C I T vs. SOHAM EDUCATION TRUST

PDF · subscribers
ITA/311/2009HC RajasthanRJHC02051031200918 May 20177 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court agreed with the Tribunal's view on both appeals. Regarding the first issue, the Tribunal found that the CIT was not justified in doubting the eligibility for registration under Section 12AA in the absence of adverse findings that the appellant was established for earning profits or against the genuineness of its objects. The Tribunal noted that the trust had furnished copies of its income and expenditure account, balance sheet, books of account, bank statement, salary expenses, and advance fees received. The CIT's presumption of commercial operation based on a potential franchise agreement was unsubstantiated. Therefore, the Tribunal directed the CIT to grant registration. For the second issue, the Tribunal relied on the Special Bench decision in Bhagwad Swarup Shri Shri Devraha Baba Momorial Shri Hari Parmarth Dham Trust vs. CIT, which held that the six-month time limit under Section 12AA(2) for passing an order granting or refusing registration is mandatory. If the order is not passed within this period, registration is deemed to have been granted. The Tribunal found that the CIT passed the order refusing registration after the expiry of six months, making the order a nullity. Consequently, registration was deemed granted. The High Court found no reason to interfere with the Tribunal's findings.

What were the facts?

These appeals by the Commissioner of Income Tax (CIT) challenge the orders of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) which allowed the appeals of the assessees, Soham Education Trust and Anupam Charitable Trust. The ITAT had directed the grant of registration under Section 12AA of the Income Tax Act, 1961, to both trusts. The CIT contended that the trusts failed to furnish required details and prove they were not operating on commercial lines. In the case of Anupam Charitable Trust, the CIT also argued that the Tribunal erred in deeming registration granted after the expiry of the six-month period stipulated in Section 12AA(2), asserting this time limit is directory, not mandatory. The appeals were admitted by the High Court, which framed substantial questions of law.

What were the issues?

1. Whether, in the facts and circumstances, the ITAT was justified in directing the grant of registration under Section 12AA, despite the trust failing to furnish required details and prove it was not working on commercial lines? (Question of law and fact, concerning Section 12AA). 2. Whether, in the facts and circumstances, the ITAT acted perversely in holding that registration under Section 12AA is deemed to be granted after the expiry of six months from the application date, without appreciating that the time limit is directory and not mandatory? (Question of law, concerning Section 12AA(2)). Assessee's contentions (implied from Tribunal's findings): The trusts submitted necessary documents and accounts, and there was no adverse material to suggest they were operating on commercial lines or that their objects were not genuine. In the case of Anupam Charitable Trust, the application for registration was received on 30.05.2007, and the CIT passed the rejection order on 04.12.2007, which was beyond the six-month period prescribed by Section 12AA(2). Therefore, registration should be deemed granted. Revenue's contentions: The trusts failed to furnish required details and prove they were not working on commercial lines. The time limit of six months under Section 12AA(2) is directory, not mandatory, and the CIT's order passed after this period is valid.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 12AA,Section 12A,Section 253(1)(c)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN BENCH AT JAIPUR D.B. Income Tax Appeal No. 311 / 2009 C I T ----Appellant Versus Soham Education Trust ----Respondent Connected With D.B. Income Tax Appeal No. 102 / 2009 C I T Jaipur ----Appellant Versus Anupam Charitable Trust ----Respondent _____________________________________________________ For Appellant(s) : Mr. K.D. Mathur for Mr. R.B. Mathur _____________________________________________________ HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE K.S. JHAVERI HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE INDERJEET SINGH Judgment 18/05/2017 1. In both these appeals, identical questions of law and facts arises, therefore, they are decided by this common judgment. 2. By way of these appeals, the appellant has challenged the judgment of the Tribunal whereby the Tribunal has allowed the appeal of the assessee. 2.1 While admitting the appeal, this Court framed the following substantial question of law:

(2 of 7)

Appeal No. 311/2009 “Whether in the facts and circumstances of the case the ITAT was justified in directing to grant registration u/s 12AA inspite of the fact that the trust failed to furnish the required details and prove that it was not working on commercial lines?” Appeal No. 102/2009 “Whether in the facts and circumstances of the case the Tribunal was justified in law and has acted perversely in holding that after expiry of six months from the date of filing application for registration u/s 12AA of the Income Tax Act, 1961 will be deemed to be granted without appreciating the fact that the time limit mentioned in the section is only directory and not mandatory?”

Heard learned counsel for the parties. 3.1 The observations of the Tribunal in regard to the aforesaid issue in Appeal No. 311/2009 reads as under: “4. Considering the above submissions, in view of material available on record and orders of the lower authorities, we find substance in the above contentions of the ld. A/R that in absence of any adverse finding of the ld. CIT that the appellant was established for earning profits or against the genuineness of object of the appellant trust to umpart education and not to earn profit, the ld. CIT was not justified in doubting the eligibility of the appellant for registration under section 12AA of the Act. Under section 12AA the scope of enquiry while deciding as to whether the applicant is eligible for granting of registration or not, the ld. CIT is supposed to call for such document or information. Which he/she thinks necessary to satisfy himself/herself about the genuineness of activities and secondly if the ld. CIT is satisfied about the object of the Trust, he/she shall pass an order granting registration. And further that in absence of any adverse material against the assessee that it was entered into an agreement with Dolphin Group to run the school on commercial basis, it was mere presumption of the ld. CIT that the appellant might have taken Franchise of that Group to run the

(3 of 7)

school especially when appellant had submitted that no such agreement was entered into with that group and know-how about school procedure, curriculum and other system support were supplied by them free of cost. Under these circumstances we are of the view that there was no reason with the ld. CIT to reject the application for registration keeping also in view that the Trust was set up only on 14.3.2007 and, therefore, no account prior to this date could be possible and the appellant trust had furnished the copies of income and expenditure account and balance sheet for the period after formation as well as books of account for that period with copy of bank statement, details of salary expenses and advance fees received, etc. We thus while setting aside order of ld. CIT in question, direct the ld. CIT to grant registration on applied period. The ground is thus allowed. 3.2 We are in complete agreement with the view taken by the Tribunal. 3.3 With regard to Appeal No. 102/2009, the Tribunal observed as under: 5. As per Section 12AA(2) every order granting or refusing registration under clause (b) of sub-section (1) shall be passed before the expiry of six months from the end of the month in which the application was received under clause (a) [or clause (aa) of sub-section (1)] of Section 12A]. The application of the assessee was received by the Department on 30-05-07 (PB 1). The assessee appeared before the ld. CIT on 4-12-07 and submitted the required evidences and documents (PB 8-9). The ld. CIT has passed the order for rejecting the registration u/s 12AA vide order dated 4-12-2007 is part of record. The order u/s 12AA was required to be passed upto 30th Nov. 07 which was passed on 4-12-07. The registration would be deemed to have been granted to the trust automatically on the expiry of the period i.e. 30-11-07 in the present case as required u/s 12AA(2) of the Act. The reliance is placed on Special Bench Decision in the case of Bhagwad Swarup Shri Shri Devraha Baba Momorial Shri Hari Parmarth Dham Trust vs. CIT, Dehradun, (2008)

(4 of 7)

111 ITD 175 (Del.) where the facts of the case and the decision of the Special Bench is as under:- “The assessee a charitable trust/institution, applied to the Commissioner for registration under section 12A on 23-1-0-2001. The commissioner, however, passed the order under section 12AA refusing registration to the assessee trust on 26.05.2003, which was beyond the period laid down in Section 12AA(2) (i.e., not within the period of six months from the end of the month in which the application for registration was foiled). He had, however, initiated certain enquiries by letter dated 3.4.2002, which was well within the peirod of six months, to which the assessee responded by furnishing the relevant details. The enquiry continued well beyond 30.4.2002. But, finally order was passed under Section 12AA refusing registration on 26-05-2003. Aggrieved by the said order, the assessee filed the instant appeal before the Tribunal and contended that once the time limit fixed by section 12AA(2) expired without the Commissioner having passed any order, it must be deemed that the registration had been granted. However, since a contrary view had been expressed by two coordinate Benches of the Tribunal on said issue, the mater was referred to the Special Bench, for decision. Held The statutory authorities have no option but to obey the mandate of the law. Unless the statute provides for exceptions, the order must be passed by statutory authorities in accordance with the time limit set by the law. Sub-section (2) of Section 12AA does not admit of any exception to the rule. Therefore, it is mandatory for the Commissioner to dispose of the application for deregistration made under section 12A within six months from the end of the month I which the application was filed (para 11) If the application for registration under section 12A is to abate because the Commissioner did not pass an order thereon and the assessee is asked to file another application again that would be putting the assessee to the grind all over again for no fault of his. That consequences should be avoided. If the application is to be treated as pending, then against the Commissioner would be getting an extended period of limitation, which Section 12AA does not allow. Further it would be uncertain as to how long the period can be extended. If it is concluded that

(5 of 7)

the application must be deemed to have bee refused, obviously, the assessee must be in a position to file an appeal against the refusal to the Tribunal, but it would not be able to do so in the absence of a written order containing the reasons for refusal; the appeal remedy would be rendered illusory. Therefore, the Commissioner must be deemed to have allowed the registration under section 12A if he has not passed any order under section 12AA within the time prescribed. That way, the rights of the Department are also protected in the sense that it would be open to the Commissioner to cancel the deemed registration by invoking sub-section (3) of Section 12AA, if it is otherwise permitted and the procedure prescribed therefor is followed. The assessee, if aggrieved by the cancellation of registration, has a right to appeal to the Tribunal under sectioin 253(1) (c). [para 12. Further the object of the introducing section 12AA was to provide for the processing of the application for registration, registration being a condition for obtaining exemption of the income of the trust or charitable institution under section 11. It would be incongruous to hold that while the condition that the trust or charitable institution must be registered with the Commissioner is mandatory or absolute, the provision that the Commissioner shall pass an order thereon within six months from the end of the month in which the application was filed is merely directory, leaving it to the convenience of the Commissioner to pass the order at any time he likes disregarding the time limit prescribed. That would introduce an element of uncertainty and confusion in the administration of the Act and may even compel trusts or institutions claiming exemption under section 11 to invoke article 226 of the Constitution. Such consequences have to be avoided. The assessments of the trust or charitable institution may in the meantime be completed rejecting the claim for exemption on the ground that it is not registered, even though the trust/charitable institution is found by he Assessing Officer to satisfy the other conditions such as application of income, investment of the funds and son on. In other words, by not passing the order under section 12AA with the time limit, the claim of the trust/charitable institution can be frustrated, albeit unintentionally. Therefore, it could not be said that the time limit within which the Commissioner has to pass an order under section 12AA on the application for registration of the trust or institution is merely directory.[para 13]

(6 of 7)

In the instant case, the order refusing registration was ultimately passed on 26.05.2003, more than a year after the expiry of the time limit. The entire chronology showed that no action was taken on the application till the time limit for passing the order was about to come to an end. When the enquiry was started a very late stage, it was found that there were many things to be enquired into and so the enquiry could not be completed and an order was passed on 30.04.2002. The time limit prescribed was given a go-by, the enquiry was continued and finally an order was passed refusing the registration. [para 14] Section 12AA was introduced to provide for the procedure for registration, enquiry into the claim and a time limit for passing the order. Therefore, whole exercising such an important power, the Commissioner should also pass an order within the time limit provided. It would be incongruous to hold that conducting an enquiry into the claim for registration is an important exercise of the power, whereas passing of the order within the time limit provided is not and it can be done at any time. [para 16] Therefore, it was to be held that in a case where the Commissioner does not pass the order granting or refusing of registration of trust within the period, laid down in Section 12AA(2) i.e., within six months from the end of the month in which the application for registration under section 12A was filed, the registration would be deemed to have been granted to the trust or institution automatically on expiry of period specified in section 12AA(2). Therefore, the order of the Commissioner refusing registration was a nullity and was, to be quashed. The registration to the assessee would be deemed to have been granted as applied for by the assessee [para 19]. 6. Therefore, in the circumstances and facts of the case and the decision of Special Bench here in before, the ld. CIT has passed the order refusing the registration after the expiry of six months from the end of the month in which the application u/s 12A was received and therefore, the registration would be deemed to have been granted to the assessee trust automatically as applied for by the assessee trust. Since the assessee has filed all the documents required by the ld. CIT and are on record, therefore, on merit also the ld. CIT is not justified in rejecting the application for registration

(7 of 7)

of the assessee trust and the ld. CIT is directed to grant the registration to the assessee trust as applied for vide application received on 30.5.2007. Trust the additional ground reaised by the assessee and Ground No. 1 to 3 are allowed. 3.4 We are in complete agreement with the view taken by the Tribunal in this appeal also. 4. Hence both the appeals stand dismissed. The issues are answered in favour of assessee and against the Department. A copy of this judgment be placed in each file. (INDERJEET SINGH),J. (K.S. JHAVERI),J. // bm gandhi 32-33

More judgments on Section 12AA

All 4,540 judgments and leading authorities on Section 12AA →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →