C I T vs. M/S MANGLAM ARTS

PDF · subscribers
ITA/270/2011HC RajasthanRJHC02035426200921 August 20177 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the issue regarding duty drawback being income derived from business and eligible for deduction under Section 10BA is required to be answered in favour of the assessee against the department. This decision was based on the law declared by the Supreme Court in Meghalaya Steels Ltd. (supra) and two previous decisions of the same High Court (CIT vs. Suresh Kumar Bajoria and CIT vs. M/s Manglam Arts). The judgment does not explicitly detail the reasoning for the second issue concerning late PF/ESI deposits, but the assessee's reliance on the cited case suggests it was also decided in their favour. The Court dismissed the appeal. No issue was expressly left undecided.

What were the facts?

This appeal by the Commissioner of Income Tax (CIT), Jaipur-II, challenges a decision of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT). The ITAT had dismissed the Revenue's appeal, upholding the assessee's claim for deduction of duty drawback as income derived from business, eligible for deduction under Section 10BA of the Income Tax Act. The ITAT also deleted an addition made on account of late deposit of Provident Fund (PF) and Employees' State Insurance (ESI) contributions. The High Court admitted the appeal and framed substantial questions of law concerning the ITAT's justification in treating duty drawback as business income for Section 10BA purposes and in deleting the addition for late PF/ESI deposits, especially when the assessee's eligibility for Section 10BA deduction was questioned.

What were the issues?

1. Whether, in the facts and circumstances, the ITAT was justified in holding that receipts of duty drawback constitute income derived from business and are eligible for deduction under Section 10BA of the Income Tax Act? 2. Whether, in the facts and circumstances, the ITAT was justified in deleting the addition made on account of late deposit of PF and ESI contributions? Assessee's Contentions: - The assessee argued that duty drawback is income derived from business and eligible for deduction under Section 10BA. They relied on this Court's decision in CIT vs. Suresh Kumar Bajoria (Tax Appeal No. 294/2008) and CIT vs. M/s Manglam Arts (Tax Appeal No. 25/2009), which in turn relied on Supreme Court judgments. For the second issue, they relied on this Court's decision in CIT vs. M/s State Bank of Bikaner & Jaipur (D.B. Income Tax Appeal No.177/2011) regarding the disallowance under Section 43B or Section 36(1)(va) for late deposits of PF/ESI if paid before filing the return. Revenue's Contentions: - The Revenue contended that duty drawback is not income derived from the industrial undertaking for the purpose of Section 10BA, citing Liberty India vs. CIT (2009) 317 ITR 218 and Pandian Chemicals Ltd. v. CIT. They argued that the proximate source of duty drawback is the government scheme, not the industrial undertaking itself. They also cited Meghalaya Steels Ltd. (2016) 6 SCC 747, which discussed DEPB and duty drawback as not being derived from the industrial undertaking. The Revenue also raised a question about the assessee fulfilling the conditions for Section 10BA deduction.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 10BA,Section 43B,Section 36(1)(va)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN BENCH AT JAIPUR D.B. Income Tax Appeal No. 270 / 2011 COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, JAIPUR-II ,JAIPUR ----Appellant Versus M/s MANGALAM ARTS, GOVIND NAGAR, AMBER PALACE ROAD, JAIPUR ----Respondent _____________________________________________________ For Appellant(s) : Mr. Prateek Kedawat for Mr. R.B. Mathur For Respondent(s) : Mr. Sanjay Jhanwar with Ms. Archana _____________________________________________________ HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE K.S. JHAVERI HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE INDERJEET SINGH Order 21/08/2017 1. By way of this appeal, the appellant has assailed the judgment and order of the Tribunal whereby the Tribunal has dismissed the appeal. 2. This Court while admitting the matter framed the following question of law:- “i) Whether in the facts and circumstances of law, the ITAT was justified in holding that the receipts of duty draw back as income derived from business being eligible for deduction u/s 10BA of the I.T. Act.? ii) Whether in the facts and circumstances of law, the ITAT was justified in deleting the addition made on account of late deposit of PF and ESI contribution.?

(2 of 7) 2.1 Further the application (23838/11) was allowed and the following substantial question of law was added. “Whether in the fact and circumstances of the case the ITAT was justified in law in directing to allow deduction u/s 10BA inspite of the fact that the assessee was not fulfilling the conditions laid down in the act for claiming said deduction.” 3. Counsel for the appellant has strongly relied upon the decision of Liberty India vs. CIT, (2009) 317 ITR 218, wherein it has been held as under:- “10. In reply, Shri Gourab Banerji, learned Additional Solicitor General, submitted that, for application of the words "derived from" there must be a direct nexus between the profit and the industrial undertaking. According to the learned senior counsel, merely because under the Scheme to encourage exports a certain amount was repaid as "duty drawback", it cannot be regarded as profit "derived from" the industrial undertaking. It may constitute profit from business under Section 28, but it cannot be construed as profits "derived from" the industrial undertaking, for its immediate and proximate source was not the industrial undertaking but the scheme for "duty drawback". According to the learned Counsel, this position was placed beyond doubt by a judgment of this Court in Sterling Food (supra). Therefore, according to the learned Counsel, the source of duty drawback was not the industrial undertaking but the duty drawback scheme of the Central Government whereunder the duty drawback entitlement became available. According to the learned Counsel, duty drawback, therefore, would stand on the same footing as import entitlements and could not be said to be derived from industrial undertaking. Reliance was also placed on the judgment of this Court in Pandian Chemicals Ltd. v. CIT reported in MANU/SC/0487/2003 : 262 ITR 278. According to the learned Counsel, duty drawback was a matter of policy, hence, the proximate and immediate source of duty drawback cannot be industrial undertaking. On interpretation of Section 80IB, learned senior counsel submitted that what was relevant for Section 80IB(1) was profits derived from an eligible business. According to the learned Counsel, various eligible

(3 of 7) businesses are enumerated in Sub-sections (3) to (11) of Section 80IB. A perusal of Sub-sections (3), (4) and (5) would also show that eligible business under those provisions means certain specific undertakings. In contrast, Sub-sections (6) and (7) cover the business of a ship, hotel etc. Thus, for all practical purposes, according to the learned Counsel, the section has used the words "eligible business" and "industrial undertaking" interchangeably and, therefore, there is no material difference between Section 80I and Section 80IB as in both cases profits have to be derived from an industrial undertaking. 18. Analysing the concept of remission of duty drawback and DEPB, we are satisfied that the remission of duty is on account of the statutory/policy provisions in the Customs Act/Scheme(s) framed by the Government of India. In the circumstances, we hold that profits derived by way of such incentives do not fall within the expression "profits derived from industrial undertaking" in Section 80IB. 22. The cost of purchase includes duties and taxes (other than those subsequently recoverable by the enterprise from taxing authorities), freight inwards and other expenditure directly attributable to the acquisition. Hence trade discounts, rebate, duty drawback, and such similar items are deducted in determining the costs of purchase. Therefore, duty drawback, rebate etc. should not be treated as adjustment (credited) to cost of purchase or manufacture of goods. They should be treated as separate items of revenue or income and accounted for accordingly (see: page 44 of Indian Accounting Standards & GAAP by Dolphy D'souza). Therefore, for the purposes of AS-2, Cenvat credits should not be included in the cost of purchase of inventories. Even Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) has issued Guidance Note on Accounting Treatment for Cenvat/Modvat under which the inputs consumed and the inventory of inputs should be valued on the basis of purchase cost net of specified duty on inputs (i.e. duty recoverable from the Department at later stage) arising on account of rebates, duty drawback, DEPB benefit etc. Profit generation could be on account of cost cutting, cost rationalization, business restructuring, tax planning on sundry balances being written back, liquidation of current assets etc. Therefore, we are of the view that duty drawback, DEPB

(4 of 7) benefits, rebates etc. cannot be credited against the cost of manufacture of goods debited in the Profit & Loss account for purposes of Sections 80IA/80IB as such remissions (credits) would constitute independent source of income beyond the first degree nexus between profits and the industrial undertaking.” 4. It has been clearly held that income which is not derived from the business is required to be assessed. 5. However, counsel for the respondent has relied upon the decision of this Court in Tax Appeal No. 294/2008 (CIT vs. Suresh Kumar Bajoria) decided on 18th May, 2017 wherein while considering the issue in para 7.1 & 7.2 this Court has observed as under:- “7.1 No doubt issue is now squarely covered by the decision of Delhi High Court whereby the Delhi High Court has considered the rebate of excise duty. In that view of the matter, in our considered opinion, the view taken by the Delhi High Court is to be accepted by this Court and we accept the same. 7.2 No doubt the counsel for the department has contended that the two views are taken by the Gujarat High Court while considering the duty draw back but this will not fall within the duty as held by the tribunal and in view of judgment of Supreme Court in Meghalaya Steel (supra). 6. He has also relied upon the other decision of this Court in Tax Appeal No. 25/2009 (CIT vs. M/s Manglam Arts) decided on 14th February, 2017 wherein it has been held as under:- “He has contended that the word ‘production’ is to be construed as a wider meaning than ‘manufacture’ and in view of the observations made by the Supreme Court, the view taken by the Tribunal is just and proper. Mr. Mathur has also contended that regarding second issue with regard to ESI and PF, however, the same is covered by the decision of this Court

(5 of 7) in the case of Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. M/s State Bank of Bikaner & Jaipur- D.B. Income Tax Appeal No.177/2011 decided on 06.01.2014 wherein it has been held as under: “Thus, we are of the view that where the PF and/or EPF, CPF, GPF etc., if paid after the due date under respective Act but before filing of the return of income under Section 139(1), cannot be disallowed under Section 43B or under Section 36(1)(va) of the IT Act.” 7. He has also relied upon the decision of the Bombay High Court in case of Union of India vs. Cus. & C. Ex. Settlement Commission, Mumbai reported in 2010 (258) E.L.T. 476 (Bom.) wherein it has been held as under:- “14. The Settlement Commission while considering the issue before it, relied upon the term "drawback" as defined in Re-export of Imported Goods (Drawback of Customs Duties) Rules, 1995 and the Drawback Rules and also Section 74 of the Act dealing with the imported material used in the manufacture of goods which are exported. They also considered sweep of Section 127B of the Act and relied upon the Apex Court judgment in the case of Chemicals and Fibres of India Ltd. v. Union of India MANU/SC/0525/1991 : 1991 (54) ELT 3 (SC) to consider the scope and purport of the "drawback" in the Act. The Settlement Commission also considered the definition of the word "case" as defined in Section 127A(b) and after referring to the various judgments of the Tribunal came to he conclusion that the Settlement Commission had jurisdiction to deal with the application for settlement moved by the respondent Nos. 2 to 4. It is not necessary to again repeat the reasons given by the Settlement Commission in support of its order which are in consonance with the law laid down by the Supreme Court in the case of Liberty India v. Commissioner of Income Tax MANU/SC/1585/2009 : (2009) 317 ITR 218 (SC); wherein the Supreme Court has observed as under: 17. The next question is - what is duty drawback? Section 75 of the Customs Act, 1962 and Section 37 of the Central Excise Act, 1944 empower Government of India to provide

(6 of 7) for repayment of customs and excise duty paid by an assessee. The refund is of the average amount of duty paid on materials of any particular class or description of goods used in the manufacture of export goods of specified class. The Rules do not envisage a refund of an amount arithmetically equal to customs duty or central excise duty actually paid by an individual importer-cum-manufacturer. Sub- section (2) of Section 75 of the Customs Act requires the amount of drawback to be determined on a consideration of all the circumstances prevalent in a particular trade and also based on the facts situation relevant in respect of each of various classes of goods imported. Basically, the source of duty drawback receipt lies in Section 75 of the Customs Act and Section 37 of the Central Excise

Act. 18. Analysing the concept of remission of duty drawback and DEPB, we are satisfied that the remission of duty is on account of the statutory/policy provisions in the Customs Act/Scheme(s) framed by the Government of India. In the circumstances, we hold that profits derived by way of such incentives do not fall within the expression "profits derived from industrial undertaking" in Section 80IB. (Emphasis

supplied) 15. Reading of the aforesaid para and the analysis made by the Apex Court with respect to the concept of "duty drawback", one cannot dispute that it is nothing but a remission of duty on account of the statutory provisions in the Act and scheme framed by the Government

India.

Under

these circumstances, the duty drawback or claim for duty drawback is nothing but a claim for refund of duty may be as per the statutory scheme framed by the Government of India or in exercise of statutory powers under the provisions of the Act.” 8. He has also relied upon the decision in Commissioner of Income Tax vs. Meghalaya Steels Ltd. (2016) 6 SCC 747 wherein it has been held as under:-

(7 of 7) “20. Liberty India being the fourth judgment in this line also does not help Revenue. What this Court was concerned with was an export incentive, which is very far removed from reimbursement of an element of cost. A DEPB drawback scheme is not related to the business of an industrial undertaking for manufacturing or selling its products. DEPB entitlement arises only when the undertaking goes on to export the said product, that is after it manufactures or produces the same. Pithily put, if there is no export, there is no DEPB entitlement, and therefore its relation to manufacture of a product and/or sale within India is not proximate or direct but is one step removed. Also, the object behind DEPB entitlement, as has been held by this Court, is to neutralize the incidence of customs duty payment on the import content of the export product which is provided for by credit to customs duty against the export product. In such a scenario, it cannot be said that such duty exemption scheme is derived from profits and gains made by the industrial undertaking or business itself. 27. A Delhi High Court judgment was also cited before us being CIT v. Dharampal Premchand Ltd. MANU/DE/1689/2008 : 317 ITR 353 from which an SLP preferred in the Supreme Court was dismissed. This judgment also concerned itself with Section 80-IB of the Act, in which it was held that refund of excise duty should not be excluded in arriving at the profit derived from business for the purpose of claiming deduction Under Section 80-IB of the Act.” 9. Taking into consideration, the law declared by the Supreme Court in Meghalaya Steels (supra) and two decisions of this Court, the issue is required to be answered in favour of the assessee against the department. 10. The appeal stands dismissed. (INDERJEET SINGH),J. (K.S. JHAVERI),J. A.Sharma/81

More judgments on Section 10BA

All 39 judgments and leading authorities on Section 10BA →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →