COMNR.OF I.TAX vs. DURGA CONDEV P.LTD
What did the High Court hold?
The Tribunal held that the Commissioner of Income Tax was not justified in invoking the provisions of Section 263 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, for issues 1 to 5. The Tribunal reasoned that the AO had duly considered these issues and taken a possible view after making enquiries, and the CIT could not invoke Section 263 simply because he held a different opinion. For issue 6, concerning dividend tax and the sum of Rs. 584 crores, the Tribunal followed the decision in Peerless General Finance & Investment Co. Ltd. vs. ACIT, holding that the CIT lacked cogent material and that the alleged failure of the AO to examine tax deduction at source was outside the AO's jurisdiction. The Tribunal concluded that the CIT's revision was an arbitrary and erroneous fishing enquiry without jurisdiction. Therefore, the order passed by the CIT under Section 263 was quashed. The appeal filed by the Revenue was dismissed as no substantial question of law could be raised, and it was also noted that defects in the appeal were not removed for a considerable period.
What were the facts?
The Revenue (appellant) filed an Income Tax Appeal challenging an order dated 12.06.2009 passed by the Commissioner of Income Tax (CIT) in ITA No.116/CTK/2008 for the assessment year 2004-05. The Tribunal, in its order, noted that the CIT had invoked Section 263 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, believing the Assessing Officer (AO) had not properly appreciated facts or made appropriate enquiries. The Tribunal found that the issues raised by the CIT were already considered by the AO. Regarding a specific issue concerning dividend tax and a sum of Rs. 584 crores, the Tribunal referred to a previous decision of the Kolkata Bench in Peerless General Finance & Investment Co. Ltd. vs. ACIT, which held that the CIT's revision was an arbitrary and erroneous attempt at a fishing enquiry without jurisdiction. The Tribunal ultimately quashed the CIT's order passed under Section 263.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the Commissioner of Income Tax was justified in invoking the provisions of Section 263 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, when the Assessing Officer had already considered the issues raised and taken a possible view after making enquiries? - Assessee's contention: The AO had duly considered all issues raised by the CIT under Section 263, and the CIT could not invoke Section 263 merely because he had a different opinion or believed the AO did not make appropriate enquiries, especially when the AO had made enquiries as he thought fit and taken a possible view. Reliance was placed on CIT vs. Gabriel India Ltd. and CIT – Vs- Trustees of Anupam Charitable Trust. - Revenue's contention: Not recorded in the judgment. 2. Whether the Commissioner of Income Tax was justified in revising the assessment order concerning dividend tax and a sum of Rs. 584 crores, alleging the AO failed to examine tax deduction at source on payments to certificate holders? - Assessee's contention: The CIT lacked cogent material to reject the assessee's submission that the Rs. 584 crores was a balance sheet item representing actual payment of liability accrued in earlier years and had no nexus with taxable business profits. The CIT's allegation that the AO failed to examine tax deduction at source was outside the AO's jurisdiction, being a matter for the TDS officer, making the revision an arbitrary and erroneous fishing enquiry without jurisdiction. Reliance was placed on CIT vs. Gabriel India Ltd. and CIT – Vs- Trustees of Anupam Charitable Trust. - Revenue's contention: Not recorded in the judgment.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
09.01.2019
Heard.
By way of this Income Tax Appeal, the appellant challenged the order dated 12.06.2009 passed in ITA No.116/CTK/2008 for the assessment year 2004-05.
Heard learned counsel for the appellant-Revenue and perused the order impugned herein. Paragraph-5 of the order of the Tribunal is relevant for our discussion, which is quoted below:
“5. Heard both the parties, perused the materials available on record and we find force in the contention of the Ld. Counsel for the assessee that the issue nos, 1 to 5 raised by the Ld. CIT in his notice u/s. 263 were all duly considered by the A.O. which is evident from the assessment record. The Ld. CIT on these issues has invoked the provisions section 263 only because he was of the opinion that A.O. has not properly appreciated the facts or has not made appropriate enquiries. Law is well settled that if A.O. after making enquiry as he thought fit has taken a possible view and the Ld. CIT on the same facts is of different opinion provisions of section 263 cannot be invoked. In view of the above, we are of the considered opinion that Ld. CIT was not justified in doing so in respect of the above issues. So far as the issue No.6 is concerned which relates to dividend tax, we find that the Kolkata Bench of the Tribunal in the case of Peerless General Finance & Investment Co. Ltd. Vs. ACIT, ITA No.868/Kol/2005, AY 2000- 01 dated 21.7.2005 has held as under:
“The CIT had no cogent material in his possession to unnecessarily reject the submissions of the assessee made by the letter dt.29th March, 2005 that the sum of Rs.584 crores was in reality a balance sheet item, representing actual payment of liability accrued in earlier years, and the same had no relevance or nexus whatsoever with the taxable business profits of the assessee for the relevant financial year. There was no material before the CIT to even come to a conclusion that the payment of Rs.584 crores to the certificate holders on maturity of the certificates, which was a balance sheet item, could have any impact on the taxable profits of the assessee for the relevant assessment year. The CIT has alleged in the order passed under s.263 that the A.O. had failed to examine whether tax had I.T.A. No.97 of 2009
2 been deducted at source by the assessee on payment made to certificate-holders. Examination of such matters does not fall within the jurisdiction of the AO and the CIT, under whom the AO works. It is a matter of concern of the TDS officer and, therefore, the CIT had no occasion to say that the AO had failed to carry out such examination, when the same was not even warranted by law. Thus, the revision of the assessment order by the CIT under s.263 with respect to the said sum of Rs.584 crores is an attempt on the part of the CIT to initiate a fishing and roving enquiry while acting on mere suspicion and without having any material on record and the same is without necessary jurisdiction and thus, the order of the CIT passed under s.263 to the extent the same relates to the CIT setting aside the said issue to the file of the AO for fresh verification, is totally arbitrary and erroneous. Therefore, the order passed under s.263 is reversed to the said extent. – CIT vs. Gabriel India Ltd. (1993) 114 CTR (Bom) 81, (1993) 203 ITR 108 (Bom) and CIT – Vs- Trustees of Anupam Charitable Trust (1987) 65 CTR (Raj) 30, (1987) 167 ITR 129 (Raj) relied on.”
In view of the above, we are of the view that on this issue also revision proceedings u/s. 263 are not sustainable. Therefore, the order passed by the Ld. CIT u/s. 263 is hereby quashed.”
On scrutiny of materials and in view of the settled position of law, we do not find any infirmity in the impugned order.
Even otherwise, the instant appeal was filed on 3rd of November, 2009. Defects were not removed up to 20.04.2017. It will not be appropriate to issue notice after nine years.
Accordingly, the appeal does not merit consideration and deserves to be dismissed as no substantial question of law could be raised by learned counsel for Revenue for our determination.
..…………………..
K.S. JHAVERI
(Chief Justice) ss
……..…………………..
K.R. MOHAPATRA
(Judge)
More judgments on Section 263
- G.S. Pharmaceutical Pvt Ltd, Muzaffarnagar vs Pr, CIT, DehradunITA 4167/DEL/2026[2019-20]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2019-20
- Kaushalkumar Rajendrakumar Patel, Ahmedabad vs Principal Commissioner of Income Tax…ITA 1161/AHD/2026[2013-14]Status: Disposed13 Nov 2026AY 2013-14
- M/S the Educationalsociety St. Marys… vs DCIT Exemption Circle, GhaziabadITA 5861/DEL/2026[2022-23]Status: Disposed12 Nov 2026AY 2022-23
- M/S Nao Spirits & Beverages Private… vs Assessment Unit, C. R. BuildingITA 3318/DEL/2025[2021-22]Status: Disposed12 Nov 2026AY 2021-22
- Waseem Ahmad, Muzaffarnagar vs ITO, Ward-3(2)(4), MuzaffarnagarITA 568/DEL/2022[2012-13]Status: Disposed10 Nov 2026AY 2012-13
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Sri Manohar Lal Patel vs. The State Of KarnatakaKarnataka · 17 Nov 2026
- Mr.Yogesh H H vs. The State Of KarnatakaKarnataka · 17 Nov 2026
- Mrs Sabrina Flora Britto Hougaard vs. State Of KarnatakaKarnataka · 17 Nov 2026
- Sri. Stephen K.J. vs. The State Of KarnatakaKarnataka · 17 Nov 2026
- Smt Daisy Stephen vs. The State Of KarnatakaKarnataka · 17 Nov 2026