MOHANAN NAIR SEKHAR PILLAI,TRIVAANDRUM vs. DCIT, CENTRAL CIRCLE, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM

PDF · subscribers
ITA 560/COCH/2024Status: DisposedITAT Cochin05 November 2026AY 2007-0810 pages
AI SummaryPartly Allowed

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal partly allowed the assessee's appeals. Regarding remuneration and interest from Manoj Medicals, the Tribunal found no infirmity in the CIT(A)'s decision to sustain the addition, considering the assessee's admission of partnership and receipt of interest/remuneration in a statement under Section 131, and the lack of new evidence from the assessee. For interest from Mr. Sunil Kumar, the Tribunal held that the addition was not sustainable. It noted that the affidavit from Mr. Sunil Kumar, stating no interest was demanded or paid, was not properly considered by lower authorities. The Tribunal found that the addition was made presumptively based on an agreement without corroborative evidence of actual receipt of interest, and thus directed deletion of the addition. The addition towards allowance as Councillor was dismissed as not pressed. The issue of unexplained loan to Dhanwanthari Modom was partly deleted by the CIT(A), and the remaining part was sustained. The Tribunal found no reason to interfere with the CIT(A)'s decision on commission on land deal from Dhanwanthari Modom and cash credit at SBT. For remuneration and interest from Ahmed Khan & Co., the Tribunal saw no reason to interfere with the CIT(A)'s decision, finding it identical to the Manoj Medicals issue. Regarding the transaction with M/s. P-1 Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd., the Tribunal directed the AO to allow expenses of Rs. 20 lakhs, which were allowed in the first round, and also directed the AO to allow a deduction of Rs. 1 crore paid to Shri Rajesh, based on his affidavit and the lack of revenue evidence to the contrary. The commission income from Smt. Sulekha and Smt. Santha was dismissed as not contested.

What were the facts?

These appeals by the assessee, Mohanan Nair Sekhar Pillai, are against the orders of the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) for Assessment Years 2006-07 to 2008-09. A search under Section 132 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, was conducted on October 11, 2007, leading to the issuance of a notice under Section 153A. The assessee did not respond, and the Assessing Officer (AO) passed an order under Section 153A read with Section 144. The assessee appealed to the CIT(A), who granted partial relief. The assessee then appealed to the Tribunal, which restored the appeals to the AO for de novo consideration, directing that income determined post-remand should not exceed that determined after the first appellate authority's relief, in the absence of a revenue appeal. The AO made additions across all assessment years based on various issues.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the addition on account of remuneration and interest from Manoj Medicals, sustained by the CIT(A), is valid, particularly concerning the assessee's denial of receiving such income and the reliance on account copies obtained under Section 131 of the Act. 2. Whether the addition of Rs. 2,60,000 as interest from Mr. Sunil Kumar is sustainable, given the assessee's contention of no interest received, supported by an affidavit from Mr. Sunil Kumar, and the revenue's failure to provide corroborative evidence. 3. Whether the addition towards allowance received as Councillor is contested by the assessee. 4. Whether the addition for unexplained loan to Dhanwanthari Modom is valid, considering the CIT(A)'s deletion of Rs. 20 lakhs based on a loan from State Co-operative Bank and the remaining Rs. 5 lakhs being provided by the assessee's brother-in-law. 5. Whether the addition for cash credit at SBT is justified. 6. Whether the commission on land deal from Dhanwanthari Modom is correctly assessed. 7. Whether the addition for remuneration and interest from Ahmed Khan & Co. is valid, similar to the Manoj Medicals issue. 8. Whether the transaction with M/s. P-1 Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. regarding brokerage commission is correctly assessed, specifically concerning the allowability of expenses. 9. Whether the commission income from Smt. Sulekha and Smt. Santha is correctly assessed. Assessee's Contentions: The assessee generally argued against additions, particularly for interest from Mr. Sunil Kumar, by providing an affidavit denying receipt. For P-1 Infrastructure, the assessee argued that expenses allowed in the first round should be considered in addition to those allowed in remand, and payments to Shri Rajesh should be allowed as deduction based on his affidavit. Revenue's Contentions: The revenue, through the Senior DR, supported the lower authorities' findings, relying on statements and documents obtained during the search and assessment proceedings.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 132,Section 153A,Section 144,Section 131

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, COCHIN BENCH, COCHIN

Before: SMT. BEENA PILLAI & MS. PADMAVATHY. S

For Respondent: Ms. Neethu S., Senior DR
Hearing: 03.11.2026Pronounced: 05.11.2026

आदेश /O R D E R

PER PADMAVATHY.S., AM :

These appeals by the assessee are against the order of the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals), Cochin – 3 [in short “the CIT(A)”] for the Asst.Years 2006-07 to 2008-09. 2. The assessee is an individual. A search u/s.132 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 [in short “the Act”] was carried out on 11.10.2007 and the assessee’s cases was included pursuant to which notice u/s.153A was issued. However, the assessee did not respond to the notices issued and therefore, the Assessing

:-2-: ITA. Nos.559-561/Coch/2024. Officer (AO) passed order u/s.153A r.w.s. 144 of the Act. Aggrieved by the order of the AO, the assessee filed further appeal before the CIT(A), who gave partial relief to the assessee. The assessee filed further appeal before the Tribunal against the order of the CIT(A) and the Tribunal restored the appeal of the assessee back to the AO for a de novo consideration with a specific direction that in the absence of department’s appeal before the Tribunal, the income determined by the AO subsequent to the remand by the Tribunal should not exceed the income already determined the order giving effect to the relief given by the first appellate authority. The AO during the remand proceedings called on the assessee to furnish various details and after perusing the various details submitted, made the additions across all the assessment years as per the table below:-

Sr. Issue AY 2006-07 AY 2007-08 AY 2008-99 No. 1. Addition on account of    remuneration and interest from Manoj Medicals    2. Interest from Mr.Sunil Kumar   3. Addition towards -- allowance as Councilor 4. Unexplained loan to  -- -- Dhanwanthari Modom 5. Cash credit at SBT  -- -- 6. Commission on land --  -- deal from Dhanwanthari 7. Remuneration and -- --  interest from Ahmed Khan & co. 8. Transaction with M/s.P- -- --  1 Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. 9. Commission income -- --  from smt.Sulekha and smt.Santha

:-3-: ITA. Nos.559-561/Coch/2024. ADDITION ON ACCOUNT OF REMUNERATION AND INTEREST FROM MANOJ MEDICALS 3. The AO during the first round of assessment proceedings, made addition towards interest and remuneration received from Manoj Medicals, in which the assessee is the partner. The AO during the remand proceedings, retained the said addition against which the assessee raised contentions before the CIT(A). The CIT(A) held that in the statement recorded u/s.131 of the Act, the assessee had admitted that he is the partner in Manoj Medicals and that from the account copies obtained from Manoj Medicals u/s.131, it was noticed that the assessee has received interest and remuneration. The CIT(A) further held that since the assessee did not contend the addition made in the first round of assessment proceedings before the CIT(A) and considering that the evidence found during the search that the assessee has received the interest and remuneration from Manoj Medicals, the impugned additions were sustained by the CIT(A). 4. We have heard the parties and perused the material on record. From the perusal of the order of the lower authorities we noticed that the addition towards interest and remuneration is made based on the statement of accounts obtained from Manoj Medicals u/s.131 of the Act, which is denied by the assessee. It is also relevant to note that the assessee did not contend the addition made by the AO during the first round of assessment proceedings before the first appellate authority. Further, during the course of hearing before us, the assessee did not bring any new material evidences to controvert the findings of the CIT(A). Further, the assessee also did not bring on record any evidence in support of the claim that remuneration as recorded in the books of account of Manoj Medicals was not actually received by him. Considering the overall facts and circumstances, we are of the considered view that there is no infirmity in the decision of the CIT(A) in sustaining the addition made towards interest and remuneration from Manoj Medicals.

:-4-: ITA. Nos.559-561/Coch/2024. INTEREST FROM MR.SUINIL KUMAR 5. From the seized documents, the AO noticed that the assessee has advanced loan of Rs.10 lakhs to Mr.Sunil Kumar, a tea shop owner, on 13.07.2005. As per the agreement, Mr.Sunil Kumar was supposed to pay Rs.1,000 each day including holidays. The AO relying on the agreement and the blank cheque received from Mr.Sunil Kumar, came to the conclusion that the assessee ought to have received the amount as stated in the agreement and accordingly made the addition from 14.07.2005 to 31.03.2006 amounting to Rs.2,60,000. On further appeal, the assessee contended before the CIT(A) that no interest has been received from Mr.Sunil Kumar and to substantiate the claim the assessee filed confirmation from the said party. However, the CIT(A) upheld the addition on the ground that the assessee during the course of search assessment has stated that Mr.Sunil Kumar has repaid the amount “as per the agreement”. The CIT(A), therefore, held that as per the agreement, Mr.Sunil Kumar should mandatorily pay the interest to the assessee, and therefore, the addition made by the AO was sustained. 6. We have heard the parties and perused the material on record. The ld.AR during the course of hearing drew our attention to the affidavit filed by Mr.Sunil Kumar, wherein it is stated that though it is mentioned in the agreement that Rs.1,000 per day would be collected, the assessee neither demanded the interest nor the amount. From the perusal of the orders of the lower authorities it is noticed that the said affidavit filed by Mr.Sunil Kumar has not been properly considered and no further enquiry is conducted. In our considered view the assessee has by filing the affidavit has discharged the burden of proving the contention that no interest was paid against the advance given to Mr.Sunil Kumar. The Revenue did not bring any material in support of the contention that the assessee has indeed received the amount of Rs.1,000 per day nor made any enquiries with Mr.Sunil Kumar in this regard. We also noticed that the only reason for the CIT(A) to sustain the addition is that Mr.Sunil Kumar has stated in the statement that he has repaid the amount as per the agreement. In our

:-5-: ITA. Nos.559-561/Coch/2024. considered view, making the addition merely based on such a statement without bring any other corroborative evidence to prove that the assessee has indeed received the interest, cannot be sustained. Further, the Revenue has also not considered the confirmation filed by Mr.Sunil Kumar categorically denying that the assessee has received the interest towards advance given to him. In view of this discussion, we hold that the addition made on the presumption that the assessee ought to have received the amount as stated in the agreement without considering the confirmation from the parties to the contrary and without bringing anything on record in support of the contention that the assessee has received the payment, the addition made by the AO cannot be sustained. ADDITION TOWARDS ALLOWANCE RECIVED AS COUNSELLOR 7. The ld.AR during the course of hearing, submitted that the assessee is not contesting the said ground. Accordingly, the same is dismissed as not pressed. UNEXPLAINED LOAN TO DHANWANTHRI MODOM 8. During the course of assessment proceedings, the AO called on the assessee to explain the source for the deposit of Rs.25 lakhs into the bank account. The assessee submitted that the said amount has retained by Shri C.P.Narayanan Nair, to whom the amount was paid as advance for purchase of property. The AO however did not accept the submission from the assessee and treated the said amount as unexplained. On further appeal, the CIT(A) deleted the addition to the tune of Rs.20 lakhs stating that the assessee has obtained loan from State Co-operative Bank to the tune of Rs.20 lakhs and held that the source for the money lent is explained to the tune of Rs.20 lakhs. However, the CIT(A) did not accept the submissions of the assessee for the balance amount of Rs.5 lakhs, which was provided by the assessee’s brother- in-law, Shri.Radhakrishnan, as a temporary measure. Therefore, the CIT(A) sustained the addition to the tune of Rs.5 lakhs.

:-6-: ITA. Nos.559-561/Coch/2024. 9. We have heard the parties and perused the material on record. During the course of hearing the ld.AR drew our attention to confirmation given by Shri.Radhakrishnan, wherein he has clearly stated that he has given the money to the assessee sourced from the amount received from his wife, who had received compensation for acquisition of land for National Highway widening. We, in this regard, notice that the CIT(A) has not considered the said confirmation from Shri.Radhakrishnan on the ground that it is an afterthought, without recording any adverse finding to the documents submitted. Considering the overall facts and circumstances, we are of the view that the assessee has discharged the onus of proving the identity, creditworthiness and genuineness of the transaction, and therefore, we hold that the CIT(A) has not correct in sustaining the addition merely stating that the evidence produced are afterthought. Accordingly, we direct the AO to delete the addition made in this regard. CASH CREDIT AT SBT 10. The ld AR during the course of hearing did not contest the issue. Hence grounds raised in this regard are dismissed as not pressed. COMMISSION ON LAND DEALING WITH DHANWANTHARI 11. The assessee during the assessment year 2007-08 has admitted an income of Rs.65,85,000 as commission received from Dhanwanthri Ayur Centre. The AO further noticed that the assessee has received commission towards a property transaction and based on the value of the transaction is eligible to get 50% of the total commission, i.e., Rs.1,38,36,500. The AO also noticed that there is shortfall in the amount declared by the assessee as commission income and proceeded to make an addition of Rs.8,80,750 being 50% of the difference amount. 12. We heard the parties and perused the material on record. The ld.AR in this regard submitted that 50% of Rs.1,38,36,500 works out to Rs.69,18,250. The ld.AR further submitted that the assessee during the Asst.Year 2006-07

:-7-: ITA. Nos.559-561/Coch/2024. has already offered a sum of Rs.6 lakhs towards commission and brokerage from the land deal from Dhanwanthri. The ld.AR also argued that the AO completely failed to take cognizance the income already offered in AY 2006-07 and has considered only the income declared by the assessee to make an addition towards the shortfall. We noticed that the assessee has declared a sum of Rs.6 lakhs towards commission income in AY 2006-07 (refer assessment order for AY 2007-08). The assessee during the AY 2007-08 has declared a sum of Rs.65,85,000 as commission income and the cumulative amount works out to Rs.71,85,000. We further notice the said sum is more when compared with assessee’s share of 50% in the total commission earned in the entire transaction, it is Rs.69,18,250. Therefore, we see merit in the contention of the ld.AR that the cumulative amount already offered by the assessee is higher than the commission income arising out of the transaction, and therefore, the AO is not correct in making further addition of Rs.8,80,750. We also noticed that the AO has made the addition merely based on the workings without bringing in any material on record to show that the assessee has received any additional commission other than what is agreed as per the impugned transaction. In view of this discussion, we hold that the AO is not correct in making the addition and accordingly direct the AO to delete the same. REMUNERATION AND INTEREST FROM AHMED KHAN & CO. 13. The facts pertaining to this issue is identical to the issue of interest and remuneration from Manoj Medicals, which was already considered and decided in the earlier part of this order. Considering that the addition is made by the Revenue based on the financial statement of the parties u/s.131(1) of the Act, we see no reason to interfere with the decision. Further, during the course of hearing, the assessee did not bring any new material on record and accordingly we see no infirmity in the order of the CIT(A) in sustaining the addition.

:-8-: ITA. Nos.559-561/Coch/2024. TRANSACTION WITH P-1 INFRASTRUCTURE PVT.LTD. 14. During the Asst.Year 2008-09, the assessee has declared a total receipt of Rs.52,20,20,000 as brokerage commission for modernisation of sale of land. The AO during the first round of assessment proceedings, allowed deduction to the tune of Rs.20,20,000 and brought to tax the remaining amount of Rs.5 crores. In the remanded proceedings the AO allowed the sum of Rs.26,58,000 towards expenses and brought to tax the difference amount of Rs.4,93,62,000. On further appeal, the CIT(A) allowed the expenditure of Rs.1 crore being payment made to Shri Gopalakrishnan Nair. The assessee is in appeal before the Tribunal against the disallowance of balance amount of expenditure. 15. We heard the parties and perused material on record. The primary contention of the ld.AR towards expenses is that the AO in the first round of appeal had made a sum of Rs.20,20,000 which has not been considered in the remanded assessment proceedings, wherein the AO has allowed a different set of expenses. The ld.AR argued that the AO during the remand proceedings ought to have allowed the amount in addition to the earlier amount allowed to the tune of Rs.20,20,000. From the perusal of records, we noticed that the amount of Rs.20,20,000 was allowed by the AO towards telephone and other expenses and includes Rs.,20,000 made to the Surveyor. We further noticed that during the remand proceedings, the AO has allowed the claim of Rs.26,58,000 towards payment to lorry, JCB hire, rent and expenses. It is relevant to mention that the said amount also includes the surveyor fee of Rs.20,000. Therefore, in our considered view, except for the surveyor fee of Rs.20,000/- the balance amount allowed by the AO in the first round and during remand proceedings are different and we see merit in the submission of the assessee that the AO ought to have allowed the amount allowed in the first round of assessment proceedings except for the payment of Rs.20,000 to Surveyor, which is once again considering during the remand proceedings. Accordingly, we direct the AO to allow the expenses to the tune of Rs.20 lakhs, which was allowed by the AO during the first round of assessment proceedings.

:-9-: ITA. Nos.559-561/Coch/2024. 16. With regard to the payment made to Shri Rajesh, the contention of the AO is that the payment made by the assessee has been subsequently utilised by Shri Rajesh for purchase of land on behalf of the assessee, and therefore, it is not an expense, but an advance given by the assessee. During the course of hearing, the ld.AR drew out attention to the affidavit filed by Shri.Rajesh (page Nos.26 and 27 of the paper book), wherein it is stated that he has not purchased any property in the name of the assessee. Accordingly, it was argued that the amount given by the assessee to Shri.Rajesh cannot be considered as advance towards purchase of property and the same should be allowed as a deduction. From the perusal of the affidavit, we noticed that Shri.Rajesh has stated that he had purchased 20 small plots of land in his own name and that the said plots are still in his name. During the course of hearing before us, the Revenue did not bring any new material on record to substantiate the contention that the amount given to Shri.Rajesh is towards an advance for purchase of property, and therefore, we see merit in the submissions of the Ld AR with regard to the allowability of the claim. We further notice that the payments made by the assessee are supported by the bank statements and the AO has not questioned the genuineness of the payment. The AO has made the disallowance based on subsequent utilization of the money by Shri.Rajesh which in our view is not tenable. During the course of hearing, the revenue did not bring any material on record to show that the payments made is towards advance for purchase of assets. We, therefore, direct the AO to allow the deduction to the extent of Rs.1 crore paid to Shri.Rajesh. COMMISSION INCOME FROM SMT.SULEKHA AND SMT.SANTHA 17. The AO made an addition of Rs.7,50,000 as commission income from Smt.Sulekha and Smt.Santha. The CIT(A) deleted the addition to the extent of Rs.5 lakhs and sustained the balance amount. During the course of hearing, the ld.AR submitted that the impugned issue is not contested, and therefore, the same is dismissed as not contested.

:-10-: ITA. Nos.559-561/Coch/2024. 18. In the result, the appeals of the assessee for Asst.Years 2006-07 to 2008- 09 are partly allowed. Order pronounced in the open court on 05th November, 2026 at Cochin.

Sd/- Sd/- (बीना धपल्लई) (पद्मावती. एस) (BEENA PILLAI) (PADMAVATHY.S) न्याधयकसदस्य/Judicial Member लेखासदस्य/Accountant Member

कोचीन /Cochin, धदनांक/Dated, the 05th November, 2026. Devadas आदेशकीप्रधतधलधपअग्रेधर्त/Copy to: Digitally signed P G by P G RAJANI 1. अपीलार्थी/Appellant Date: RAJANI 2026.11.13 2. प्रत्यर्थी/Respondent 15:23:25 +05'30' 3.आयकरआयुक्त/CIT 4. धवभागीयप्रधतधनधि/DR 5. गार्ाफाईल/GF

More judgments on Section 132

All 16,113 judgments and leading authorities on Section 132 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →