, Ms. Akshita Goyal and Mr. Shubham Gupta, Advs.

ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CIRCLE 46(1) DELHI AND ANR $~177 W.P.(C) 4209/2022 with CM APPLs. 12576-77/2022 MANVI GUPTA INCOME TAX OFFICER, WARD 2(1), DELHI & ANR. $~178 W.P.(C) 4210/2022 with CM APPLs. 12578-79/2022 M/S. PRECISION REALTORS (P) LTD Mr. S. Krishnan, Adv. $~179 W.P.(C) 4211/2022 with CM APPL. 12580/2022 VIJAY ARORA

INCOME TAX OFFICER WARD 36(1) DELHI AND ANR. $~180 W.P.(C) 4212/2022 with CM APPL. 12587/2022 VARUN ARORA INCOME TAX OFFICER WARD 36 1 DELHI AND ANR. $~181 W.P.(C) 4213/2022 with CM APPLs. 12581-82/2022 MANOJ KUMAR ITO WARD 50 (1), DELHI AND ANR. $~182 W.P.(C) 4215/2022 PRET STUDY BY JANAK FASHIONS PRIVATE LIMITED Mr. Rishi Jaiswal, Adv.

ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, CIRCLE- 19(1), DELHI Rai, Ms.Adeeba Mujahid, Jr. SC. $~183 W.P.(C) 4216/2022 with CM APPLs. 12586/2022 & 12753/2022 DILIP MAJI .... Petitioner $~184 W.P.(C) 4218/2022 with CM APPLs. 12589/2022 & 12754/2022 PRASHANT SONI $~185 W.P.(C) 4219/2022 with CM APPLs. 12590-91/2022 GURUDAYAL GUPTA (HUF) (THROUGH KARTA SH. RAJAN GUPTA) INCOME TAX OFFICER, WARD 35(1) DELHI & ANR.

$~186 W.P.(C) 4220/2022 with CM APPLs. 12593-94/2022 M/S. NUCLEUS CONBUILD (P) LTD Mr. S. Krishnan, Adv. $~187 W.P.(C) 4221/2022 with CM APPLs. 12598/2022 & 12755/2022 BASIC DEVELOPERS PRIVATE LIMITED INCOME TAX DEPARTMENT, CIRCLE 4-2, DELHI & ORS. Mr. Gigi C. George, Adv. for UOI. $~188 W.P.(C) 4222/2022 with CM APPLs. 12601-02/2022 BASIC DEVELOPERS PRIVATE LIMITED INCOME TAX DEPARTMENT, CIRCLE 4-2, DELHI & ORS.

$~189 W.P.(C) 4224/2022 with CM APPLs. 12605-06/2022 RAM CHANDER SONI $~191 W.P.(C) 4228/2022 with CM APPLs. 12614-15/2022 RIVER INFRACON PRIVATE LIMITED Mr. Nitesh Kumar Sinha, Adv. ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX AND ORS. Rai, Ms.Adeeba Mujahid, Jr. SC. Mr. Jatinder Kaur, Adv. for R-3. $~193 W.P.(C) 4232/2022 with CM APPLs. 12620/2022 & 12756/2022 AASHIMA GUPTA (PREVIOUS NAME AASHIMA JINDAL)

ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CIRCLE 43 (1), Tushar Gupta, Jr.SC, $~194 W.P.(C) 4234/2022 with CM APPLs. 12623-24/2022 VIJAY KUMAR ITO WARD 34 (5) AND ORS. $~195 W.P.(C) 4236/2022 with CM APPLs. 12628-29/2022 NIRMALA SONI $~196 W.P.(C) 4237/2022 with CM APPL. 12630/2022 DUGGAL AND SONS BUILDWELL PVT LTD.

INCOME TAX OFFICER WARD 7(1) DELHI AND ANR. $~197 W.P.(C) 4238/2022 with CM APPLs. 12631-32/2022 VIVO APPARELS PRIVATE LIMITED Mr. Rakesh Gupta, Mr. Somil Agarwal Anshul Mittal, INCOME TAX OFFICER WARD 26(3) DELHI & ORS. $~198 W.P.(C) 4239/2022 with CM APPLs. 12635-36/2022 URTAN NORTH MINING COMPANY LIMITED ..... Petitioner Salil Kapoor, Ananya Kapoor Tarun Chanana, INCOME TAX OFFICER, WARD 27-1, DELHI AND ANR.

$~199 W.P.(C) 4240/2022 with CM APPLs. 12633-34/2022 M/S INVER AIRCRAFT LEASING LIMITED. ..... Petitioner Anuradha Dutt, Sanchit Jolly, Mr. Rohit Garg, Ms. Disha Jham, Mehak Sachdeva Mr. Sohum Dua, Advs. DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CIRCLE 2( 1 )(1) INTERNATIONAL TAXATION & ORS. $~200 W.P.(C) 4241/2022 with CM APPLs. 12638/2022 & 12711/2022 SURJAN SINGH MEHTAB SINGH PVT LTD INCOME TAX OFFICER AND ANR. $~201 W.P.(C) 4243/2022 ROSHAN LAL AGGARWAL Mr. Vineet Bhatia, Adv.

THE INCOME TAX OFFICER WARD 36 (1 ) DELHI AND ANR $~202 W.P.(C) 4246/2022 with CM APPLs. 12642-43/2022 GOLDSTAR FOOTWEARS PVT. LTD. INCOME TAX OFFICER, WARD 10(1) NEW DELHI AND ANR. $~203 W.P.(C) 4248/2022 with CM APPLs. 12645/2022 & 12758/2022 GOVIND SHARDA EX-DIRECTOR, DJIL INVESTMENT & EXPORTS PVT.LTD. Mr. Rakesh Gupta, Mr. Somil Agarwal Anshul Mittal, INCOME TAX OFFICER WARD 7(1), DELHI & ANR. $~204 W.P.(C) 4250/2022 with CM APPLs. 12651-52/2022

Mr. Alok Singh, SPC with Ms.Sonam Awasti, Adv. for UOI. $~205 W.P.(C) 4251/2022 MAGNOLIA MARTINIQUE CLOTHING PRIVATE LIMITED Mr. Satya Prakash Yadav, Adv. ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CENTRAL CIRCLE 17, DELHI AND ANR. $~207 W.P.(C) 4255/2022 MAGNOLIA MARTINIQUE CLOTHING PRIVATE LIMITED Mr. Satya Prakash Yadav, Adv. ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX & ANR.

$~209 W.P.(C) 4257/2022 with CM APPLs. 12663-64/2022 S.S. PROMOTERS PVT. LTD. Sanyam Khetrapal, Mr.Nitesh Goyal and Ms. Prakriti Anand, Advs. Ms. Ritu Reniwal, Adv. for R-3/UOI. $~210 W.P.(C) 4259/2022 with CM APPLs. 12666-67/2022 RAKESH RAWAT (HUF) Mr. Sarthak Jain, Mr. Vishal Malik and Mr. Linoy Varghese, Advs. INCOME TAX OFFICER, WARD 36(1) DELHI & ANR. $~214 W.P.(C) 4265/2022 with CM APPLs. 12676-77/2022 VANDANA BENGANI ACIT, CIRCLE 34(1) AND ORS

$~216 W.P.(C) 4267/2022 with CM APPLs. 12684-85/2022 M/S ANUJ TRADING COMPANY Mr. Naveen Malhotra and Mr.Nilansh Malhotra, Advs. DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, WARD 60 (1), $~218 W.P.(C) 4269/2022 with CM APPLs. 12694-95/2022 Mr. Alok Singh, SPC with Ms.Sonam Awasthi, Adv. for UOI. $~219 W.P.(C) 4276/2022 with CM APPLs. 12704-05/2022 KIWI ALLOYS LIMITED

INCOME TAX OFFICER, WARD-14(3), DELHI & ANR. $~221 W.P.(C) 4278/2022 with CM APPLs. 12708-09/2022 KIWI ALLOYS LIMITED INCOME TAX OFFICER, WARD-14(3), DELHI & ANR. CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANMOHAN HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUDHIR KUMAR JAIN O R D E R % 14.03.2022 1. Learned counsel for the parties admit that as the impugned notices in the present matters have been issued post 31st March, 2021 without following the procedure prescribed in the substituted Sections 147 to 151 w.e.f. 01st April, 2021, the present matters are covered by the judgment dated 15th December, 2021 passed by this Court in the case of Mon Mohan Kohli vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax & Anr., W.P.(C) No.6176/2021. 2. The conclusion reached by this Court in Mon Mohan Kohli (supra) is reproduced hereinbelow:- “CONCLUSION 97. This Court is of the view that as the Legislature has introduced the new provisions, Sections 147 to 151 of the

Income Tax Act, 1961 by way of the Finance Act, 2021 with effect from 1st April, 2021 and as the said Section 147 is not even mentioned in impugned Explanations, reassessment notices relating to any Assessment Year issued under Section 148 after 31st March, 2021 had to comply with the substituted Sections. 98. It is clarified that the power of reassessment that existed prior to 31st March, 2021 continued to exist till the extended period i.e. till 30th June, 2021; however, the Finance Act, 2021 has merely changed the procedure to be followed prior to issuance of notice with effect from 1st April, 2021. 99. This Court is of the opinion that Section 3(1) of Relaxation Act empowers the Government/Executive to extend only the time limits and it does not delegate the power to legislate on provisions to be followed for initiation of reassessment proceedings. In fact, the Relaxation Act does not give power to Government to extend the erstwhile Sections 147 to 151 beyond 31st March, 2021 and/or defer the operation of substituted provisions enacted by the Finance Act, 2021. Consequently, the impugned Explanations in the Notifications dated 31st March, 2021 and 27th April, 2021 are not conditional legislation and are beyond the power delegated to the Government as well as ultra vires the parent statute i.e. the Relaxation Act. Accordingly, this Court is respectfully not in agreement with the view of the Chhattisgarh High Court in Palak Khatuja (supra), but with the views of the Allahabad High Court and Rajasthan High Court in Ashok Kumar Agarwal (supra) and Bpip Infra Private Limited (supra) respectively. 100. The submission of the Revenue that Section 6 of the General Clauses Act saves notices issued under Section 148 post 31st March, 2021 is untenable in law, as in the present case, the repeal is followed by a fresh legislation on the same subject and the new Act manifests an intention to destroy the old procedure. Consequently, if the Legislature has permitted

reassessment to be made in a particular manner, it can only be in this manner, or not at all. 101. The argument of the respondents that the substitution made by the Finance Act, 2021 is not applicable to past Assessment Years, as it is substantial in nature is contradicted by Respondents’ own Circular 549 of 1989 and its own submission that from 1st July, 2021, the substitution made by the Finance Act, 2021 will be applicable. 102. Revenue cannot rely on Covid-19 for contending that the new provisions Sections 147 to 151 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 should not operate during the period 1st April, 2021 to 30th June, 2021 as Parliament was fully aware of Covid-19 Pandemic when it passed the Finance Act, 2021. Also, the arguments of the respondents qua non-obstante clause in Section 3(1) of the Relaxation Act, ‘legal fiction’ and ‘stop the clock provision’ are contrary to facts and untenable in law. 103. Consequently, this Court is of the view that the Executive/Respondents/Revenue cannot use the administrative power to issue Notifications under Section 3(1) of the Relaxation Act, 2020 to undermine expression of Parliamentary supremacy in the form of an Act of Parliament, namely, the Finance Act, 2021. This Court is also of the opinion that Executive/Respondents/Revenue cannot frustrate the purpose of substituted statutory provisions, like Sections 147 to 151 of Income Tax Act, 1961 in the present instance, by emptying it of content or impeding or postponing their effectual operation.” 3. Keeping in view the aforesaid, Explanations A(a)(ii)/A(b) to the Notifications dated 31st March, 2021 and 27th April, 2021 are declared to be ultra vires the Relaxation Act, 2020 and are therefore bad in law and null and void.

4.

Consequently, the impugned reassessment notices issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 are quashed and the present writ petitions are allowed. If the law permits the respondents/revenue to take further steps in the matter, they shall be at liberty to do so. Needless to state that if and when such steps are taken and if the petitioners have a grievance, they shall be at liberty to take their remedies in accordance with law. MANMOHAN, J SUDHIR KUMAR JAIN, J MARCH 14, 2022 N

More judgments on Section 148

All 49,222 judgments and leading authorities on Section 148 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →