M/S.TRICHUR EDUCATIONAL TRUST vs. THE INCOME TAX OFFICER

PDF · subscribers
WP(C)/4935/2013HC KeralaKLHC01048133201320 February 2013Author: HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE ANTONY DOMINIC4 pages
AI SummaryRemanded

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the Income Tax Officer should not have issued garnishee proceedings (Ext.P3) after the appellate authority had substantially varied the assessment order (Ext.P1) in Ext.P2. The Court reasoned that once the appeal was allowed and the assessing officer was directed to give effect to the appellate order, the ITO ought to have done so and should not have initiated recovery proceedings based on the original demand. The principle established is that recovery proceedings must align with the final demand after appellate modifications. The Court directed the ITO to give effect to the appellate order (Ext.P2) by issuing a revised assessment order within three months and stayed further proceedings pursuant to the garnishee notice (Ext.P3) in the meantime.

What were the facts?

The petitioner, M/s. Trichur Educational Trust, is challenging garnishee proceedings initiated by the Income Tax Officer (ITO), Ward 1(1), Thrissur. The ITO had passed an assessment order under Section 143(3) for assessment year 2009-10, which was challenged by the petitioner in appeal. The appellate authority, in its order dated January 23, 2013, allowed the appeal and directed the ITO to give effect to the appellate order. Despite this, the ITO issued garnishee proceedings on February 7, 2013, to the Branch Manager of Federal Bank Ltd., Thrissur, demanding payment of ₹1,32,12,794/- due under the original assessment order. The bank then communicated this to the petitioner.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the Income Tax Officer was justified in initiating garnishee proceedings for recovery of tax demand when the original assessment order had been substantially varied by the appellate authority. (Question of law) Assessee's contention: The assessee argued that once the appellate authority had allowed the appeal and directed the assessing officer to give effect to the appellate order, the assessing officer should not have proceeded with garnishee proceedings based on the original, varied demand. The assessee relied on the fact that the appellate order (Ext.P2) had substantially varied the assessment order (Ext.P1). Revenue's contention: The judgment does not record any specific contentions from the revenue regarding the propriety of the garnishee proceedings after the appellate order.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 143(3)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM PRESENT: THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE ANTONY DOMINIC WEDNESDAY, THE 20TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2013/1ST PHALGUNA 1934 WP(C).No. 4935 of 2013 (N) -------------------------- PETITIONER(S): -------------- M/S.TRICHUR EDUCATIONAL TRUST JYOTHI ENGINEERING COLLEGE CAMPUS CHERUTHURUTHY P.O. THRISSUR - 680005 REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY FR.VARGHESE KUTHUR. BY ADVS.SMT.SUMATHY DANDAPANI (SR.) SRI.MATHEW KURIAKOSE RESPONDENT(S): --------------- 1. THE INCOME TAX OFFICER

WARD 1 (1) AAYKAR BHAVAN, S.T.NAGAR

THRISSUR - 680001. 2. THE BRANCH MANAGER, FEDERAL BANK LTD, T.B.ROAD, S.T.NAGAR

THRISSUR - 680001.

BY SRI.JOSE JOSEPH, SC, FOR INCOME TAX THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 20-02-2013, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

WPC NO.4935/13 APPENDIX PETITIONER'S EXHIBITS EXT.P-1 TRUE COPY OF ORDER DTD 23/12/2011 U/S.143(3) OF THE 1ST RESPONDENT. EXT.P-2 TRUE COPY OF ORDER NO.ITA07/R1/(1)/TCR/CIT(A) V/12-13 DATED 23.1.2013. EXT.P-3 TRUE COPY OF NOTICE DATED 7/2/2013 NO.AAATT6583FA/W1(1)/R1/ TCR/2009-10 EXT.P-4 TRUE COPY OF REQUEST DATED 13/2/2013 GIVEN BY THE PETITIONER. EXT.P-5 TRUE COPY OF LETTER TCRB 208/2013 DATED 12/2/2013 ISSUED BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT. //True Copy// PA to Judge Rp

ANTONY DOMINIC, J. ================ W.P.(C) NO. 4935 OF 2013 =================== Dated this the 20th day of February, 2013 J U D G M E N T Heard the learned senior counsel for the petitioner and the learned standing counsel for the 1st respondent. 2. Ext.P1 is an order of assessment passed against the petitioner under the Income Tax Act for the assessment year 2009-10. This order was challenged by the petitioner in an appeal which was disposed of by Ext.P2 order. In Ext.P2 order, the appeal was allowed and the assessing officer was directed to give effect to the appellate order. While the matter is thus pending before the assessing officer, the 1st respondent has issued Ext.P3 garnishee proceedings calling upon the 2nd respondent to make payment of `1,32,12,794/- due under Ext.P1 order. On its receipt, Bank issued Ext.P5 communication to the petitioner. It is in these circumstances, the petitioner has filed this writ petition. 3. Once Ext.P1 has been substantially varied by the appellate authority in Ext.P2 order, the 1st respondent should have given effect to Ext.P2 and should not have in the meanwhile issued Ext.P3 garnishee proceedings.

WPC.No.4935/13 :2 : 4. Therefore, I dispose of this writ petition directing that the 1st respondent shall give effect to Ext.P2 by issuing a revised assessment order, as expeditiously as possible, at any rate within 3 months of receipt of a copy of this judgment. In the meantime, further proceedings pursuant to Ext.P3 communication issued by the 1st respondent to the 2nd respondent will stand stayed. Petitioner will produce a copy of this judgment along with a copy of the writ petition before respondents 1 and 2 for compliance. Sd/- ANTONY DOMINIC, JUDGE Rp

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →