PANKAJ GOYAL,NEW DELHI vs. PR.CIT, FARIDABAD
In favour of the assessee: the assessee's appeal was allowed. From the AI summary of this appeal.
What did the Tribunal hold?
The Tribunal held that the PCIT erred in revising the assessment order under Section 263. The primary issue was the taxability of interest received on enhanced compensation. The Tribunal noted that the issue of whether such interest is taxable as capital gains or income from other sources is debatable. Citing the Gujarat High Court's view, the Tribunal opined that interest received under Section 28 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, should be taxed as capital gains in accordance with Section 45(5) of the Income Tax Act. Even if the interest were chargeable as income from other sources, the Tribunal found that the issue was highly debatable. Relying on Supreme Court decisions in Malabar Industrial Co. vs. CIT and CIT (Central), Ludhiana vs. Max India Ltd., the Tribunal held that revision under Section 263 is not permissible for debatable issues. The Tribunal also referred to a coordinate bench's decision in Manish Tuteja vs. PCIT, Rohtak, which dealt with a similar issue and quashed the revision order. Consequently, the Tribunal quashed the revision order passed by the PCIT under Section 263 and allowed the assessee's appeal.
What were the facts?
The assessee, Pankaj Goyal, filed an appeal against an order passed by the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax (PCIT), Faridabad, under Section 263 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, for Assessment Year 2017-18. The PCIT had held that the assessment order passed by the Assessing Officer (AO) under Section 143(3) was erroneous and prejudicial to the interest of revenue. The assessee had initially filed a return declaring income of Rs. 64,31,690, which included interest on enhanced compensation of Rs. 1,22,02,247 claimed as deductible under Section 37. Subsequently, the assessee revised the return to Rs. 4,36,600, omitting this interest income and deduction. The PCIT noted discrepancies in the sale consideration reported versus TDS returns and the AO's limited inquiry into the claim of exemption under Section 10(37).
What were the issues?
1. Whether the PCIT erred in holding that the assessment order passed by the AO under Section 143(3) is erroneous and prejudicial to the interest of revenue, warranting revision under Section 263 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. 2. Whether the PCIT erred in holding that the AO failed to make proper inquiries into the assessee's claim of exemption under Section 10(37) of the Act regarding interest on enhanced compensation amounting to Rs. 1,22,02,747, despite the assessee providing relevant documents. Assessee's Contentions: The assessee argued that the AO had considered all relevant documents and details during the assessment proceedings. The view taken by the AO was a plausible one, and therefore, the assessment order could not be termed erroneous. The assessee also contended that the interest received on enhanced compensation is an accretion to the value of land and partakes the character of compensation, thus being taxable as capital gains and exempted under Section 10(37). The assessee relied on the Supreme Court decision in CIT, Faridabad vs. Ghanshyam (HUF) [2009] 182 Taxman 368 (S.C.). Revenue's Contentions: The revenue, through the PCIT, contended that the interest on enhanced compensation was not exempt from taxation and was liable to be taxed under Sections 2(28A) read with Sections 56(2)(vii), 57(iv), and 145B of the Act. The PCIT also highlighted a lack of inquiry by the AO into the nature of the land, its use, the acquisition process, and the conditions of Section 10(37). The PCIT also pointed out that the revised return was filed belatedly, and the AO did not examine this legal infirmity.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 2(28A),Section 56(2)(vii),Section 57(iv),Section 145B,Section 10(37),Section 37,Section 143(3),Section 263,Section 139(4),Section 139(5),Section 142(1),Section 45(5)
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, DELHI BENCH “A’’ : NEW DELHI
Before: SHRI MAHAVIR SINGH, HON’BLE & SHRI M. BALAGANESH, HON’BLE
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL (DELHI BENCH “A’’ : NEW DELHI)
BEFORE SHRI MAHAVIR SINGH, HON’BLE VICE PRESIDENT AND SHRI M. BALAGANESH, HON’BLE ACCOUNTANT MEMBER
ITA No. 1288/Del/2022 Asstt. Year : 2017-18
PANKAJ GOYAL, VS. PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF House No. 17, H-Block, INCOME TAX, FARIDABAD 2nd floor, South City-2, Sohna Road, Gurugram-122018 (PAN: AHIPG0833G) (Appellant) (Respondent)
Appellant by : Shri Dr. Rakesh Gupta, Sr. Adv. & Shri Deepesh Garg, Adv. Respondent by : Shri Zafarul Haque Tanweer, CIT(DR)
Date of Hearing 01.09.2026 Date of Pronouncement 06.11.2026
ORDER PER MAHAVIR SINGH, VICE PRESIDENT : This appeal has been filed by the Assessee is emanating from the order of the Ld. PCIT, Faridabad order dated 30.03.2022 in Din & Order No. ITBA/REV/F/REV5/2021-22/1042065479(1) passed u/s. 263 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred the Act) relevant for the assessment year 2017- 18. The following are the grounds of appeal raised by the assessee:- 1. That the Ld. PCIT has erred on facts and in law in passing the order under section 263 holding that the assessment made by the Assessing Officer u/s. 143(3) of the Act is erroneous as well as prejudicial to the interest of the revenue. 2. That on the facts and circumstances of the case, the Ld. PCIT has erred in holding that the Assessing Officer has failed to make enquiries into the claim of exemption under section 1
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
10(37) of the Act made by the assessee in respect of interest on enhanced compensation amounting to Rs. 1,22,02,747/- without appreciation that all the relevant documents / details were duly examined in the course of assessment proceedings.
That the Ld. Pr. CIT has erred on facts and in law in holding as above without appreciating that the view taken by the Assessing Officer after considering the details submitted by the assessee constitutes a plausible view and, therefore, the order passed u/s 143(3) cannot be termed as erroneous in so far as prejudicial to the interests of revenue warranting revision u/s. 263 of the Act.
The brief facts of the case are that the assessee filed his original return of income on 13.10.2017 u/s. 139(4) of the Act for the A.Y. 2017-18 at an income of Rs. 64,31,690/-. Subsequently, Assessee revised his return of income u/s. 139(5) of the Act on 9.3.2019 showing of income of Rs. 4,36.600/-. The PCIT noticed from the computation of income that the assessee in the original return of income has declared interest on enhanced compensation of land amounting to Rs. 1,22,02,247/- and claimed deduction on the same @50% u/s. 37 of the Act, whereas in the revised return of income the assessee has not disclosed this interest received on enhanced compensation amounting to Rs. 1,22,02,247/- and no claim of deduction u/s. 10(37) of the Act was made.
The PCIT further noted that the assessee was having agricultural land vide Khasra No. 442 located in Village Jasola, which was acquired by the State Government having LAC No. 21/2014, the land being used for agricultural purposes, in support of which assessee filed copies of Khasra/Girdawari. These documents show that the cultivation was done on this land i.e. cultivation of crops over a piece of land as per present Khasra/Girdawari specific recitals in the Khasra Girdawari proved that the shadow of a doubt that agriculture operations were infact being carried out on this land. Even the revenue records certify that the land was sold by the assessee during the year under consideration 2
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
is an agricultural land. The PCIT records that since the assessee did not disclose the income of interest received on enhanced compensation, the assessee’s case was selected for scrutiny assessment u/s. 143(2) of the Act and reasons in the scrutiny selection under CASS are cited by the PCIT that “Return has been revised and large refund has been claimed as the assessee has shown lesser taxable income in revised return as compared to the taxable income shown in the original return”.
Further, the PCIT records that sale consideration of property reported by the assessee in Schedule CG of ITR of ITR is less than the compensation on acquisition of immovable property reported by transferee of property in TDS return (for TDS u/s. 194L and 194LA). PCIT further noted that Assessing Officer has issued notice u/s. 142(1) dated 27.11.2019 and the relevant questionnaire issued in the scrutiny notice reads as under:-
S.No. Issues 1. Reduction of Income in Revised Return & Claim of Refund. 2. Capital Gains / income on Sale of Property
The PCIT also noticed that the Assessing Officer asked only two questions i.e. question no. 23 & 24 in the last of the questionnaire issued u/s. 142(1) of the Act and the relevant questionnaire are reproduced in the order of the PCIT at Para 6 Page No. 8-9 which read as under:-
Please give justification & explanation regarding the Taxable income shown in revised return is less than of immovable property as shown in TDS return filed by acquirer is more than sale consideration reported in the Return of Income.
Please give justification & explanation regarding the payment of compensation on acquisition of immovable property as shown in TDS return filed by acquirer is more than sale consideration reported in the Return of income. 3
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
The above questionnaire was answered by the Assessee vide reply dated 10.12.2019 and he has filed complete note of justification regarding the income shown in the revised income vide Annexure-3 and accordingly, framed assessment u/s. 143(3) of the Act vide order dated 11.12.2019 and accepted the revised income as returned by the assessee at Rs. 4,36,600/-. The PCIT after going into the facts issued show cause notice for revising the assessment order u/s. 263 of the Act dated 16.3.2022, which is reproduced in the order of the PCIT at page no. 15-16. According to this show cause notice, the assessment order of the AO is erroneous and prejudicial to the interest of revenue and for this he recorded as under:-
“40. After due consideration it is observed that the decisions of Hon’ble jurisdictional High Court of Punjab & Haryana are applicable along with Hon’ble Supreme Court in your case and therefore, interest of Rs. 1,22,02,747/- is not exempt from taxation. It is held that interest of Rs. 1,22,02,247/- is liable to be taxed as per provisions of section 2(28) r.w.s. 56(2)(vii), 57(iv) and 145B of the Income Tax Act, 1961 in the year of receipt. Further, the Assessing Officer has not verified the nature of land and its use preceding two years of acquisition and hence it is held that there was lack of enquiry on this issue. Further, the Assessing Officer has not inquired into the nature of land and acquisition process and also the various conditions mentioned in section 10(37) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The assessee has filed the belated return of income for A.Y. 2017-18 on 13.10.2017 while the due date was 5.8.2017, declaring an income of Rs. 64,31,690/-. Further a revised return of income was filed on 9.3.2019 declaring an income of Rs.4,36,600/-. Further, the A.O. did not examine this legal infirmity and computed the income as per the revised return without taking into consideration that the revised return is the invalid return. The assessment order of 4
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
the A.O. is found to be erroneous and prejudicial to the interest of revenue on the above three issues.”
The assessee replied to this show cause notice vide email dated 25.03.2022. The only disputed point remains whether the interest received on enhanced compensation u/s. 28 of the Land and Acquisition Act, 1894 (hereinafter referred as ‘LA Act’) is taxable under the Act as income from other sources, in view of the amended provisions of section 2(28) r.w.s. 56(2), 57(iv) and 145B of the Act or not. Whether this issue is debatable or not in the given facts and circumstances of the case.
The assessee in its reply submitted that interest u/s. 28 of the LA Act awarded by Court is an accretion to the value of the land acquired and hence, part of compensation. The interest awarded on enhanced compensation is accretion to value of land and partakes character of compensation is, taxable as capital gain exempted u/s. 10(37) of the Act. It was contended that the interest u/s. 28 of the LA Act is directed to be paid on enhanced compensation if the sum which, in the opinion of the Court, the Collector on being awarded as compensation is an excess sum which the Collector did not award as compensation, the aware of the Court may direct that the Collector shall pay interest on such excess payment from the date on which he took position of the land to the date of such payment of excess amount, as per directions of the Court.
Ld. Counsel for the assessee further relied upon the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of CIT, Faridabad vs. Ghanshyam (HUF) [2009] 182 Taxman 368 (S.C.). Ld. Counsel for the assessee also relied upon the decision of the Hon’ble Gujarat in the case of Movaliya Bhikubhai Balabhai vs. ITO-TDS-1, Surat [2016] 70 Taxmann.com 45 (Gujarat). But the PCIT after considering the facts and circumstances of the case, judgements and legal 5
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18) provisions, revised the assessment holding the assessment order as erroneous and prejudicial to the interest of revenue vide para no. 77 to 79 as under:-
Therefore, in the facts and circumstances, discussion, legal provisions and following judgements of jurisdictional High Court of Punjab and Haryana and Hon’ble Supreme Court, it is held as follows:- a) The interest received on enhanced compensation is not exempt under any specific provisions of Income Tax Act, 1961 and is taxable. b) The interest received on enhanced compensation is not exempt and has been stated to be taxable under the provisions of Income Tax Act,1961 by the jurisdictional High Court of Punjab & Haryana or Supreme Court. c) The provisions of section 56(2)(viii); 57(iv) read with section 145A introduced from 01.04.2010 are applicable in the case of the assesses being statutory provisions brought in as law after judgements of the; appellate authorities. d) The assessee without showing the receipt in the return or computation of income cannot claim any income as exempted from taxation without specifying any provisions of law. e) The Assessing Officer has to follow the jurisdictional High Court judgements on any legal issue pronounced after considering the judgements of Hon’ble Supreme Court and statutory provisions of law. He cannot deviate and held the law otherwise. f) The interest received on enhanced compensation is taxable as income under the head “Income from Other Sources” as per section 2(28A); 56(2)(viii); 57(iv) r.w.s. 145A of the Income Tax Act, 1961. g) If an assessment order is passed without inquiry and not following the valid judgements of jurisdictional High Court of Punjab & Haryana, Supreme Court or ignoring the statutory provisions then Principal Commissioner of Income Tax is duty bound to held the said order as erroneous and prejudicial to the interest of revenue as per law. However, Explanation 2 to section 263 introduced by Finance Act, 2015 w.e.f. 01st June, 2015 6
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
statutorily gives the power to the PCIT/CIT to held such an order as erroneous and prejudicial to the interest of revenue. 78. The assessee was required to file the return of income as per section 4 and 5 of Income Tax Act, 1961 showing correct income and paying taxes accordingly under section 139 in which the assessee has failed. The assess has failed in his legal duty to pay taxes on the income. As per Latin legal maxim Nullus Commodum Capere Potest De Injuria Sua Propria/ Juri Ex Injuria Non Oritur means no man can take advantage of his own wrong/No person can claim any right arising out of his own wrongdoing. The maxim nullus commodum capere potest de injuria sua propria has a clear mandate of law that, a person who by manipulation of a process takes legal advantage should not be permitted to take advantage of his wrong or manipulations as held in (i) Eureka Forbes Limited Vs Allahabad Bank MANU/SC/0322/2010: (2010) 6 SCC 193; (ii) Advanta India Limited Vs B.N. Shivanna, M ANU/SC/0190/ 2018: (2018) 14 SCC 666. A person who has not filed his Income Tax return truly and correctly cannot take advantage of his own wrong and plead bar of any law or proceedings before Assessing Officer initiated as per law, where his all pleas will be heard as per law with opportunity to plead his case which was omitted in the earlier proceedings. As per this maxim the person(s) violating the law cannot be permitted to urge that their wrong action cannot be subjected to inquiry, trial, or investigation. Nor can a person claim any right arising out of his own wrongdoing i.e., Juri Ex Injuria Non-Oritur as held in (i) Devendra Kumar Vs. State of Uttaranchal, MANU/SC/0772/2013: (2013) 9 SCC 363; (ii) Akhilesh Shrivastava Vs State of Madhya Pradesh & Ors., MANU/MP/0396/2020. The assessee cannot take the benefit of his failure to pay the taxes on one or the other pretext including some lacunae here and there in the procedure being followed by the department to collect the due amount of taxes as per law. The non-payment of taxes on availing legal and procedural lacunae is against the jurisprudence of civil liabilities relating to payment of due taxes to the Government.
After due consideration it is observed that the decisions of Hon’ble jurisdictional High Court of Punjab & Haryana are applicable along with Hon’ble Supreme Court in your case and therefore, interest of Rs.1,22,02,747/- is not exempt from taxation. It is held that interest of Rs.1,22,02,747/- is liable to be taxed as per 7
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
provisions of section 2(28A) r.w.s. 56(2)(viii), 57(iv) and 145A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 in the year of receipt./The provisions of 2(28A) r.w.s. 56(2)(viii), 57(iv) r.w.s. T45A of the Income Tax-Act, 1961 are very loud and clear to held that interest, received on all compensations of land acquisitions are taxable under Income Tax Act, 1961 as income under the Head income from “Other Sources”. The interest received on enhanced compensation received on acquisition of agricultural land is not exempt u/s 10(37) of Income Tax Act, 1961.The assessment order of the Assessing Officer is found to be erroneous and prejudicial to the interest of revenue on the above issues.”
Ld. CIT(DR) relied upon the order of the Ld. PCIT.
We have heard the rival contentions and gone through relevant records and noted that the issue involved is whether interest u/s. 28 of the LA Act awarded by the Court is a revenue receipt chargeable to tax as income from other sources or is an integral part of enhanced compensation awarded under the LA Act and thus is a capital receipt exempted u/s. 10(37) of the Act being received on compulsory acquisition of agricultural land by the State Government. The fact is that where agricultural land is acquired for public purposes by the Government, the Land Acquisition Authority awards compensation to the landowners under the LA Act and where land owner filed Reference u/s. 18 of LA Act against such award or compensation granted by the Land Acquisition Officer, the Court may also award additional amount u/s. 23(1-A), solatium u/s. 23(2) and interest u/s. 28 of the LA Act to the assessee apart from the market value of the land on the date of acquisition forming part of enhanced compensation. Subsequent to appeal, the Hon’ble High Court and or Hon’ble Supreme Court, the Courts may confirm, enhance, or reduce the market price of the acquired land and consequently assessee is entitled to interest u/s. 34 of the LA Act only if there is delay in payment of compensation on or before taking possession of the land. Section 28 of the LA Act provides for interest which is discretionary and determined by the Courts. Section 28 of the LA Act applies 8
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
when the original compensation has been paid and deposited and when the Court awarded excess compensation in Reference or Appeal filed by the land owners. Section 28 of the LA Act empowers the Court to awards interest on the excess amount of excess amount of compensation awarded by it over the amount of compensation awarded by the Collector along with the additional amount u/s. 23(1A) and solatium u/s 23(2) of the LA Act, forming part of enhanced compensation. Interest paid on the excess amount under section 28 of the LA Act depends upon a claim by the person whose land is acquired, and quantum of interest is awarded by the Court. 12. Thus, interest under section 28 of the LA Act, is awarded by virtue of the discretionary power of the Court for accretion in the value of the lands, hence, it can be considered as part of enhanced compensation or consideration or not. This issue has been considered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of CIT v. Ghanshyam (HUF) [2009] 182 Taxman 368/315 ITR 1(SC) [PB-Pages 180- 195], wherein it was held that interest under Section 28 of the LA Act, unlike interest under Section 34 of the LA Act, is an accretion to the value, and, hence, it is a part of enhanced compensation or consideration which is not the case with interest under Section 34 of the LA Act. The additional amount under Section 23(1-A) and solatium under Section 23(2) of the LA Act also form part of enhanced compensation under Section 45(5)(b) of the 1961 Act. The position in this respect is explained in para 23, 24, 32, 33 & 35 of the judgment which read as under:
In addition to the market value of the land, as above provided, the \ Court shall in every case award a sum of 30 per cent on such market \ value, in consideration of the compulsory nature of acquisition. This is 'under section 23(2) of the 1894 Act. In short, section 23(2) talks about solatium. Award of solatium is mandatory. Similarly, payment of 9
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
additional amount under section 23(1 A) is mandatory. The award of interest under section 28 of the 1894 Act is discretionary. Section 28 applies when the amount originally awarded has been paid or deposited and when the Court awards excess amount. In such cases interest on that excess alone is payable. Section 28 empowers the Court to award interest on the excess amount of compensation awarded by it over the amount awarded by the Collector. The compensation awarded by the Court includes the additional compensation awarded under section 23(1A) and the solatiumunder section 23(2) of the said Act. This award of interest is not mandatory but is left to the discretion of the Court. Section 28 is applicable only in respect of the excess amount, which is determined by the Court after a reference under section 18 of the 1894 Act. Section 28 does not apply to cases of undue delay in making award for compensation [See: Ram Chand v. Union of India [1994] 1 SCC 44], In the case of Shree Vijay Cotton & Oil Mills Ltd. v. State of Gujarat [1991] 1 SCC 262, this Court has held that interest is different from compensation
To sum up, interest is different from compensation. However, Interest paid on the excess amount under section 28 of the 1894 Act depends upon a claim by the person whose land is acquired whereas interest under section 34 is for delay in making payment. This vital difference needs to be kept in mind in deciding this matter. Interest under section 28 is part of the amount of compensation whereas interest under section 34 is only for delay in making payment after the compensation amount is determined. Interest under section 28 is a part of enhanced value of the land which is not the case in the matter of payment of interest under section 34.
The issue to be decided before us - what is the meaning of the words 10
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
"enhanced compensation/consideration" in section 45(5)(b) of the 1961Act? Will it cover "interest"? These questions also bring in the concept / of the year of taxability.
It is to answer the above question that we have analysed the provisions of sections 23, 23(1A), 23(2), 28 and 34 of the 1894 Act. As \ discussed hereinabove, Section 23(1-A) provides for additional amount. It takes care of the increase in the value at the rate of 12% per annum. Similarly, under Section 23(2) of the 1894 Act there is a provision for solatium which also represents part of the enhanced compensation. Similarly, Section 28 empowers the court in its discretion to award interest on the excess amount of compensation over and above what is awarded by the Collector. It includes additional amount under Section 23(1-A) and solatium under Section 23(2) of the said Act. Section 28 of the 1894 Act applies only in respect of the excess amount determined by the court after reference under Section 18 of the 1894 Act. It depends upon the claim, unlike interest under section 34 which depends on undue delay in making the award. It is true that "interest" is not compensation. It is equally true that Section 45(5) of the 1961 Act refers to compensation. But as discussed hereinabove, we have to go by the provisions of the 1894 Act which awards "interest" both as an accretion in the value of the lands acquired and interest for undue delay. Interest under Section 28 unlike interest under Section 34 is an accretion to the value, hence it is a part of enhanced compensation or consideration which is not the case with interest under Section 34 of the 1894 Act. So also additional amount under Section 23(1-A) and solatium under Section 23(2) of the 1961 Act forms part of enhanced compensation under Section 45(5)(b) of the 1961 Act.” 11
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
It may also be apt to quote the following part of the decision of the Supreme Court in Ghanshyam (HUF)'s case (supra):
“35. ...... Section 45(5) read as a whole [including clause (c)] not only deals with reworking as urged on behalf of the assessee but also with the change in the full value of the consideration (computation) and since the enhanced compensation/ consideration (including interest under Section 28 of the 1894 Act) becomes payable/ paid under the 1894 Act at different stages, the receipt of such enhanced compensation/consideration is to be taxed in the year of receipt subject to adjustment, if any, under Section 155(16) of the 1961 Act, later on. Hence, the year in which enhanced compensation is received is the year of taxability. Consequently, even in cases where pending appeal, the court/tribunal/authority before which appeal is pending, permits the claimant to withdraw against security or otherwise the enhanced compensation (which is in dispute), the same is unable to be taxed under Section 45(5) of the 1961 Act. This is the scheme of Section 45(5) and Section 155(16) of the 1961 Act. We may clarify that even before the insertion of Section 45(5)(c) and Section 155(16) w.e.f. 1- 4-2004, the receipt of enhanced compensation under Section 45(5)(b) was taxable in the year of receipt which is only reinforced by Insertion of clause (c) \ because the right to receive payment under the 1894 Act is not in doubt. I It is important to note that compensation, including enhanced : compensation/consideration under the 1894 Act, is based on the full I value of property as on the date of notification under Section 4 of that Act. j When the court/tribunal directs payment of enhanced compensation under Section 23(1-A), or Section 23(2) or under Section 28 of the 1894 Act it is on the basis that award of the Collector or the court, under I reference, has not compensated the owner for the full value of the property as on date of notification." 12
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
Thus, it is clear that the Hon’ble Supreme Court after considering the scheme of Section 45(5) of the Act has categorically held that payment made under section 28 of the LA Act is part of enhanced compensation. From the above judgement of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Ghanshyam (HUF) (supra) and after considering the Scheme of Section 45(5) of the Act has categorically held that payment made u/s. 28 of the LA Act is part of enhanced compensation. 14. Further, legislature for inserting clause (b) in section 145A, clause (viii) in section 56 and clause (iv) in section 57 by the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2009 w.e.f. 1.4.2010 and applicable for AY 2010-11. The appended Memorandum explaining the provisions to the Finance Act (No. 2) of 2009 explained the intention behind the insertion of this provision. The Board i.e. CBDT explained the intention of legislature for inserting this provision by Circular No. 5/2010 dated 3.6.2010 explaining the provisions of the Finance Act (No. 2) of 2009 and the relevant part of the Circular read as under:- “46. Rationalizing the provisions for taxation of interest received on delayed compensation or on enhanced compensation. 46.1 The existing provisions of Income-tax Act provide that income chargeable under the head "Profits and gains of business or profession" or "Income from other sources", shall be computed in accordance with either cash or mercantile system of accounting regularly employed by the assessee. Further, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Rama Bai v. CIT (181 ITR 400) has held that arrears of interest computed on delayed or enhanced compensation shall be taxable on accrual basis. This has caused undue hardship to the taxpayers. 46.2 With a view to mitigate the hardship, section 145A is amended to provide that the interest received by an assessee on compensation or enhanced compensation shall be deemed to be his income for the year in which it was received, irrespective of the method of accounting followed by the assessee.
46.3 Further, clause (viii) is inserted in the sub-section (2) of the 13
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
section 56 so as to provide that income by way of interest received on compensation or on enhanced compensation referred to in clause (b) of section 145A shall be assessed as "income from other sources" in the year in which it is received.
46.4 Applicability - This amendment has been made applicable with effect from 1st April, 2010, and will accordingly, apply in relation to assessment year 2010-11 and subsequent assessment years."
We have gone through the amendment brought in by the Finance Act (No. 2) of 2009 w.e.f. 01.04.2010 in clause (b) in section 145A, clause (viii) in section 56 and clause (iv) in section 57 and Memorandum explaining the provisions to the Finance Act (No. 2) of 2009 and consequent CBDT Circular 5/2010 and is of the view that these amendments were brought to mitigate the hardship caused to the assessee on account of decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Rama Bai (Supra). Moreover, these amendments were not in connection with or to overrule the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the Ghanshyam HUF (Supra). The CBDT Circular clearly says that rationalizing the provisions for the purpose of Supreme Court decision in the case of Rama Bai particularly in para 46.2 clearly talks about interest received by the assessee on compensation or enhanced compensation shall be deemed to be assessee’s income for the year in which it was received and interest referred to in clause (b) of section 145A shall be assessed as income from other sources and these amendments in section 56, 57 and section 145A of the Act have not changed the character or nature of receipt of interest awarded by Court u/s. 28 of the LA Act from capital receipt being part of enhanced compensation as held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Ghanshyam HUF (Supra). One more interesting fact to be noted that Finance No. 2 Act, 2009 was introduced in Lok Sabha on 06.07.2009 whereas Hon’ble Supreme Court delivered this judgment in Ghanshyam HUF (Supra) pm 16.7.2009 after the introduction of the Bill in Lok Sabha. Therefore,
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
there was no occasion to consider the decision in the case of Ghansyam HUF (Supra) while proposing amendments in the Finance No. 2 Act, 2009. Even after the amendment, Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of CIT vs. Govindbhai Mamaiya [2014] 367 ITR 498 (SC) relying upon its earlier decision in the case of Ghanshyam HUF (Supra) held that interest u/s 28 is accretion to the value and therefore, part of enhanced compensation, wherein it has been held as under:- “8. It is clear from the above that whereas interest under section 34 is not treated as a part of income subject to tax, the interest earned under section 28, which is on enhanced compensation, is treated as a accretion to the value and therefore, part of the enhanced compensation or consideration making it exigible to tax. After holding that interest on enhanced compensation under section 28 of 1894 Act is taxable, the Court dealt with the other aspect namely, the year of tax and answered this question by holding that it has to be tested on receipt basis, which means it would be taxed in the year in which it is received. It would mean that converse position i.e. spread over of this interest on accrual basis is not admissible…...”
Similarly, Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of Surjit Kumar Chetal vs. CIT [2017] 86 taxmann.com 121 (Delhi) also concluded that interest awarded u/s. 28 of the LA Act is accretion to enhance compensation. 17. Further, Hon’ble Punjab and Haryana High Court in the case of HSIDC vs. Savitri and another also expressed the opinion that interest u/s. 28 LA Act forms part of enhanced compensation. 18. This issue further came up for consideration of Hon’ble Gujarat High Court in the case of Movaliya Bhikhubhai Balabhai vs. ITO [2006] 388 ITR 343 (Guj) wherein even the substitution of section 145A read with section 56 clause (viii) and Section 57 clause (iv) of the Finance No. 2 Act, 2009 w.e.f. 1.4.2010 was considered as under:- “13. The upshot of the above discussion is that since interest under 15
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
section 28 of the Act of 1894, partakes the character of compensation, it does not fall within the ambit of the expression "interest" as contemplated in section 145A of the I.T. Act. The first respondent - Income Tax Officer was, therefore, not justified in refusing to grant a certificate under section 197 of the I.T. Act to the petitioner for non-deduction of tax at source, inasmuch as, the petitioner is not liable to pay any tax under the head "income from other sources" on the interest paid to it under section 28 of the Act of 1894. 14. The petitioner had earlier challenged the communication dated 9th February, 2015 whereby its application for a certificate under section 197 of the I. T. Act had been rejected, and subsequently, tax on the interest payable under section 28 of the Act of 1894 has already been deducted at source. Consequently, the challenge to the above communication has become infructuous and hence, the prayer clause came to be modified. However, since the amount paid under section 28 of the Act of 1894 forms part of the compensation and not interest, the second respondent was not justified in deducting tax at source under section 194A of the I.T. Act in respect of such amount. The petitioner is, therefore, entitled to refund of the amount wrongly deducted under section 194A of the I.T. Act…...” 19. Hence, in our view the amendment made u/s. 145A , 56(2) and 57 of the Act w.e.f. 1.4.2010 has no bearing on the taxability of interest on enhanced compensation awarded to the assessee u/s. 28 of the LA Act by the Court.
Admittedly, Hon’ble High Court of Punjab and Haryana in the case of Manjeet Singh HUF Karta Manjeet Singh vs. UOI [2016] 65 taxmann.com 160 and Ram Pal and others vs. State of Haryana and others in CWP No. 2276/2015 held that interest u/s. 28 of the LA Act is taxable as income from other sources as per the provisions of section 56(2)(viii) read with section 57(iv) and 145A(b) of the Act and the year of receipt. In reverse situation, Hon’ble Punjab and Haryana High Court in the case of Mahender Pal Narang vs. CBDT (2021) 126 taxmann.com 105 (SC) dismissed the SLP in liminie and affirmed the judgement stating that interest u/s. 28 of the LA Act received on enhanced compensation is taxable as income from other sources in view of the amended provisions. Similarly, Hon’ble Supreme Court in CWP under Article 32 of the Constitution held on 15.07.2016 in the case of Brahamparkash and ors. Vs. Haryana State 16
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
Industrial and Infrastructure Development Corporation Ltd. (HSIIDCL) & Ors. In Writ Petition (Civil) 590 of 2016 and judgement passed in the case of UOI and Ors. Vs. Hari Singh and Ors. Reported in (2018) 91 taxmann.com 20 (SC) reiterated that while determining the compensation paid was for agricultural land or not, the AO will keep in mind the provisions of section 28 of the LA Act and the law laid down by this Court in Ghanshaym HUF (supra) in order to ascertain whether the interest given in the said provisions amounts to compensation or not. It means that time and again Hon’ble Supreme Court reiterated its own decision in Ghanshaym HUF (Supra) and stated that this issue is no more res integra that interest awarded in section 28 of the LA Act is an accretion to the value, hence, it is a part of enhanced compensation paid for compulsory acquisition of agricultural land as envisaged under section 45(5) of the Act. Hon’ble Supreme Court in its order dated 19.7.2019 has dismissed the Misc. Application no. 1236/2019 in WP © no. 590/2016 as the same was withdrawn by the Income Tax Department through the ASG vide following correspondences:-
“MOST URGENT / TOP PRIORTIY
Central Board of Direct Taxes Directorate of Income Tax (Legal & Research) Room No. 303, Drum Shape Building, I.P. Estate, New Delhi – 110 002 Tel. No. 011-23370298 Fax No. 23378132, Email: itosccl.h@gmail.com F.No. ADG-II/(L&R)/NZ/Pr. CIT/Gurugram/ASP/112/2018/2556
dated 22.5.2019.
The Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax, Vanijya Nikunj, Udyog Vihar, Phase-V, 17
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
Gurugram-122016 Madam/sir, Subject : WP (C) No. 1226 of 2018 in the case of Jai Bhagwan Singh & Ors. vs. Haryana Development Corporation Ltd. & Ors. – Reg. Kindly refer to the above cited subject. In this connection, I am directed to forwards herewith a copy letter dated 20th may, 2019 alongwith copy of letter dated 8.5.2019, received from Mrs. Anil Katiyar, Addl. Govt. Advocate which is self explanatory, for information and necessary action at your end.
Yours faithfully, Encl: As above Sd/- Income Tax Officer (L&R) Supreme Court Cell, New Delhi”
“Ministry of Law & Justice Department of Legal Affairs Central Agency Section Supreme Court Compound 20th May, 2019
Director Direct rate of Income Tax (L&R) Drum Shape Building I.P. Estate New Delhi Subject : WP (C) No. 33816/2018 filed by Jai Bhagwan Singh and Others vs. Haryana State Industrial and Infrastructure Development Corporation Ltd.
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
Sir, The aforesaid matter was listed in this Hon’ble Court on 8th May, 2019 in which Shri ANS Nadkarni, Ld. ASG and Shri HR Rao, Advocate appeared enclosed herewith a letter dated 8.5.2019 of Shri HR Rao, Advocate alongwith Proceedings who assisted Ld. ASG in this matter. The letter is self explanatory in itself.
This is for your information and taking necessary action at your end. Yours faithfully, Encl: a/a Sd/- (Mrs. Anil Katiyar) Advocate on Record”
“H. Raghavendra Rao Advocate Supreme Court K-12, Ground Floor, Kailash Colony, New Delhi – 110048 Phone : 011-46061425 Mobile: 9711975569 Email: r_rao@outlook.com
08.05.2019 Mrs. Anil Katiyar, Government Advocate Central Agency Section Supreme Court of India New Delhi
Dear Madam,
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
Subject : WP (C) No. 33816/2018 filed by Jai Bhagwan Singh and Others vs. Haryana State Industrial and Infrastructure Development Corporation Ltd. and others – Reg. The above writ petition filed by a group of petitioners challenging the orders passed by the Income Tax officer, Ward 2(2), Gurugram, Income Tax Officer, Ward 1(4), Gurugram etc. were listed before Court Hall No. 12, as item 6 today and the said matter was heard by the Hon’ble Supreme Court. The Hon’ble Court after hearing arguments from both sides was pleased to dismiss the writ petition filed by a group of farmers challenging the order of the Assessing Officer passed under section 154 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 but with certain observations and directions. A copy of the order of the Court dated 8.5.2019 is enclosed herewith for your reference.
The issue involved in these cases are whether the tax deducted at source is to be deducted on the amounts which are paid as compensation or enhanced compensation or interest on the said compensation on account of compulsory acquisition of land under the provisions of Land Acquisition Act, 1894. While disbursing the compensation, the Land Acquisition Collector had deducted the tax at source and deposited the same with the Income Tax Department. These petitioners preferred the writ petitions before the High Court stating that no such deduction at source was permissible in view of the provisions of the Section 10(37) and Section 194I of the Act since the land which was acquired was agricultural land and this provision categorically mentions that in respect of agricultural land tax at source is not be deducted. The High Court allowed the said writ petitions and the Income Tax Department challenged these orders before the Supreme Court in Civil Appeals No. 15041/2017 and connected cases.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court by order dated 15.9.2017 disposed of the said appeals with the following directions: 1. The respondents shall file appropriate returns before the Assessing Officer(s) in respect of Assessment Years in question within a period of two months from today in case they feel that the compensation in respect of land belonging to them which had been acquired was agricultural land, and claim refund of the tax which was deducted at source and deposited with the Income Tax Department. On the filing of these returns, the Assessing Officer(s) shall go into the aforesaid question and wherever it is found that the compensation was received in respect of 7 C.A. No. 15041/2017 @ SLP (C) No. 28069 / 2010
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
etc. agricultural land, at the tax deposited with the Income Tax Department shall be refunded to these respondents. (2) While determining as to whether the compensation paid was for agricultural land or not, the Assessing Officers(s) will keep in mind the provisions of Section 28 of the Land and Acquisition Act and the law laid down by this Court in Commissioner of Income Tax, Faridabad vs. Ghanshyam (HUF) [2009 (8) SCC 412) in order to ascertain whether the interest given under the said provision amounts to compensation or not. (3) The direction to refund the amount of Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) to the Land Acquisition Collector is, accordingly, set aside. However, in those cases where the amount has already been refunded, no interference is called for and it will be for the Income Tax Department to proceed in accordance with the provisions of Income Tax Act. (4) Where such notices have not already been issued or assessments have not already been made, if such an action is taken within a period of two months from today, issue of limitation would not come in the way of the Income Tax Department. This order is passed having regard to the fact that the present proceedings 8 CA No. 150412/2017 @ SLP (C) No. 28069/2010 etc. were pending in this Court because of which it was not possible for the Income Tax Department to issue these notices earlier. (5) In future, Land Acquisition Collectors shall follow the procedure as stipulated by the High Court of Kerala in Nalini’s case, which is reproduced above. “The above directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court are binding on the Income Tax Department and it should be implemented in good spirit whether we like it or not instead of implementing the directions given by the Court, surprisingly in some of the orders the Assessing officers while dismissing the orders passed under section 154 of the Act have strangely stated that the department has initiated review petition proposal to be submitted before the Hon’ble Supreme Court against this order and hence they are dismissing the claim petitions. The Assessing officers in my view clearly flouted the order of the Supreme Court and are liable for contempt. As long as the order of the Supreme Court is in force, the department should give effect to the direction of the Hon’ble Supreme Court at any cost and filing of a 21
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
review petition is no ground to deny the relief to the tax payers. Fortunately, the tax payers have not filed any contempt petitions before the Supreme Court otherwise the Court might have issued contempt notices to the concerned officers as it is clear violation of the order of the Supreme Court and hence liable for contempt.
Mr. ANS Nadkarni, learned ASG has submitted to the Hon’ble Court that the concerned Assessing Officers before whom the returns of income have been filed and refund claim applications are filed may be allowed to pass fresh orders in accordance with law. The respective Assessing Officers before whom return of income are filed or applications for claim of refund of TDS are filed, may be instructed first to ascertain and give a finding as to whether the land acquired by the State Government is an agriculture land or not. If it an agricultural land, then the benefit of exemption should be given to the assessee. Interest paid under section 28 and 34 of the Land Acquisition Act cannot be treated as income from other sources in view of the categorical finding given by the Supreme Court in CIT vs. Ghanshyam 2009-8SCC- 412 at paragraph 50 where it was held as under:-
“50. It is true that “interest” is not compensation. It is equally true that Section 45(5) of the 1961 Act refers to compensation. But as discussed hereinabove, we have to go by the provisions of the 1894 Act which awards “Interest” both as an accretion in the value of land acquired and interest for undue delay. Interest under section 28 unlike interest under section 34 is an accretion to the value, hence, it a part of enhanced compensation or consideration which is not the case with interest under section 34 of the 1984 Act. So also additional amount under section 23(1-A) and solatium under section 23(2) of the 1961 Act forms of enhanced compensation under section 45(5)(b) of the 1961 Act.”
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
Hence, in my opinion the Assessing Officers may be directed / instructed to give effect to the orders of the Supreme Court in CIT vs. Ghanshyam (2009-8-SCC- 412) and Civil Appeal No. 15041/2017 dated 15.9.2017 in good spirit or else the court may take serious view of the matter for flouting its orders.
Thanking you,
Yours sincerely, Sd/- (H. Raghavendra Rao)”
In view of above, it is observed that there can be three different components of amount received or to be received by a person whose land has been compulsorily acquired under any law for the time being in force: the initial compensation which is awarded by the competent authority, the enhanced compensation which is awarded by the court, and interest, on compensation or the enhanced compensation which becomes payable due to the direction of the court or due to the statutory provision of the relevant law. Sub-section (5) of section 45 of the Act is a charging provision and it creates a charge on the capital gains on transfer of a capital asset, being a transfer by way of compulsory acquisition under any law, or a transfer where the consideration for which is determined or approved by the Central Government or the Reserve Bank of India. The relevant portion of the sub-section (5) of section 45 of the Act is reproduced below: Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1), where the capital gain arises from the transfer of a capital asset, being a transfer by way of compulsory acquisition under any law, or a transfer the consideration for which was determined or approved by the Central Government or the Reserve Bank of India, and the compensation or the consideration for such transfer is enhanced or further enhanced by any court, Tribunal or other authority, the capital gain shall be dealt with in the following manner, namely…
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
Further, it is noticed that an accrual or a receipt which can be considered as ‘the compensation or the consideration’ in the circumstances specified in section 45(5) of the Act gets covered within the ambit of this provision and needs to be taxed as ‘capital gains’ in the manner provided therein. In particular, sub- clause (b) of section 45(5) of the Act deals with the taxability of the enhanced amount of compensation or consideration and it provides as under:
(b) the amount by which the compensation or consideration is enhanced or further enhanced by the court, Tribunal or other authority shall be deemed to be income chargeable under the head ‘Capital gains’ of the previous year in which such amount is received by the assessee.
Therefore, the whole of the amount by which the compensation or consideration is enhanced by the court is deemed to be the income chargeable under the head capital gains irrespective of the manner in which such enhanced amount of the compensation or consideration has been determined or how that amount has been referred to in the relevant governing law under which it has been determined. What is relevant is that the compensation or the enhanced amount needs to be brought to tax under the head ‘capital gains’ by virtue of the deeming fiction created under the aforesaid provisions.
There are no separate or specific provisions dealing with the taxability of the interest received on compensation or enhanced compensation which is being taxed as per the general provisions of the Act, particularly sections 56 to 59 of the Act. The confusion about the year of taxation was addressed by the Apex Court in the case of Smt. Ramabai. A set of the specific provisions was inserted in the Act by the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2009 with effect from 1st April, 2010 to provide that such interest shall be taxable in the year of receipt nullifying the ratio of the Supreme Court decision. The issue of taxation of such interest was dealt with extensively by the Supreme Court in the case of Ghanshyam (HUF) 24
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
while dealing with the taxation of capital gains u/s 45(5) of the Act. The issue before the Supreme Court was about the year in which the enhanced compensation and interest thereon, received by the assessee, were taxable. The assessee contended that those amounts could not be held to have accrued to him during the year of receipt, as the entire amount received was in dispute in appeal before the High Court, which appeal stood filed by the State against the order of the reference Court granting enhanced compensation; and that the amount of enhanced compensation and the interest thereon were received by him in terms of the interim order of the High Court against his furnishing of security to the satisfaction of the executing Court. As against this, the Revenue pleaded that those amounts in question were taxable in the concerned year of receipt in which they were received by relying upon section 45(5) of the Act.
For deciding this issue, of the year in which the enhanced compensation as well as interest thereon were taxable, the Supreme Court in that case, of Ghanshyam (HUF), had to first decide as to what fell within the meaning of the term ‘compensation’ as used in section 45(5) of the Act. It was for the obvious reason that if any of the components of the receipt could not be regarded as ‘compensation’, then such component would not be governed by the provisions of section 45(5) of the Act so as to deem it to be income chargeable under the head ‘capital gains’. Apart from dealing with the nature of different amounts which were awarded under different sub-sections of section 23 of the LA Act as part of the enhanced compensation, the Supreme Court also determined the true nature of receipt of ‘interest’ granted under two different provisions of that Act, i.e., sections 28 and 34 of the LA Act.
The Supreme Court, explaining the distinction between the interest that became payable under both the above provisions of the 1894 LA Act held that the interest u/s 28 of the LA Act only was needed to be considered as part of the 25
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
compensation itself. The relevant extracts from the Supreme Court’s decision in this regard are reproduced below:
Section 28 applies when the amount originally awarded has been paid or deposited and when the Court awards excess amount. In such cases interest on that excess alone is payable. Section 28 empowers the Court to award interest on the excess amount of compensation awarded by it over the amount awarded by the Collector…
This award of interest is not mandatory but is left to the discretion of the Court. Section 28 of the LA Act is applicable only in respect of the excess amount, which is determined by the Court after a reference under section 18 of the LA Act. Section 28 of the LA Act does not apply to cases of undue delay in making award for compensation [See: Ram Chand vs. Union of India (1994) 1 SCC 44]. In the case of Shree Vijay Cotton & Oil Mills Ltd. vs. State of Gujarat [1991] 1 SCC 262, this Court has held that interest is different from compensation.
To sum up, interest is different from compensation. However, interest paid on the excess amount under section 28 of the LA Act depends upon a claim by the person whose land is acquired whereas interest under section 34 of the LA Act is for delay in making payment. This vital difference needs to be kept in mind in deciding this matter. Interest under section 28 of the LA Act is part of the amount of compensation whereas interest under section 34 of the LA Act is only for delay in making payment after the compensation amount is determined. Interest under section 28 of the LA Act is a part of enhanced value of the land which is not the case in the matter of payment of interest under section 34 of the LA Act.
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
The issue to be decided before us – what is the meaning of the words ‘enhanced compensation / consideration’ in section 45(5)(b) of the Act? Will it cover ‘interest’? These questions also bring in the concept of the year of taxability. We find that Section 28 of the LA Act applies only in respect of the excess amount determined by the Court after reference under section 18 of the LA Act. It depends upon the claim, unlike interest under section 34 of the LA Act which depends on undue delay in making the award. It is true that ‘interest’ is not compensation. It is equally true that section 45(5) of the Act refers to compensation. But as discussed hereinabove, we have to go by the provisions of the LA Act, which awards ‘interest’ both as an accretion in the value of the lands acquired and interest for undue delay. Interest under section 28 of the LA Act unlike interest under section 34 of the LA Act is an accretion to the value, hence it is a part of enhanced compensation or consideration which is not the case with interest under section 34 of the LA Act.
Thus, though a component of the amount received was referred to as the ‘interest’ in section 28 of the LA Act, such part was to be considered to be part of the ‘compensation’ insofar as section 45(5) of the Act was concerned. When it came to the ‘interest’ referred to in section 34 of the LA Act, it was to be treated as interest simpliciter and not as the ‘compensation’ for tax purposes and such interest was to be brought to tax as per the general provisions of the law. This was because of the Court’s understanding that interest u/s 28 of the LA Act was in the nature of damages awarded for granting insufficient compensation in the first instance. The Court held that the interest under the latter section 34 of the LA Act was to make up the loss due to delay in making the payment of the compensation, the former section 28 of the LA Act interest being at the discretion of the court and the latter section 34 interest being mandatory.
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
We note that later, this decision in the case of Ghanshyam (HUF) was followed by the Supreme Court in the cases of CIT vs. Govindbhai Mamaiya (2014) 367 ITR 498 and CIT vs. Chet Ram (HUF) (2018) 400 ITR 23.
Now the question arises as to whether the amendments made by the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2009 with effect from 1st April, 2010 have altered the position. The relevant amendments are narrated below: • Section 145A as existing then was substituted whereby a sub-clause (b) was added to it to provide as under:
(b) interest received by an assessee on compensation or on enhanced compensation, as the case may be, shall be deemed to be the income of the year in which it is received.
• Sub-clause (viii) was inserted in sub-section (2) of section 56 to provide as under:
(viii) income by way of interest received on compensation or on enhanced compensation referred to in clause (b) of section 145A.
• Sub-clause (iv) was inserted in section 57 to provide as under:
(iv) in the case of income of the nature referred to in clause (viii) of sub- section (2) of section 56, a deduction of a sum equal to fifty per cent of such income and no deduction shall be allowed under any other clause of this section.
These amendments, in our considered opinion, will apply only if the receipt concerned, like in section 34 of the LA Act, can be regarded as ‘interest’ in the first place and not otherwise. If the amount concerned has already been considered to be a part of the compensation and, hence, governed by section 45(5) of the Act, it cannot be re-characterised as ‘interest’ merely by relying on the aforesaid amended provisions. The characterisation of a particular receipt either as ‘compensation’ or ‘interest’ needs to be done independent of these provisions and one needs to apply these amended provisions only if it has been
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
characterised as ‘interest’. Therefore, the basis on which the interest payable u/s 28 of the LA Act has been regarded as part of the compensation by the Supreme Court still prevails and does not get overruled by the aforesaid amendments.
Recently, in the context of a motor accident claim made under the Motor Vehicles Act, the Bombay High Court in the case of Rupesh Rashmikant Shah vs. UOI (2019) 417 ITR 169, after considering the amended provisions of the Income-tax Act, has held that interest awarded under the said Act as a part of the claim did not become chargeable to tax merely because of the provision contained in clause (viii) of section 56(2) of the Income-tax Act. Similarly, Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Tehri Hydro Development Corporation Ltd. vs. S.P. Singh and Others in Civil Appeal No. 3454 of 2019 dated 31.07.2026 while adjudicating the issue of charging of stamp duty on transfer of land through compulsory acquisition and interest paid u./s. 28 of the LA Act is to be considered for the purpose of computing the total consideration for charging of stamp duty or not. Hon’ble Supreme Court answered this vide para no. 23 as under:- “23. Applying these settled principles to the facts of the present case, it is evident that the appellant sought deletion of the additional amount under Section 23(1-A), solatium under section 23(2) and statutory interest under section 28. Each of these amounts forms an integral part of the compensation awarded by the Reference Court and consequently forms part of the decretal amount. The appeal was therefore, one relating to compensation within the meaning of Section 8 of the Court Fees Act. The appellant was accordingly liable to pay and ad valorem court fee on the value of the relief claimed, and payment of a fixed court fee of Rs. 10/- was legally impermissible.
Further, section 2(28A) defines the term ‘interest’ in a manner that includes the interest payable in any manner in respect of any moneys borrowed or debt incurred. In a case of compulsory acquisition of land, there is obviously 29
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
no borrowing of monies. Is there any debt incurred? The ‘incurring’ of the debt, if at all, arises only on grant of the award for enhanced compensation. Before the award for the enhanced compensation, there is really no debt that can be said to have been incurred in favour of the person receiving compensation. In fact, till such time as the enhanced compensation is awarded there is no certainty about the eligibility to it, leave alone the quantum of the compensation. This is also one of the reasons in support of the argument that the amount so awarded u/s 28 of the LA Act cannot be construed as ‘interest’ even when it is referred to as ‘interest’ therein. 35. It is important to appreciate the objective for the introduction of the amendments in sections 56(2), 57(iv) and 145A which was to provide for the year in which interest otherwise taxable is to be taxed. This objective is explained in clear terms by Circular No. 5/2010 dated 3rd June, 2010 issued by the CBDT for explaining the objective behind the introduction. The relevant paragraph of the Circular reads as under:
‘The existing provisions of Income Tax Act, 1961, provide that income chargeable under the head “Profits and gains of business or profession” or “Income from other sources”, shall be computed in accordance with either cash or mercantile system of accounting regularly employed by the assessee. Further the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Smt. Rama Bai vs. CIT (1990) 84 CTR (SC) 164 : (1990) 181 ITR 400 (SC) has held that arrears of interest computed on delayed or enhanced compensation shall be taxable on accrual basis. This has caused undue hardship to the taxpayers. With a view to mitigate the hardship, section 145A is amended to provide that the interest received by an assessee on compensation or enhanced compensation shall be deemed to be his income for the year in which it was received, irrespective of the method of accounting followed by the assessee.
Further, clause (viii) is inserted in sub-section (2) of the section 56 so as to provide that income by way of 30
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
interest received on compensation or enhanced compensation referred to in clause (b) of section 145A shall be assessed as “income from other sources” in the year in which it is received.’
In the circumstances, it is clear that the provisions of clause (viii) of section 56 and clause (iv) of section 57 and section 145A of the Act are not the charging sections in respect of interest under consideration and their scope is limited to defining the year of taxation of a receipt which is otherwise characterised as interest.
The amendment as noted by the Gujarat High Court was brought about by the Legislature to alleviate the difficulty that arose due to the decision of the Apex Court in the case of Smt. Rama Bai (Supra) wherein, it was held that arrears of interest computed on delayed or enhanced compensation should be taxable on accrual basis in the respective years of accrual. It was to mitigate this hardship that section 145A of the Act was amended to provide that the interest received by an assessee on compensation or enhanced compensation shall be deemed to be his income for the year in which it was received, irrespective of the method of accounting followed by the assessee. By relying upon this clarification, the Gujarat High Court held that the concerned amendments by the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2009 were not in connection with the decision of the Supreme Court in the Ghanshyam (HUF) case but was brought in to mitigate the hardship caused to the assessee on account of the decision of the Supreme Court in the Rama Bai case.
To sum-up, it is appropriate to not decide the taxability or otherwise and also the head of taxation simply on the basis of the nomenclature used in the relevant law under which the payment is made, of compensation or enhanced compensation or interest, whatever the case may be. The receipt for it to be classified as ‘interest’ or ‘compensation’ should be tested on the touchstone of 31
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
the provisions of the Income-tax Act. The better view, in our considered opinion, is the view expressed by the Gujarat High Court that the interest received u/s 28 of the LA Act should be taxed as capital gains in accordance with the provisions of section 45(5) of the Act. 39. Assuming that this interest is chargeable as income from other sources, even then the PCIT cannot revise the assessment u/s. 263 of the Act for the reasons that issue is highly debatable and once the issue is debatable, in view of the Hon’ble Supreme Court decision in the cases of Malabar Industrial Co. vs. CIT (2000) 109 Taxman 66 (SC) and CIT (Central), Ludhiana vs. Max India Ltd. [2008[ 166 Taxman 188 (SC), hence, the revision is bad in law and cannot be sustained and assessment is liable to be quashed. 40. We further note that recently the Third Member vide his order dated 24.8.2026 in the case of Manish Tuteja vs. PCIT, Rohtak in ITA No. 1569/Del/2024 (AY 2018-19) has dealt the similar and identical issue by holding as under:- “59. To sum-up, it is appropriate to not decide the taxability or otherwise and also the head of taxation simply on the basis of the nomenclature used in the relevant law under which the payment is made, of compensation or enhanced compensation or interest, whatever the case may be. The receipt for it to be classified as ‘interest’ or ‘compensation’ should be tested on the touchstone of the provisions of the Income-tax Act. The better view, in my considered opinion, is the view expressed by the Gujarat High Court that the interest received u/s 28 of the LA Act should be taxed as capital gains in accordance with the provisions of section 45(5) of the Act.
Assuming that this interest is chargeable as income from other sources, even then the PCIT cannot revise the assessment u/s. 263 of the Act for the reasons that issue is highly debatable and once the issue is debatable, in view of the Hon’ble Supreme Court decision in the cases of Malabar Industrial Co. vs. CIT (2000) 109 Taxman 66 (SC) and CIT (Central), Ludhiana vs. Max India Ltd. [2008[ 166 Taxman 188 (SC). Hence, the revision is bad in law and cannot be sustained.” 32
ITA NO. 1288/DEL/2022 (AY 2017-18)
Consequent upon the aforesaid decision of the Third Member, the Coordinate Bench has passed the confirmatory order and allowed the appeal of the assessee on 13.10.2026 (which was pronounced in the Open Court on 09.09.2026). 42. In the background of the aforesaid discussions and respectfully following the precedents as discussed above, we quash the revision order passed u/s. 263 of the Act and allow the appeal of the assessee accordingly. 43. In the result, the appeal filed by the assessee is allowed in the aforesaid manner. Order pronounced in the Open Court on 06.11.2026.
Sd/- Sd/- (M. BALAGANESH) (MAHAVIR SINGH) ACCOUNTANT MEMBER VICE PRESIDENT SRBhatnagar Date: 06-11-2026 Copy forwarded to: - 1. Appellant 2. Respondent 3. DIT 4. CIT (A) 5. DR, ITAT
By Order,
Assistant Registrar, ITAT, Delhi Bench
More judgments on Section 2(28A)
- Laxmichand Meghji Dedhia, Mumbai vs Ward 27(2)(3), Mumbai, Navi MumbaiITA 3505/MUM/2026[2013-14]Status: Disposed7 Oct 2026AY 2013-14
- Naresh Kumar, Gurgaon, Haryana vs PCIT, JaipurITA 209/JPR/2024[2019-20]Status: Disposed28 Sept 2026AY 2019-20
- Ascendas Property Fund (Fdi) Pte Limited… vs Deputy Commissioner of Income-Tax…ITITA 211/DEL/2026[2020-21]Status: Disposed25 Sept 2026AY 2020-21
- Ascendas Property Fund (Fdi) Pte Limited… vs Deputy Commissioner of Income-Tax…ITITA 210/DEL/2026[2017-18]Status: Disposed25 Sept 2026AY 2017-18
- Universal Tractor Holding Llc, Usa vs DCIT, International Taxation Circle…ITA 2216/DEL/2022[2019-20]Status: Disposed15 Sept 2026AY 2019-20
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Tvl. Devaerakkam Mercy Mary vs. The Assistant Commissioner (St)Madras · 4 Nov 2026
- Procter And Gamble Health LTD vs. Union Of INDIATelangana · 4 Nov 2026
- M/S Ritika Ispat PVT. Limited, Balanda, Sundargarh vs. The Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes And Goods And Services Tax, Odisha, CuttackOrissa · 4 Nov 2026
- M/S.Ritika Ispat PVT. LTD.,Balanda, Sundergarh vs. The Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes And Goods And Services Tax, Odisha, CuttackOrissa · 4 Nov 2026
- Biswanath Pradhan vs. The Principal Commnr., CGST And Central Excise, BhubaneswarOrissa · 4 Nov 2026